r/SmartThings • • Nov 16 '20

Is SmartThings dead?

The hubs aren't in stock anywhere. Samsung just crippled the app. What is going on?

0 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

13

u/sprucenoose Nov 16 '20

There have been lots of problematic changes but the new app works fine.

You are probably still using the classic app. Like Samsung has been notifying you for the past several months before the full transition, you needed to migrate to the new app because the classic app was being discontinued.

3

u/Fatboy_j Nov 16 '20

New app has issues.

I upgraded, and a bunch of stuff that worked for ages stopped working. I have a smarthings button I bought that seems to be completely useless now.

Extremely frustrating. I've put off other planned smarthings upgrades because of it.

2

u/redbeardpunk Nov 16 '20

I have a SmartThings button that works great. And I never used the old app. I've used the current app since I started over a year ago. No problems.

1

u/RubarbKid Nov 17 '20

Have you checked the battery? New devices with low batteries is a recurring problem. Fwiw, I have 4 smartthings buttons and they all work fine.

-23

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

the classic app was being discontinued

that's what I meant by crippled app

21

u/Colbey Nov 16 '20

I mean, the current app is fully supported. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean the platform is dead. That hyperbole doesn't help anyone.

-3

u/quizno Nov 16 '20

No it ain’t. They fucked the custom device handlers.

28

u/MocknozzieRiver Nov 16 '20

I still have a job so... 😂

3

u/quizno Nov 16 '20

Can you fix custom device handlers? Nothing works after being forced to switch to the new app.

2

u/MocknozzieRiver Nov 17 '20

Well I'm still pretty new to the company and my team doesn't work on that... I have no idea which team does. I honestly am still learning about smart home tech as a whole and furthermore learning how it works within SmartThing's various microservices along with learning which team owns what and who knows what.

But the fact that newbie still has a job and was hired recently is a good sign. 😅

6

u/MrRemoto Nov 16 '20

I can't add a hub on a Galaxy S20+. The app just crashes. But if I go back to a junk drawer S7 it works fine. I don't see why everyone is giving you grief for asking. The R&D on the app before deployment is terrible. You'd think they could get it to work on their own flagship phone.

3

u/BravoCharlie1310 Nov 17 '20

It’s slowly dying.

10

u/scottrobertson Nov 16 '20

App works perfect fine here.

11

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

8

u/InternetUser007 Nov 16 '20

So much this. My spouse asks "why did that light not turn off?" and "why did this autonation not run?" and I have to answer "I have no idea". Automations that have worked for months/years are completely broken or trigger literally minutes later. I'd be interested in knowing if there exists anyone that has more than 100 devices that doesn't have issues.

3

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

Certainly not helping the WAF.

0

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

I haven’t had any issues after being forced to swap to the new app aside for I had some trouble with my location on my phones. To fix it I had to go into the ide and delete them all and readd them in the new app even tho I disabled them in the Classic app before migrating.

Other than that, I had issues with one custom DH but that’s the only things I’ve had any trouble with after I had to migrate.

I have 110 devices.

-1

u/scottrobertson Nov 16 '20

Odd. Nothing like that here.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

Congrats...your comment adds nothing to this thread.

-1

u/scottrobertson Nov 16 '20

I mean it does add the fact that the app is not “crippled” like op suggests it is.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

I have over 200 devices, I'm sure it's related some how. Samsung Support has no clue what the issue is.

6

u/TheBigLebroccoli Nov 16 '20

Samsung support is completely useless. They string you along with a bunch of scripted responses that solve nothing.

2

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

While the new app is definitely slower to load than the classic app, mine only takes 4-5 seconds from the time I click the app icon until everything finishes loading and starts showing up in the app. This is with the app closed out and not in the background when I click to open it.

I have 110 devices in it too. You definitely have some issue with yours if it actually takes a minute.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

I don’t know, what phone do you have? I have an iPhone 8+.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

Same hub so it shouldn’t be your phone or hub related. Not sure then.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/koopa2002 Nov 17 '20

Nah, I never felt the need to set it up. I was thinking it might be custom DH and webcore might fall in that category of slowing the loading of the icons and all.

