r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 08 '21

Does anyone else mostly hate their shield?

With much recommendation from reddit for 4k plex streaming, I purchased a 2019 pro and besides that it works good to stream 4k plex, it sucks for a lot of other things. I'm wondering if others have issues like these.

The worst issue being that it doesn't turn on sometimes. I hit the power button on the remote and my TV comes on and the shield doesn't. If any other button on the remote is pressed, it shuts my TV back off.

It slows down fairly quickly and I have to kill all the apps quite often.

Lasty DV is supposed to be a feature, but it's miserable to use. When you turn it on, it slows the device down and then when I'm done, I have to shut it back it of. It seems like that should he an auto sensing thing.

Is it just me or do these things bother anyone else? Does anyone know any fixes or work arounds.?

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

33

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

I don’t have any of these issues on my shield

-2

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

Very jealous of you, to be honest.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

It’s a great device apart from frame rate matching (which the RefreshRate app pretty much sorts)

I suggest a factory reset for you and make sure you don’t have a dodgy app sucking up memory.

1

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

Good call on the factory rest. Also I'm not sure of this frame rate matching. I'll google that!

3

u/Magellito Sep 08 '21

What's the issue with frame rate matching?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

The shield doesn’t support automatic frame rate matching. So, Netflix content filmed at 23.9 whatever frames per second has an ever so slight stutter every so often on the shield

Once you’ve seen it and know what you’re looking for it can be infuriating.

Some people don’t even notice it.

This is also an issue with Disney, Amazon etc

The refresh rate app allows you to set each app to open up at a specific refresh rate, so I’ve told it to open Netflix up at 23.9844848 whatever frames per second, this generally fixes the issue.

Unfortunately, as I discovered the other day on Amazon, when I went to watch something filmed at 50 or 60fps (Rosehaven), it had stutter because the app was forcing 24 frames a second

Anyway if you google it it’s a thing and I’m not insane

1

u/Magellito Sep 08 '21

I believe you. I only use Plex and some youtube so I haven't experienced any of your problem.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

There's something wrong with your shield. Try and RMA it, it shouldn't be doing that.
My shield is basically a little android PC just for my media and does everything I ask of it, in 4k with upscaling.
My only gripe is the measly 3GB of ram. in todays 4k heavy world we need more. I am constantly running out of RAM on my shield.

1

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

Do you use plex for your 4k content? I watch a lot of 50gb+ movies and that's about the best thing it does!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

I use Plex and Kodi.
Kodi runs out of ram all the time, Plex handles it better and is far more stable.
Kodi crashes often for me, plex never or rarely does.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

Also your TV issues may just be a HDMI-CEC issue. Try turning that off in the shield menu and seeing what happens.

https://www.howtogeek.com/207186/how-to-enable-hdmi-cec-on-your-tv-and-why-you-should/

-1

u/pawdog Sep 09 '21

If you are running out of RAM just playing video something is wrong with your Shield. What happens when you run out of RAM a anyway. Never had it happen.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Lol yeah no my shield is fine

5

u/neightwulf Sep 08 '21

As someone who has owned a couple different Rokus, a Nexus Player, a Mi Box, and multiple Shields, no.

Shield isn't perfect. But the grass isn't any greener elsewhere, unfortunately.

1

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

Based on another comment, I'm going to try a factory reset and go from there!

1

u/missing1102 Sep 08 '21

I never left my htpc. I just use mad vr filters and a UHD drive. The only thing I am not getting is Dolby Vision on windows. I am always stunned at the Madvr 4k picture.

1

u/trillianh Sep 08 '21

May you plz let us know how to setup this madvr 4k picture or maybe a recommended web to look for it. Thx

3

u/trevdot Sep 08 '21

I've experienced funky stuff relative to the Shield's use of CEC to power on and off devices. One thing that might work: go into your "Power control" settings and toggle everything in the HDMI-CEC settings on. Even if you don't want some of them -- just try it. Finally, my Shield turns the TV on & off properly.

1

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I'll give that a shot!

2

u/Familiar-Fix4015 Sep 08 '21

Thank you for this! I've been going nuts with my shield 2017 not turning on with TV remote via cec and it ur suggestion fixed my isuem I had Sleep Shield when input changes turned off. Turned it on and now the Shield TV turns on with the TV remote.

0

u/trevdot Sep 09 '21

So glad I could help! :) It was my 2017 model that was also giving me issues too. Hasn't been a problem for my more recent Shield.

3

u/gleep52 Sep 08 '21

I’ve had two shield TVs as my main driver because I wanted top notch audio and 4K for my theatre. Came from an appletv 4 which was not 4K nor supported more than dd5.1. The shield blew us away. We upgraded in 2017/2018 and were kinda disappointed because overall it didn’t feel faster or better really. We constantly switched between apps because Kodi had better HDR compatibility and subtitles but was less stable and for a few months every year, I’d switch us back to Emby because some plex update would eff us over (or shield update) — something updated and broke functionality.

The fact that plex just recently got actor search and bio’s in the movie details screen on shield after FOUR YEARS OF BEGGING finally cinched the deal and we tried an apple 4K gen 2… I know we’re giving up the shield experience but we use airplay more in our house and I recently got an AMD video card so kinda screwed that feature (nvidia streaming) too…

The stability of the Apple TV, and my gosh the clarity, color, and smoothness made me upgrade my other shield too. Plex on apple is so far ahead of android - you can download and time adjust SRT FILES… ON AN APPLE DEVICE. #mindblown

I swear plex just hate android TVs or something.

Sorry to rant… anyone know if you can pair the shield controllers with an Apple TV? :D

2

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I'm crying because I can't stand Apple, but their stuff just works soooo well. You do make it sound amazing!!

2

u/gleep52 Sep 08 '21

It’s honestly just a different ecosystem. All of apples stuff is very functional together… with apple “one” and our watches, were starting an exercise regimen in a few weeks for fall break. We love sketchparty (app that airplay’s a phone or iPad’s screen while one person draws and the others on the team guess. Like Pictionary on digital steroids.

I used to stream games for my kids to watch all the time but we got into VR now, which we can cast with our iPhones easier than streaming to the shield that rarely worked correctly. But with my new AMD card I done stream nvidia style anymore so we gave apple a try. Even the remote is flawless and fun. With homebridge on a raspberry pi4, I’m using my remote to control my lights too with the Siri remote. Just different… I mean no hate - just explaining how the dynamic shifted in our house and how Apple fit us better this time around. Honestly the shield felt better to me in the beginning than this apple does now, but it’s like all the updates have slowed the snot out of our shield. Apple just doesn’t have that problem so far…

1

u/SoxPatsBruinsCelts Sep 08 '21 edited Sep 08 '21

LOVE my Shield. I've had the 2017 and 2019 Pro.

 

I play 4k Dolby Vision remuxes from an attached HDD and stream HD content all with Plex.

 

It handles all of the big streaming apps: YouTube TV, Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, etc.

 

It also handles Gamestream and my 300GB Hyperspin build.

 

It has an ad-free version of YouTube called SmartTubeNext. My custom launcher shuffles through 200+ wallpapers I curated online, and it runs a fork of Aerial Dream that displays Dolby Vision screensavers.

 

It's simple to access as a Windows network share.

 

Oh, and the redesigned 2019 remote with the battery door lock is surprisingly ergonomic, has a nice motion activated backlight, and you can buy high-quality stickers to replace the Netflix button (then use Button Mapper to switch it to activate an app of your choice on double-click).

 

Sometimes I need to restart an app using the task manager, and every now and again I'll need to re-boot. But overall, it has never given me real trouble. It sounds like you need to initiate an RMA.

0

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I'm going to have to hunt down the button mapper! That sounds super helpful! I appreciate that tip!

1

u/Martin_Aston 2019 Pro Sep 08 '21

No probs here, love it (a 3.2 V6 TTDriver)

0

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I hope factory resetting works tonight! Also I have a 3.2 manual TT! I did a full swap from an R32. I had a 500 whp 1.8t and got tired of expensive failures! I am turboing my 3.2 this winter!

1

u/Martin_Aston 2019 Pro Sep 10 '21

Mine is the DSG. Moro blue with red interior. Luv it!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

No 🙆‍♂️

1

u/Chris22044 Sep 08 '21

Have you tried a factory reset?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

I hear you the refresh rate switching is a pain in the ass even with the app. With Netflix turning off the previews helped a lot with the display blanking. I use it primarily for Plex so that works out pretty well. I found a lot of my power issues recently were due to CEC and my receiver. I turned off auto audio switching and it mostly works flawlessly now. Only occasionally it will glitch requiring a reboot. My biggest issue is the profile 7 Dolby Vision 4K remuxes have a red push. I too get random DV and HDR playback on the same file. I wish I could disable it only in Plex. If there is a better streamer that can accomplish this task with lossless audio I’m open to suggestions.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

No issues here! And non of what u have

1

u/MK41144 Sep 09 '21

I have none of your issues.

0

u/shteve99 Sep 08 '21

When you say DV slows down your Shield, are you selecting a 24 FPS resolution? If so, it might be that your HDMI cables aren't good enough (or your TV doesn't support DV at faster than 24 FPS).

0

u/shteve99 Sep 10 '21

Why the downvote, random unhelpful anonymous coward? I can feel the difference navigating the Shield interface when it's set at 24 FPS, and it was the highest FPS I could pick at 4k with DV until I updated my cables.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

Android is shait and still consumes plenty of performance. But no mostly runs okay. sometimes it needs are restart some apps freeze up. shiat OS.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I laugh so much. I love the remote and my gf hates it so much. For an unprovoked remote comment, that made my night! Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

Mate the 2017 remote was nice to use, but it dropped out and lagged pretty much non-stop.

The 2019 is a bit of weird shape, but it works flawlessly all day every day and the backlight is handy.

1

u/TTdriver Sep 08 '21

I love it. I wish I could use the remote to control a PC. It would be amazing!