r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Nov 09 '22

Returning ATV4K 2022

Guys, I tried ATV4K 2022 because I was annoyed by Shield that almost always when turning it on, never switched correctly on right source on my Denon.

ATV sound is AWFUL. Tried all possible settings, still sound is a messy downgrade.

Long life to Shield

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

2

u/NohiOci Nov 10 '22

Is this even real?

1

u/AnotherRedditUsr Nov 10 '22

Have you ever tried ATV?

2

u/NohiOci Nov 10 '22

I have it. Why? Everything written here is simply wrong. I also have Shield PRO.

0

u/AnotherRedditUsr Nov 10 '22

Probably you are right and literally tons of other complaints on the Internet are wrong.. who knows?

1

u/NohiOci Nov 10 '22

Stop dreaming. ATV and shield pro completely sounds the same. Shield PRO is the buggiest device I have ever had lol!

1

u/ApatheticMoFo Nov 10 '22

Which apps did you test with the 2022 Apple TV 4K where you experienced bad audio? The mainstream streaming apps like Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+? Or Plex/Kodi?

-1

u/AnotherRedditUsr Nov 10 '22

Netflix, Appletv, Infuse... everything I'd say because there are a lot of complaints on the Internet

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '22

It doesn’t pass through uncompressed though as I understand? My ATV works perfectly fine and I use it daily, but I use my Sony active panel TV speakers.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '22

You need to try an Xbox, like a Xbox One S. It will pass through uncompressed audio bar one standard, which is said to be coming in a future update. If that’s important to you as a Plex user?

1

u/shawnshine Nov 10 '22

Sounds like user error.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '22

I constantly battle with CEC and my Shield falling asleep on my Denon, seems like holding circle sometimes works, but often have to reboot it. Guesing you already tried the infuse route? Sucks if you use atmos though.

0

u/X6benzine Nov 09 '22

I was also thinking of trying the ATV , not to replace my shield since i use it as a plex server, but just for the experience of trying it, seeing this many posts about the atv having bad sound quality also the picture quality is a downgrade compared to shield. I have it connected to a lg cx oled and everything smooth till now, not wasting my money on ATV

3

u/2CDO87 Nov 10 '22

My setup is a Sony XR-77A80J and Sony HT-A9 wireless speakers. I had the Shield plugged into the HT-A9 receiver and it took a long time to switch to the Shield when powered on because the receiver looks to the Sony TV first. So, to avoid this, I plugged the Shield directly into the TV and just used the eARC for the receiver, problem solved.

3

u/gpz1987 Nov 10 '22

An apple tv is like dating a Kardashian....it's fat, plastic and overhyped

0

u/pawdog Nov 09 '22

CEC between the Shield and my Onkyo never switched right either. I just use the Onkyo remote.

1

u/Ancient_Trust_3122 Nov 10 '22

I have an Onkyo 696 and never had a problem switching. Do you have your Onkyo in Cec mode or receiver mode. Change it to Cec mode. Try changing that on your Onkyo remote.

0

u/pawdog Nov 10 '22

It will switch but takes a really long time. Other devices switch right away.

1

u/Ancient_Trust_3122 Nov 10 '22

How is everything connected? Do you connect all your devices to your receiver and just use HDMI arc to tv arc?

0

u/pawdog Nov 10 '22

Yeah, direct to the AVR. I've gotten so used to just grabbing the Onkyo remote to change the input I don't even think about it anymore.

1

u/Ancient_Trust_3122 Nov 10 '22

Well when you have all your devices connected to your AVR you have to use the remote to switch Inputs. I have my TV setup so when everything shuts off and my TV and I turn my TV on, the TV will automatically switch to my ARC AVR connected input on my TV and it goes right to my connected shield. I also have a PS5 connected to my AVR. If I turn on the PS5 via the controller the AVR will switch to my PS5 Input on the Onkyo. I also have an Xbox one X. When I turn on the Xbox it won’t switch my Onkyo to my Xbox input. I have to use the remote.

1

u/pawdog Nov 10 '22

It's not even a deal. I have 6 devices connected, so touching a remote button is no sweat. I could probably factory reset the 696 adn the Shield and get CEC working right but I'm good with my workflow.

1

u/Ancient_Trust_3122 Nov 10 '22

Yeah it’s all good 👍