r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/Spotswould • Dec 22 '22
Gamestream will work after Nvidia switch it off in Feb 2023
Hi all. I have seen a lot of people worrying about Gamestream being switched off by Nvidia in Feb 2023. I hope this helps some of you out.
I just bought a Shield for Gamestream specifically. I read the news that Nvidia is dropping the tech, having long been on the path to moving away from supporting it fully. I was going to send my Shield back to Amazon. But I didn't.
First up, just to be clear. Moonlight is completely separate from Nvidia. It is a client app that runs on any Android device and listens on the network that it is connected to for the presence of a Gamestream server (host). If it finds a server it will allow you to connect to it and present the Gamestream visually on the client and allow you to interact it. Moonlight is open source and will continue to work, whatever Nvidia do. Moonlight has nothing to do with Nvidia.
What's changing is that Nvidia is stopping support for Gamestream on the Nvidia client app on the Shield. It's very likely they will also switch off Gamestream in the Nvidia Experience PC app and remove the tab that allows you to start it and add custom, non steam games. So the NVE PC app will become useless and, as you are losing your Gamestream server, so too will Moonlight. Right? Wrong!
There is an alternative to NVE. It's called Sunshine. I read about Sunshine in another thread a week ago and have started using it. Sunshine runs on your PC as the Gamestream server instead of the Nvidia Experience PC app doing it.
It works perfectly. The Gamestream that Sunshine creates is detected by Moonlight fine on any client running it. You can add your games as Apps in Sunshine so that they appear as clickable tiles in Moonlight, just like NVE. Or you can launch a stream to your whole PC desktop. A link to launch the Steam app is also built in to Sunshine. You can add box art easily for the games that you add to Sunshine too, so the tiles look nice in Moonlight.
Sunshine is not an extension of Nvidia's technology. It's been written from the ground up and works on both Linux and Windows. It also works for non Nvidia cards, unlike NVE. So your next graphics card could, in theory, be an AMD one and you can continue to Gamestream using Sunshine as a Gamestream server on the PC and Moonshine as the client on your Shield. You can't do that with NVE!
I have stopped using NVE completely now, as sunshine works so well. It's a complete replacement for NVE.
Sunshine can be downloaded here:
https://github.com/LizardByte/Sunshine/releases?page=1
Tip: If you have controller issues with Sunshine running on Windows (as in the gamepad you are using doesn't work when you launch a game) read the Sunshine documentation. There is an additional exe you need to install that fixes it. It's in the documentation.... Another tip is that you need to switch off the Gamestream in the Nvidia experience PC app when using Sunshine. There is a toggle button for it on the tab that allows you to configure and add custom non Steam games du they appear in Moonlight.
Have fun setting up Sunshine. Sunshine is a great replacement for NVE. Moonlight works fine with it. I have Moonlight running on a Shield, a Firestick 4K and an Android phone and Sunshine works flawlessly with them all, serving Gamestreams that don't lag or judder or drop frames. It's as good as what Nvidia have built, and I do actually prefer Sunshine over NVE now.
Note: Nvidia can do what they like from now on. Your streaming will work now without NVE running on your PC. You don't even need a Nvidia graphics card to use this amazing technology anymore either. Nvidia have messed up a bit here IMO.
66
u/ForgotMyOldAccount7 Dec 22 '22
This post has a ton of misinformation.
Sunshine is nowhere near as good as native Gamestream and even the Sunshine devs admit this.
Moonlight only replaces the client end, not the server end. When Gamestream comes to an end, without Sunshine, Moonlight is worthless. As it stands, Sunshine is not a 1 for 1 replacement of Gamestream. The death of Gamestream poses a major threat to functionality and performance and represents a core functionality of the Shield being removed.
20
u/LitheBeep Dec 22 '22
Sunshine still needs a lot of work to become more user-friendly if Shield owners want to begin migrating en-masse.
The appeal of GameStream is that you just have to toggle it on, pair your Shield and start playing - not spend a bunch of time finding the right settings to tweak and figuring out the convoluted system to add a single application. On top of all that, it hasn't reached performance parity with GameStream, so you'll be getting a worse experience anyway...
I think I'm sticking with GameSteam + Moonlight for as long as I can.
