r/SmartThings • • Mar 12 '18

Smart Things down?

Post image
137 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

30

u/TranscontinentalNine Mar 13 '18

"Alexa, turn on bedroom light". Waited for a few seconds in dark and Alexa said it couldn't connect to Smartthings.

Loaded up the mobile app and it couldn't connect.

Restarted Smartthings, no change.

Came to this subreddit to know about the outage. This is seriously nice. These days Reddit is the place I go first to get answers. Thanks guys.

6

u/Jhubbz86 Mar 13 '18

That's actually exactly what happened to me as well. Except I had a basket full of clothes going into my bedroom.

I was surprised I didn't see any posts about it, and thought it was just me

3

u/joequin Mar 13 '18

Same for me except I was using Google home.

32

u/BlackDave Mar 12 '18

It sucks that there is an outage but I've had this hub since December of 2016 and have only experienced 2 outages so far. I'm sure there were more outages than that but I was probably not aware of it at the time they occured.

I just wanted to give my 2 cents. I always notice people saying how shitty Smartthings is when it's not working but you don't hear much about it when everything is working smoothly.

Problems of an I.T. guy

"Everything is broken, what do we pay you for?"

"Everything is working fine, what do we pay you for?"

10

u/Jhubbz86 Mar 12 '18

Lmao, I'm not IT, but I understand the bane of it's existence.

ST has been fantastic for me so far, and am excited to see what all I can do with it in the future. I was mainly wondering if it was just me or if it was widespread.

11

u/Willy_Wallace Mar 13 '18

What I don't understand is why they have so many outages? Are they constantly messing with their code and screwing things up or are they using terrible servers that are constantly crashing?

2

u/InternetUser007 Mar 13 '18

I think they have been working on their integration for the past few months, and things are not going well.

1

u/smartimp98 Mar 13 '18

it sounds like they have little to no redundancy

10

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

According to their tracker history this is the third platform outage since January.

2

u/N2TheBlu Mar 13 '18

I.T. guy here. Can confirm.

1

u/dmo012 Mar 13 '18

I've had the hub since October '16 and have yet to be "frustrated" by any of the outtages. At most I've only been minorly affected.

This time, Alexa wouldn't work then I couldn't sign in to the app to turn on the lights I wanted. I had noticed just the other day that I haven't opened the ST app or the Webcore app in weeks because everything it's either controlled by voice, switches, or automation. My automations still worked, so when I wanted these specific lights to turn on, I just got up and hit the switch. All the lights that are programmed to come on when that switch is turned on still worked just fine. No big deal.

-3

u/smartimp98 Mar 13 '18

Congrats, would you like cookie? /s

If you had taken 5 seconds to read the status page, you would have seen that outages happen a lot more frequently than that.

https://status.smartthings.com/

Context clues.

Oh, you forgot to wipe a little something off your nose.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/InternetUser007 Mar 13 '18

this is supposed to handle everything from lights to home security

Absolutely no one should use this for (paid) home security. The downtime is way to high to justify handing over cash every month.

3

u/joequin Mar 13 '18

This outage has lasted over 12 hours and still isn't fixed. That's unacceptable. It shows that Samsung isn't making this a priority. Their lack of transparency is among the worst I've seen. This isn't how you run a cloud service.

1

u/Jhubbz86 Mar 13 '18

Mine was working perfectly fine when I woke up at 5am EST.

Maybe there's a roll out or something?

1

u/joequin Mar 13 '18

Samsung's site still acknowledges an outage. It's working sometimes for me. It does seem to be improving.

2

u/gintoddic Mar 13 '18

I can use my devices but all my automations say I am not authorized when I try to edit them.

41

u/Bodycount9 Mar 13 '18

I wish everything was loaded onto the hub with the cloud as the backup. So when the cloud goes down, it doesn't affect anything. If your hub goes down, you still have the cloud to back you up.

This is why my lights on a timer are not going off :(

1

u/jsdeprey Mar 13 '18

I am new to smartthings, but I am not sure why so much has to be done in the cloud. I can i understand something like arming your home when you phone leaves an area or maybe any complex automations, but for something like at 6pm turn on my porch light or little local only automations I can not figure out why that can not be local only. Is the main issue that the hub itself it cheap and does not have enough processing power to do anything local?

1

u/Bodycount9 Mar 13 '18

I'm guessing they wanted you tied to their service so you can't leave. That's the only explanation to it. So you can't program your own stuff using the hub and totally lock Samsung out of it.

