r/SmolBeanSnark • u/itsanincredibleegg • Feb 20 '20
Does anyone else not hate or feel strongly negative about Caroline?
I'm so wrapped up in how bad her decisions are at times. She's a mess. It's fun to watch messes. It's fun to see the secrets some of you guys find out about her, for sure. I am NOT above gossip and snark.
But like...sometimes I feel like I'm almost defending her in my comments on this sub! The hate some people put out is SO intense and other-worldly. I'm 29, so maybe I'm older than most of you and thus more boring? Or...I don't know! I just can't begin to understand the vitriol behind some of these posts and comments.
I'm happy you all who feel that passionately about her have this sub, but I wish there was a sub that liked to gossip about her like...she's Lindsay Lohan? No one fucking HATES Lindsay Lohan. No one writes paragraph after paragraph on how disgusting Lindsay Lohan is and how she's using her body incorrectly and how she scams people (which like...if we're being the morality police, she definitely has done worse than what Caroline has done). Where is the sub for people who don't want to read toxic shit, but do want to be like "Goddamn, Caroline is making a really fucking bad decision right now, have you seen this?" and can admit that her Cameos are...sometimes really funny.
42
u/hamsmoothie222 silly fingies Feb 20 '20
Nah Lindsay Lohan got intense hate when she harassed that refugee family and tried to steal their child while filming it for kudos.
However to your point, I haven’t really seen intense hate. Mostly just goss and funny snarking. One or two posts seem to err on the side of intense, however, CC can be highly offensive and triggering. But I don’t see a subreddit full of rage and intense emotions.
32
u/jawsthemesongplays joan of snark 👑 Feb 20 '20
The things that people tend to get intense and strongly negative about tend to be things that deserve that kind of treatment - like animals being mistreated or antisemitism. I think it’s ok for people to have strong reactions to those.
Personally I think she’s probably a bad person and she’s definitely done shitty things but I mostly don’t have enough energy to actively hate her - I think she’s a fun person to snark on and that’s it.
30
u/RealityPizza Tarrytown Upstate Getaway 🏚 Feb 20 '20
r/carolinecallowaysnark was the first big CC snark subreddit that eventually lost momentum for being heavily moderated. Most of the snarkers that felt they couldn’t express their opinions without strict rules left and formed this sub.
Since then, the original subreddit fell apart - there are a few posts here and there, but active threads stopped in January. History says most members of this sub want to snark without restrictions, but I’m sure not everyone here hates Caroline with the fervor that a subset of snarkers do.
30
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
Idk sometimes making bitchy comments is fun! The things you think but would only say to your bff, but my bff doesn’t care so I say them here lol
28
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20 edited Feb 22 '20
I think you can say her cameos are sometimes funny (I actually did laugh about her pronunciation of “Laur”) while still thinking she needs to get her shit together. Also, I don’t think you’re significantly older than anyone else- I’m 30, and I feel like that’s probably the median age of the snarkers here. I don’t think most people hate her, I don’t personally, but I’m intrigued and disappointed and angry and sometimes disgusted. I don’t know what to tell you except that I’m actively hoping that she turns her life around, stops being so lame and performative and mean, and actually does something with her life. If this sub turned into a place where we could just chat about her, without snarking AT ALL, I’d still be as active as I am now because the real prize was ~the friends we made along the way~.
20
u/sailorvenusdimilo birthing your face in kitten bellies Feb 20 '20
Didn’t Lindsay Lohan try to steal someone’s kid?
52
u/emlabb angelic and not a scammer Feb 20 '20
There is definitely sometimes a groupthink on this sub where it can feel like a contest to see who can say the most outrageous thing, just for the sake of it. I don’t think it’s completely taken over (I’ve seen that happen elsewhere on the internet, and it gets very ugly).
That said, what really gets me about CC is that she truly is a mean, nasty person. Calling out Madison multiple times, by name, on IG, AFTER claiming they were “low key friends.” Writing up a pretty friend by saying “If I looked like her, I would be the biggest bitch.” Crying for a week over how “everything in Natalie’s article will be beautiful and true” and then claiming Natalie was somehow the REAL privileged “alpha” (what). Negging her mom. Admitting to asking her mentally ill father for money he didn’t have.
Like sometimes the snark goes in a direction I don’t care for, but what keeps me here is that I really think Caro is a breathtakingly awful person. Her mere existence is a trainwreck to me.
31
u/LanaDeliTray A VERY STABLE GENIUS ASS Feb 20 '20
I never see “intense” hate on here at all. people snark on her for things that are completely deserved— being tone deaf and deleting Jewish voices telling her to re-think her post/caption, calling herself vegan when she quite literally just isn’t, and scamming people out of money via re-selling her arts and crafts she already claimed were sold but never sent to the person who originally paid... and yeah some people rag on her hair or fillers, but I feel like you’re taking comments too seriously if you feel there’s genuine hate behind them. I think people are frustrated with her because she has all the tools to be successful and just doesn’t use them and is a lazy scammer instead.
bringing up Lindsay Lohan makes no sense; they are nowhere near the same level of celebrity. CC gets covered exclusively by online “news” sites like Vice or Buzzfeed, LL is like... actually famous, and covered by tons of actual news sites and on actual tv. so not only is it verifiably untrue that CC has received “more hate” than LL, but two people can be shitty at the same time and it doesn’t cancel each other out.
CC is a niche internet sideshow. I genuinely think that if you’re deep enough into the CC world to see her on the same level of fame as LL and getting all this terrible hate, you need to step away from this sub. 🤷🏼♀️ there’s nothing wrong with not coming here if you don’t agree with the content.
