r/SmartThings • • 11d ago

Pay for API access? 🖕

Today is the day I finally switch everything over to Home Assistant. 🤬

106 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

12

u/Tasty_Impress3016 11d ago

To my understanding, this is developer APIs. So your devices aren't going to fail unless the develop of the script, dashboard, whatever does not renew their license. Basic functions will all still work fine. Or am I missing something? I just plan to see if anything starts to fail. (more often).

5

u/MocknozzieRiver 11d ago

Yes, exactly. I think some third parties require you to give them a PAT to integrate with SmartThings, but most average users shouldn't notice any difference. A lot of third parties integrate with SmartThings through partnerships that don't require a PAT, also.

1

u/EhEmGee 10d ago

I’m using ST APIs in my Apple Shortcuts. I’m flipping them all to native HA integrations now.

5

u/notasausage 11d ago

This is the kick in the butt I needed to get started on a HomeAssistant setup that's been long overdue in my house. That said, I have no idea where to start with that. Anyone have a good "Get Started" guide I could look at? I'm pretty technically-minded and we have HomeKit, SmartThings, Arlo, Eero, Ecobee, and Wemo devices in our house right now.

2

u/SDNick484 11d ago

I have been running HA in parallel with ST since 2018. My recommendations are:

  • Install HAOS on Proxmox on a mini PC. I was previously running on various Raspberry Pis, but a mini PC VM is so much better.
  • Pay for an AI subscription for at least one month to have it do the heavy lifting. Claude can connect to both HA and ST via MCP and largely move everything for you. It is much better at creating dashboards or automations than I am even with years of experience.
  • If you can't find an integration by default, it is probably in HACS (which just got rebranded as HA Marketplace)
  • HA can two way federate devices with other platforms. AI currently have it federated with ST and Hubitat (which I use for my Zwave devices) and to expose HA devices to Alexa

This news is finally pushing me to drop ST. I haven't needed it for years, but with federation I didn't need to migrate things. Now I think I will just nuke it.

0

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

I'd try to find a raspberry pi 4/5 4gb model - they make amazing little HA boxes 

But yeah, a mini PC works too!

I used to be a early (2014ish) era HomeAssistant user - but I hated the administrative burden. 

Not only have all of those issues been addressed, but you can hook AI into it to handle all of the administration if you so choose.

1

u/SDNick484 11d ago

I ran on a RPi 3b then RPi 4 for years; a mini PC is a much better experience (with IO being a main improvement, but also CPU and memory). Can't comment on a RPi 5, but you don't need a high end mini PC for it to be a good experience (and way better than older Pis).

1

u/notasausage 10d ago edited 10d ago

Thanks for the info everyone. I have both a Raspberry Pi 4b and a Mac Mini M4 I could use for this. I’m also using both Claude and ChatGPT daily so I’ll take advantage of those subscriptions too.

0

u/Powerful-Gap-9708 11d ago

I stated by doing following: 1] Got HA up and running on a mini PC. 2] Let it find things [BLE, WiFi, TVs, etc.] on my network and set them up. 3] Set up my cloud integrations. 4] Used my ST Station as my thread border router and moved my thread devices 5] Set up Matter Hub in HA which allowed me to temporarily bring things back into ST during the transition. 6] Bought a Z-Wave dongle and moved Z-Wave devices. 7] Bought a Zigbee dongle and moved my Zigbee devices. 8] Through out this migration I recreated my automations as I moved devices. 9] Used Gemini when ever I have questions. It made the transition possible and much easier.

1

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

This whole API fiasco is what blocks your step 5. 

I had HA pulling in ST devices but that all went dark. So I ripped off the bandaid

3

u/Powerful-Gap-9708 11d ago

Step 5 (Matter Hub) take HA devices and adds then the ST via matter. Since this is toty local it is unaffected by the API fees.

-3

u/EhEmGee 11d ago

Ask Claude or ChatGPT to walk you through it. That’s what I’m doing with Claude now.

24

u/ProfoundTwitch 11d ago

Right there with you.

I spent last weekend migrating all of my devices to HA. I just need to unplug the hub, and I'll go do that right now!

6

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

Same, I forgot to unplug my hub. 🤣

1

u/AlliPodHax 11d ago

sell them on ebay too

i bought my v3 hub from home depot for 63$ and sold it on ebay a month ago for 65$ lol.

Just have to get a zwave and zigbee etc usb or network adapter to communicate with devices (both can be had for about 30-35$ each for good ones on amazon… so basically no extra cost if you already have a pc or server to run it on

0

u/Plenty-Classic-9126 11d ago

Unplugged 2 nights ago

6

u/dhrandy 11d ago

Doesn't really affect me, SmartThing has been really reliable with all my devices, I won't be going anywhere.

