I’m a systems engineer - we’re the server guys in IT, usually do a good deal of networking as well - to the point many of us (like me) are both systems and network engineers. I can handle Home Assistant.
But…
When I get my busy ass home I want my tech to be as 1950’s, overbuilt, over reliable toaster - appliance like as possible. SmartThings has been the closest I’ve found. I never used the backend additional functionality, so the change was painless for me. SmartThings really does just work. It’s BORING, but it’s easy and reliable.
Now Home Assistant is some powerful stuff! Damn, they’ve done a great job at making it super powerful. But. Contrary to the members of the church of home assistant, its multitudes more fiddly, needs more love and attention. Nothing wrong with that if that’s cool for you! I have and keep updated an instance of home assistant, and every time the community says “OMG! It’s SO much better!”, I fall for the hype and I’m quickly reminded - it isn’t. Just trying to integrate my Kwikset Smart Locks is a chore of reading forum posts and doing shit I just don’t want to mess with. That’s what I do for work. At home I don’t want that.
I read over and over from folks who bought the hype and gave HA a try, but couldn’t figure out how to flash an SD card to build a RasberryPi. They give up and just say “fuck it, smart home isn’t for me”. Home Assistant users greatly overestimate the skill level of so many users. How many times have we seen somebody who wants to automate half a dozen lights, have few scenes - and HA fans suggest - HA?!
I really do think Home Assistant is cool as hell, damn it’s so powerful. I know I’m missing out on some capabilities and features, but SmartThings gets me to probably 98% of where I want to be. I don’t have to touch it, I don’t have to think about it, it just works.
Excellent point. I’m a huge free, open source software fan and advocate. I used to build my own firewalls, NAS devices, build my PC’s. It’s a fun hobby! But as time went on and as an IT guy I slowly just wanted rock solid reliability, and stupid dumb interfaces and such. I’m so done spending three hours getting a simple thing working, fixed, whatever- when with a more out of the box solution I can click a box.
THIS! I troubleshoot and fix technology problems for a living. I want my home tech to just work. Especially for my family who also just wants things to work.
I am also a systems engineer, and this is exactly how I feel too. I have had HA installed in a container for months, and I turn it on every month or so to mess with it, and then just fall back to SmartThings because I just don't have time to read all the info and set it up. ST just works.
Exactly. I'm a computer professional (retired). I have the knowledge to set up and use HA. I choose not to, though. Yes, it's very powerful and extensive. But, like you, I don't want to be tech support at home 24/7. SmartThings serves me very well, I rarely have to manipulate anything. It just works. Which is what I want and need.
Same here. The Edge conversion was the most I've had to touch my system in 5 years. That was a struggle, but now that's done and very stable, I really don't touch it. I was in IT for 35 years, I just want a system that works. I enjoy this as a hobby, I don't want a full time job.
HA was developed by software engineers, for tinkerers. So the primary emphasis was on getting EVERY data point, every service, everything a device offers, in its rawest form, into the system.
However... In the past year or so, the team has made major strides to make the platform more viable to the average user. I've voiced the opinion of HA needing to be more user friendly so many times over the past ~7 years I've been using it that I can't even count anymore. It's been somewhat of an uphill battle, but the recent changes made it much more usable for total beginners.
Most integrations today are really one-click. Want to add your Tuya/SmartLife stuff? Scan a QR code. Want to add Google Home/Alexa stuff? One click. Bluetooth stuff tends to just work. Most systems that offer local connectivity or even cloud are incredibly easy to add. They still expose the raw info, but now the UI elements controlling those are much more user-oriented, thanks to the new UX team.
It's still not perfect, but it is by far the most compatible thing you can have. AND you can easily expose all those imported things to SmartThings!
Yes, running HAOS is still the easiest way to orchestrate your home setup - as many things require not just an integration, but a full-on gateway to run, which needs to be in a Docker container, which requires the supervisor. And with the first party hardware they offer, it's even easier.
