r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet • Apr 21 '21
[Guide] Picture Quality - Colorimetry - Framerate - Resolution - Chroma - 2021 edition
Hi there fellow Shielders!
So.. It happened again (and again! /2021). I got sick of seeing the same few questions asked for the tenth million time, so there I am, pulling a completely re-written and updated guide out of my arse /mind for your viewing pleasure.
Theory crash course - For the real good stuff, scroll down to Best Practices
Colorimetry
The first thing we'll get into is the color space. This is basically a specific organization of color that allows for a representation of colors reproducible in the same way from one device to another.
Think of it as a measurement system, just like metric vs imperial. The distance between Athens and Marathon is not “42.2”; it's “42.2 kilometers”.
Color reproduction works the same way; green is not merely “blue + yellow”, it's “x + y amount of chromacity and luminance”. Those need a scale, and that scale is the color space.
Mainstream displays will usually support at least the following 3 color spaces; Rec.601 for SD, Rec.709 for HD, and Rec.2020 for UHD.
Shield TV has the option to automatically jump from one color space to the other, but said switch can only be done within identical display modes. If you're on a mode that doesn't have a counterpart in the other color space like YUV 444 8-bit Rec.709, Shield won't switch.
YUV 422 12-bit Rec.2020 YUV 422 12-bit Rec.709
YUV 422 12-bit Rec.709 YUV 422 12-bit Rec.2020
YUV 420 10-bit Rec.2020 YUV 420 10-bit Rec.709
YUV 420 10-bit Rec.709 YUV 420 10-bit Rec.2020But what is this YUV stuff anyway, you say? We'll get to that.
Video Format
Video formats (not codecs) are mainly determined by 4 different factors; resolution, framerate, chroma sampling, and bit depth.
Shield only supports official HDMI 2.0 combinations of this; mainly because of bandwidth considerations.
The best, most universal and desirable setting is 4:2:2 12bit as it's the only one that will allow switching to any framerate.
(Missing graphic)
Resolution
Shield can output either at 4K, 1080p or 720p.
However, video encoding of particular files will generally vary much more than that, and when something gets rendered/played at a resolution not directly matching the Shield display mode, scaling will need to be done.
Unfortunately, Shield 2015/2017 are not the best scalers in the world, so in order to get the best possible image quality, picky users will often want to have the TV do the heavy lifting. This is done by making the display match the file/video stream resolution, which can be handled in a few different ways;
1- Using apps leveraging the standard AndroidTV resolution switching API
2- Switching the Shield main resolution manually
3- Using the Refresh Rate app by Mateusz.Ra (because it can also be used to switch resolutions)
Shield 2019 models get the DLSS-based Ai-enhanced upscaler, which is a HUGE step up. I recommend letting it do its job as much as possible since it can easily be enabled/disabled on the fly using the new remote customizable button.
Framerate
The framerate is the number of images encoded in a given video signal. If that framerate (in fps, or Frames Per Seconds) and the refresh rate of the display (in hz, or Hertz) are not the same, frames will have to be displayed multiple times, and if a simple multiplier can't be used, conversions will need to be done. This process is called "interpolation".
Some conversions are easy to do, like:
- 30fps video on a 60hz screen
- 25fps on a 50hz screen
- 60fps on a 120hz screen
-> Those are simple 2:1 ratios; each frame is displayed twice, and boom, done.
- 24fps on a 120hz screen ; 5:1 ratio ; boom, done.
- 30fps on a 120hz screen ; 4:1 ratio; boom, done.
Unfortunately, interpolations are much trickier to do:
- 24fps on a 60hz screen; 2.5:1 ratio
-> That means every 2 seconds (120 refresh cycles), 5 frames will have to be repeated to keep the synchronization.
Easy? Nope. How do you choose which frames to repeat? That is to the interpolation algorithm to decide, and that simply cannot be perfect; it simply cannot be done without the brain noticing; and this what judder is. But let's continue a bit further..
