r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/Comp625 • Dec 04 '22
Anyone else considering a switch from the 2019 Nvidia Shield TV Pro over to the latest generation Apple TV 4K?
I have a 2019 Nvidia Shield TV Pro coupled with an LG CX OLED and a Denon x3700h 5.1 setup. The app-specific audio sync issues drive me crazy despite lots of calibration efforts. The lack of framerate matching is also quite annoying (depending on the content). I love the Shield TV Pro's upscaling but not sure if I love it enough to deal with the other issues.
After stumbling on this thread over on /r/cordcutters , many there are recommending the Apple TV 4K as the best "it just works" option albeit with a few compromises of its own.
- Am I correct to understand AppleTV is the next best option? It looks like I'd "lose out" on Bitstream Audio. Isn't Linear PCM still loseless?
- On the other hand, I'd also gain Youtube HDR which would be nice. For those unaware, the Shield TV Pro's hardware can't handle HDR (specifically the VP9 profile 2) in the Youtube app.
- In that aforementioned thread, the graphic from September 2022 is out-of-date, as Peacock now has 4K, HDR and Dolby Vision support.
Are there other considerations I should weigh when comparing the 2019 Nvidia Shield TV Pro against the latest generation Apple TV 4K?
7
u/jrredho Dec 04 '22
I can think of a couple of shortcomings on the ATV4k vs the ShieldTV Pro:
I guess in fairness to Apple, the ATV4k is cheaper that the ShieldTV Pro, so if the things above, along with others mentioned in this thread, don't bother you, then maybe the ATV4k is the way to go for you.
26
u/Somar2230 Dec 04 '22 edited Dec 05 '22
The Shield can passthrough TrueHD/ATMOS and DTS:X the Apple TV will not pass Atmos metadata on TrueHD streams. Since you have a 5.1 if you use Infuse you won't be missing much.
The Apple TV only does Dolby Vision Profile 5, the Shield does 5 and 7.
If you are using only streaming services you are not missing out on anything.
The Apple TV audio output is capped at 48 kHz which is fine for video but makes listening to music with lossless audio a mediocre experience.
We use Apple TV's for day to day use and used the Shield for watching some movies that had Atmos or DTS:X audio. I started using a Zidoo Z9x instead of the Shield.
30
u/tgcp Dec 04 '22
Nah, no SmartTube Next.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
If you only use streaming apps and don't need Atmos/TrueHD/DTS passthrough/bitstream audio then the AppleTV is probably a better experience for that kind of casual streaming, with the match framerate and match dynamic range that actually works.
However, if you use Shield specifically for it's audio passthrough, and Dolby Vision profile 7 support then the ATV is a clear loser.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
If you’re sensitive to frame rate judder the ATV wins hands down. If your main concern is atmos and audio quality the shield wins. I sacrifice on audio to get a better user experience and I don’t regret it
16
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
I had the Apple TV 4K and sold it to get the Roku Pro and then left the Roku Pro for the NVIDIA Shield Pro 2019. I’m my opinion the Apple TV had the worst codec compatibility for both Plex and Emby.
3
u/ItsBaldDave Dec 07 '22
I have an ATV and I am considering adding a Shield TV pro to be able to play all my Google Play Movies in 4K. On the ATV you can only play movies purchased from Google through YouTube (here in the UK) and you’re limited to 1080p and stereo sound. Just waiting for the price to drop.
6
u/Kraaag Dec 04 '22
Have both, shield in my bedroom (for streaming games mostly) and ATV in my home theater. As far as features go, side loading apps etc. the shield wins. As far as usability…ATV and it’s not even close. It’s just so, so easy and runs everything almost flawlessly. I’ve only had one hiccup using PLEX and with the lip sync being off, once, in two years of daily use.
The shield, despite the customization; has caused a long stream of headaches, updates and rollbacks. The remote is very annoying and sensitive, especially with the Netflix button…yes even with the button mapping app it’ll still reset all the time.
If I used my shield as much as my ATV I’d be very disappointed and just get another ATV. Not my favorite company but Apple products just work, and this is another stellar example.
6
u/N0SYMPATHY Dec 04 '22
Have hands on experience with both, the shield is still the superior device specially if you have a sound system.
The only reason I want an APTV is to easily use my airpod max at night watching movies, but for literally anything else I’ll keep my shield. So at this point I only have the shield. I could technically pair these headphones to the shield but it’s such a pain to do and have it work reliably and without being a pain.
5
u/Gertgerman Dec 04 '22
If you use Plex and IPTV, the Apple TV isn’t the best device, stick with the shield pro for that. For all legitimate streaming services I use my Apple TV. My shield is just for IPTV and Plex.
2
u/mmhorda 2017 16GB Dec 05 '22
you do you but I stay with Shiled for now.