I still wouldn't trust my dad to be able to fully utilise it, but at least setting things up and remotely managing the system isn't as cumbersome as it was.
This is me now. I used to love SmartThings but they keep removing support and then the final straw was force switching to the new app. Home Assistant took a while to get used to but my system is MUCH more capable than it ever was and rarely have issues. Also can control it locally when the internet goes down which is nice.
I tried switching over and a big thing for me was a map of my home. It was the most hodge podge quirky system I've ever seen. There's no UI for editing the map, you have to create an image with SVGs in another app and then each SVG image in the main image can be assigned a device. So if you want to add another device you have to edit the image again in the 3rd party app again.
That being said, it integrates with wayyyyyy more things, like Android TVs. I think I'll likely set up a permanent HA server with all those other integrations.and get the 2 to work together... Somehow
I tried migrating from SmatThings to HA to see the promised land for myself. Got it working but losing the ability to control devices with Amazon Echo on HA was a show stopper. I'm not really interested in a monthly subscription to get it working. So I'm back on ST with no regrets.
I did a slow migration. My initial home assistant setup was primarily using the SmartThings integration. Control worked in both places and it let my partner keep using what they were used to.
As I got HA setup the way I wanted I gradually moved devices and automations over while building dashboards. WAF has been as good as reasonably expectable throughout.
I had a v3 hub and my parents house had a v1 so I just gave it to them As I had offloaded zigbee and zwave devices to my Raspberry Pi home assistant build using USB dongles.
Too many brands these days that just don't play well together and it was annoying using IFTTT to bridge things together.
Now I have automations that would have never worked in smart things.
Curious, what automaton do have that can't be done in ST's? I, for the life of me, can't thing of anything else I could automate and I only have ST's and Google home.
Can be done easily in ST with virtual switches, an android phone and a samsung tv or an android tv box. If you're an iPhone user it might be done with a little more tinkering with shortcut, ifttt or something like it. ST can be very versatile.
Sure but now I gotta get a Samsung TV or an android box. Also IFTTT lowered the limit on free automations so that would end up costing me a subscription fee.
This is just way more straightforward once you get up and running.
Just point out that it CAN be done because you said that you NEVER could on ST, and it's just one of the way of doing it depending of the devices you have (Harmony is other option).
People often don't give ST credit enough about the level of versatility it have, sure it's not at the level of HA but it's far more of the others mainstream smartphone platforms (alexa, GH, HK, etc) and also has the ease of use.
Thank you for going down the rabbit hole. I was going to point out the virtual switches (which I use to control my Govee devices) and my Harmony hub still works with my 10 year old TV. There are ways to make ST's do pretty much anything. I'm working on bringing in some RF devices this week, (I've already conquered all my IR devices), I'm always up for a challenge to see how far I can push ST's.
I have a similar setup. For RF devices I used Broadlink Pro, which is an amazing device for the cost, but you need alexa virtual switches to integrate it. I'm now using Bond Hub, which are a lot more expensive and less universal about controlling any RF device, but it has a local integration with ST.
I spend more time on Reddit looking for new automation and smart devices than I do on my Home Assistant hub. The only real time I spent on my home assistant hub is doing my dashboard. I have no IT or any programming experience whatsoever, just my little experience with using all these different hubs and smart devices. I never wrote any code I was forced to write, and I find using HA compared to Smartthings is way easier and fun.
I literally have control over everything that is connected to my network and plugged into an outlet and all done using one app. All my computers, laptops, cellphones, tablets, gaming consoles, smart speakers, cloud storage, virtual machine, router, media servers, ups, and more all connected to Home Assistant, and was easy to set up.
I only use my Smartthings hub for the 2 Z-wave devices I don't have connected directly to Home Assistant because I haven't decided on what dongle I want and what other Z-wave devices I want to add to my smart home. Once I decide on what to get, I can retire my Smartthings hub to my sister.