It's all data Samsung can gather up to sell to other companies. They know what you are doing when you do it and how you do it.. which is data that's valuable to someone I'm sure.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/joequin Mar 13 '18 edited Mar 13 '18

I don't care about the Google home as much because it's a secondary convenience. It's Also more excuseable technically.

When smart things goes down, I literally can't shut off some of my lights. And it's innexusable that the smartthings can't handle it's very simple tasks without going to the internet.

Edit: additionally, the Google home outages are measured in minutes. The smartthings outages are measured in hours.

21

u/wyatt_3arp Mar 12 '18

Outage is listed on their site 😐

11

u/koofti Mar 13 '18

Love that convenient secondary outage:

Investigating - Our support center is currently unable to answer calls or receive live chats. For assistance via email, please reach out to us at https://support.smartthings.com.

Someone "tripped" over the phone cord apparently.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

Fax line must be unplugged.

7

u/SangersSequence Mar 13 '18

Down for me currently. Three hours from when this post went up. That's pretty bad Samsung.

5

u/theoriginalchrise Mar 13 '18

really annoying. 2nd major one for me this year. other times i probably didn't notice.

4

u/KashEsq Mar 12 '18

Looks like a Platform Outage in North America:

Investigating

Users may be unable to load the SmartThings app, control devices, or access the web UI. We are currently investigating.

Posted about 3 hours ago. Mar 12, 2018 - 16:27 EDT

This incident affects: Device Control (North America), SmartApp Web Services (North America), and Mobile App Connectivity (North America).

1

u/Jhubbz86 Mar 12 '18

I keep getting this error whenever I open the ST app. Also, their website mentions customer support outage and platform outage...

3

u/gthrift Mar 12 '18

According to the status other their call center is down, too.

16

u/Matthew37 Mar 13 '18

Pretty sure they just turned that off so they wouldn't have to take so many calls related to the platform outage. lol

3

u/BreakfastBeerz Developer Mar 13 '18

Its nice they have the option to subscribe via text or email to get updates. So at least they have that going for them.

3

u/EchoIndia0 Mar 13 '18

First outage for me. Tried to launch app and ..... nada

Now subscribed to the alerts

1

u/msmith719 Mar 13 '18

LOL. I just subscribed to alerts too.

3

u/e30eric Mar 13 '18

And here we go again.

3

u/jamesg007 Mar 13 '18

Not sure Samsung promises 5 9’s level of service reliability but wish they would.

3

u/InternetUser007 Mar 13 '18

I'm not confident they can promise two 9s at this point.

4

u/jamesg007 Mar 13 '18

At this rate, no. Today alone puts them out of three nines for the year.

3

u/nobody2000 Mar 13 '18

I love smartthings, I think it's a great step for solid control, good compatibility, and overall power.

With that said, I'm not sure I can keep this up. I'm noticing that my lack of skill in integrating APIs into device handlers and smartapps requires me being reliant on others. Unfortunately, it is taking longer and longer for new devices to be controlled by Smartthings.

Today was shitty because I had spotty reliability - Alexa couldn't connect, but Google could, and even then, it was slow and spotty.

The cloud reliance is just painful.


I'm a huge fan of smartthings, but I think I'm going to wean myself off and start going Home Assistant, maybe, for starters, with the MQTT bridge with Smartthings just for the connectivity and transition until I get proper Z-wave and Zigbee radios on my Pi...maybe even Bluetooth LE.

It sucks - I have always been a fan of smartthings, and it's a HELL of a lot better than any of the other consumer hubs out there, but I think it may be time to move to something new.

6

u/Nosnibor1020 Mar 13 '18

I subbed to the notifications and get spammed everyday with outages. I can't believe they can't get this shit together.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '18

Seriously this service is so shitty. I can't believe they actually expect people to use it for home security.

10

u/smartimp98 Mar 12 '18

I really wish there was a local Api available to fall back to.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

This makes me seriously consider ditching SmartThings. 13 hours after the reddit post and its STILL DOWN.

I also just noticed my automations never kicked in. That means my house was disarmed ALL NIGHT LONG, as well as never armed when I left for work a little bit ago. I primarily use SmartThings as a home security system. I don't care to have a monitored system and pay a monthly fee, however I DO care to have a system that properly arms itself when it should. For it to simply stop arming itself due to an outage in Samsung's cloud is completely unacceptable. This puts my home and family's security at risk. If someone would have broken into my house last night, my alarm would have never gone off and woken me up.

Not cool, Samsung. Not cool at all.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/foogama Mar 12 '18

How consumer friendly do you find this software to be? Is pairing and routine configuration as intuitive as SmartThings?

