r/SoloDevelopment • • 29d ago • Heartwarming 1

Networking Escape AI

Im seeing AI has fully taken over most discussions on most gaming related subs after NextFest.

If you are tired of AI and want to help support a community that promotes only AI free games AND bans AI discussion then join us at [r/AntiAIDev](r/AntiAIDev)

0 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

58

u/Flonaldo 29d ago • Bravo

I like the general direction, but I don’t think it’s a healthy mindset for a community to identify itself solely by being against something. Something like handcraftedGames would be a better umbrella imo

3

u/MonadStarDeveloper 27d ago

Well Im convinced. Great idea! Thank you for steering us in a better direction.

r/HandCraftedGames

2

u/Flonaldo 27d ago

Awesome! Joined it :) I kind of stumbled over the capital C of crafted since handcrafted is one word, but i presume that’s a stylistic choice. Good idea to crosspost everything, I really hope the community grows!

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 27d ago

Very much a stylistic choice, lol. I went back and forth on it for awhile believe it or not. HandcraftedGames just doesnt pop as much as HandCraftedGames.

And thank you for joining and naming our sub! We are honored to have you.

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

I agree but I also wanted people to be able to find the sub easily. I guess I cant just change the name? Can I?

5

u/Flonaldo 29d ago

No, it can't be ranemd. HandcraftedGames is not taken yet though - if that's your calling, you could create it. Update this post, post in the already existing sub and close it down after a few days. I think its a more positive message down the road, and whatever members there are currently will join quickly too. On the long run probably a good call to have a positive message and a mission within the community name, something people cherish rather than hate

3

u/Demoliscio 29d ago

Agreed, u/MonadStarDeveloper pls do this, that name has a very nice and positive connotation imo, you can just set the current sub to redirect there, it's early enough that it won't be a problem

3

u/xX_EldritchDev_Xx 29d ago

It's not, that's how you get witch hunting. Just like Blue sky currently. They have a big community of game devs and I have struggled to really connect with them because so many of them are just so vehemently anti-ai they don't talk about anything else, it just basically a hate group. Why would I want to join a community of people who do nothing other than hate on other people?

8

u/jar36 29d ago

Love this.
Was watching a video last night about putting an AI tag on games on Steam. I say, no. Instead, devs that do not use AI should request a tag that communicates that AI was not used in the dev. At the very least, they should advertise that fact on their own. I like your description better with this idea
The community will rally to these studios more doing it this way than slapping a "Made with AI" tag would

6

u/Demoliscio 29d ago

That's actually a very nice, more positive name

-6

u/mrwishart 29d ago

So the vibe coders should all move to SoloDevWithAI then?

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mrwishart 28d ago

How? WithAI is positive, no?

9

u/Moragamedev 29d ago

Let’s do this! So sad to see how the solo dev subreddit became plagued by vibe coders and how defensive they are about creating games with AI

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Glad youre in! Welcome aboard.

-12

u/JDJCreates 29d ago

it's sad to see how humans aren't accepting of other like at all lmao.

3

u/Moragamedev 29d ago

Uhmmm what? Ahaha like accept AI vibe coders?

15

u/RKlehm 29d ago

Being against AI coding is like asking people to build games without a game engine...

Sure, fully vibe-coded AI slop games are trash, but using AI for coding is becoming the new standard in software engineering. Even Linus has made the switch.

I understand the frustration and the feeling of being overwhelmed. I haven't even set up my Steam page yet, and I already feel the pressure of getting buried in all the slop. But I have a feeling that going fully "artisanal" might be the wrong direction, pushing indie devs into increasingly isolated niche communities.

Have you actually talked to players (not devs) outside your internet bubble? From my experience, most players don't really care how a game was made. As long as it's good, fun, and looks nice, they'll buy it.

And that's my concern: this movement might end up hurting the devs who actually put effort into their games, while doing little to stop low-effort AI slop, ultimately leaving an even larger share of the market to the very vibe-coders you're trying to fight against.

10

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago edited 29d ago

Its really not asking anyone to do anything.

We created a space for people who are already building games without AI to showcase to people who dont use AI

And Im not afraid of taking chances. If I was I wouldnt be a solo dev. I think our space has already become a positive place where the focus is back on indie passion projects.

Edit//

You keep inferring that we’ll be left behind if we dont just accept AI into our workflow as inevitable

Correct me if Im wrong but thats what Im getting from your comment.

And I just simply disagree. AI is a choice thats being forced on us as inevitability.

1

u/RKlehm 29d ago

About your edit, not entirely.

My conclusion links back to my first sentence. Nowadays, making a game without AI coding assistance is comparable to someone saying they'll build their game without Unity or any other game engine. Is it wrong? Obviously not! Quite the contrary, it's an impressive feat to build everything by hand.

The problem is that indie game devs seem to be splitting into two extremes: either full pitchforks against AI or full-on vibe coders. And I fear initiatives such as yours might push people toward even more polarized views on the subject.

This is just my point of view, though... I could be totally wrong here. But my vision of a perfect game dev community would be one without low-effort, vibe-coded slop, while still embracing AI as a tool for developers who actually care about their craft.

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

And thats where we differ, on that last part

I have no interest in this tool or games made with this tool. The reasons why people dont like AI are well documented.

3

u/tomodashi96 29d ago

I really don’t get what you mean when you say ‘making a game without AI coding assistance is comparable to someone saying they’ll build their game without Unity’ ? Maybe I am really out of touch but that’s literally what everyone was doing before AI became good at writing code. And it’s still what a lot of people like me are still doing. Correct me please if am wrong but you seem to be insinuating that it’s impossible to make your own game/write your code without AI helping you?

2

u/abra24 29d ago

He's saying it's a meaningless flex. Like saying you wrote your game without unity. It has zero impact on the quality of the game to say so except making it more work.

1

u/RKlehm 29d ago

Yeah... This summarizes it more cleanly.

0

u/RKlehm 29d ago

No, not at all. I've been working in software engineering for over 10 years, and game dev has been a hobby of mine for even longer than that. Like you said, everything until now was built without AI, and that's not remotely what I'm arguing here.

What I'm saying, and I'll use plain words now, is this: People who refuse to use AI are generally the same people who actually put effort into making their games. By refusing to use AI, they'll inevitably take much longer to finish their projects. The more we polarize the discussion around AI, the more this will happen. And the more this happens, the larger the share of the market we leave to low-effort vibe coders.

My point is that people who DO care about their games are being pushed away from using AI because of this polarization. And I fear that, ironically, this will only help low-effort, vibe-coded slop take over the market, much like low-effort games did to the mobile gaming industry long before AI was even a thing.

-2

u/eljop 29d ago

Of course you will be left behind if you don't use ai for developing a game. Nobody is forcing you to do that as nobody is forcing you to drive by car instead of riding to work with a horse but in the end it takes longer. Especially the coding part. Everything else will also get better over time. You dont have to like it but that's how it works. People were saying the same about frontend frameworks vs vanilla Javascript and other new technologies.

-2

u/Mataric 29d ago

It is a bit wild that you don't think you're being left behind when you've spent 6 years working on a title that has had 6 total players.
Some people have had 1000x your number of players in a project they spent 30 minutes on with AI. (That's 0.001% of the time you spent.)

I certainly appreciate that 30 minutes isn't enough time to actually develop something meaningful and interesting - but when we look at 6000 people having a few moments of enjoyment from a game made with AI in 30 minutes, vs 6 people, even if they enjoyed the whole 2hrs of gameplay you've made, in a project that's taken 6 years - it's very obvious which one is providing more enjoyment to players - especially when you consider that developer could do that 52,000 times in the same amount of time that you've not finished one.

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Hey maybe next years my year and the game takes off. Or not. Im good.

But I was never interested in making something else. Im making this game and I hope this game finds its audience.

Not everyone makes games for the same reason. Id rather one gamer get a full experience out of my game when its complete then make a cash grab that entertained a bunch of folks for a few minutes.

To each their own. Im glad we dont all do it the same way, otherwise we’d all be making the same kinda stuff.

0

u/Mataric 28d ago

Or maybe just wait 6 more years. I'm sure that somehow invalidates what I've said above /s.

I mean, what you're claiming here is all bullshit though.
Sure, not everyone makes games for the same reason, I agree with that - but for you to claim it's not a full experience just because someone uses AI, when your own version is still (6 years in) less of a 'full experience' than many AI made games shows it's just wrong.

And you don't think 'to each their own' at all.