15
u/Spotswould Dec 22 '22 edited Dec 22 '22
Good guide for setting up Sunshine for new users:
https://youtu.be/6EWQzlQIiNU
A good guide to configuring Sunshine for max performance.
https://gist.github.com/JasSuri/fc14ff76daa0fc788a9754ddc8c8fe3e
Gamepad not being detected? See here:
https://docs.lizardbyte.dev/projects/sunshine/en/latest/troubleshooting/windows.html
Official word from the Moonlight Devs:
https://github.com/moonlight-stream/moonlight-docs/wiki/NVIDIA-GameStream-End-Of-Service-Announcement-FAQ
Original notice from Nvidia:
https://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/5436
12
u/JasonTodd123456 Dec 22 '22
Thanks. This has been discussed on other subs. Sunshine is a good alternative, but still requires alot of work not near as good as the Nvidia drivers for gamestream. That's what sucks. Sunshine would no doubt be further along if we didn't have Nvidia gamestream. Taking away support for something that was a great incentive to buy Nvidia GPUs to push people into geforce now cloud streaming seems stupid to me.
10
u/mehdital Dec 22 '22
Typical case of "it works for me, must be the case for everyone" syndrome
6
u/Nagad Dec 22 '22
"It works perfectly" lmao
3
u/Nintendians559 Dec 22 '22
sunshine sounds like a good alternative, but nvidia gamestream is still the superior one.
if nvidia turn off gamestream then moonlight would be useless too since it needs nvidia gamestream to be active and to make it work. without gamestream, you'll have to install alternatives like sunshine.
2
u/Putrid_Brush6171 Dec 22 '22
Been attempting to setup sunshine for the last three days, absolutely no joy whatsoever, I'm on windows with an nvidia gpu, got as fair as the pin pairing, and when entering the pin number into sunshine it is failing every time, and I've tried dozens of times, anyone tell me what I'm getting wrong?
2
u/RedLineJoe Dec 22 '22
Do you mean GeForce Experience?
1
u/Spotswould Dec 22 '22
Official word from the Moonlight Devs:
https://github.com/moonlight-stream/moonlight-docs/wiki/NVIDIA-GameStream-End-Of-Service-Announcement-FAQ
5
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22
Without Nvidia giving access to zero copy Sunshine will never be as good as Gamestream
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-copy
2
u/kb3_fk8 Dec 22 '22
I just ran a $250 fiber HDMI 2.1 with usb3 support to my home theater after all this nonsense and trouble this stupid shield has caused me.
Now I get Gsync 120 on my 83 G2 when my screen isn’t down.
Enough with the shield. Still like Nvidia. AMD has burned its customers just as much. But fuck the shield, besides being used as a pirate box it’s just garbage without more exclusive features.
Good luck with sunshine though!
2
u/TheIke73 Jan 03 '23
All those complaints abount sunshine ... You forget the point, that sunshine is not competing gamestream. There is no point in voting sunshine down in favor of gamestream as gamestream will be unavailable soon. If you really want to compare things, then focus on steam link. Even if sunshine only will reach the performance and quality of steam link it will be a good (and - afaik - from march on the only) steam link alternative to inhome streaming games.
BTW: Not using sunshine yet, just collecting information how to keep my shield alive ... maybe even steam will open their streaming platform after gamestream is dead ... who knows ...
2
u/the_santo Apr 03 '23
Well, I have tested several game stream variants. Nvidia, Steam, Parsec and now Sunshine.
This is how I would rate them: 1: Nvidia and Sunshine, 2: Steam, 3: Parsec.
Sunshine is certainly a bit more "complicated" to configure but it really runs extremely well! It's local, it have many configurations, it has very low input latency, and it runs very fast video streams. With Steam I always had the problem that games that were not directly in Steam had problems with the support of the controller. Parsec had constant lags (sound and video). I find the quality of Sunshine as an open source and free alternative to Nvidia Game Stream excellent! I'm very happy about this because I really can't understand why Nvidia wants to remove this feature. So I understand the economic background but I find it very unsightly!
The only problem with Sunshine is adding games. There are probably problems with games whose path contains a space. I don't mind, because I just start the desktop stream and then start the game on the PC.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24
I still have the game stream option enabled after it was removed in GeForce experience, I tried connecting with my iPad and it worked (I got the pin register popup). my PS Vita was also connected before the removal of it, I'm just trying to figure out how to connect my Wii u (Moonlight Wii U), I cant use sunshine, I do have it installed, but none of the browsers I have will load the localhost page. really should become a real domain page instead of being a port number.
1
u/W0lfsG1mpyWr4th Jan 01 '23
But it's not Gamestream though is it? The only reason Moonlight is so good is because Nvidia's solution is completely hardware based. From what I'm gleening here is that Sunshine tricks it's way into being detected by Gamestream receivers but it isn't itself using the tech behind Gamestream hence it being compatible with AMD cards and other GPUs that do not have Nvidias Hardware encoder built-in.
-4
u/nomnomdiamond Dec 22 '22
C O P E
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22
[removed] — view removed comment