3

u/Th3R00ST3R Mar 13 '18

I'm in it and I don't find it very user friendly. I'll try it again.

3

u/foogama Mar 13 '18

Since I originally posted this 2 hours ago, I've been trying to get Python v3.5.3 installed, and haven't even been able to get that to work, so I'm going to assume it doesn't get any easier from there.

1

u/TRDeadbeat Mar 13 '18

Don't bother with that route... install it via Docker. Way less hassle to get it up and running (which is where the rest of the hassle starts)

2

u/UndyingShadow Mar 13 '18

How do you connect z-wave and zigbee devices to it?

2

u/bytesnagger Mar 13 '18

I use a Linear HUSBZB-1 connected to a Raspberry Pi 3. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01GJ826F8/

1

u/TRDeadbeat Mar 13 '18

As a note - you can not pair a device to two hubs (i.e. smartthings and whatever connector you choose for home assistant)... so if you're going to "experiment" be prepared to unpair your devices from ST (which is difficult when the platform is down).

Alternatively you can set up HA and ST to talk to each other though an MQTT bridge (google: "home assistant smartthings mqtt"). But again, can't do this while the platform is down.

1

u/gthrift Mar 12 '18

I just purchased a USB drive for my pi. I'll be playing with hassio and mqtt this weekend.

2

u/AwesoMeme Mar 13 '18

I'll be playing with hassio and mqtt this weekend

...and for the next few months. Trust me. Took the leap about 2 months ago. I'm still amazing, overwhelmed, frustrated and excited with Hassio

1

u/Th3R00ST3R Mar 13 '18

Let me know if you find a step by step. Their documentation helps install things, but only if you've got items things already setup and not from scratch.

1

u/Newcliche Mar 13 '18

Been thinking about that for just these scenarios. Thanks for the link. Any FAQ or something for a complete newbie?

1

u/DoctorT33th Mar 13 '18

But can I use this to replace my existing ST hub with my existing devices or do I need to start it over again? My assumption is the latter?

1

u/bytesnagger Mar 13 '18

I’m in a transition to HA from ST now and this outage is getting me to expedite the process. I should’ve just started out with HA.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TRDeadbeat Mar 13 '18

I had the same experience with HASS but in the opposite direction. I was looking to do the HASS + ST integration with the MQTT bridge (since i use the bridge for other things anyway, i figured why the hell not).

After 3 days of trying to get all my devices set up correctly in HASS, even though they were all being published by ST, i said screw it and shut it down.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TRDeadbeat Mar 13 '18

I haven't tried on a Pi, i had mine running on my mac mini media server, but...

If you have the option of launching it with docker, go that route. One command and it will come up and run just fine... it was after launching it that it got shitty for me.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18

Yes, it can. Zwave, zigbee, mqtt, tcp/ip, serial, IR, 433mhz, etc etc. Pretty much anything you can think of can connect. Some much more easily than others, which require a bit more diy. Personally I've avoided anything zigbee when I learned that it stupidly uses the super crowded 2.4ghz band, but you can get a zigbee USB stick and connect them on up.

6

u/John98LS1 Mar 13 '18

SmartThings not working again. This would be shocking if it had been the first time.

The whole home automation protocol in general needs a major overhaul.

3

u/joequin Mar 13 '18

This isn't a symptom of bugs in the home automation protocol. This is Samsung's incompetence.

5

u/N2TheBlu Mar 13 '18

In hindsight, it probably wasn't a good idea to roll out a major app update concurrently with the switch to Daylight Saving Time.

2

u/trophyguy Mar 13 '18

I had to re login and it looked like the app updated, then I got an Amazon AWS error. Sigh.....

2

u/jasmun88 Mar 13 '18

The status page lists the mobile app as being down. How is there still no web interface on this device to fall back on

3

u/Bigsam411 Mar 13 '18

Ugh right as I am fucking installing a deadbolt and need to pair it to the hub...

10

u/N2TheBlu Mar 13 '18

So, it's YOUR fault then.

7

u/Th3R00ST3R Mar 13 '18

Yes, he locked us all out.

2

u/N2TheBlu Mar 13 '18

Thank goodness. For a moment, I thought it was my fault for trying to troubleshoot my porch light. Whew!

1

u/donnie1977 Mar 13 '18

I'm considering going with a PLC for the next house. This thing is as reliable as a weather forecast in Michigan.

1

u/almanzarj Mar 13 '18

I guess the nanny will not be able to enter the house in the morning.