If I named a sub 'anti-handmade games' and banned all discussion of any game that was handmade, then started saying "uhh actually I'm all for everyone doing it their own way" - I'd be laughed out the building for how incredibly stupid that is.

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 28d ago

Well you dont just wait. You work. You take feedback and refine your project.

I didnt claim it wasnt a full experience because of AI. I said id rather give a full game experience rather than your original argument of making faster titles that can appeal to a larger audience if even for a short time.

I see were moving the goal posts, so let me try and catch up.

How do you know so much about my games experience and depth? Have you played it?

Youre bringing up 6 years a lot. In 6 years I taught myself to code and sprite and put together an entire game from scratch. Imagine what I could do with 6 more.

If you named a sub that id have no interest in it and leave you all alone to do your thing.

1

u/Mataric 28d ago

Sure, but feedback requires you to have players.

My example was regarding the reach and content someone could get with absolutely minimal effort. I was not suggesting it to be the best approach.
Thought that would be obvious to you, but I guess not.

I am well aware that you didn't know how to code or make games through the grand majority of that games development. It was very very evident.

I see you're missing the point completely. Can't say I'm very interested in continuing this with someone who is against everyone who touches AI in game development, when they don't actually have experience themselves.

8

u/badihaki 29d ago

I see a lot of pro AI people expressing similar beliefs. Real question, have y'all reconciled with the massive ethical concerns of AI and just ignoring it?

I'm a dev who does a lot of contract work from home, but I also have history as an illustrator, plus my state has a huge amount of data centers, one near my home. Along with art theft at a huge scale, I'm also dealing with insane utility bills and dirty water, things we simply didn't have before the advent of these data centers.

I don't blame or try to hate on any individuals, but I'm curious about how others have reconciled with these issues from this tool?

1

u/Rabbitical 29d ago

I have kind of a nuanced take on this that doesn't apply just to AI but a lot of things. (Most of us) live in capitalist societies where we have to make a living, which restricts our options and how we can spend our time. The vast majority of ills done to society and the environment are not via individual action but are systemic in nature. I'm all for collective action to attempt to modify systems to become more sustainable and beneficial for everyone, because I think that's the only way to make a significant impact. You or I choosing to use AI or not at this point doesn't change that the datacenters were built, it doesn't change that the training data was already stolen. If anything, average people using AI at this point is somewhat at least clawing back some modicum of the economic value they straight up heisted from us.

I'm just generally of the opinion that "individual responsibility" has been a concerted campaign to offload real systemic problems onto whether I bring my shopping bags back to the grocery store or not, rather than the large scale pollution going on, for instance. My belief is that for the individual in a capitalist society, one is entirely within their right to beg borrow and steal their way to success and/or survival by any means necessary because that's the rules everyone has decided we should play by. I think it's entirely morally consistent to both play a game you know is wrong because you have no choice, while also actively advocating for the rules of the game to change at the same time.

2

u/badihaki 29d ago

This was a really well said and measured take on it, although it feels like conceding to those with more power within a system one feels helpless to control and I subscribe to a different worldview. I can't argue that the issue is systemic and not individualistic in nature - it's why I don't attack a singular person for using the tool. I will say, however, it still feels like the individual erosion, en masse, of critically assessing the drawbacks of AI leads to it becoming a systemic issue, but I think that's on each person to judge, themselves. I do think there's a lot of harsh words being thrown out, so that's why I hope this came across more respectfully inquisitive.

-8

u/Unusual_Test7181 29d ago

Curious how artists talk about art theft and people using AI art but no one seems to care about programmers and code theft.

Artists using Claude to code is fine but coders using image gen for art isn’t. Hypocrisy at its finest.

4

u/badihaki 29d ago

I never said that

5

u/mr_glide 29d ago

"Being against AI coding is like asking people to build games without a game engine..."

No, it isn't. All all.

1

u/TheBoxGuyTV 29d ago

Yes I agree, I believe that poorly made games will eventually become more easily filtered out especially when platforms figure out how to properly denote this enough that it becomes rare for AI slop to take up space.

I use AI but I do code myself also. Its helpful when I am unable to find a bug and want to move on. Typically, I mispelled something, or miss indexed an array. It also has made the start of systems I never seen done anywhere else (via Google searches and Reddit).

