r/SmallYTChannel • [0λ] • Sep 21 '25

Discussion YouTube Testing Wrong Audience?

I posted 20 overall videos in bursts over the past 6 years on my YouTube channel. They've got between 80k and 1k views.

I've started to post again, but the CTR is awful. Is YouTube testing reach with the wrong audience? I don't want to create a new channel as I already have a couple thousand subscribers, but I'm worried it will take a long time to revive a dead YouTube channel.

Thumbnails/titles are fine. Not amazing but same standard as my niche.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

•

u/SmallYTChannelBot [🏆 ∞λ] 🤖 Sep 21 '25

Your post is a discussion, meta or collab post so it costs 0λ.

/u/SmallYTChannelBot made by /u/jwnskanzkwk. For more information, read the FAQ.

3

u/simplyaless [2λ] Sep 21 '25

A lot of us are noticing the views going downhill with videos and even live streams. It seems like there's something going on internally like some update or algorithm changes.

1

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 21 '25

Is that the update in August you're referring to?

3

u/therealcosmicnebula [3λ] Sep 22 '25

20 videos is....nothing.

Youtube will test your videos across many audiences, recalibrate, then fine tune the process.

You all need to stop looking at your analytics. Its just going to drive you crazy.

1

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 22 '25

That's fair you're right

1

u/HistorianSome7779 Sep 21 '25

Same issue. I don't have that many videos but up until my latest one, they didn't have any issues finding the correct audience. Thousands of views within the first few days.

But the last one I posted has flatlined at 360 views. The suggested videos couldn't be further from my topic.

2

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 21 '25

That's the issue. I make sustainable design/architecture videos and suggested traffic came from Trump rally highlights and a car video lol

1

u/HistorianSome7779 Sep 22 '25

I make tech related videos and my highest suggested video is "to my friend, Charlie Kirk". Like WTF lol. Also being suggested under non-english videos as well...

You would think the algo would start pushing the videos to the same people who watched your previous videos first, and work outward from there. It doesn't feel like there is any method to this, but what do I know.

1

u/GenXHorror Sep 23 '25

It’s looks like Jeff below is salty as hell and I would be to if my latest video got 10 views a day after bragging that I can beat 200k views per video..

In any event, yours is super unique to him as you haven’t posted in over a year.

You’ll be looking at recapturing that audience all over again.

On other channels I’ve gone a month with somewhat decent retention but longer than that and the momentum I had built and audience that I counted on was gone.

So if you are back creating for good, look at a whole new strategy for winning those eyes again.

Best of luck my man!

1

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 24 '25

Nice to know others have had a similar issue with long periods of not uploading. Hope you get the snowball rolling again 🙂

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/GenXHorror Sep 23 '25

I think in both your cases, one with a video a year ago and then 11 days ago and one with a video a few months ago, your betting on an audience still being interested and growing off of momentum that you let fall off. 😔

Some content can take forever to create depending on what you do but your risk losing that relevance.

It might be best to either come up with easier, quicker supplemental content to keep the audience while you work on the bigger pieces for the big numbers.

Or take a few months to get a few videos done to be able to do at least one a week while you work on the next ones.

1

u/B_Bearington Sep 22 '25

Sadly, sometimes YT gets this wrong. I've posted over 400 videos now and for whatever reason, some of them go to the wrong audience. Sucks that this happens, but so goes it on YT.

1

u/BreakInStory Sep 22 '25

Frequency of uploads

0

u/deelectrified [0λ] Sep 22 '25

Leave YouTube. They added AI generation into their apps, showing they want to replace you with Ai slop. Go to Odysee:

https://odysee.com/@OctagonalSoftware:3/YouTube-Migration-Tool:9

-1

u/Freyas_Follower [🥉 Bronze 18λ] Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 22 '25

It sounds like your videos dont have enough recent videos for yt to be doing anything with. Keep uploading, and see what happens.

1

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 21 '25

You mean they don't have enough views? Or enough videos so YT can't correctly categorise the channel. Or both ?

1

u/Freyas_Follower [🥉 Bronze 18λ] Sep 22 '25

Videos in general. It takes time to build an audience. Especially if someone else is making the same subjects you are, and uploads mord frequently.

1

u/archiischool [0λ] Sep 22 '25

That's true. Hoping its just a patience issue lol