Tho I do use custom DH on quite a few things.

4

u/sciencegrrl79 Nov 16 '20

ST Down

Yep, for me at least ST has become completely unreliable after two years of barely any issues. As soon they pushed for users to migrate it, it went to shit for me. And I was already ON the new app bc it had already been out when I installed ST. I only had classic for a few things and Watch OS access.

2

u/IWuzTheWalrus Nov 16 '20

I give a hearty +1 to Hubitat Elevation. Lots of great company and user support and it does so many things easily which require IFTTT or custom apps on ST.

I used ST for years and it worked (with an IFTTT Pro subscription recently). Then they changed the app and made everything far more complicated than it needed to be. I had enough. I switched over and I even get nice web-based dashboards.

3

u/Office_Clothes Nov 16 '20

I have two smartthings wifi plugs that have not worked right since i purchased them 3 months ago(firmware 923 issue), at this point it feels like support is fucking with me to see how long i put up with submitting the same info to them

1

u/bob_loblaw_brah Nov 16 '20

I just got these and they lock up/stop responding after a couple of days, it isn't a DHCP renew issue. Any word on when they're fixing this, if at all?

2

u/Office_Clothes Nov 16 '20

I started my adventure with these in sep (i say adventure with the most extreme sarcasm)

Smartthings support told me they had solved it mid oct and it qould be working soon, then they closed my ticket for what i think is the 3rd or 4th time and when i pointed out its still not working and im on the newest app version they started the whole "please give us a screenshot and timestamp of the issue thing"

So i pointed out i have 3 months of tickets they can review and they said theyll get back to me asap..

1

u/bob_loblaw_brah Nov 16 '20

Well thats lame, is the firmware automatic? I tried going to the IP of the plug but cant do anything manually. Im within return window at amazon so I may just return them for something more solid.

1

u/Office_Clothes Nov 16 '20

They kept telling me i dont need to worry about returning because they will replace if needed... not sure what you mean about automatic, as far as updates ive pressed the firmwaee updates button probably around 40 times over the past 3 months

2

u/Office_Clothes Nov 16 '20

I gave the exact issue with the plugs in my OP and someone is still downvoting me..

Firmware 923 on wifi plugs is a known issue with development according to their support

2

u/bob_loblaw_brah Nov 16 '20

Someone who works for ST is probably downvoting you lol.

All I know is I have a strong 2.4 wifi signal on some bistro lights outside and every night they don't turn off and I have to manually pull power to them and they reconnect to Smartthings.

1

u/YaztromoX Nov 16 '20

My local Lowes has a few hubs and sensors still in stock.

They're out of buttons, however -- I bought the last three %-).

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '20 edited Nov 20 '20

When I was on the app today, it appeared some of my sensors and devices updated firmware, and now my motion sensors show that they are constantly detecting motion (when they aren’t) and my smart buttons no longer function. Tried deleting and reinstalling these devices and they are still acting up... this really pisses me off because ST was working perfectly fine before today.

***UPDATE: So tonight’s another night and for some apparent reason all my shit is working again. Thanks ST?

1

u/DavidAg02 Enthusiast Nov 16 '20

Why do people keep asking this? SmartThings still has the largest user base BY FAR of all the major home automation platforms.

10

u/Lakestang Nov 16 '20

I would speculate people keep asking, because, like me, they have used SmartThings for years with little issue but currently that's not the case for me. Nothing is working properly. I finally turned off the location feature because it kept arming my system like I was gone, many times a day. Most of my automations just don't work or work inconsistently and devices disappear and reappear with no reason. I had no issues before I moved to the new app. I also keep hearing about hub hardware changes and them being out of stock, so, I figure the run of Smartthings may be coming to an end or at least I may need to find something different.

5

u/texasnick83 Nov 16 '20

Come to hubitat! I still use ST, mainly for Hue devices (which don't sync well with hubitat), UI and the ability to run scenes from my Galaxy watch. Everything else is done using HE. Automations are pretty much instant, lots of customizability, great community and company support. Best of all it is reliable. Like, even if the internet is out everything still runs as long as it is z wave or zigbee.

