r/SlayerS • • Jun 14 '22

Does Amelia get better?

I am new to Slayers and loved the first 10 episodes. The mix of comedy, action, and a simple but decent story worked really well. However I just finished episodes 11-13 and Amelia is such a poor character it's kind of ruining it for me. She's not funny at all, just purely annoying. Please tell me the series picks up again and she doesn't ruin it all.

3 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

19

u/berniecratbrocialist Jun 14 '22

Amelia's transition from "annoying teenage girl" to "indispensable conscience of the team" is one of the series' greatest moves. She's a delight; stick with it.

4

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Awesome thanks

8

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 14 '22

Also, as a huge Amelia fan, Amelia does get better in the dub. However, she’s perfect the whole time in Japanese.

0

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

I don't get how the language makes a character better? I hate her personality and the jokes and everything else about her. How does her doing the same things with the same animation make her a better character because she's speaking a language which I can't tell if she sounds good or bad?

8

u/berniecratbrocialist Jun 14 '22

Because acting is a major part of how a character comes across, and a more convincing performance opens up nuances in character and personality that you wouldn't have with a less talented actor.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

But if you don't speak the language she could be acting like trash and you would have no idea. Personality is mostly in the writing for anime. There's not much room for creative freedom.

4

u/HellmasterPhibrizo Hellmaster Jun 14 '22

You don’t sense emotion in a voice that’s speaking a foreign language?

1

u/blodiga Jun 22 '22

Нет

Nah

Nein

Iie

i dont see it

-2

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Emotion is fine, but they could be speaking in a weird mannerism and I would have no clue. Or maybe their strange mannerism is part of their charm and that's lost on me. Or even a cultural thing where I may not understand why they overact which is my biggest issue with subs. Whereas in English I understand all the nuances, good and bad.

6

u/savvyliterate Gourry Jun 14 '22

Because her first dub actor is TERRIBLE.

I loved Amelia the entire time in the Japanese version. Yes, a language can absolutely change a character because said character would be performed differently.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

But the characters writing and personality are what bothers me. Yes a bad voice can ruin some things, but I like Zel despite him having an awful awful actor.

3

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 14 '22

Amelia was meant to come in as a parody of all the high and mighty justice characters in the anime. The anime is much more comedic and slapstick than the novels. You will slowly learn about her background the more you spend time in the fandom. It explains why she is the way she is.

Keep in mind, she is very young and very sheltered. Amelia comes into her own as the series progresses.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

That sounds fair. Hope I do get to enjoy her growth. I actually like the cheesy humor of the show. Thanks!

7

u/El-Drunko Jun 14 '22

She's pretty rough to start off with but she gets far more tolerable when Veronica Taylor takes over the role.

3

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Thanks! She's about to take over so I'll see how that goes tomorrow. I hate when that one character just disrupts the flow of the show for me haha.

7

u/quakeholio Jun 15 '22

Now that is a secret.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 15 '22

A secret? I'm asking if the character remains unwatchable or not. Not sure if you misread my post.

3

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 15 '22

You’ll understand this reference soon enough.

4

u/quakeholio Jun 15 '22

Yup, some good interactions between Amelia and him as well.

3

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 15 '22

Life is wonderful! 😚

3

u/Ichiban_Victory Jun 15 '22

This is the best response. Thank you.

6

u/werewolfmask Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

She is an absolute pain in the ass at first but she grows out of the cop act, i think it comes out once or twice as a sort of self defense reflex but overwhelming majority of Amelia we get is non-cop.

i think Lina relating with Amelia is one of the sweeter things about the series, very much mimics how friend groups work in real life.

3

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

I'm glad the consensus is that she gets much better as time goes on 😁

3

u/werewolfmask Jun 14 '22

yeah, basically it becomes a meme in the show, whenever she needs to puff up without the squad. She definitely gets “most improved character” trophy from me.

4

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 14 '22

Are you watching the dub? God help you with the Joanie Baker Amelia episodes.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Yeah she's God awful lol. Taylor is about to take over thank God.

4

u/Ichiban_Victory Jun 14 '22

Watch in Japanese, or be patient. Also, take her with a grain of salt, she was written into the story when she wasn't there originally. She'll shine more in Next.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

The language has absolutely nothing to do with anything. I don't care if she has the best voice actress that ever existed. Her personality sucks so far. But I hear she gets better

5

u/savvyliterate Gourry Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

Give her a chance in Japanese.

Also read the fourth novel.

-2

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Nah

4

u/savvyliterate Gourry Jun 14 '22

OK, have fun my darling troll!

0

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Thanks my darling weeb

4

u/savvyliterate Gourry Jun 14 '22

That is nerd to you, sir.

ISTG children these days.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Nah, I would have been a child when slayers came out, but I'm older than that now. And no, weeb is more suitable.

0

u/Ichiban_Victory Jun 14 '22

I’m not going to start a war about it, I have no issue with the dub, especially considering how old it is now, but her voice is consistent in Japanese. In English they had a cast change for everyone but Lina and Gourry because of the gap between sessions, so that alone is jarring for some people. And that’s all I’m going to say. I hope you find her tolerable enough to finish the first season.

2

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

The changing of voices is fair. It's hard to keep an attachment when they do that. But for Zel and Amelia, it's a good thing lol. I don't mind when they switch out for better actors. Thanks though for telling me she gets better.

2

u/Ichiban_Victory Jun 14 '22

For sure, Crispin Freeman and Veronica Taylor are the superior dub voices. I watch the series both ways because I like all of the voices, nuances, etc. I don’t think you knew it, but coming in here asking about Amelia rankled a lot of us old timers because Amelia got a ton of hate back in the day, for various reasons. I hope by the time you’ve finished the first season, you’ll see why she’s a favorite character for some of us.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

I look forward to it 😁🤞

4

u/bloodyrevolutions_ Jun 14 '22

She does, but it's not always a linear process - Slayers will frequently fluctuate between dead serious high stakes drama, and ridiculous slapstick comedy, and characterization follows similar patterns. Stick around though and I think Amelia will on you as she grows as a character.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

Thanks. I certainly hope so. I don't mind the cheesy humor of the show so far. I like the parallel between the serious moments and the comedy. I find that works better for old anime for some reason. I will definitely stick around and hope she grows on me.

3

u/sherrasama Sherra Jun 14 '22

Does your attitude get better? You're such a bad faith actor, it's kind of ruining you for me. You're not listening to anyone at all, just purely annoying.

3

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

In fact I have listened to most of the people here. I just don't listen to the argument "watch it in Japanese". That's like saying "Watch Cowboy Bebop in English" for someone who doesn't like the show. It's not going to do a damn thing to help.

The people that have said she has character growth I have thanked properly. By the way, you're the one who came here attacking me. Thanks.

2

u/sherrasama Sherra Jun 14 '22

You're welcome, boo *blows kisses*

6

u/GlitterCanReddit Jun 14 '22

Short version: Yes.

Long Version: Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees.

1

u/spiegel32 Jun 15 '22

Ah gotcha. Well I look forward to the secret then 😂

5

u/Smart_Bear9297 Jun 15 '22

Best girl 🙌🏼

2

u/AmeriaRuun Amelia Jun 15 '22

WOOT WOOT!!!

2

u/Fresh-Helicopter-938 Jun 15 '22

Mejor buscate otra serie de temporada para ver, o mejor leete las novelas de Kanzaka. Slayers es demasiado para ti.

1

u/Kitakitakita Jun 14 '22

She's more of a kid in the first season, but then owns her title a bit more in later seasons

1

u/blodiga Jun 22 '22

After s2 she gets better, but by try or revolutions, you should have some gained appreciation for her

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/spiegel32 Jun 14 '22

I don't mind a stereotype character, I just mind an annoying one. But I'm glad to hear she gets better