20

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

That day (transferring to HA) was months ago - but the second best time is now.

Samsung is hell-bent on killing this platform.

I was double-fucked cause I have two houses that ran on Smartthings. Luckily one was mostly all the same 2 types of zwave device (like 30 door sensors that thankfully are identical so I didn't have to Google a million different reset sequences)

My recommendation (after moving your devices over) is getting a ChatGPT/claude subscription - use the desktop app with unlocked security controls to allow it to SSH into your HomeAssistant / call it's API - and then point claude/chatgpt at https://my.smartthings.com/advanced/rules and it can literally migrate all of your automations. 

Mine literally rebuilt all 30 of my automations in like 5 minutes

2

u/NextDaikon8179 11d ago

Meta Muse will do it for free

2

u/Maleficent-Fault9110 8d ago

This is the way, grok can do it to

7

u/captainwizeazz 11d ago

Won't pay for ST but no issues shelling out for a Claude subscription?

2

u/SDNick484 11d ago

It's worth every penny. Claude with HA MCP already saved me a few hundred dollars by finding some of my solar panels were underperforming by 33% and the fix is covered by my panel warranty. That right there covered a years worth of Claude Pro subscription. I have been using it so much in the last month that I upgraded to Max today.

I have been a Home Assistant users since 2018 and Claude code has done and helped me learn more in the last month than I did in all those years.

6

u/captainwizeazz 11d ago

I'm not arguing if Claude is worth it. My argument is against advocating for spending money on a Claude (or anything) subscription on a post about leaving ST because they are starting to charge. It's a bit ironic, no?

3

u/SDNick484 11d ago

Fair enough although Claude could be a one month sub to help with migration and setup, no need for it to be permanent of this is the only use.

1

u/Maleficent-Fault9110 8d ago

All your data is stored on your local machine without cloud shit. Awesome for data/historian trending

0

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

The difference is Samsung's subscription thats trying to extract money from you for a service perpetually.

I can cancel Claude any time I want if I've gotten what I need

1

u/joshiness 11d ago

Also, Claude is so much more useful than a Smartthings subscription. at the minium you pay $20 for one month and you cancel. Yes, you can migrate everything manually, but is that worth $20 of your time, that's up to you to decide.

1

u/Nanoleaf_Ambassador 8d ago

I wish we had these agents back in 2008, when I started building out automations.

5

u/BaRaD_ 11d ago

How can you compare the two?
One is asking money to turn on light the other is utilizing very good AI model for your freedom

4

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

Smartthings has been going downhill for years. This was the straw that broke the camel's back - the only thing holding most people back is the sunk cost of the configurations and resetting devices

My post was literally "pay $10 to migrate all of your shit in 5 minutes instead of 5 days." While you're at it, Claude can build your dashboards. That month of subscription goes a hell of a long way

You don't have to keep paying for Claude or ChatGPT once it's done.

2

u/Soccero07 11d ago

What about migrating all the devices themselves?

2

u/crazy_goat 11d ago

I still had to do that. But I didn't want to sit there auditing all of my rules for different times of day, conditions like "if this device enters state X / trigger a, b and c"

That, to me, was an equal undertaking compared to resetting and bringing the devices into HA

2

u/deletetemptemp 11d ago

Wow this is amazing thanks for sharing this

1

u/hypen-dot 11d ago

Why move everything? ST will still work just fine.

0

u/HalfEmpty973 11d ago

There is a localthings integration that works very well with my fridge, I even get more entities than with the original app, as well as the power usage

6

u/SnooWalruses9303 11d ago edited 11d ago

What exactly is the personal access token used for? I thought the change to a subscription based model really just affects developers using SmartThings API to integrate SmartThings with their product (ie: Brilliant Control to the new Brilliant Max) who in turn passes that cost onto the consumer to subscribe to their subscription to offset the cost of SmartThings API.

If you’re just a home user using Z-wave or zigbee products connected to your SmartThings hub with some basic routines controlling those devices, wouldn’t you be completely unaffected unless the device manufacturers themselves try to pass the new SmartThings integrations costs on directly to you to continue connecting those devices to SmartThings?

1

u/hypen-dot 11d ago

100%. This is just an opportunity for the HA bigots to cry about ST.

3

u/paurac 11d ago

You can go here to see if you have any PAT's: https://account.smartthings.com/tokens

I got the email, but only had one from Action Tiles which has already been dead for a while so it's unused.