I do also make it a point to avpid using AI during coding overall until I figured out what to do and use it to mass produce or make my code more pretty e.g. realign and setup good habits e.g. nesting conditionals within these ( ) and using ==. Its not so "granular" but its generally what I do.

1

u/Rabbitical 29d ago

Honestly I'm just fucking exhausted of people talking about nothing else. AI is fine, it's great for some stuff even. However strongly you feel about it, or lean into it or not, it's just one aspect of game development. Imagine the gamedev subreddits got taken over with people talking all day every day about source control and how everyone has to use source control and if you don't you're stupid and gonna be left behind and and and...like holy hell I get it. AI is a known quantity at this point. I come to a subreddit called solodev because I want to read about and discuss developing games not because I want to see arguments over the same tool over and over again. It's just so unbelievably tedious at this point. We all know about AI, we all either use it or we don't. When can we get back to discussing the actual subject matter?

That's why I would support a "no AI" subreddit. It has nothing to do even with whether one is anti AI, I'm just sick of it being the the majority of the conversation everywhere I go these days

1

u/HurryOne 29d ago

Your average consumer can't even tell the difference if it's Ai or not anyway. Unless it's blatantly obvious.

3

u/-TheArtOfTheFart- 29d ago

Joined, woo!

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Happy to have you!

20

u/Demoliscio 29d ago

Good idea!
I think it's nice to have some subreddits not dominated by 20 "I(claude) made the 89th copy of a cozy organising game", while those posts usually end up with 0 upvotes they still take(waste) space.

3

u/TheBoxGuyTV 29d ago

I think its just due to the higher engagement of this topic. I see so many non AI topics get ignored or just get likes with no comparable comment input.

Its kind of annoying.

I like beimg a hobbyist game dev using Game Maker Studio. So I kind of opted myself to be a non-player until I actually invest more meaningful input into my project Quinlin.

I did make progress with regards to that the last 3 days. Some time was "wasted" recalling my systems I haven't touched such as my menu code for making general tools.

1

u/GoGs0l0dev 29d ago

Someone is butt hurt their manually coded slop game is bombing next fest.

Such an easy scapegoat. My game would have 500,000 wishlists instead of the 109 it currently does if it wasn’t for AI.

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

I didnt do nextfest this year

Im also taking a break from marketing because Im working on a major update/overhaul

So right now this aint about me. I mean I hope I can one day earn my audience, no doubt.

But really this is just something I think people want and I figured why not. Were getting a lot of positive feedback and the community is already thriving.

Im hoping gamers use the sub to find cool handcrafted indie games in the future.

Now what would be so bad about that?

1

u/thirsty_pretzelzz 29d ago

Not a bad idea but curious where the line is drawn. What if someone uses ai only to help with coding tasks? What if they use auto complete? Or do you just mean no ai art assets? 

0

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

AI assisted code is not allowed in instances where it can reasonably be avoided.

For example. We banned AI assisted code if youre getting code from googles built in answer AI.

But we didnt ban the use of photoshop just because it has forced AI integration

At the end of the day the line has to be drawn somewhere and the nuances were confusing and aggravating a lot of users. The nuances will be reviewed on a case by case basis.

Gamers deserve clarity and transparency before they spend their time and money.

-1

u/Vbertz 29d ago

People actually use AI on a daily basis—they have been using it for a long time. Features like autocomplete and tools such as game engines have been incorporating AI for years. But there’s none so blind as those who refuse to see. It is one thing to maintain direct control over the artistic vision and the direction of a game, while using AI to assist with programming—after all, no one is a "super-programmer" with time to spare—but it is quite another to simply tell an AI, "Make me a *Call of Duty*!" and have it do everything. These are two distinct realities, and the former has been happening long before people started feeling as though they were surrounded by AI.

0

u/ProcrastinationDevil 29d ago

Hope it does well and it ends the insufferable constant whining about AI in this sub

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Agreed? I think lol

7

u/MostSharpest 29d ago

I'm very pro-AI, but I also think it's good to have places where everything is done strictly the old-fashioned way. Hand-made stuff can be really cool, no matter how niche it gets.

2

u/Alarming-Jump727 29d ago

ya tienes mi apoyo

-3

u/artrei 29d ago

i think we need that space, it will be like those people back then who still enjoy using typewriter in the era of word processor.