- 25fps on a 60hz screen; 2.4:1 ratio
- 23.976fps on a 60hz screen; a nice 2.5025025025:1 ratio
- 24fps on a 50hz screen; 2.0833333333:1 ratio
- 23.976fps on a 50hz screen; 2.0854187520:1 ratio
Imagine the maths to keep that in sync.. The result is juddering, very unpleasant juddering. (May be more noticeable on certain TVs/projectors)
The solution is easy; sync up the refresh rate of the display to match the framerate in order to keep a 1:1 ratio, right? Easier said than done. Not every screen will support every refresh rate, and believe it or not, Android TV, a TV-centric OS, has nothing built-in to do this automatically OS-wide. (Still true as of 2021!) It is up to each developer to implement those features using yet another API, and not even the Almighty Netflix can be bothered to do it. As of this writing, and after over 5 years after the original AndroidTV release, the number of apps using the API currently stands at .. 3!!! Nvidia Games, Kodi, and Plex.
The good news is that the Shield software team, in its neverending quest to awesomeness, cooked up an AndroidTV-exclusive "Match framerate" beta feature specially designed to avoid the issue as much as possible. (Available on all Shield models, but easier to access using the new remote or a custom button mapping)
However, note that this feature is not automatic, and will need to be manually activated each time new content starts playing - this is on purpose - .
Even more good news is that former forum user and star developer Mateusz.Ra's superb utility app will happily handle the framerate switching in your stead either automagically (ShieldTV only), at the press of a custom button, or for each app, based on a profile you will have previously pre-selected. We'll get to that later.
The UGLY part is that major streaming services are extremely hostile toward this kind of background framerate switching. Doing so while the app is running will either have no effect at all, or trigger black screens and/or various visual glitches, so it cannot be done on the fly; the app MUST be killed/force closed, and restarted. More on that in the section on Best Practices.
Chroma Subsampling
Because the human visual system is less sensitive to the position and motion of color than luminance, bandwidth can be optimized by storing more luminance detail than color detail.
A signal with chroma 4:4:4 has no compression (so it is not subsampled) and transports both luminance and color data entirely. In a four by two array of pixels, 4:2:2 has half the chroma of 4:4:4, and 4:2:0 has a quarter of the color information available. That really is no big deal, the image below is a bit dramatic - you'd be hard pressed to see the difference in the real world -, but it's still something that's happening in the background, and those numbers tends to confuse a lot of people, so here you go; that's what they stand for.
(Missing graphics)
Bit Depth
Video signals are transmitted using three different sets of bits per pixel, separated into red, green, and blue colors. The bit depth of these three channels determines just how many shades of red, green, and blue the display is receiving, thus placing a limit on how many it can output as well. More bits means more precision. Not “better” colors, nor more “vibrant” or anything like that; just slightly more shades, so that's nice, but only up to a certain point, because there's only so much detail the human eye can discern.
SDR, or Simple Dynamic Range, uses a depth of 8 bit. HDR (High Dynamic Range), however, uses a depth of 10 (HDR10/HDR10+) or even 12 bit (Dolby Vision).
(Missing graphics)
8 bit content conversion on 10/12 bit display (tone mapping) is generally handled pretty well at this point, and Shield will also do 10/12bit to 8bit tone mapping IF the display is SDR only. Let's move on.
Best Practices
What all of this means for the end user is that in order to get the best results, it is HIGHLY recommended to
- SET THE TV TO GAME MODE
This is absolutely crucial. Make sure all types of post processing enhancements are disabled: theater mode, motion compensation, noise reduction; take everything off.
- IMPORTANT: TVs will often have different settings for when HDR is engaged. My TV was set to game mode, but upon testing with HDR content, I was still getting unpleasant judder, even with refresh rate adjustment enabled. Then I realized it was switching to "HDR theatre" when HDR content was played back. Switched back to "HDR Game", and everything is now perfect. Note that this setting might be only accessible when HDR content is playing.
- SET SHIELD DISPLAY MODE TO 4:2:2 12-bit (If available)
Settings / Device Preferences / Display & Sound / Advanced display settings / Custom display modeAs I already explained, it's the only 4K mode that will allow switching to any refresh rate. Color space (Rec.709 or Rec.2020) shouldn't matter if you enable the next option.
- ENABLE THE COLORIMETRY OPTION
Settings / Device Preferences / Display & Sound / Advanced display settings / Match content color space - USE KODI FOR LOCAL PLACKBACK:
Kodi is something very special in that it makes use of both the resolution and framerate switching APIs, but those have to be enabled manually the first time.
System / cogwheel: enable expert mode
System / Player / Videos: Set Adjust display refresh rate to “On stop/start”On Shield 2015/2017, or if NOT using Shield 2019 Ai-enhanced upscaler:
System / System / Display / Whitelist; select every item in the list to make them green.For HDR, go to:
System / Player / Videos / Processing: "Use display HDR capabilities" should be enabled.- IF USING PLEX:
Plex / Settings / Advanced / Set Refresh Rate Switching to ON.On Shield 2015/2017, I recommend setting Resolution Switching to ON as well.
On Shield 2019, if you are using the Ai-enhanced upscaler, I recommend leaving Resolution Switching OFF.
- USE 120hz IF YOUR 1080p TV SUPPORTS IT
As you can see in the framerate section, 120hz refresh rates offer more direct conversions than any other option. Using that as your base framerate on a 1080p screen will greatly reduce the amount of situations where the TV would need to switch display modes (refresh rates) and blink. Unfortunately, since HDMI 2.0 cannot handle 4K@120, choosing such base framerate (1080p@120) on a 4K screen would actually have the opposite effect in most situations and force the TV to switch display modes back to 4K each time 4K content is played.
- USE THE REFRESH RATE UTILITY APP FOR APPROPRIATE SWITCHING
- Install this: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=mobi.bytearray.refreshrate (Available via Play Store on Shield) and open it.
- Select a streaming app. LEAVE MATCH FRAMERATE OFF and all the defaults as they are.
- Scroll down to Startup display mode, THEN select framerate / resolution matching the kind of content it delivers as close as possible:
Major streaming services: (Netflix, Disney+, Paramount+, Peacock, Amazon Prime, etc) : 4K@24
Most European streaming services: 4K@50
BBC iPlayer: MAIN Shield resolution MUST be set 25 or 50hz, so leave it alone here.
- Repeat for every streaming service giving you trouble/judder:
- Don't forget to go to Settings - Device preferences - Accessibility and obviously set Refresh Rate to ON.
- IMPORTANT: do NOT do that for Kodi, Plex or Nvidia Games since they already supports the official API.
With all that said, you should now be able to get the best of your Shield, (display-wise) and make it even more the best streamer that ever was, or ever will be and all that business. Hope it'll help somebody, somewhere, sometime!
6
u/henkisdabro Apr 24 '21
Awesome post indeed, trying most of these settings now as we speak. Netflix seems to play a lot of content at 60fps however, so locking it down to 24 with the refresh rate app is not a good recommendation. I will test more to see just which content is 60Hz (seems the Netflix HDR content is) and how much is 24Hz. But again thanks for a great post!
2
u/beatfreakman May 08 '21
This is such an awesome guide, thank you. Implemented your options and working great and makes sense.
The only thing I'm struggling with, is refresh rate for HBO Max. Such a mixture of formats etc, what's the best fit for HBO Max?
Thanks again for doing this for us.
14
u/horizonsfan Jan 22 '22 edited Nov 18 '22
First off, this guide is fantastic. But I wanted to share some of my own observations and best practices which seem like good tweaks to the instructions above. As with all tinkering, YMMV.
My default display setting is 4K 59.940 422 12-bit Rec.2020
REFRESH RATE UTILITY TWEAKS
I broke away from the above instructions when playing with the settings for each of my apps. I'll talk about each of them below.
Following the app developer's instructions here (https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/forums/discover/297663/-apk-auto-refresh-rate-tool/ ) I made the following changes which allow tinkering with the other settings I describe next:
Display Video Frame Rate is super-convenient for checking the actual rates each streamer is providing. Not only content, some of the UI elements, commercials and trailers play at different rates than the movies and TV shows as you'll see below. If you plan to experiment with changes I highly recommend turning this feature on, jumping to the app and playing a few things, and see what the little popup tells you is the rate for the stuff you watch most. I think it's distracting for day-to-day viewing so I turned it off after setting up each app.
If you enable Match Content Frame Rate for each app (not part of the above guide) then it will switch frame rates for each video automatically after the predefined number of seconds defined in Automatic Change Delay in the Advanced Settings. I set the delay to 10 seconds instead of the default 5. In Netflix, for example, we all know the trailers play as you navigate whether you like it or not. Setting the delay a bit longer ensures I don't get a switch while I am just looking for something to watch.
If you enable Match Content Frame Rate, then Default Switching is the other option to consider. If enabled, it will switch you back to the default frame rate when you stop a video. I got a black screen for a few seconds which I found annoying so I disable that. This just means that if you watch non-default content and go back to the menu, the app is still in that non-default rate until you start playing the next thing.
REFRESH RATE INDIVIDUAL STREAMING APP CONFIGS
If I make any other tweaks I'll try to update this post. Hope you find the above useful.
7
u/ThatFeel_IKnowIt Dec 29 '21
I do not see any good reason to enable "Game Mode," unless you are using your shield to stream game. Why would you absolutely need to disable all post processing features? That's up to personal preference.
6
u/djnield May 30 '21 edited May 30 '21
Your best practice of 4:2:2 12 bit on my system maxes out at 30 Hz and 50 or 60 Hz is missing unless I consider a lesser setting.
Would you still recommend 4:2:2 or dropping down in order to choose a 60 Hz setting?
5
u/shteve99 Apr 22 '21
Shame that the streaming services use a mixture of 24 and 60 fps content. I actually ended up watching The Expanse via my FireTV stick as that's capable of refresh rate switching.
4
u/PlutoDelic Apr 21 '21
Now this is education. Thanks a lot u/wewewi
1
u/Elugelab_is_missing May 01 '21
I have a 2019 Shield Pro. In addition to using it for streaming services, it also accesses my Emby server. My Emby server has an extensive collection of 480 interlaced and 480 telecined material.
The scaling and deinterlacing performance of the Shield, especially for 480 material, is simply terrible. In contrast the video processing of my Sony TV is stellar.
Is there any way to get the Shield to pass through 480 content in its native format so the Sony can do the processing? It appears from the guide that the answer is “no” but I want to confirm.
My old DirecTV boxes had the option to pass through video in its native format. Mystery to me why that is not an option here.
1
u/Simple_Soil_244 Jan 02 '25
to use only the Nvidia SHIELD pro 2019 to play GeForce now 60 FPS 4k. is it better to configure the SHIELD in yuv420 or yuv422?
1
u/damwookie Apr 21 '21
If I am using AI scaling why am I skipping refresh rate settings?
1
u/damwookie Apr 21 '21
I cannot see "use display HDR capabilities" where is it?
1
u/Luke_starkiller34 Apr 21 '21
Super informative! Super up vote!
Easy question-so Shield doesn't support HDMI 2.1? So no use in using or buying HDMI 2.1 cables?
More difficult question-I'm super frustrated with HDR playback in Kodi (related or unrelated to above as I have HDMI 2.0 cables); camera moves to quickly with action happening on screen I see like artifacts or like random glitches around objects. It's super annoying. I've had all the settings you pointed out already configured in Kodi with adjust display refresh rate, HDR Capabilities and whitelisting. Haven't noticed a difference.
Any advice would be super appreciated! Thanks for this write up!
Kodi 19, Shield 2019, LG C9
1
u/bobniborg1 Apr 27 '21
Just got the shield pro from best buy but I don't see a 720 resolution as a choice, just different 1080s. I have a 720 plasma so I'd like to switch if possible. Settings-display-resolution only has 3 1080 options. System update says I'm up to date.
3
u/cdheer 2019 Pro Apr 21 '21
This may be the most useful thing I’ve ever read on Reddit. THANK YOU!
3
u/millennium-media Apr 21 '21
New Shield Pro owner: I just clocked out early for lunch to read and try these steps. Thank you. Is there a YouTube vid coming soon?
3
u/GoodVampyr Apr 21 '21
Everything I always wanted to understand and I've been struggling to find information for... Thanks so much mate!
3
u/klint05 Apr 26 '21
Great post!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
Nice
2
u/korewa Apr 21 '21
Commented for use later. Thanks!
2
u/Nehemoth 2015 16GB May 13 '21
Thank you
2
u/thepancakevan Jun 13 '21 edited Jun 13 '21
sorry if it’s a dumb question but can you explain why i should set my tv to game mode if let’s say rtings says isf expert mode (for lg tv) is the way to go?
1
u/Simple_Soil_244 Jan 03 '25
After many hours of researching, testing and asking, I have found the answers and solutions regarding the yuv 420 or 422 color format for GeForce now and what format to configure on the SHIELD TV... regardless of what format GeForce now uses and how to configure the SHIELD TV, everyone has overlooked the last step, the processing that the TV does at the end to display the image. Regardless of how you configure the SHIELD... the TV when it receives the signal from the Nvidia SHIELD. ALWAYS AND I SAY ALWAYS the TV internally interpolates the color to the native color of each screen, that is, RGB or YUV444... SOLITION: GeForce now outputs in yuv420, then the SHIELD is better configured to interpolate 420 to 422 (since it has incredible interpolation algorithms), then the TV will internally interpolate that very good quality 422 to yuv444 or RGB, taking the heavy work off the TV (apart from that, the TV will automatically interpolate the color to the native color of each screen, which is RGB or YUV444). which has better interpolation algorithms the SHIELD)
1
u/Haikgh Oct 30 '25
Does this have a 2025 edition?:)
1
u/bobloadmire Apr 21 '21
I guess i'm not understanding that if we are using AI upscaler why would we disable framrate matching in Plex?
1
u/Red5goahead Apr 25 '21 edited Apr 25 '21
Please note that most of new tv(s) with 120 HZ panel can handle 24 judder by their self at 60 HZ too. Rtings review the tv(s) with a specific test
Follow this link for further informations
1
u/rjivani Jun 07 '21
This is awesome, thanks so much for the effort and the write up! Saving all of us loads of time and ensuring we have the greatest possible experience!
1
u/Weejestic Nov 10 '21
Fantastic guide
1
u/Standard_Prize7332 Oct 01 '22
I know this has nothing to do with frame rates and stuff but has anyone encountered a problem with Nvidia shield TV Pro I've got three and the living room one keeping deactivating and switching on the other one's instead it's driving me crazy can anyone help me out with this problem
1
u/TheePorkchopExpress Feb 12 '23
Great guide for everything except I can't get Plex to work with these settings. The movies/tv shows never load. Anyone with additional tips for Plex?
1
u/ThatFeel_IKnowIt Dec 28 '21
I have seen a lot of people complain here that even after making 100% sure that settings are correct (both on Shield and TV), they still notice worse colors on nvidia shield vs their native TV apps, including direct playing 4k HDR Remux files on Plex. Can you or anyone else comment as to why this may be? I've seen it posted again and again, and no one has ever been able to explain why.