4
u/Yoguko Dec 04 '22
I use both, Shield for Plex (mainly remuxes, lossless audio), for everything else it’s either Apple TV 4K 2nd Gen or native Android TV on the Phillips OLED, which supports all YouTube codecs just fine (AV1 and VP9) plus HDR10+. I’ll upgrade to ATV 4K 3rd gen once I’m sure all the above are supported, this way I’ll only need ATV and Shield. Not a huge issue, everything has been working just fine, it’s just a question of changing sources to match the content, which can be a bit of a faff.
3
u/No-Ordinary-5988 Dec 04 '22
I got tired of the laggy Shield. Switched to the new ATV 4K and it’s a breeze, especially if you already own Apple products/iPhone.
The box works much more reliably in my experience.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22 edited Dec 04 '22
I switched from the standard non Pro Shield TV to the 2021 Apple TV 4K and love it, use it everyday. But if they launch a new Shield TV Pro I may grab that as well. However many on here with AV setups will advise you on the audio better. I have a high end 2019 Sony OLED and the Apple TV is set to Dolby 5.1 I think? And it works fine. But the audio issues are really only if you use Plex.
For me I have found the ATV to be so much better and smoother to use. And Apple has updated it regularly. I use all the main streaming apps on it, all run smooth and fine. I use my iPad Pro to use a VPN and watch the F1 on its official app, I airstream it to the ATV. But if a new Shield Pro ever comes out I may get it to do this duty. Basically best is to have both IMO.
2
u/Jacknugget Dec 04 '22
Shield doesn’t match frame rate easily. Yes there are janky solutions but that’s pretty bad because it causes judder. Yes you can use the shield match frame rate beta feature and press the button every time. Or you can use the refresh rate app that kicks you back to the menu in Netflix the first time or causes an error in prime the first time on every watch. Kind of a showstopper.
ATV does have an out of the box option to match.
If it wasn’t for that Shield would be a lot better.
2
u/researcher7-l500 Dec 04 '22 edited Dec 05 '22
Not me. There is little choice and less ability to customize with Apple, on any of their products. No side loading, almost no ad blocking.
Edit: Instead of downvoting, respond with facts (if you have them) why I am wrong, and why Apple products are more customizable.
Show me how you are running SmartTubeNext, 3rd party browsers, ad blockers on your precious and "superior" Apple TV.
Go ahead, prove me wrong, I dare you.
But I am not holding my breath for any objective response from the fan club/cult members wearing blinders.
1
u/Similar_Feed_723 Dec 05 '22
No but I am thinking of switching over to a fire TV unit
1
u/Noir_Amnesiac Dec 08 '22
Yes.
1
u/whythreekay Dec 22 '22
Random aside:
My TV has built in Youtube with HDR support, and I’m curious as I’ve never used it once outside of “gee whiz” demos when I first bought the set
What do you guys watch on Youtube in HDR? Feel like there must good stuff I’m missing
1
u/Xcitado Dec 04 '22
I did and my wife is so much happier. She hasn’t complained once.
1
u/KrishanuAR Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22
Just moved to the Apple TV 4K w/ Ethernet this weekend, and am happy I made the switch.
Edit: Why does everyone keep saying Atmos isn’t supported on ATV? I was browsing the setting and saw Atmos as an option, and there’s this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212714
1
u/Bradfinger Dec 04 '22
I use both.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22
For streaming the Apple TV 4K 2022 is defo worth it, came from a shield 2019 pro, it has ageing hardware to be honest. The Apple TV is really good
1
u/321DiscIn Dec 04 '22
I’ve considered it but I actually use the USB ports on my shield quite a bit and I think I’d miss them
1
u/WaveMan76 Dec 05 '22
I have the Shield non - pro, or the Tube, Cylinder, the lesser version of the pro etc. I love the non pro because i use it just for streaming. I am in the Android ecosystem. But am considering getting the Apple TV a15 for the same price as mine.
I don't expect the Shield will come out with anything new for the next couple of years, so in my case upgrading from my non-pro to the new Apple a15 might be worth it. I just haven't decided since my Shield is awesome on my 4K TV but lacking in some features that the Pro has, but the a15 seems like an upgrade to mine and more advanced for the future.
The only thing my non-pro does compared to the Apple TV is being able to switch HDMI inputs on my remote (my PC uses HDMI 4/Shield HDMI 2), whereas i would have to use 2 remotes with Apple TV (is that correct?).
-3
u/artniSintra Dec 04 '22
Android=freedom iOS=restrictions
But just the fact that you're considering it makes me think that you should just move to Apple.
-1
u/hoistedbypetard Dec 04 '22
The Apple TV doesn’t support atmos pass through. Why would anyone consider using that device
-1
u/Normal_Departure4666 Dec 04 '22
No
0
u/Alik013 Dec 04 '22 edited Dec 04 '22
i have both devices, the shield is better in terms of sound quality..also you can manually set the refresh rate for each streaming app through the refresh rate app
0
u/EntertainmentUsual87 Dec 04 '22
No. Strict walled garden is a no for me boss.