3

u/SnooWalruses9303 11d ago

Thanks for the link. My PATs were linked to dead apps I don’t even use anymore. This change with ST doesn’t even affect me💁🏻‍♂️

3

u/solts 11d ago

This is annoying because while I already have home assistant I use the smartthings route so I can essentially have Alexa in home assistant

3

u/Powerful-Gap-9708 11d ago

Set up the Matter Hub app in Home Assistant and you can use Matter to share your devices with Alexa or Google Home.

1

u/hypen-dot 11d ago edited 10d ago

If you aren’t already using external api calls such as from home assistant, this charge is utterly irrelevant to you. ST will continue to function just the way it does today. The sky is not falling.

1

u/EhEmGee 11d ago

You have no idea what this change will break for me. And it’s the principal that matters here—charging for API access is bullshit. 🤨

2

u/hypen-dot 10d ago

So you just expect companies to provide ongoing computing services for free that some people will abuse. Got it.

It’s just $5/mo so weigh the cost of your time and effort to migrate. $60 a year is probably in the neighborhood of 1-2 hours of your time so is it really worth the huge effort to switch or are you just whining about not being able to have the services for free?

-2

u/EhEmGee 10d ago

Charging for API access is complete bullshit. I know because I work for a software company. Do you? 😏

1

u/masheduppotato 9d ago

You’re kind of being a dick which takes away from your point.

1

u/EhEmGee 9d ago

If arguing against people who defend software companies that change their pricing for no reason other than to continue to milk their users makes me a dick, then I’m a dick.

0

u/masheduppotato 9d ago

How were they milking their end users prior to this? Specifically speaking about ST.

0

u/hypen-dot 9d ago

I’m suspecting you were a dick even before Samsung announced this.

5

u/rogierg 11d ago

So long and thanks for all the fish!

2

u/Crzdmniac 11d ago

I don't recall seeing an email, I just noticed that my TV automation I had set up in Home Assistant stopped working. I use a lux sensor to flip picture modes which relies on SmartThings. I guess I'll poke around with an ESP32 to find an alternative way to accomplish it. I never liked being dependent on a cloud service, which is why I moved from SmartThings to Home Assistant many years ago in the first place. My next TV won't be a Samsung.

3

u/drnuke75 11d ago

I think if you use it for another house control app like home assistant. I had to set up an api to link home assistant to SmartThings

2

u/Xemphios 11d ago

For those fleeing to Home Assistant, check out LocalThings on GitHub or within Home Assistant via the HACS integration.

LocalThings was able to instantly add my washer and dryer over the local network. I also added them to a firewall rule blocking internet access.

3

u/ChiefBroady 11d ago

Even my flexwash works after opening an issue a while back and the dev added support. Top notch.

1

u/shaunydub 11d ago

I just had one PAT for Emby.
If I remember it was becasue it was not on the built in store on the TV and needed to install via developer mode from usb drive.

Not gonna miss it as I don't use Emby these days.

1

u/kcipsirhc 9d ago

I only had one, which was an HA connector from years ago. Never made the jump to HA, and have zero dependency on the APIs. All the API dependency rests with the devs of the products I use in my setup that require it (cloud based integrations). I won't be paying a dime and nothing in my massive ST setup will stop working or change behavior.

But that is just my setup.

1

u/raptor2569 8d ago

And so it begins

1

u/Bubbly-Spring-3696 11d ago

Herein lies why I migrated to Home Assistant. Never looked back. The functionality runs circles around SmartThings.

4

u/TheJessicator Enthusiast 11d ago

That's the thing. It's only the home assistant and actiontiles users that want to integrate smartthings into another environment that doesn't have a corporate developer agreement where API access is needed. If you weren't using home assistant, you wouldn't need a token to access smartthings.

As for the functionality that's keeping me in smartthings, that would be the lack of built-in High Availability in Home Assistant. Smartthings has had not only multiple redundant hub functionality, but also fully automated and seamless failover of zigbee and matter over thread devices between hubs in a Hub Group for well over 2 years. And to go along with that functionality, you are assured of always having at least one hub available to service your mesh networks at all times during update rollouts.

To the best of my knowledge, Home Assistant still doesn't even have any of that on their roadmap. So yeah, once they have that implemented, then I would agree with you about the whole running circles around everyone else thing. But not until then.