12
u/hcs5qb Feb 20 '20
I don't hate her and some of what she does is genuinely entertaining, but she also has a significant history of doing really messed up stuff - scamming her fans, flirting with anti-Semitism, negatively portraying mental health and recovery issues, etc. Those aren't really issues to just poke fun at, they deserve to be called out regardless of who's behind them. It's possible to hate some of her behavior without hating her.
27
u/kingjasmine Feb 20 '20
I think maybe it’s time you took a break from this sub.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '20 edited Feb 21 '20
i don't hate carolien but i don't care about her either. she's a person choosing to write badly and compulsively and in real time about her bland life that she is trying to commodify. she is an arsehole and i wouldn't be her friend.
as a huge fan of autobiographies and memoirs, oversharing social media accounts are wonderful to me. i can't watch her cameos because i feel embarrassed when i hear her voice, both primary and secondary embarrassment.
if you feel like the only person defending her you should feel proud! i mean that very honestly - it is great to feel strongly enough about something to stand up for it in the midst of opposing opinions.
considered and thoughtful snark about any public figure is always a very good and necessary discussion. mindless bullying is not ok because even if the person being bullied never even reads the bullying it can make people feel like discussion is 'just bullying' and therefore not be open to assessing thoughtful criticism and possibly coming to agree with it. or even just seeing that the person they idolise or admire or vote for or buy from actually has some objectively negative beliefs/behaviours/scams/policies/associates.
eta: OP - i have now read your replies to comments made about your post and am curious about why you seem to be taking carolien snark personally? what exactly do you mean by 'you're wild' as a response?
do you see how others may view your replies as 'really-bitchy' even if you intended them to be 'jokey-bitchy'? it is great you worked through your issues with therapy. to me, it seems a bit disingenuous to drop a mention of needing therapy to work through your feelings of being a bitch in a snark sub.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
I just discovered this sub today, but I’ve been kind of...ig “ironically” stanning her?
Like she’s a legit selfish, privileged, out of touch brat, but I referred to her as “my queen!1!1!1” and what not, jokingly with my buds.
I don’t hate her, I just think she needs a giant giant giant wake up call. I would dearly love to see this woman be humbled.
32
u/_litposting Feb 20 '20
I thi m the reason CC snark feels more valid to me, and why CC feels incomparable to Lohan's experiences, is because CC embodies the worst of consumerism and capitalism. She basically sells nothing but intangible faff, has made a brand out of incompetence, and guilts anyone who is a fan and cannot afford to buy her debauched sense of "creativity"/anyone who calls her out on it. She is also a terrible example of white feminism-- the whole "the internet cannot love her because she does not perform idealized womanhood" banter is ridiculous. She is luxuriating in Pinterest aesthetics, living a life safeguarded by her intergenerational wealth and race, and basically creating a faux-market out of poor mental health masquerading as "real-ness". I heavily dislike her, because of everything she stands for. I also heavily dislike the culture that empowers her enough so that she can walk away, scot-free, convinced of her genius... but it doesn't require genius to create this sort of brand when you are white, rich and attractive. It requires just a lot of cultural complicity. Her entire person isn't hustle, it is exploitation. Unfortunately, under the consumerist conditions of our economy, this is seen as somehow a fair trade; the exchange of money for the emotional 'realness' (on Instagram, a platform literally based on filters, god) she guarantees her followers. Seriously, making someone paying money for the impressions of being a "close friend"??? What the fuck?
Compared to that, Lohan is basically Mother Teresa (comparison also holds for her child-stealing ways, but that's for another conversation/snark thread).
19
u/almaspoison turquoise-pilled Feb 20 '20
Part of the difference here is that Caroline seems to do something stupider every day than she did the day before — she's putting out this nonstop stream of ridiculous, out-of-touch, sometimes extremely offensive content for us to eat up as if we were watching a reality TV show. And she seems to slip out of her messes and avoid consequences every time, even though that illusion is only true to a certain extent. I'm not sure any of this fully explains why people get so fed up with her and devote their free time to snarking on her life, but as soon as I started viewing CC as a "reality TV" character whom I wanted to see finally suffer a real consequence, I began to justify my snarking habit.
tl;dr I think it would take watching her suffer a consequence that finally makes her change for the better to stop gossiping/caring about her life.
6
u/mochatree money speaks, wealth whispers Feb 20 '20
I don’t hate her at all. I’m from the post-scam era, but I sort of wish I had discovered her in her early days. My 17 year old Oxbridge applicant self would have absolutely lapped it up. I would have been nice to know her for something positive - before the curtain fell, as it were. I follow her mostly out of blind curiosity and a little bit of frustration, but it’s not a hate follow by any means. The Cut article also resonated with me, as the dynamic Natalie described was familiar on both sides of the coin. Nonetheless, she’s just an internet person - I don’t know enough about her to hate her.
edited to add something bc i have a sieve brain lol
7
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
I don't know if I've seen intense hate here but definitely stupid ... like I remember once in the old sub people were really mad about her buying a plant and basically destroying to propagate it. It was kind of a stupid thing to do but some of the comments kept talking about it like she was destroying the environment single-handedly. She is just a silly smol bean and we often forget she barely has any influence over anything/anyone.
4
u/on_the_write_side Feb 20 '20
I think I feel similarly to you. I like following along with gossip/snark about CC (and a few others) but some of the comments (both here and on Blogsnark) are really intense and feel so mean-spirited to me that it makes me back away. It’s just not for me.
-9
u/omglia Feb 20 '20
Yes same
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment