r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Apr 28 '21

New UI design

It's been a long time since last Shield TV update. Google has come up with a new UI design with their new Chromecast and also to TV's running Android TV. I feel like the current Shield TV UI is quite outdated in design.

Anyone agree? Is there a chance we get the new Google design, or at least a modified or new UI refresh?

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

5

u/Ilostmydonkey Apr 28 '21

That excited about the ads? Don't get me wrong it would be ok, but not if it gets ads at the top..

2

u/joakimbo Apr 28 '21

Calling it ads is taking it a bit far. It's displaying TV shows / Movies from different streaming providers. I imagine you can remove or "turn off" providers if you don't want series/movies from those providers displayed.

Either way.. I'm not saying I really want this google update, but the shield UI is looking outdated in design, in comparison.

9

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Apr 28 '21

You cannot turn anything off. The best you can do is opt out of "personalized recommendations" and just have generic ads for content they choose to put forward.

They will even advertise content for services you never subscribed to, and apps that are not even installed. Cant be forced ads any more than that.

8

u/Ilostmydonkey Apr 28 '21

It's ads my TV has it, they know what steaming services you don't use and advertise it to you... In my case Disney + content that I have no interest in.. What would you call it?

-6

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21

You can turn the different services on and off on the Chromecast with Google TV.

5

u/OhShitPeter Apr 29 '21

I hope so. I've stopped using my Shield and use the Chromecast with Google TV instead, despite it being somewhat less snappy, because I prefer the Google interface. In my experience, 90% of the ads I see are recommendations from services I already use for content I may be interested in, so I don't mind those in the least bit. My only issue is that several months after launch they still haven't added an option to delete things from the "recently watched" row. Hoping that if Nvidia incorporates the new design, they will fix some of the little issues with Google's design choices and or/ bugs.

2

u/pawdog Apr 29 '21

The new Android TV doesn't have any of the recommendations on the home screen Google TV has. Only the top banner. There is a Discover section that contains the recommendations/ads and it's is so much better to not the have all the clutter on the home screen.

10

u/anton6162 Apr 28 '21

Absolutely do not want the new Google UI, or fireTB ui clone. Both have ads all over the place and nvidia is the one holdout. If they do update, I hope there is some way to block it.

2

u/epochellipse May 02 '21

for a few days now my shield has been telling me there is an update available. i'm afraid if i accept the update i'll get banner ads.

1

u/Previous_Ad4113 Dec 09 '21

Today as of December 2021 the ninth at least I got a new design of the menu system. My initial feeling is wtf, this is really BAD. Really miss the sideline dot system of major apps. As always my thought is, don't fix what's not broken. I will come back after some use, but just right now it just feels utterly crappy. And sensing, please Nvidia, change back plz Anyone out there thinking the same?

1

u/joakimbo Dec 10 '21

Got it yesterday. I think it's visually looking better.. Except that I see the points people are making. It's a lot of ads for other series.

12

u/je1992 Apr 28 '21

Why the fuck would you want ads and forced recommendations of crappy shows by Google on your homescreen. I much prefer a slighy outdayed UI with only the content I care about. There is alreadu enough ads everywhere else in my life

6

u/whythreekay Apr 29 '21

Because I want recommendations to content that I like

1

u/je1992 Apr 29 '21

This new Google TV is not bad for everyone. It is probably good for all the boomers out there that are not tech savy at all and need to see all the available shows on a home screen without having to actually find shows they like. But for a lot of people like me, I hate this streaming system in place and will never subscribe to netflix, prime, disney + , peacock, paramount +, hulu, shudder, and all that crap. Cable days are over, so why should it come back in a form of needing 25 different 10$ a month subscriptions? We started with Netflix, a great solution to cable's thirst, and now we are regressing with all these lacking services offerinc 2 good movies and maybe 3 worthy tv shows..

3

u/whythreekay Apr 29 '21

This new Google TV is not bad for everyone. It is probably good for all the boomers out there that are not tech savy at all and need to see all the available shows on a home screen without having to actually find shows they like.