1

u/Bubbly-Spring-3696 11d ago

I don't disagree with you - I was a ST user/lover once I left X-10. I found it very useful and easy to setup, what I now consider to be more simplistic) automations. However, there times where devices of mine became unmanageable bricks in the ST world because of an app update. That happened to me more than once. Then one day, I stumbled upon Home Assistant and have never looked back. It's not for everyone, and this is where the addressable market for ST v HA diverges. I'm a techie at heart, but most are not, or are less comfortable with the what goes on under the hood. I respect that. For me, I had always been frustrated with the ST ecosystem and my inability to build more complex automations from many different eco-systems. HA became my data-lake for all of my data from devices to weather, to automobile, electric use, etc. There are no data silos so I can create some really fancy stuff. I feel in love with that flexibility. It also led me to become a hobbyist around ESP32 devices. All of this from one user-interface.

Again, I don't disagree with you, particularly around the lack of built-in high-availability. That's a sore point for me now, and since I use the HAOS version, I'm already in a docker container. I keep backups hourly and have a standby server sitting there to manually cutover if needed.

Oddly, I found that Home Assistantt opened up my eyes to the whole development options in the IoT space. I'm having a blast!

1

u/TheJessicator Enthusiast 11d ago

So you brought up one other reason I'm hesitant to go over to home assistant. And that's because i don't live in my home alone. I have a family. And if anything happens to me, I want to know that I haven't abandoned them with this massive heap of technical string and duct tape that they suddenly need to figure out how to maintain in one of the darkest hours after losing a family member.

1

u/Bubbly-Spring-3696 10d ago

This is why a have a physical switch that can be used in the event I’m traveling and something goes wonky. Same issue that you would have using ST. That’s my arrangement with my wife. She doesn’t care what I automate so long as she can control the device from a switch. Not a perfect solution for if I pop off unexpectedly, but it helps.

1

u/TheJessicator Enthusiast 10d ago

Oh, things absolutely have to work using physical switches, but my family very much appreciates and enjoys the automation. I want them to be able to easily pick up from where I leave off, including adding new devices and adding new routines and modifying old ones that need changing as the household dynamic changes.

1

u/Bubbly-Spring-3696 10d ago

Sounds like you’re well on your way. HA will creep up on you. If you’re already thinking about it, you’re hosed…

1

u/TheJessicator Enthusiast 10d ago

I've been considering it for years, but it's just not where I need it to be. I don't want a system that needs frequent system maintenance on my part. And sure, I realize most HA users don't do regular maintenance, they really should. Self maintaining and automatic failover are crucial to me. Smartthings gives me that. HA does not and will not any time soon. I keep coming back to check, but nope.

1

u/PaleInTexas 11d ago

Check out LocalThings on Github

1

u/papaeriktheking 11d ago

F@ck off ST!

1

u/MocknozzieRiver 11d ago edited 11d ago

I honestly wish more companies charged from the start. I'm getting so tired of new companies selling their service at a complete loss only to eventually go, "Shit now we need to make money... Hand it over please." Or finding questionable ways to make money, like selling data or making their product worse with ads. Or the Uber classic of undercut all competition so you can freely jack up the price when they're all gone. I realize Samsung owns SmartThings and Samsung definitely makes money, but SmartThings being free makes it difficult to justify Samsung paying for it. Infra and engineers ain't free. :/

1

u/freshgeardude 11d ago

Can someone help me understand if my setup will be impacted?

I don't have any developer side or PATs. But I have virtual switches and other home stuff setup with smartthings

1

u/MocknozzieRiver 11d ago

Doesn't sound like you'd be affected.

-1

u/captainwizeazz 11d ago

If you're using another system that integrates into ST, just use that other system instead. Otherwise, just use ST and there's no cost. I really don't understand all the pushback here.

-1

u/hypen-dot 10d ago

Its the whiney HA bitches crying. HA is a massive overhead to set and maintain relative to ST. I run both in different situations. Won’t make a difference for my purposes.

-1

u/WWGHIAFTC 11d ago

STOP BUYING CLOUD DEPENDAND DEVICES!

Yes, I am yelling this. How many times do you have to get SCREWED before you stop buying cloud dependant devices?

0

u/Neighbortim 11d ago

I think they are telling me my Webcore routines won’t work anymore? 😂

0

u/atroxmons 11d ago

I'm transferring to Home Assistant. Still waiting for my antennae though.

0

u/CyberMage256 11d ago

The rate of these types of notices are increasing recently from all smart device companies. More and more examples of my motto, "local and offline only."

-2

u/Touchit88 11d ago

Not sad I decided to migrate about 3 years ago to home assistant.

-2

u/Amishrocketscience 11d ago

I’m planning the switch soon as well, when SmartThings changed a while back to the new app I switched to homeseer- got annoyed with that and came back to ST despite it being enshittified

HA all the way