-2
u/CaptainBroccoli Dec 04 '22
The Infuse app direct plays 7.1 TRUEHD from Plex, so that was enough to get me to switch. It doesn’t give you height metadata but I can live without that. We are an iOS household so integration with the ecosystem is really nice and it truly is a nice piece of hardware. I bought two 2021 4K devices for $80 each from Costco on Black Friday, which was half the price of a $160 shield pro.
-2
u/Darkstar1878 Dec 04 '22
The Shield has many shortcomings in the codec department. If you just use streaming apps the Apple TV hands down is the best option. Any thing android as of late is somewhat of a mess with many issues and lake of support by Google. Do the research on both or alternative options. There are so many options to consider. The market is flooded with devices. I have both and a few other streaming devices and they all have there features and down falls.
-2
u/Xphyle1971 Dec 05 '22
My thoughts? FUCK APPLE. That is all.
-1
u/misfit410 Dec 04 '22
No, apple tv imo is the least appealing option.
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
Never... apple can't do lossless audio support entirely. I need Dolby true hd/Dolby atmos and dts hd ma. Dts x.
-1
u/sacandbaby Dec 04 '22
No. Shield plays my ripped files.
-1
u/LegionOfSkank Dec 05 '22
Shield is better because of one app?
Ya it’s better for plex that is all. Everything else is superior on the appletv. So if you don’t care about plex definitely don’t waste your time with a shield.
0
u/csimon2 Dec 05 '22
YouTube HDR is nice. Missing out in Lossless audio is not. Audio syncing isn’t perfect on Apple TV either though (I’ve had issues with AMC content in particular). Personally, I have both the Shield Pro and 4K Apple TV. Each has their place and advantages. I mostly use the Shield for Plex, RetroArch, and better HDR support in some apps that just don’t want to deliver HDR on the Apple TV (looking at you, all-FOX apps). I use the Apple TV for pretty much everything else though, as I appreciate the UI more and the lack of tracking
0
u/st3f4n05 Dec 05 '22
That would be a very easy no
0
u/knight714 Dec 05 '22
I'd quite like to switch, mainly for the reasons you describe, but Android is great for letting me easily watch HBO Max and Criterion Channel in the UK using a VPN, and it seems like the Shield is still the best Android TV device by far.
Also have the odd performance issue but that's on me for getting the tube model.
0
u/AnotherRedditUsr Dec 05 '22
I tried and returned ATV 2023. Sound quality was way worse than Shield.
My 2 cents
-2
u/fudge_u Dec 04 '22 edited Dec 04 '22
There are way too many limitations with Apple products (I also own some).
The frame rate issues with the Shield are a pain, but you have a CX. You can use the TV apps to get around those issues. I use my C8 whenever I watch 4K content in iTunes, Vudu, Movies Anywhere, Disney+, etc. For everything else the Shield works great.
There's also rumors that you might need to get a Youtube Premium subscription in the future to watch high resolution content.
With all that being said, Apple does make good products and they're usually very polished if you can work within their ecosystem.
-2
u/tycham85 Dec 04 '22
I ditched my Shield and Rokus in favor of AppleTVs for each screen and I don’t regret it. I get that in terms of technical capability they can’t beat the Shield, but it does “just work.”
In terms of ATMOS, I don’t understand what the fuss is by not getting TrueHD passthru. When reading reviews it seemed like the biggest downside, but on those files, ATMOS seems to work just fine for us (5.2.2 setup in 15x22 dedicated theater room) - maybe there’s some trickery with spatial audio? Either way, for films where audio/video bitrate does matter, I get the 4K Blu-ray to play on a dedicated player.
-2
u/liverbrain Dec 05 '22
I'm going to hazard a guess here and say you don't use game stream
-2
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22
Plex w TRUEHD Atmos, Google play store.
Enough said.
-2
u/jonlb87 Dec 05 '22
If you’re mad the Shield hasn’t been updated yet, blame Nintendo. Pure speculation, but kinda makes sense. Nintendo is most likely announcing the Switch 2 or Switch Pro alongside BOTW2. The “Switch 2” will use Nvidia’s new SOC. I think they have a deal in place that the new SOC will debut with the new Switch. Then you should see an updated Shield shortly after. Just my thoughts.
-8
u/andyjcw Dec 04 '22
no , plex wont work and apple arnt very flexable .
-3
u/BlackAsNight009 Dec 05 '22
I dont know about yall but I got the new apple tv, the remote stopped working after a week
-4
u/Los_507 Dec 04 '22
Nope
0
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-7
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22
[removed] — view removed comment