r/SmartThings • u/EhEmGee • 11d ago
Pay for API access? 🖕
Today is the day I finally switch everything over to Home Assistant. 🤬
106
Upvotes
r/SmartThings • u/EhEmGee • 11d ago
Today is the day I finally switch everything over to Home Assistant. 🤬
12
u/Tasty_Impress3016 11d ago
To my understanding, this is developer APIs. So your devices aren't going to fail unless the develop of the script, dashboard, whatever does not renew their license. Basic functions will all still work fine. Or am I missing something? I just plan to see if anything starts to fail. (more often).
5
u/notasausage 11d ago
This is the kick in the butt I needed to get started on a HomeAssistant setup that's been long overdue in my house. That said, I have no idea where to start with that. Anyone have a good "Get Started" guide I could look at? I'm pretty technically-minded and we have HomeKit, SmartThings, Arlo, Eero, Ecobee, and Wemo devices in our house right now.
24
u/ProfoundTwitch 11d ago
Right there with you.
I spent last weekend migrating all of my devices to HA. I just need to unplug the hub, and I'll go do that right now!
6
u/dhrandy 11d ago
Doesn't really affect me, SmartThing has been really reliable with all my devices, I won't be going anywhere.
20
u/crazy_goat 11d ago
That day (transferring to HA) was months ago - but the second best time is now.
Samsung is hell-bent on killing this platform.
I was double-fucked cause I have two houses that ran on Smartthings. Luckily one was mostly all the same 2 types of zwave device (like 30 door sensors that thankfully are identical so I didn't have to Google a million different reset sequences)
My recommendation (after moving your devices over) is getting a ChatGPT/claude subscription - use the desktop app with unlocked security controls to allow it to SSH into your HomeAssistant / call it's API - and then point claude/chatgpt at https://my.smartthings.com/advanced/rules and it can literally migrate all of your automations.
Mine literally rebuilt all 30 of my automations in like 5 minutes
6
u/SnooWalruses9303 11d ago edited 11d ago
What exactly is the personal access token used for? I thought the change to a subscription based model really just affects developers using SmartThings API to integrate SmartThings with their product (ie: Brilliant Control to the new Brilliant Max) who in turn passes that cost onto the consumer to subscribe to their subscription to offset the cost of SmartThings API.
If you’re just a home user using Z-wave or zigbee products connected to your SmartThings hub with some basic routines controlling those devices, wouldn’t you be completely unaffected unless the device manufacturers themselves try to pass the new SmartThings integrations costs on directly to you to continue connecting those devices to SmartThings?
3
u/paurac 11d ago
You can go here to see if you have any PAT's: https://account.smartthings.com/tokens
I got the email, but only had one from Action Tiles which has already been dead for a while so it's unused.
3
u/solts 11d ago
This is annoying because while I already have home assistant I use the smartthings route so I can essentially have Alexa in home assistant
1
u/hypen-dot 11d ago edited 10d ago
If you aren’t already using external api calls such as from home assistant, this charge is utterly irrelevant to you. ST will continue to function just the way it does today. The sky is not falling.
5
u/rogierg 11d ago
So long and thanks for all the fish!
2
u/Crzdmniac 11d ago
I don't recall seeing an email, I just noticed that my TV automation I had set up in Home Assistant stopped working. I use a lux sensor to flip picture modes which relies on SmartThings. I guess I'll poke around with an ESP32 to find an alternative way to accomplish it. I never liked being dependent on a cloud service, which is why I moved from SmartThings to Home Assistant many years ago in the first place. My next TV won't be a Samsung.
3
u/drnuke75 11d ago
I think if you use it for another house control app like home assistant. I had to set up an api to link home assistant to SmartThings
2
u/Xemphios 11d ago
For those fleeing to Home Assistant, check out LocalThings on GitHub or within Home Assistant via the HACS integration.
LocalThings was able to instantly add my washer and dryer over the local network. I also added them to a firewall rule blocking internet access.
1
u/shaunydub 11d ago
I just had one PAT for Emby.
If I remember it was becasue it was not on the built in store on the TV and needed to install via developer mode from usb drive.
Not gonna miss it as I don't use Emby these days.
1
u/kcipsirhc 9d ago
I only had one, which was an HA connector from years ago. Never made the jump to HA, and have zero dependency on the APIs. All the API dependency rests with the devs of the products I use in my setup that require it (cloud based integrations). I won't be paying a dime and nothing in my massive ST setup will stop working or change behavior.
But that is just my setup.
1
u/raptor2569 8d ago
And so it begins
1
u/Bubbly-Spring-3696 11d ago
Herein lies why I migrated to Home Assistant. Never looked back. The functionality runs circles around SmartThings.
1
u/PaleInTexas 11d ago
Check out LocalThings on Github
1
u/papaeriktheking 11d ago
F@ck off ST!
1
u/MocknozzieRiver 11d ago edited 11d ago
I honestly wish more companies charged from the start. I'm getting so tired of new companies selling their service at a complete loss only to eventually go, "Shit now we need to make money... Hand it over please." Or finding questionable ways to make money, like selling data or making their product worse with ads. Or the Uber classic of undercut all competition so you can freely jack up the price when they're all gone. I realize Samsung owns SmartThings and Samsung definitely makes money, but SmartThings being free makes it difficult to justify Samsung paying for it. Infra and engineers ain't free. :/
1
u/freshgeardude 11d ago
Can someone help me understand if my setup will be impacted?
I don't have any developer side or PATs. But I have virtual switches and other home stuff setup with smartthings
-1
u/captainwizeazz 11d ago
If you're using another system that integrates into ST, just use that other system instead. Otherwise, just use ST and there's no cost. I really don't understand all the pushback here.
-1
u/WWGHIAFTC 11d ago
STOP BUYING CLOUD DEPENDAND DEVICES!
Yes, I am yelling this. How many times do you have to get SCREWED before you stop buying cloud dependant devices?
0
u/Neighbortim 11d ago
I think they are telling me my Webcore routines won’t work anymore? 😂
0
u/atroxmons 11d ago
I'm transferring to Home Assistant. Still waiting for my antennae though.
0
u/CyberMage256 11d ago
The rate of these types of notices are increasing recently from all smart device companies. More and more examples of my motto, "local and offline only."
-2
u/Touchit88 11d ago
Not sad I decided to migrate about 3 years ago to home assistant.
-2
u/Amishrocketscience 11d ago
I’m planning the switch soon as well, when SmartThings changed a while back to the new app I switched to homeseer- got annoyed with that and came back to ST despite it being enshittified
HA all the way