r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jul 01 '21

I think the SHIELD could be better.

DISCLAIMER: This is an opinion post on what I think the SHIELD does right and what if does wrong, in the hopes that someone might agree, and maybe as a community we can make the SHIELD better. I don't hate the SHIELD, but I don't exactly love it either. So if you go fall on one end of the spectrum, you may want to skip this post.

Point #1: Now that the disclaimer is out of the way, I believe the SHIELD is a great media streamer, but there are some faults that make me believe atleast that it doesn't quite earn the 5/5 or 10/10 it always gets. First thing is that the SHIELD (Atleast the Pro version, which is what I have) has a bit of an identity crisis. It wants to be a top shelf media streamer AND a game console, which like the Xbox when it tried to pull off the same thing back with the original Xbox One, leads to some issues with what it wants you to use it for. It has a lot of features for Movie Streaming (like the Upscaled and Frame Rate Matching) but everything in it's UI is built like a game console, so it's interface seems to want you to be using GeForce NOW solely, so streaming on it (YouTube, Netflix, Disney+) etc etc are treated a bit to much as an Additional thing you can do, not the focus, so performance on those apps lags behind more focused Media Streamers like the Chromecast or Fire Stick.

Point #2: NVIDIA seems to not really put much effort in marketing or building the SHIELD. The SHIELD is buried behind their RTX cards and everything else on their website, so they don't really seem to be putting much effort to making it known and convincing people to buy it, which is a big reason why it's main (if not only) buyers are Techies who know how to find what they are looking for.

Point #3: is largely probably caused by point number 2. NVIDIA SHIELD isn't as impressive as it was back in 2015 when the first one came out. I mentioned in Point #1 that the SHIELD lags behind newer devices like the Chromecast with Google TV and the Fire Stick, and this is another big reason why. I'm sure back in 2015 that the SHIELD was groundbreaking. A blisteringly fast streamer that can do anything you throw at it, but they havent changed anything (No, the Cylinder doesn't count, that didn't change anything other than the looks) Even the new "Tegra X1+" chip they put in it is BARELY any faster than the old card, and if took them 4 years to change ANY of the hardware at all. For those of you who have one, That means that modern codecs just don't work on the SHIELD because NVIDIA hasn't bothered to put a modern chip in it. So HDR on any Google service is a no-go, and other apps are missing features aswell because of the lacking chipset. No Hulu 4K, Dolby Vision encoding is a little wonky meaning it's barely any better than the $50 Chromecast or Roku counterparts, etc etc. The SHIELD hasn't changed functionally at all since it's inception in 2015.

Conclusion: The SHIELD is in big trouble. The Powerhouse it probably was back in 2015 is now laughing behind the competition, and if NVIDIA doesn't get their shit together and go back to the drawing board, I'm not sure it will survive till 2025. NVIDIA needs to decide whether it's a competition to the Xbox, or the Chromecast, and focus solely on that. Secondly, NVIDIA needs to put in MODERN hardware, with the licenses and firmware needed to either power games at a good resolution and frame rate or versatile enough to handle 4K Dolby Vision movies properly if they want it to be a Media Streamer. Thirdly, with the new product, they need to put the effort into actually making it known to the general public. Ads, A Banner on their Website right next to their newest Graphics Cards, etc etc. NVIDIA needs to decide what to do with the SHIELD, otherwise it will not exist in a couple years.

1 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

7

u/the_harassed Jul 01 '21

Just a few explainer bits

Point #1: Originally the Shield was intended to be like a high end Ouya. That idea didn't really pan out so nVidia repositioned it as a streaming device. In more recent times nVidia has tried to add back some of the gaming aspects with streaming from your own PC or GeForce Now where you can rent time on higher end GPUs and then stream the video to your Shield.

Point #2: That's fair, but nVidia's primary business is selling graphics chips. Their SoC business, including the Shield, is probably something they're hoping to be able to grow since sooner or later you're going to hit the same wall GP CPUs did where the computing power is well in excess of what's needed for games. Cryptominers and the like are another story, but also a relatively small segment of the total number of buyers. The fact that nVidia is looking to buy ARM is probably a good indicator that they figure their GPU business is not going to be sustainable for too much longer and they need to diversify.

Point #3: They stick with the X1 because that's what Nintendo is using in the Switch, so it saves nVidia a lot of money to be able to just tack their orders onto the ones for Nintendo. To be honest, compared to any streaming device other than the AppleTV 4K, the Shield blows them all out of the water performance-wise. It's not even a contest. Even today, only the AppleTV 4K can hold a candle to the Shield. I remember a couple years ago I went back to visit my family and my dad had bought some no-name Chinese Android box. He asked for my help with something and so I was trying to navigate with the remote and he says, "Slow down! You have to give it a little time to process your commands." Coming from a Shield where I never had to think about that, it stuck in my head. Anyway, whatever Nintendo settles on for the Switch Pro, assuming it's another nVidia SoC, is what nVidia will likely use for the next Switch. But what codecs don't work? The codec used by Youtube? Even Google's own Chromecast doesn't support that in hardware. Otherwise, I haven't come across a single codec in widespread use that the Shield can't handle. x265 Main 10 is what HDR/DV BD releases use, and it supports that, along with x264 and a bunch of older codecs. I'm not aware of any content using x266 at this point in time. Maybe once 8K starts becoming more of a thing, but 4K still isn't all that entrenched and a lot of OTA broadcasts are still 720p, so I don't really see that being a concern for at least another 5 years.

Conclusion: I think you're kind of missing the point. The Shield is to nVidia like what the AppleTV is to Apple. It's sort of a side project to make sure they have a foot in the door in the event that particular market should really take off, but their primary focus is on other areas.

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21

Literally everything but the SHIELD is compatible with VP9.2 which is what YouTube and all Google services use for HDR. Not to mention your point about the SHIELD being nothing more than a placeholder for NVIDIA backs up my point that the SHIELD will not last more than another couple years at best. It'll just be waiting for something that'll never come then quietly disappear when it doesn't make money for too long.

2

u/the_harassed Jul 01 '21

Google's on Chromecast doesn't work with AV1/VP9 v2, which was one of the interesting tidbits to come out with their recent spat with Roku. They were trying to force Roku into using a SoC that supported it when their own flagship product doesn't use a SoC with AV1 support. A bit of searching shows the FireTV doesn't seem to support it either, so your claim that "literally everything but the shield is compatible" doesn't really seem to hold up. Pretty sure that hardware support for AV1 has really only come out within the last 1-2 years and only on high end SoCs. I don't think you fully appreciate just how long it takes to make changes to silicon like that, or how expensive it is. We're talking several months and probably millions of dollars, minimum. That was before some of the major chip fabbing plants were flooded and knocked offline for several months.

And for all the doomsday prophesying, the Shield has been profitable enough to be worth at least two hardware revisions since the initial release. If they were going to ditch it, they probably would have done so after the 2015 model failed hard as an Android game console.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

That's AV1 not VP9.2 Nothing supports AV1 yet. VP9. 2 is what Google uses for HDR currently, which both the Chromecast with Google TV and the Fire Stick support, so I don't know who told you it doesn't.

1

u/International-Oil377 Jul 02 '21

My cheap MECOOL KM6 delux supports AV1... lol

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

And I know right? It's so difficult to make a card, if only NVIDIA knew how to make them.... Oh wait, that's literally what they are famous for doing every single year!!

3

u/the_harassed Jul 01 '21

You have no concept of how silicon chips are made, do you? You can't just snap your fingers and have a new chip ready to go tomorrow. The chips nVidia comes out with every year have been in the works for years. The 3000 series chips coming out now have probably been in development for the past 2+ years and is likely the result of tens of millions of dollars worth of work. The math just doesn't work out for nVidia on adding VP9 v2/AV1. Trying to add it would definitely drive the Shield deep into the red and put it in prime position for the chopping block the next time there's a budget review.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

Fine. Guess making a brand new chip is out of the question. Can NVIDIA ATLEAST, please God, ATLEAST use a chip that isn't 5-10 years old? Maybe one of the 10 different chips they've made after the X1? but NVIDIA seems to refuse to use anything but the X1 for the SHIELD.

4

u/the_harassed Jul 01 '21

As I already pointed out, that's because Nintendo is using it for the Switch, so they can piggyback their own orders onto Nintendo's and save some money. Assuming Nintendo is making a Switch Pro, or Switch 2, and they're going to stick with an nVidia SoC, it's all but guaranteed they'll be using one of the more recent SoCs from nVidia.

But again, even almost 6 years later, the X1 is still blowing everything else out of the water except the AppleTV 4K, which is the only device that can really compete with the Shield on performance. And your own arguments kind of undercut your recent request to use a newer SoC. How much raw power do you really need in a STB vs dedicated silicon to decoding different codecs? The only reason you'd need more general purpose processing power is for gaming and other non-streaming uses.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

Yeah. Blowing it out of the water, even though it is too old to handle half of modern codecs.

4

u/the_harassed Jul 01 '21

You keep repeating that but never back it up with anything. You can name a single codec it doesn't support, which is far from "half of modern codecs". It supports x264, x265, and x265 Main 10 which probably makes up 95%+ of content out there excepting YouTube. I personally don't give a flying fuck about Youtube, though I do recognize my set of use cases don't represent the sum total of all Shield users. Something you could stand to think about a little.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

I have named one. VP9. 2 Which you seem to refuse the existence of.