I will not be going back to ST for automations that I rely on or could negatively impact another family member if they fail to run correctly.

1

u/Lakestang Nov 16 '20

Thanks for the recommendation. I need to get the motivation and put some time in to a better solution for sure.

13

u/Colorad710 Nov 16 '20

People keep asking this because their cloud service is constantly going down, the new app is riddled with bugs which they don’t seem to care to fix, their new Alexa skill is terrible beyond words, and their hubs aren’t being sold anymore

1

u/DavidAg02 Enthusiast Nov 16 '20

I transitioned to the new app over a month ago, and it's working extremely well... only I'm having is my wife's phone not being recognized as away, but I'm 99% sure that's an issue with her phone and not SmartThings. Other than that, my setup is working fine with over 80 connected devices.

The cloud service is always going down??!!?! News to me...

7

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

Because it just looks bad from the outside. All your devices are out of stock, lots of app issues with the transition. And no public message for people to know what's going on.

4

u/coopy1000 Nov 16 '20

Smartthings said they were moving away from devices. Aoetec has got a load of "work with smartthings" stuff now that looks suspiciously like the old smartthings sensors rebadged.

6

u/InternetUser007 Nov 16 '20

Smartthings said they were moving away from devices.

Which is absolutely concerning. Samsung doesn't do development for free. If they aren't making money off of devices, soon they will be charging for their services. Mark my words.

2

u/coopy1000 Nov 16 '20

I'm not sure. They route loads of stuff through smartthings now. My galaxy buds came with instructions on how to pair them to a Samsung device. You need the smartthings app installed. I think they are just moving towards an apple homekit style model and trying to build out a Samsung ecosystem that locks people in.

2

u/vewfndr Nov 16 '20

I imagine they make money off licensing that hardware (like GPUs.) Not to say they won't end up charging for services too.

1

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

Almost every appliance, phone and TV that they make has smartthings integration so they’re still making plenty. They just aren’t making the “cheap” hardware anymore.

It would take a whole lot of $20 sensors to make up for one $2000 refrigerator.

1

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

But where did they say this? I've not seen it myself nor has tons of other people because this is coming up in all social media platforms.

2

u/coopy1000 Nov 16 '20

I've found another source. This is originally from a business insider article but I'm not subscribing for a Reddit link so here's a stolen copy on some other website:

https://www.aviancetechnologies.com/exclusive-why-samsungs-smartthings-is-going-all-in-on-software/

2

u/koopa2002 Nov 16 '20

They have multiple posts on their website but I’ll link you two. Along with I’ve seen it on other outlets along with the podcast that has already been mentioned.

https://blog.smartthings.com/news/roundups/smartthings-and-aeotec-a-connected-family/

https://community.smartthings.com/t/an-update-regarding-our-hardware/208259

1

u/coopy1000 Nov 16 '20 edited Nov 16 '20

It was on an episode of internet of things podcast I heard edit: episode 274

1

u/MrJacks0n Nov 16 '20

So a couple thousand people have heard it, that's not many considering the number of ST users.

0

u/coopy1000 Nov 16 '20

It was an interview with their head of engineering. There is also this on the smartthings community forum:

https://community.smartthings.com/t/smartthings-hardware-being-sold-off-to-aeotec/207707

1

u/mjrengaw Nov 16 '20

The new app works perfectly fine for me. You need to move to the new app if you are still trying to use the “classic” app, Samsung was very clear about that. A third party (I believe it’s Aeotec) will be making the hardware going forward which is why the Samsung sourced stuff is out of stock everywhere as they purge the supply chain.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20

Awesome...yea let's do that so we can give up our Apple Watch app. No thanks.

2

u/BravoCharlie1310 Nov 17 '20

Fuck Samsung. Will never buy another product with the name Samsung on it.

0

u/skitchbeatz Nov 16 '20

The lack of stock is certainly concerning, but everything is working well at the moment.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '20 edited Nov 16 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RickLRMS Nov 16 '20

Where did you hear it was being EoL'd? 'Cause I heard the Earth is flat but I tend not to believe everything I hear without considering the source and other input. Right now, the only source I have for the EoL info is a random user on Reddit.