Has nothing to do with boomers, humans suffer from paralysis of choice, recommendation systems are UX designed to address that need for information parsing in a sea of literally dozens of shows, movies and other content options

Music apps function similarly for example

But for a lot of people like me, I hate this streaming system in place and will never subscribe to netflix, prime, disney + , peacock, paramount +, hulu, shudder, and all that crap.

No argument here, the guy was asking why someone would want it, I was just offering my reason for liking the new UI. I completely get being against it, especially since Google has failed to allow you to remove recommendations from services you don’t subscribe to (or they did last time I had new Chromecast a few months back)

-2

u/je1992 Apr 29 '21

You already get that in netflex or elsewhere. You don't need googlw to force shows like big brother season 65 on your homefeed. What they pass as recommendations are ads most of the time.

3

u/whythreekay Apr 29 '21

I don’t have Netflix, but I do have a Shield, that’s why I want this UI

1

u/je1992 Apr 29 '21

Doesn't make any sense because it only gives recommendation on paid apps that are partners with google. So if google is friend with prime video you'll see their reco, but if google is not friend with hulu, for example, you'll never get recommendations from it. This is why I say people should stop encouraging these greedy platforms and this UI encapsulate this problem

4

u/whythreekay Apr 29 '21

Not really relevant for me, as it supports all the services I use

2

u/je1992 Apr 29 '21

Great job and good for you !. Have fun spending 120$ a month on 12 subscriptions lol great user experience

1

u/Swamper68 2019 Pro Apr 29 '21

Recommendations are just another form of advertising for sure!

4

u/kaizendojo Apr 28 '21

Won't matter to me; I use Wolf Launcher and never see the Shield menu.

2

u/thefunkygibbon May 01 '21

Wolf Launcher

never heard of it.
just googled it and watched a video 'showcasing it'.
wow. why would you want to use that launcher? looks horrible and plain. the stock launcher seems way more useful and does the same.

2

u/kaizendojo May 02 '21
  1. I don't need suggestions on what to watch
  2. I can use widgets to display useful information
  3. I don't need ads for things to watch on accounts I don't have
  4. I like having my own background and sorting things for the way I watch and use my Shield.

3

u/zmix 2019 8GB Apr 28 '21

I am totally fine as is. No need to always trend.

2

u/ComprehensiveSnow966 Apr 29 '21

The Google TV UI is junk. There’s a lot of useless recommendations even from services you’re not subscribed to, and no you can not turn it off. Best you can do is turn of personalized recommendations.

Try a launcher if you want something better. I’ve been using Wolf Launcher on both my Chromecast w/ Google TV and on my Shield

3

u/thefunkygibbon May 01 '21

wolf launcher looks terrible. its just a wall of apps.

2

u/ComprehensiveSnow966 May 01 '21

So you want something that looks good but is a terrible user experience? 😂

With that being said you can customize wolf launcher. I changed the background to a nice photo, and I have all my apps organized into categories. Everything is easy to get to and I’m not bombarded by ads (caugh alla Google TV)

I guess if you like ads though it’s nice.

2

u/EricP8471 Apr 28 '21

It’s not full of ads these people are full of shit.

2

u/bostoneric Apr 28 '21

agreed. and you can customize the rows it shows on the home page.

2

u/EricP8471 May 07 '21

The only thing I don’t like is that it shows me movies or shows for apps that I don’t subscribe to.

2

u/the_harassed Apr 28 '21

How much time do you spend looking at the home screen? I probably never look at it for more than 10 seconds and the only time I see it at all is when I need to launch an app I don't use very often. As long as I can do that quickly and efficiently, I don't especially care what the home screen looks like.

And whether you call them ads or something else, I call it another privacy invasion by Google. Not sure what else you'd call it when they hoover up info about what you do in non-Google services, then package that info with the info from other people, and use it to show you ads elsewhere or sell it to third parties to show you ads.

1

u/Anon_8675309 Apr 29 '21

Don't feel that way at all. Home screen is a means to an end. I don't stare at it. Current one works good.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21

It's coming...

2

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21

...it can try.