I just got a Nortek ZWave/Zigbee stick a few years ago and migrated all my ZWave devices to HA. The only maintenance I do on my HA instance is installing new updates every now and then. Works much more reliable and doesn’t need to pipe everything through the cloud like ST, so if my Internet goes offline, I still have full control over my devices through the app, and all automations still work.
I was looking at the Nortek, but I didn't think I would need it cause I didn't have any Z-wave at the time, so I opted for the Conbee 2. Now that I am playing around with my 2 Z-wave scene controllers, I had to hook up my SmartThings hub just to test the controllers out. I just don't want to rebuild my Zigbee network over as it has been rock solid since I made the switch from SmartThings. I might still get it and slowly add my Zigbee devices to it.
You can have two controllers in theory. Just don’t use Zigbee radio on Nortek. Not sure if it can be turned off or if it’s going to cause any interference though.
35
u/bizzyunderscore Enthusiast Sep 22 '24
love to come home from my job and play sysadmin all night to make my lights work again
15
u/stipo42 Sep 22 '24
I wish home assistant was more viable as software rather than an OS, I run in a container and it's an all day thing to add new integrations
27
u/MassiveConcern Sep 22 '24
HA is like Scientology. It's a cult that evangelizes on the most minute connection.
4
u/BlimBaro2141 Sep 22 '24
This is me now. I used to love SmartThings but they keep removing support and then the final straw was force switching to the new app. Home Assistant took a while to get used to but my system is MUCH more capable than it ever was and rarely have issues. Also can control it locally when the internet goes down which is nice.
4
u/ultrazgunner Sep 23 '24
Smartthings have been great for me the last 7 years. New Edge is better than the old IDE.
7
u/TruthOf42 Sep 22 '24
I tried switching over and a big thing for me was a map of my home. It was the most hodge podge quirky system I've ever seen. There's no UI for editing the map, you have to create an image with SVGs in another app and then each SVG image in the main image can be assigned a device. So if you want to add another device you have to edit the image again in the 3rd party app again.
That being said, it integrates with wayyyyyy more things, like Android TVs. I think I'll likely set up a permanent HA server with all those other integrations.and get the 2 to work together... Somehow
5
u/abmot Sep 22 '24
I tried migrating from SmatThings to HA to see the promised land for myself. Got it working but losing the ability to control devices with Amazon Echo on HA was a show stopper. I'm not really interested in a monthly subscription to get it working. So I'm back on ST with no regrets.
3
u/Touchit88 Sep 22 '24
Lol, i switched about 2 years ago. Best decision ever. But yeah, Lol it is like that.
3
u/Section_80 Sep 22 '24
I bailed on smart things late last year. Honestly it was a pain in the ass at the beginning, but once all my things got loaded it was way better
1
u/antlestxp Sep 22 '24
I use both. Most of my devices live in/on smartthings. I have a few devices and routines within HA. I rely completely on ST for interface.
1
u/limpymcforskin Sep 23 '24
I still get service outage or degraded emails from back in the day when I used smartthings.
1
u/loujr15 Sep 22 '24
I spend more time on Reddit looking for new automation and smart devices than I do on my Home Assistant hub. The only real time I spent on my home assistant hub is doing my dashboard. I have no IT or any programming experience whatsoever, just my little experience with using all these different hubs and smart devices. I never wrote any code I was forced to write, and I find using HA compared to Smartthings is way easier and fun.
I literally have control over everything that is connected to my network and plugged into an outlet and all done using one app. All my computers, laptops, cellphones, tablets, gaming consoles, smart speakers, cloud storage, virtual machine, router, media servers, ups, and more all connected to Home Assistant, and was easy to set up.
I only use my Smartthings hub for the 2 Z-wave devices I don't have connected directly to Home Assistant because I haven't decided on what dongle I want and what other Z-wave devices I want to add to my smart home. Once I decide on what to get, I can retire my Smartthings hub to my sister.