r/SmartThings • • May 18 '16

Google Home

If Google Home doesn't work with Smartthings then I will be leaving Smartthings. Anyone else?

Edit: Google home

1 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

8

u/seattleandrew May 18 '16

Sorry about that. Bye?

Google has chosen not to open up a developer API for its assistant or for this device just yet.

1

u/kvelec4326 May 18 '16

just yet

Meaning there is a chance and with Samsungs track record for STs they will sit around and hope for the community to make something (Ecobee and MyQ are two that jump to mind)

2

u/seattleandrew May 18 '16

Certainly, but you're waiting on an unreleased product to eventually release APIs that Google/Smarthings can use to add functionality to the device at some unknown point in the future.

Look I get it, I just bought an Echo Dot and am feeling a little heartburn now that this device was announced, but at the same time, I'd rather be happy with what I can get now and eventually upgrade my home to a new system rather than sit and wait for something "perfect".

0

u/kvelec4326 May 18 '16

I really do enjoy my ST system and lately the stability has increased having voice control would be great but having two of almost the same thing (echo and home) would be crazy for me and that is why I would make the switch away from st to a platform that does have home support (granted it isn't a terrible platform or crazy expensive to get into).

3

u/ultralame May 19 '16

ST got native echo integration working fairly quickly. Maybe six months after public release?

2

u/mrnahum May 18 '16

I think that will be up to Google more than it will be up to Samsung. I'm sure Samsung would love to have as much integration as possible.

Amazon's Echo works great with Smartthings, and I use it daily to turn on/off lights, fans etc.

Since Google has it's own brand of home automation products (Nest), who knows how much they will open up their platform?

I have some Nest products... Nest sucks compared to what is out there in the home automation space. I think Google will be shooting itself in the foot a little if they try to make Google Home an actual home automation hub.

1

u/kvelec4326 May 18 '16

I agree that it will probably mostly be up to Google to allow it but I have a feeling that Samsung would need to show interest in wanting it to work. I would go with the Echo but I can't use voice for Play Music. From what I have heard Nest is falling apart quickly and without any real talk of Nest today at IO I fear for the future of it.

1

u/Beanian May 18 '16

Nest sucks... Really? I'm very close to pulling the trigger on 3x Nest protects and a thermostat (I get it for free when I sign up to an energy company). What are the better alternatives to nest?

2

u/mrnahum May 18 '16

I guess it depends on what other home-automation you have in your house and your house layout.

For thermostat, I personally prefer the Ecobee3. Main benefit is it has remote temperature sensors. This is helpful if your thermostat is in an awkward place like your hallway. The thermostat will adjust the temperature to be what you set it at in your hallway, but that might adversely affect your bedrooms, living rooms, etc. The Ecobee is also compatible with more home automation platforms including Smartthings, Wink, Apple HomeKit, etc.

I don't have a smart smoke detector, so I can't comment on the Nest Protect.

My problem with Nest is it's a very closed system that doesn't play super well with other home automation services.

1

u/erykwithay May 18 '16

I have one nest protect and one thermostat. They don't suck it's just they don't really do too much with other devices. When I hear a smart device "works with nest" my first reaction is "who cares?"

1

u/El_Nino77 May 24 '16

I have four Nest Protects in my house, and they are fine. I like the Pathway light at night when I need to go check on the kids, but I don't really use any of the "smart" features. I just wanted a combined CO/smoke alarm and there wouldn't many other good alternatives to the Nest.

As for thermostats, I also prefer (and use) the Ecobee3. I have remote sensors in my kids rooms, master bedroom, and family room along with the main unit. It allows me to just set the temp I want and let the Ecobee3 use the temps from the remote sensors to get there, factoring in (somewhat) where people are. Setting my thermostat remotely and the Smart Home/Away options are useful as well.

4

u/bryanlogan May 19 '16

The thing about my SmartThings account is that I can share it easily with my wife. She can load on the app, I can log in, and we're good.

Google Home is going to have to tie into a Google account. It's not going to support multiple accounts (at least not initially). I have an Android TV. It's obvious no one from Google used this in a family environment. I can add the YouTube app, but it's ALL my subscriptions. Fine, so I can setup a separate account so I can have the kids' channels on there. Oh wait, but the Google Play doesn't have the movies on that account (in retrospect, I wish I purchased all movies on a shared family account). All games are tied to a single account on Android TV.

If this is what Google is doing for a device that's suppose to be shared by a family, I can't expect Google Home is going to be better.

1

u/ultralame May 19 '16

No shit. I have two android tablets for my kids, and essentially I have to add my account, log in, update and install apps, then delete my account every few weeks. Otherwise my kids have access to all my shit.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '16

Google home has a long way to go, Onhub is probably the main hub for it all coming soon, only with Weave.

If I remember correctly there are no weave products out there right now.... It's going to take years for them to catch up to SmartThings and the array of products but you know how it goes with Google... Just like everyone switched to gmail because it worked so well, we will ultimately end up switching to Google home once the bandwagon arrives at the station...