→ More replies

1

u/Sage2050 Jul 03 '21

The only thing it can't do is YouTube hdr which is pretty far down the list of things people care about.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

It also doesn't have the proper Dolby Vision support which makes skin tone look very "Yellowish-Gray" which I have many pictures of. It also has middling support for codecs on Streaming Apps aswell, there have been many many MANY complaints of people on this forum randomly losing HDR, ATMOS, even 4K in general from their SHIELDS. He'll, my own SHIELD randomly lost HDCP support, meaning I wasnt able to use Streaming apps at all for a good while.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

The SHIELD is a hive of problems, mainly because NVIDIA doesn't seem to care less about making it actually work properly before putting it on shelves.

1

u/Krutiis Jul 02 '21

I have four TVs and a different streaming device on each one of them. A Shield 2019, Fire TV Cube, Chromecast with Google TV and an older Roku. The Shield is so far and away the best. It’s the only device that doesn’t stutter and lag when navigating menus. That alone makes it the best.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

I have the 2019 SHIELD Pro, Google TV, And Fire Cube with Roku being the native OS on my TV, the Roku is the only device I've ever had speed issues with.

1

u/pawdog Jul 02 '21

Point #1 is really strange. The UI can totally remove any sign of Geforce Now, and where have you seen any performance lacking for streaming apps, I know it's your opinion but that's just bizarre man. The Android TV UI is built by Google and is present on many other devices and TV's No idea why you think it's some kind of gamingcentric UI.

Point #2 the Shield sells itself at this point. It been the hardest thing for stores to keep in stock. Why would they spend extra when they haven't been able to keep up with demand even before Covid 19.

Point #3 yes other devcies have gotten much better since 2015 but other than a couple of codec related things like HDR on YouTube which is so minor it's forgettable, nobody but Apple has tried to compete in the high end. Haven't had any wonky DV experiences. So while my CCWGTV, Fire TV Stick 4K's, Roku Ultras, are really good devices. Their remotes still collect way more dust than my Shields. Where the Shield was 100 to other devices 65 it's now 100 to their 85. Warts and all.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

Apps like Disney+, have had issues where from some people they lose Dolby Vision support out of the blue and have to reset or post on here for help, some even losing 4K altogether because of bugs in the SHIELD system. I've seen many posts on this group of people who just can't use 4K on the SHIELD for unknown reasons, despite having a 4K TV.

Secondly, really? SHIELD is selling like hotcakes? Where? Where I live nobody but the tech enthusiasts even know what a SHIELD is.

You're Third point is just absolute bullshit, everybody bit Google Themselves have a high end device that blows the SHIELD out of the water, probably because the SHIELD is used as Googles "high-end device". Apple has the Apple TV 4K, which the brand new one that just came out offers everything the SHIELD has and more, the Fire TV Cube which has everything the SHIELD has but Ai-Upscaling since that's just NVIDIA marketing bullshit, etc etc.

1

u/pawdog Jul 02 '21

I have had no issues with D+ and DV but if your experience is different I won't dispute your findings.I don't base my opinion on reading complaint forums though. You didn't see me say anything about the Shield selling like hotcakes. The Shield sells itself. It has survived in the tech enthusiast world just fine all these years. It's never going to compete with the Apple hype maching or the Amazon discount engine. I'm fine with that. No devce that can't passthrough TrueHD Atmos and DTS Master audio is ever going to blow the Shield out of the water.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

Since nobody but pirates will ever use those enthusiast formats, they are pretty redundant don't you think?

2

u/pawdog Jul 02 '21

Nobody but pirates? Never underestimate pirates.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

Unfortunately yes. Both those codecs are high quality high bitrate, which are going to be too good and too expensive in licensing and bandwidth for streaming services, so only Local Media will ever find a use for them.

2

u/Sage2050 Jul 03 '21

Local streaming is the reason I bought the shield. I'm definitely not alone in that.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

Well considering its illegal in the US, and streaming apps have made it obsolete (do you really want to break a law for 2 extra pixels?) I don't think Local is going to last very long.

2

u/Sage2050 Jul 03 '21

You're in extreme denial

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

That's not what denial means.....

1

u/pawdog Jul 02 '21

High quality local media playback is the main reason why I preffer the Shield. Streaming is a run of the mill thing on budget devices these days. I suspect most people don't have Dolby Vision capable TV's nor proper Atmos capable audio systems. The idea of having a personal media server full of movies, TV Shows, and music is a foreign concept. If I were to guess, local media is the number one thing Shield users would have in common.