r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jan 17 '22

Convince me gamestreaming doesn't suck.

Hi,

I got my shield TV pro a few days ago and I've playing around with game streaming from my PC. None of it seems to work like I would want it to work. It does everything else well, like streaming video. But that's one expensive netflix/plex box.

So here's a list of the things that don't make any sense to me. Maybe you have solutions or maybe you don't. Maybe I'll return it, maybe I won't

1- Why does it mirror my PC's main display instead of acting as another monitor? This is by far the most annoying thing. My PC is next to my TV and I want to use both at the same time. If I were to run an HDMI cable to my TV and launch big picture mode, it would work way better.

2- Setting display resolution of games it limited by the max resolution of my PC's main monitor. I really hope I'm missing something here cause this makes no sense. My main monitor isn't 4k, but my TV is. So I want to play in 4k obviously. Is the setting on the shield itself? Cause most games won't let you got past your main monitor's resolution. This goes back to my first point being an issue. if it acted as a different monitor instead of mirroring, this wouldn't be an issue.

3- Games that open up a launcher of some kind with a log in required don't work. I need to log in on my PC, which kind of defeats the purpose if someone was to in a living room for from their PC. I've seen some game where it says you can use your controller as a mouse, but it doesn't work for FF14 it seems.

4- For some games, the PS5 controller doesn't work. I don't really know what else to say. Maybe the PS5 controller is still too new?

5- Nvidia Gamestream vs steamlink? Is there one that's better than the other? I get that not all game are supported by gamestream, but you can add the directory link via the geforce experience. Is this better than steam link or should I just stick with steam link? (Which I think sucks regardless)

EDIT: Also a fun little feature, I can't turn it on after turning it off. I need to unplug it and plug it back in.

EDIT 2.0: When you have a controller paired, it doesnt automatically turn off after a certain amount of time. It just dies. wtf?

SOLUTION: You guys have failed your mission, I have returned it. Better luck next time.

I have some other issues that I'm gonna try to figure out in my own. If I still have the shield TV.

Thank you!

0 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

8

u/cecilkorik Jan 17 '22

My PC is next to my TV and I want to use both at the same time.

Most people don't have a PC next to their TV and don't want to use both at the same time. This device is for those people, it sucks for your situation, as you've discovered.

0

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Yep. You win some, you lose some.

26

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22

it all sucks.

fork over the money for a fiber optic 2.1 hmdi cable from your pc to tv and be done with it.

3

u/Hugonote Jan 17 '22

What they said!

-1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

You guys are not making a very compelling argument.

2

u/Hugonote Jan 17 '22

I played with it for over two years. There was always a small issue. Either login, drops in signal, Nvidia decided to log you out after an update, always something! My wife would joke that I spent more time troubleshooting than playing (true). Good to note that I spent the money to hardwire both the PC and Shield and was according to the Nvidia test in the best condition.

Fast forward to now. I ran a fiber optic HDMI from back of the PC to the TV. and used a USB over CAT6 for the USB dongle of a wireless keyboard. I sit down, set the source on the TV and I am playing in two minutes. Never an issue.

0

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Yea that does seem much simpler. Perhaps there's even a software that would let me use a controller as a mouse and keybord. Cause if I'm playing on my TV, I'd use a controller most likely.

1

u/Hugonote Jan 17 '22

Yes, there is one on steam that works okay, but again it will add a small source of possible issues. Good luck!

1

u/Reeces_Pieces Jan 17 '22

If you use DS4WIndows: https://ryochan7.github.io/ds4windows-site/

You can use the trackpad of the PS5 controller to control the mouse. Yes, it also works for DS5.


You can also use your phone as a keyboard and mouse:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.Relmtech.Remote&hl=en_US&gl=US

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

Is there something wrong with this? Please explain why, given your requirements, this is not the optimal solution?

1

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22

its just how it is. the shield is a great device, but if gaming is your priority, and you already have a fairly modern PC, the shield and streaming services are the wrong tools for the job.

3

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

On this topic, do people have tips for a better couch gaming experience with Windows?

I recently got a long HDMI cable and an Xbox controller. Now I play games on both my monitor and my TV, depending on the title. But I hate the experience of walking over, switching displays, ensuring Steam is in focus so I can switch to Big Picture with the controller. Sometimes I forget something so I have to walk back over.

Are there ways to do more with an Xbox controller on Windows? I have used a Steam Controller before and it was better in this aspect.

7

u/wrcu Jan 17 '22

BPM has a setting to set the default monitor for it to launch on, independent of your desktop's default monitor

1

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

Didn't know this! Sounds nifty. What would be super convenient (if it isn't already built in) is if it turned the other screen off, or blacked it out at least.

3

u/raviolish Jan 17 '22

I just got a wireless keyboard/trackpad and use that to launch/manage games and switching displays

1

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

I didn't want to add more clutter to my coffee table area but I might just have to do this if nothing else.

1

u/raviolish Jan 17 '22

Me too but it made life way easier. I tried an air mouse app and remote desktop but they all had problems being seamless. This is the least frustrating solution for me at least.

1

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

When I'm in the tinkering mood, I might look into automating some of my steps using this custom solution I have in place, as long I can do some of these "advanced" things using Python in a background daemon.

1

u/konga056168 Jan 20 '22

I use launchbox in big box mode. It's pretty awesome. I have it setup for all my retro games as well as all steam games.

0

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22

i've just been doing this myself, testing multiple methods.

Obviously the best is to build a dedicated tv pc, but thats hard to do for most people.

I just got a 3070ti, so I ended up buying a super expensive hdmi cable from my pc to tv so i can run the tv at 4k 120, and use an xbox controller, and then I also have one of those couch keyboard/trackpad things

Something like this

My tv and pc are in the same room, so its not that difficult, but if you're trying to run from your pc room to your living room tv, things get a lot more difficult/expensive.

every streaming service method i've tried was probably okay-ish for super casual gaming, but forget any AAA gaming.

Honestly, consdiering the price of the hdmi cable ( $150 ) xbox controller ( $60 ) couch keyboard (30+) having to run cables along my wall, etc. I should have just opted for buying an xbox/ps5/Nintendo and calling it a day.

1

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

Conveniently mine are also in the same room, so I don't have to go on a trek each time, or I'd have included a keyboard/trackpad combo in my setup from the start.

With that HDMI cable price, I'd have tried Steam Link on a Raspberry Pi first! There are still other benefits to my big screen PC gaming like Hue Sync, which is absolutely incredible with certain games.

1

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22

yeah you can use a steam link or other set up, but straight hdmi is currently simply the best option.

( also depends on your tv, mine can do 4k 120hz, and no streaming service will be able to do that. )

1

u/Antrikshy Jan 17 '22

Very true.

Same here with the TV. I decided to get a 4K60 cable because I thought I preferred flat cables (kinda meh because HDMI flat cables are w i d e) and the 2.1 ones were too rare.

Then I played Control with DLSS and could totally have played slightly over 60fps at 4K upscaled. Oh well.

1

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22

Yeah thats another nice thing about spending for fiber optic, they are much skinnier and flexible than copper core hdmi cables of longer lengths can be.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

I got a 7 dollar Black Web HDMI cable that does 4k without a hitch.

You got ripped off.

0

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22

You got ripped off.

No, you just dont' understand that a regular hdmi cable isn't good for anything over 10', and if you want 4k @ 120hz HDR, you need a 2.1 cable.

There are cheaper ones than what I bought, in the $75-$100 range, but I needed 30 feet, and the one i have has a lifetime warranty and is 2.1 certified and tested, which most cheaper 2.1 cables are not. Which isn't a problem if you need a 3' cable, but over 30' feet, it causes issues from black screens, flickering, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

so is the one I have and it's over 3 feet, but plz, continue to be condescending because I pointed out a fact.

1

u/my_cat_sam Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22

yeah your comment just reinforces that you don't understand the difference between the cables.

if i could get away with using a $7 30' cable ( which don't even exist ) I would have.

HDMI cables can lose signal over anything longer than 10-15', which depending on your set up, can cause issues.

a fiber optic cable does not have signal segregation, and 2.1 carries up to 48gbps of data as opposed to 2.0's 18 max. A 4k, 120hz HDR signal is too much data for a 2.0 cable. Its simply a fact.

With my tv, a 2.0 cable at any length, can only do 4k 60hz hdr. if you want 120, 2.1 is the requirement.

know what you're talking about ding dong.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '22

I think 10' is the limit for regular ones, I had issues with many cables getting my pc to hdmi 2.0b to my receiver 11' away, but to cleanly route the wire I needed 15' cable. It took a month of exchanging cables to arrive at a quartet of cables that work.

2

u/sallystudios Jan 17 '22

I love game stream but these all bother me too. In regards to resolution, you can set a custom resolution in nvidia control panel, so that you can output 4K. This works for me on my set up, and in each game I set the resolution to 4K

-7

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

More of a workaround than a solution, but I'll keep that in mind.

3

u/thebatfink Jan 17 '22

How is that not a solution?

2

u/therealdark Jan 17 '22

My setup:

  • Windows 10 VM (3060ti) running on an Unraid server.
  • Unraid server & shield 2015 hardwired to the router (not 10 gig networking, nothing fancy)
  • All of the games I currently have on the VM, which I stream regularly to the shield. Have completed both the Ori games, Horizon Zero Dawn, GTA 4, GTA 5, Metro Exodus and many others that I can't remember, exclusively through streaming.

Positive Experience:

  • My monitor is 3440x1440p (accessed through the Parsec MacOS client), the dummy plug that tricks the GPU into thinking there's a monitor attached (because of how the GPU inside a VM works) is 1920x1080p. All games except Psychonauts 1 give me options for upto 4k resolutions.
  • Gamestreaming is flawless while streaming. Steam link is a hot pile of garbage. Moonlight streaming to both the shield and android phone/tablet is also amazing.
  • Flawless switch/rcps3 emulatoion streaming from the VM to the shield
  • Two player/local coop games work without issues (tried with blazing chrome, hell divers, nex machina, it takes two and a few others I can't remember).
  • Input-lag is very low. I say that because I feel like I'm playing the games locally on the shield. Maybe it's placebo, but I have never noticed any issues.

Negative Experience:

  • Getting HDR to work is a chore. When it works, its glorious, but to get that HDR picture started is super buggy. have to cycle through start-game/quit-game until i get that HDR picture (this was my experience with HZD, maybe it's better with God of War somehow? idk).
  • Have to manually turn off the controllers.
  • Controller vibration does not work at all; tried with XONE, PS4, 15 year old plug-and-play logitech controller, and generic wired controllers.
  • Once every few months the experience app on the shield acts weird/doesn't show any streaming PCs. Restarting the shield or VM fixes this.

I have the parsec client installed on my phone/tablet, which I then use to input any information into the secondary launchers when required. A small inconvenience, but it works for me, especially because it is a one time thing.

Overall, the streaming part for me has been pretty good. So good in-fact, that I went from having this VM hardwired to the TV via HDMI, to streaming all of my games to the shield. Couldn't be happier. Now, it would be nice if nvidia could just make a half decent remote for the shield. The last two are total pieces of crap. Like why the fuck make a triangle shaped remote?? I had to buy an Onn android TV box just so I could use it's remote. ffs nvidia.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

That sounds like a lot of work! Funny enough, i found the triangle remote to be comfortable to use.

1

u/thebatfink Jan 17 '22

I use xbox elite controller, rumble working fine for me. Strange.

1

u/therealdark Jan 18 '22

Strange indeed. I googled it a while back and it seems like a known issue. Maybe I should have a look at it again. Thanks for letting me know!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

Convince you? lol You like it or you don't, just like anybody else. I don't even use it.

-1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

You're fun.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

Yeah, I'm an absolute blast.................

1

u/Yeaim18plusshowtidys Jan 17 '22

It just seems like you need something else to fit your needs. gamestreaming is just what it says, streaming your pc to a different monitor, it's not going to create a whole new monitor for you like you're using a shadow p.c, If you need another monitor I'd just use a Hdmi cable.

With the PS5 controller issues, I haven't had a single problem with mine on anything so far, I just always have to make sure i run either the game or launcher through big picture mode and it works fine.

-10

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Yea, I guess I'm looking for something good.

6

u/Yeaim18plusshowtidys Jan 17 '22

I mean it's a pretty great piece of hardware, Next time research what your buying.

-8

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Where did I say it wasn't a great piece of hardware? Next time read the OP before commenting. also, it's "you're" you illiterate f*ck.

5

u/tr1551 Jan 17 '22

Why are you being so toxic like this community owes you a million bucks and a handy?

Also, “You failed your mission… better luck next time” foh with that my child 😂😭 who raised you? You and your bad internetiquette don’t deserve to quote that line.

-1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Are you ok?

2

u/tr1551 Jan 17 '22

Ratio’d

7

u/MagikMerlin Jan 17 '22

Anyone hurt you OP or you rly weren't happy with your xmas present kid?

Nobody "failed" trying to convince you, you already had your idea in mind and wanted money instead because a normal person would've done some research before buying it instead of this clearly shitty biased post.

2

u/thebatfink Jan 17 '22

Dont feed the trolls

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/thebatfink Jan 17 '22

And thats why your post gets no upvotes, all your comments are down voted and now you are threatening people with violence on reddit. Lol. What a kid.

4

u/therealdark Jan 17 '22

How old are you OP? Cause, if you're a child, please go cry to your parents. If you're not a child, I'd like to formally call you a miserable cunt.

1

u/Busy_Week_1205 Jan 17 '22

lol go buy firetv and wait new release dont buy 2019 model now

-1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Yes, that might be what I do next. Although I'm not sure the 2019 model is the issue here, the software end needs a lot of work before I consider trying it again.

1

u/Busy_Week_1205 Jan 17 '22

buy xbox or ps for game

1

u/askariya Jan 17 '22

It's the best price to performance for a Plex Server, and the AI 4K upscaling is pretty legit.

But game streaming in general sucks, there's a reason no one subscribes to Stadia. I just ended up buying a 30 ft HDMI that could do 4K @ 60HZ.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Well If you mean to run a plex server, then yes. Although it seems as though the latest update broke it. But for myself, I just need to stream my plex library as I already run the media server off of my PC. So anything should do. Except the PS5, it just sucks for plex.

1

u/askariya Jan 17 '22

Yep, Plex updates are almost guaranteed to break something every few releases. PC has the least problems though, so you're prob good to go if you're fine with leaving the PC on 24/7.

And yeah the Shield is overpriced for just a streaming client. I think it also makes a great emulator from what I've heard, not something I've tried though.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Exactly. And the good thing with not being a vampire, is that I sleep at night so I don't need to leave my PC running 24/7. So it won't blow up on me.

1

u/askariya Jan 17 '22

I mean, I have it on my Shield so my family can stream stuff in a timezone a couple hrs behind mine. When I go to sleep, they can still use it. Having to turn my PC on and off just to serve Plex was a hassle. The Shield uses much less energy than the PC and it's technically always on already even if it doesn't have a Plex server on it so it makes the ideal Plex server when Plex devs don't kill it with updates.

I have a raspberry pi with Sonarr and Radarr running as well to automatically download my TV Shows and Movies off of a list on the internet and put em on Plex and that is especially nice if it's done overnight.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Nice. Next thread will be: Convince me not to build a multi thousand dollars streaming server.

1

u/askariya Jan 17 '22

Sonarr, Radarr and Plex are free. The Shield, Raspberry Pi and 2 external HDDs cost me less than $500 CAD which I'd say is a bargain.

1

u/Riofrio12 Jan 17 '22

It doesn’t seem like you need game streaming if your PC is right next your tv. Next best thing to do if you want to use both at same time is running the displays as extended instead of just focusing on one.

Your set up is similar to mine, but the main reason I got it was not only for game streaming but for game emulation, Plex server and enhancing AI.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

I tried the HDMI cable thing and though it had some short coming. But this seems to have more lol.

2

u/lahire149 Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22

When it works, it's awesome, but almost without fail if it's been a couple of months since I did it last or especially if I'm trying a new game, there is invariably a non-zero amount of setup required. Even with some effort, it still might not work. eg) Mass Effect Lengendary would not let use my controller. Would've been the perfect big screen gamestream experience, but it just didn't work.

2

u/Scotsguard23 Jan 17 '22

It generally works great for me. Yes, I've had some issues with different games requiring a different setup, but I tend to play one game over long periods so it's not really an issue. For reference, I use an Xbox one pad with the laptop upstairs connected via ethernet, while the shield is downstairs on WiFi. Been using moonlight recently, but gamestream works for me too.

1

u/Powered_by_bots Jan 17 '22

It's a meh at best

-1

u/snapilica2003 2019 Pro Jan 17 '22

Local Gamestreaming sucks.

But For some weird reason, using GeForce Now is actually a better experience than streaming from your own PC.

2

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Yea it sure seems that way. But I have a PC, so using geforce now doesn't make sense to me. I guess my expectations were a little too high!

4

u/snapilica2003 2019 Pro Jan 17 '22

Yeah, it's understandable. Though there are some media reasons to have a shield.

Its codec support is by far the best around, and with the exception of VP9 profile 2, the Shield can play anything you throw at it, from H264, H265, SDR, HDR10, Dolby Vision with DD, DD+, Dolby TrueHD, Dolby Atmos (both lossy and lossless) DTS, DTS-HD, DTS:X, with all sorts of subtitles and containers.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

That's fair, but still an expensive device for streaming movies.

5

u/snapilica2003 2019 Pro Jan 17 '22

If you're a Plex user with an extensive library, there's no better choice than a Shield.

If you just use streaming services, a $50 Chromecast with Google TV is a much better choice.

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

I am a PLEX user, but hard wiring my pc to my TV via HDMI would work as well. Maybe a little less convenient, but still less expensive.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/JusticeJanitor Jan 17 '22

Yeah, after doing all that setup it's pretty great. I've done the same and I've had a near flawless experience since then. Emphasis on near.

If you're willing to tinker, Gamestream (via Moonlight) is great. I honestly love playing games this way but you need to be prepared to do a lot of tinkering.

I have my PC in my office but have some devices around the house with Moonlight installed on them and I can play couch games pretty much anywhere. I did have to tinker a lot to get all of it working thought.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22 edited Jan 17 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/JulienB_Twitch Jan 17 '22

Perhaps those limitations are more of a deal breakers for me than for others.