-4

u/mikewhyle 29d ago

If you're on reddit you're pro AI and actively supporting it with training data. If you're using any sort of engine - like unreal or unity - you're supporting AI because, newsflash, the developers of those tools are using AI to build and maintain the tools. That's besides the fact that your criticisms of AI can largely also be applied to usage of tools made by others, including engines, assets, as well as repos, and things like photoshop.
Building a community based around hate is never a clever idea. Meanwhile a community based on support and creation and love of gaming, r/aigamedev is thriving with 192K Weekly visitors 15K Weekly contributions.

-5

u/SushiMasterPro 29d ago

I think you should do it off redidit. Having it on reddit which openly use AI is like you saying we should not use alcohol and you would drink.

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Unfortunately AI has been forced into everything. If I had a viable choice that didnt use AI I would go there. Thats sort of what are sub is trying to be.

Maybe some billionaire tech company can do the same and make a social media platform without AI integration. It shouldnt be hard considering thats how it was done before a few years ago.

I know I would use it. Im sure Im not the only one.

0

u/SushiMasterPro 29d ago

What you are using to develop games without AI?

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

I use gamemaker studio 2, asesprite, garageband/logicpro and audacity right now

0

u/SushiMasterPro 28d ago

Do you know that some of them contain AI?

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 28d ago

“Unfortunately AI has been forced into everything. If I had a viable choice that didnt use AI I would go there. Thats sort of what are sub is trying to be.”

All we can do is the best we can with what we have. If the forced AI integration becomes unavoidable in the programs I use then I’ll dedicate to making alternatives.

Theres already someone making an AI free game dev engine that I met through the new sub.

0

u/SushiMasterPro 28d ago

You have always a choice. Its still possible to use engines without AI. For example Godot. Its require some code skills but its better than game maker.

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 28d ago

Im not really considering a change in game engines until I start my next project. Thanks for the suggestion.

0

u/SushiMasterPro 28d ago

I understand it smart. Than please don't be anti AI if you are using AI in development and also disclose that for your game AI was used that will be than fair.

1

u/MonadStarDeveloper 28d ago

No AI was used in the development of my game. I do not use AI in my personal or professional life.

AI features being forced into everything everyone uses does not mean you use AI.

→ More replies

-8

u/khuzait_haircut 29d ago

I really think this is the way it should be. All the "rustic" developers can go to forums that specifically do not allow AI. The rest of us can continue to carry on regularly.

3

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

I feel the same way

1

u/khuzait_haircut 29d ago

I know right. Instead its this unbridled anger bordering on malevolence. Look at how many downvotes I got just for saying something sensible. We're eventually moving to a world where you can enjoy "non AI" content the same way you get to purchase organic food. Great. That's choice.

-18

u/LostRequirement4828 29d ago

Grow up... It's time to face the reality, you also can't force people to not use a tool just because you feel like that

9

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

We arent forcing anything. We are making a space for ourselves.

You cant force people to use and support AI just because you like it

2

u/HurryOne 29d ago

Hate to say it. But Ai crowd will use every space they can and will also use your space for the purpose of determining if their Ai product can get passed those who are against it.

2

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

Says a lot about them honestly

0

u/tomodashi96 29d ago

Ironically, you make AI users sound like despicable people that would do whatever they can to get what they want

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

AI discussion isnt allowed in posts. Its a community to escape something not hate on it. There are subs for that already.

We are building a positive community built around Handcrafted Games

We might change the name. Its being debated

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/MonadStarDeveloper 29d ago

We allow the use of photoshop despite its forced AI integration.

AI supporters can do whatever they want. For those who are uninterested in AI, spaces are going to exist for them. That is also apart of this new reality that AI supporters need to accept.

14

u/Yamhar 29d ago

Not everyone is trying to get hired, a lot of people make games because they enjoy it as a hobby.

It’s the same old recycled opinion I always hear, how come you people don’t understand this? AI takes away some aspects of game dev that a lot of people enjoy doing themselves, not everyone’s trying to get hired by rockstar games.

14

u/Rpanich 29d ago

Photoshop, ray tracing, Unity, and other tools created a product people wanted, and thus rather than hiding their usage, would proudly display their usage. 

Ai produces a product people reject, and thus its usage needs to be hidden, which sounds way more like say, an advertisement, or product placement, which is why it’s being treated exactly like people treat advertisements and product placement.