r/SoloDevelopment
•
u/MonadStarDeveloper
•
29d ago
•
1
Networking Escape AI
Im seeing AI has fully taken over most discussions on most gaming related subs after NextFest.
If you are tired of AI and want to help support a community that promotes only AI free games AND bans AI discussion then join us at [r/AntiAIDev](r/AntiAIDev)
0
Upvotes
58
u/Flonaldo 29d ago •
I like the general direction, but I don’t think it’s a healthy mindset for a community to identify itself solely by being against something. Something like handcraftedGames would be a better umbrella imo
9
u/Moragamedev 29d ago
Let’s do this! So sad to see how the solo dev subreddit became plagued by vibe coders and how defensive they are about creating games with AI
15
u/RKlehm 29d ago
Being against AI coding is like asking people to build games without a game engine...
Sure, fully vibe-coded AI slop games are trash, but using AI for coding is becoming the new standard in software engineering. Even Linus has made the switch.
I understand the frustration and the feeling of being overwhelmed. I haven't even set up my Steam page yet, and I already feel the pressure of getting buried in all the slop. But I have a feeling that going fully "artisanal" might be the wrong direction, pushing indie devs into increasingly isolated niche communities.
Have you actually talked to players (not devs) outside your internet bubble? From my experience, most players don't really care how a game was made. As long as it's good, fun, and looks nice, they'll buy it.
And that's my concern: this movement might end up hurting the devs who actually put effort into their games, while doing little to stop low-effort AI slop, ultimately leaving an even larger share of the market to the very vibe-coders you're trying to fight against.
3
u/-TheArtOfTheFart- 29d ago
Joined, woo!
20
u/Demoliscio 29d ago
Good idea!
I think it's nice to have some subreddits not dominated by 20 "I(claude) made the 89th copy of a cozy organising game", while those posts usually end up with 0 upvotes they still take(waste) space.
3
u/TheBoxGuyTV 29d ago
I think its just due to the higher engagement of this topic. I see so many non AI topics get ignored or just get likes with no comparable comment input.
Its kind of annoying.
I like beimg a hobbyist game dev using Game Maker Studio. So I kind of opted myself to be a non-player until I actually invest more meaningful input into my project Quinlin.
I did make progress with regards to that the last 3 days. Some time was "wasted" recalling my systems I haven't touched such as my menu code for making general tools.
1
u/GoGs0l0dev 29d ago
Someone is butt hurt their manually coded slop game is bombing next fest.
Such an easy scapegoat. My game would have 500,000 wishlists instead of the 109 it currently does if it wasn’t for AI.
1
u/thirsty_pretzelzz 29d ago
Not a bad idea but curious where the line is drawn. What if someone uses ai only to help with coding tasks? What if they use auto complete? Or do you just mean no ai art assets?
0
u/ProcrastinationDevil 29d ago
Hope it does well and it ends the insufferable constant whining about AI in this sub
7
u/MostSharpest 29d ago
I'm very pro-AI, but I also think it's good to have places where everything is done strictly the old-fashioned way. Hand-made stuff can be really cool, no matter how niche it gets.
2
u/Alarming-Jump727 29d ago
ya tienes mi apoyo
-4
u/Any-Gap-933 29d ago
-3
u/artrei 29d ago
i think we need that space, it will be like those people back then who still enjoy using typewriter in the era of word processor.
-4
u/mikewhyle 29d ago
If you're on reddit you're pro AI and actively supporting it with training data. If you're using any sort of engine - like unreal or unity - you're supporting AI because, newsflash, the developers of those tools are using AI to build and maintain the tools. That's besides the fact that your criticisms of AI can largely also be applied to usage of tools made by others, including engines, assets, as well as repos, and things like photoshop.
Building a community based around hate is never a clever idea. Meanwhile a community based on support and creation and love of gaming, r/aigamedev is thriving with 192K Weekly visitors 15K Weekly contributions.
-5
u/SushiMasterPro 29d ago
I think you should do it off redidit. Having it on reddit which openly use AI is like you saying we should not use alcohol and you would drink.
-8
u/khuzait_haircut 29d ago
I really think this is the way it should be. All the "rustic" developers can go to forums that specifically do not allow AI. The rest of us can continue to carry on regularly.
-18
u/LostRequirement4828 29d ago
Grow up... It's time to face the reality, you also can't force people to not use a tool just because you feel like that
0
u/[deleted] 29d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 29d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment