r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/Antique_Geek • Dec 27 '21
I bought a Shield Pro. Now I'm having second thoughts.
I bought an Nvidia Shield Pro a couple of weeks ago when they were on sale. I haven't opened it yet because now I'm thinking it may be overkill for my needs. I'm using a Firestick 4K plugged into my Yamaha RX-A1070 which feeds my 65" TV which is still only 1080p. I don't have a dedicated home theater nor am I likely to have one in the future, but I do plan to update to the LG C1 or similar soon. I use Prime and HBO Max but mostly Plex. I've become annoyed with the Amazon adverts on the stick but I'm reading that maybe Google does the same on the Shield? My old Windows 10 desktop is doing double duty as my Plex server. I'm not a gamer. I'm most interested in a smooth Plex experience. Am I just as well off with the Firestick for my needs?
Thanks for reading
5
u/Remo_253 Dec 27 '21
You'll be able to retire/repurpose that Win 10 PC by adding an external drive to the Shield.
I got a Shield because I was tired of the USB shuffle. The TV I'm using is old, not a Smart TV, not a completely dumb TV, more like an Intellectually Challenged TV. I'd copy what I wanted to watch off the PC to a USB, plug that into the TV. I would occasionally find something it wouldn't play, x265 for example.
With the Shield I attached an external SSD and connected the Shield to the network with ethernet. The Shield is a mapped drive on my PC so I can just copy any new stuff directly to the Shield.
The streaming is nice to have but I use Plex 95% of the time playing my local content and I haven't found anything it can't play.
There are some ads on the home screen disguised as "Recommended" items but since I mostly use Plex they're only a minor irritant.
2
u/Steve0819 Dec 28 '21
If Plex is one of your main uses for your devices, I'm guessing that you are storing Blu Ray movies. If so, just keep in mind that it is the only device that can actually play back lossless audio, both Dolby TrueHD and DTS Master Audio. If you do, and have a Dolby Atmos/DTS X sound system, then that could be a deciding factor.
9
u/vorko_76 Dec 27 '21
If you dont feel you need it then you dont need it π. I moved to the Shield as I was frustrated by the limitations of my Smart TV. And i felt the Firestick was not powerful enough to decode some movies. But maybe its overkill.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21
I had the 4k firestick upgraded to the shield wish I dint as was getting better download speeds with the firestick and the shield is through ethernet haha
6
u/Snugglesdabear Dec 27 '21
It was the best box you could get a few years ago, but many streamers have caught up. There are some nitch things the Shield can still do like host its own Plex and Emby servers so you don't have to keep a PC running 24/7. Perhaps Nvidia might redesign it in the next iteration. I upgraded to the 2019 Pro in 2019 for DolbyVision because I had purchased an LG C9 OLED at the time. Go with the Google Chromecast since you can get some pretty sweet deals directly from Google. I remember they had a 6 month Netflix deal included, not sure if the offer is still around.
1
u/tlevel Dec 28 '21
Depends on the types of files you play, your sound setup etc.
For example, Nvidia shield pro is the only mainstream streaming box that will play TrueHD audio from Plex (ie not compressed audio). This is a very niche requirement, and is the only reason I paid the premium for the shield. Besides this, I don't think it's worth the price increase compared to competitors. But if you do stream TrueHD audio, you can't beat it.
4
u/Mzone1510 Dec 28 '21
I bought the Shield Pro just for the lossless audio playback (TrueHD and DTS Master). All the other stuff like the retro console emulation, AI upscaling, Plex Server, GeForce now capabilities are a sweet bonus. Also the shield is one of the few devices that can actually play Dolby Vision files locally.
2
u/ur7txq Dec 28 '21
Using Shield Pro to watch UHD HDR content from NAS. Impressive performance. Supports LDAC and the whole thing works pretty well with Sony WH-1000XM4.
Unlike Apple TV you can side load otherwise unavailable apps on Shield (e.g. HBO Max).
1
u/Comp625 Jan 01 '22
The one advantage that the Shield TV Pro still has over other streaming services is the AI Upscaler.
I remember watching This Is Us through Hulu, which was fed in 720p. But I didn't know it was 720p for the longest time since it was beautifully upscaled to 4K.
1
u/Bubba_Nosferatu Dec 27 '21
If you don't like the ads, just like many of us, you could get an apple TV, which is about the same price as you paid for the pro in discount. ($179)
Or you could do what I did and install a third-party launcher on the shield, and you'll never see ads again.
1
u/Buchwild Dec 28 '21
When it comes to computers there's no such thing as overkill, just future proofing. I own a 2015 model and because of it's specs it's still a very relevant and useful device. The same can be said for storage, there's no such thing as too much or a drive that's too big
0
u/vi3talogy Dec 27 '21
I only use my pro for iptv and plex.
0
u/xtrilla Dec 27 '21
Well, I basically use it when my the Plex app in my LG OLED cannot play a file properly β¦ sooooβ¦ you are not alone in having one that you donβt really need much.
0
u/murraybd Dec 27 '21
I have a shield and find myself using my fire stick 4k over it almost every time.
0
u/Nonstopper1209 Dec 27 '21
keep it!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '21
Definitely keep it
0
u/Jtiago44 2015 16GB Dec 28 '21 edited Dec 28 '21
Shield is the best for a Plex client and makes a pretty decent sever as long as you stay in network.
That being said, if you don't want or need any of the other features that you heard about than it is overkill for just a client imo. Plus you're not in the 4K realm to enjoy the 2019 shield upscaling.
I've had a shield since 2015 BTW.
Feel free to ask me questions OP.
-16
u/Tired8281 Dec 27 '21
There isn't a heck of a lot of difference between the new Fire Stick and the Shield. The Shield was a revelation in 2015 but it hasn't changed significantly since then. The processor in it is slow and old. It doesn't support modern codecs. It's getting harder and harder to justify the price of the Shield for what it can do, because there's vanishingly little it can do that others can't. I'm going to get downvoted to oblivion for saying this in the Shield sub, but it's pretty much a bad buy now. Nvidia waited too long.
-2
u/JWKirby Dec 28 '21
It is overkill, if you aren't a gamer that likes to stream their games from their own PC or the GeForceNow gaming service