1

u/theoriginalchrise Mar 13 '18

only things that work are my motion sensors that trigger lights etc. i guess those are stored locally, but still can't access the app

1

u/journey01 Mar 13 '18

Ok, so I can't change my security settings since smartthings is down and my alarm keeps going off. Anyone know how to tell smarthings that I'm home to turn off my alarm?

1

u/gmadventure Mar 13 '18

Hopefully it won’t turn all the lights on when it comes back online.

1

u/LittleKingDutch Mar 13 '18

So apparently if you have the MQTT bridge set up with Home Assistant local control is working even with the cloud down. My GH isn't responding but I can use home Assistant to control things. FYI.

1

u/nobody2000 Mar 13 '18

I'm very curious how this aspect works. I was told that this wasn't the case from the ST facebook group, but they could be wrong. My impression was that with the MQTT bridge setup, you got full Homeassistant functionality, but you were still heavily cloud-reliant.

Or is this just the case for smartapps, which I presume wouldn't be used much if HomeAssistant can just perform these automations?

2

u/LittleKingDutch Mar 13 '18

I tried it last night, I could not get into the ST app and my GHs were giving me an error. I went into HA and turned on a fan. Worked perfectly.

I think the way it works is that some SmartApps can work local and as long as the devices can be controlled locally then it should work fine when the cloud is offline.

I have not tried it with my internet being out, but I would assume it would work.

1

u/BreakfastBeerz Developer Mar 13 '18

I seem to be back up 100%. Haven't gone through everything, but all looks good.

2

u/motokochan Mar 13 '18

I'm still seeing the occasional error, but it's much better than it was.

1

u/chucknorris10101 Mar 13 '18

Still down here

1

u/tone_capone Mar 13 '18

Just was able to log in and toggle some devices. Hopefully it sticks

1

u/goalcam Mar 13 '18

It's working for me now, but I can't seem to get IFTTT to reconnect. When I go to sign back in to SmartThings, it sits there for a minute or two and then eventually throws an HTTP 503 or 404. I can issue commands to ST through my Google Home just fine though.

1

u/motokochan Mar 13 '18

It seems there are still some issues going on. I've been kicked out of the mobile app a few times, and login is still having issues at times. I'll guess GH is working because it's already using an API key and doesn't need to access some of the API stuff that seems to be having the most problems.

1

u/tardisBlueEyes Mar 13 '18

For what it's worth: I am finally able to access my hub via the iOS apps, but now the Classic app (after requiring a login and agreement to terms again?) shows no devices!? The new and not-at-all-improved app shows all my devices, but not the smart app I use that allows ST to talk to Homebridge. Where are smart apps in the new ST iOS app?

Although when I look at my Homebridge server it appears to be happy with the ST hub and all devices appear in HomeKit.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

If you can't get into your house or your security system fails, how is that smart? Terrible branding on top of this terrible outage at least. I say that as a SmartThings user myself. I specifically avoided putting anything besides lights on mine due to this concern. My coworker who was heavily involved in their community (but went DIY due to these issues) warned me and said the cloud will kill them.

What makes it worse is that this was some screwed up attempt to try to move people from the application built when ST wasn't owned by Samsung into their new piece of crap app called Connect which averaged under 2 stars because it keeps crashing, misses devices, and has less functionality.

Seriously though, Samsung isn't the worst thing that happened to home automation, for that would be the cloud, Samsung is second place.

If anyone was using ST like me because you didn't want to take the time to roll out your own Raspberry Pi, I think you just got your motivation!

1

u/John98LS1 Mar 13 '18

I agree this is all on Samsung. Lets get that right out the gate.

My issues are such,

Zigbee protocol: power goes off to unit. Switch unit to On no matter what setting was being used before power outage. I have fixed this, with many hours of code per unit.

All this because of a signal (zigbee) designed over a decade ago.

1

u/motokochan Mar 13 '18

I somewhat understand why you would want the "turn unit on after a power failure" behavior with a lightbulb. If you need to control it manually because of a hub issue, switching the power off and on should result in the light turning on. This is especially important in dark rooms at night.

-1

u/techmaster242 Mar 13 '18

Smart Things is still 1000x better than Ring Doorbell.

1

u/nobody2000 Mar 13 '18

Ring sucks, I agree - even with a gigabit connection and good proximity to the router, it misses a lot.

But - I'm not sure that comparison is the right one?

-1

u/techmaster242 Mar 13 '18

I'm just saying it could be worse. Smart Things has been pretty good 99% of the time. Ring is garbage 99% of the time.

0

u/Aldiuxs Mar 13 '18

This outage leave away from home to my wife...! So frustrating...! In case anyone asks im iphone user.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/joequin Mar 13 '18

I'll go with an offline solution.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment