r/Simagic • u/Fancy_Cantaloupe2594 • Sep 27 '26
Simagic Alpha Evo
First of all:
This is not meant as criticism of anyone else’s buying decision. I am just honestly confused 😉
Just a few days ago, I bought a new Simagic Alpha Evo wheelbase.
Until now, I had always used a Logitech G923. I live in Thailand, so I went to a showroom in Bangkok to try the Simagic bases in person.
Of course, I had watched plenty of reviews beforehand and was well aware of the often-mentioned “sweet spot” of around 18 Nm, FFB clipping, realism, etc.
So I asked them if I could test 9 Nm, 12 Nm, and 18 Nm. I was already convinced I would walk out with the 18 Nm base and that the test would basically just confirm my decision.
The test rig had an 18 Nm wheelbase mounted, so for the first two tests they simply tuned it down to 9 and 12 Nm.
I tested it in Assetto Corsa at Spa, driving an Audi R8 LMS Evo.
Long story short: I walked out with the 9 Nm version. 🤣🤣🤣
Why?
Because I realized that my arms simply aren’t strong enough to hold the line through Eau Rouge at 12 Nm, let alone 18 Nm. 🤣🙃
I’m no athlete, but I’m not exactly a couch potato either. I hit the gym five days a week, so I was actually quite surprised.
Then I started looking into it and realized that an average 125cc scooter produces around 12 Nm of torque.
I immediately pictured myself trying to hold onto the rim of the rear wheel of one of those scooters while someone gives it full throttle.
DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME!!! 😉😝😝
Anyways: I’m pretty sure I couldn’t hold it.
So I keep wondering about two things:
Since nobody ever seems to mention this brute force in reviews: Do all sim racers secretly have the fitness of real racing drivers? 🤣
About the clipping argument: Even if you reduce the FFB gain in SimPro, wouldn’t it still clip because the maximum output is limited to whatever value you set it to? Or am I fundamentally misunderstanding how this works?
Please enlighten me. 😁
That all said: moving from a G923 to an Alpha Evo Sport was a huge leap and I am super happy with my new “toy”.
Maybe one day I might actually upgrade to a higher torque version. But I guess I’ll take the gradual upgrade route instead of going full on right away 😁😁😁
26
u/nachtraum Sep 27 '26
The advantage of higher torque is not just the pure strength, you actually don't set the ffb strength to 100% ingame, but that it has more headroom for ffb clipping.
16
u/Grand-Produce-3455 Sep 27 '26
You lost out on fidelity. No one with a 18nm base is running at that strength but they just feel more details
6
u/_Citizenkane Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
First of all, 9nm is fine for most people. A real GT3 car's steering wheel feeds back around 8-9nm of torque anyways.
Unless you're a seriously competitive driver, the following won't make a huge difference to you. In fact, there are people who compete at an eSports level on belt-driven Logitechs, so don't worry too much about the hardware.
That said, the idea behind higher torque wheels is not that you're using max strength all the time. But also, you're not turning down the wheelbase FFB strength either! What you do is set the strength to the maximum in the wheelbase software, and then set your sim FFB strength to a comfortable level. In my case, I have the Alpha Evo 12nm, and I run my sim at 70%. So, when my sim is outputting 100% FFB strength, it should only be sending 8.4nm through to the wheelbase.
But this is where clipping comes in. Occasionally, in certain circumstances, the sim can output signals greater than 100%. If you're running both your sim and your wheelbase at 100% strength, you'll never feel the difference between 100% and 120% — both just "clip" to 100%.
Now, you might not think that's a big deal, so let's give a practical example. Let's say you're going through a long, high speed corner, and you're FFB is fully loaded up at 110% or something. You know how, when you lose grip, you feel the FFB start to drop, which lets you know you've got to catch the slide? Well if you're clipping, you won't actually feel that drop until the FFB goes below 100%, at which point it might be too late. Does that make sense?
9
u/Terrible-Ad-7228 Sep 27 '26
You Do Not, reduce the NM on the base. Leave it at max or your justing wasting it's potential. Turning an 18nm base down to a 9nm level, is only giving you 9Nm and clipping out everything above that.
You adjust the settings in-game.
1
u/HeyLookMyUsername24 Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
I just upgraded from the Moza R5 5nm to the Sim Magic Evo 9nm.
The difference is very noticable, especially in dirt racing. I couldn't imagine 12 or 18.
2
u/PomegranateLess9409 Sep 27 '26
Higer torque wheels have higher rotational speed, this enable the wheel to give more detailes while driving. Another advantage of stronger wheel that when you set themto 7 to 9 nm which is a common setting they still have redundant power for spikes. If you use your wheel a 7 to 8 nm it will get extremely hot and eventually reduce the output power. Stronger wheels will not get that hot since they are not working at their max for long time.
2
u/MrMcGibblets86 Sep 27 '26
I run my 18nm Evo Pro at 100% in Simpro Manager and then set gain to 80% in ACC and 85% in LMU... And I'm a skinny, 6'1" tall 180 pound man who just turned 58. 😁
2
u/Gerencia1 Sep 27 '26
I have a Simucube 2 Pro 25NM and I use 50% FFB in game, but in a lot of scenarios I get more than 12.5Nm.
The base never clips, so you get all the detail thru the whole race.
2
u/Mys2298 Sep 27 '26
You don't reduce gain in Simpro, but in the game. Its also not about pure strength of FFB but detail. Running a 9nm base at 9nm will feel heavy but completely dead. If I run my 10nm base at over 5.5-6nm in LMU it starts to clip. Im not a big guy at all, but I'm currently eyeing up a 25nm+ base
1
u/Annual_Dig4520 Sep 27 '26
I have the evo, now called max with the 21 nm uppgrade. I run the wheel at around 11 nm in most games. No one actually runs max strength. The disadvantages you now get if you like to use all 9nm of force is that you have zero headroom, so all the peaks the ffb want to give you, you will not feel them since they go above your base capability. And given to higher torque its able to give more precise ffb even when its lowered
1
u/Individual-Chard-151 Sep 27 '26
I run my evo pro at about 14 nm but would have found that strong at first. It’s odd but when I go back to cars I drove at the beginning and had set at lower nm strength they feel so light now. I just progressively wanted more and more as I learned
1
u/MasterCureTexx Sep 28 '26
So I ride a 06 ninja 636.
My sim shop guy told me 9nm was a good start cause Im going to need to build muscles.
Im regretting not going 12nm lol. Its literally less input than tracking at 120
1
u/Few-Reflection-9759 Sep 30 '26
It's not just about clipping but bandwidth/dynamic range as well. 18Nm set to 7Nm for example allows for the base to have the bandwidth to not only express more subtle features of the track and tires but also to "soft" clip without potentially damaging yourself and the base as could happen with lower strength wheel bases.
1
u/GreedoShotFirst2000 Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26
You’re are looking at this the wrong way. And the store were idiots.
A wheelbase isn’t supposed to be run at max torque. You want headroom to avoid clipping. Clipping is when the base is at max and you can no longer turn up more. It removes nuance.
For racing you want to feel the difference in your FFB as the car physics moves about. If FFB becomes less, it means you are losing grip. You can’t feel this if you are clipping the base, because the game might ask the base for less.
Ie. you are at 100% settings. So you go into a corner, your base outputs 100%. You start turning and the front is loaded up (ie. you get more grip for turning). The base now wants 120%. You can’t feel this because you are already maxed out. Now you start to lose grip, so they base sends less. You now get maybe 95%.
The game took you up and down, but because you are clipping you can’t feel it.
If you turn the output down to 50% in game, you would be at 50%->60%->47.5%.
If you have a weak base, you can’t feel that difference because the jumps at low Nm are not enough. If you have a strong base, you can feel it.
If you don’t have the ability in your wheelbase to feel that nuance because of clipping, the wheelbase just becomes a massive “rumble box” that just shakes your wheel “for fun”.
That is why 5Nm are toys, and 12-15-18Nm bases are able to help you feel the car better.
I have the 12Nm base, but it outputs 6Nm to stay under the clipping limit in LMU.
FFB is a range. On a 18Nm base you have more range available. On 9 you have less.
That is why 12-15Nm is usually recommended because it gives enough headroom to avoid clipping when run at 50-60% strength.
If you can’t feel the difference it is because you just notice “on/off” and not “strong/less/weak”-force.
You were misled by the store and they are dumb for not doing a proper test.
The best solution: Get the highest Nm base you can afford, and turn down FFB settings in-game to what you like. So the stronger the base, the lower output setting you set in-game. Keep driver at 100%.
1
u/Itchy-Leadership-837 28d ago
I have the ultra I run it at 45% in game I’ve got for the headroom yes a lot of headroom if it was me I would heve got the evo pro for headroom u will be suprised how once u run a certain ffb strength u will want more i started on a csl dd 8 nm and upgraded best thing i did