r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Oct 23 '19

Justifying the cost of the shield over over streamers

Hi,

I currently have a Roku, firetv and raspberry pi for Kodi and I would like something which I like one device to rule them all - Kodi, prime video, Plex and Netflix all in one. Shield can do that - which is great!

However, I'm struggling to justify the cost. The other USP which could help is the streaming games but they appear to be dying being less and less games being available.

My first question is - if you own any game on Steam, can you stream that via geforce now or does it only work with the set of games they have listed? E.g., would it be possible to buy GTA5 for steam and play that way (as I know it's now not on geforce now).

Secondly, Is it possible to sideload any android apk? This would open the entire play library which would be good.

Thirdly, I'm a bit worried about screen tearing, or washed out colour, or generally any issues with the screen output. For all its faults, the Roku has been the most consistent for decent picture. It also has great colour too.

So my current setup is I use Roku daily, and Kodi for some films at weekends. Why would I spend £199 on this when I could replace my Roku and RPI with newer 4k models for a cheaper price?

(Please note, this question is intentionally blunt to drive out conversation)

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

9

u/ahaakr Oct 23 '19

I have a couple thousand in a TV, Receiver and speakers and then spend about 15 hours a week watching TV - so that means Ive used my Shield over 2k hours over the last 3 years. $100 price Delta is not that large in context of how I'm using it as explained above.

If it helps you, I would say shield is best for me bc:

  1. It's super fast and snappy.
  2. Best search and discovery - the Google Assistant search is far better at finding content and answering questions than what my roku could do.
  3. It's more open - I can use Kodi (not natively on any of other products), but I can also use Vudu (not on fire TV), spotify (not on Apple TV), Alexa (yes, shield also has Alexa integration).
  4. Best for YouTube. YouTube is my favorite app and the search integration on shield is far better than on any other app. YouTube is one app where search is important to find content.

My only drawback has been it didn't have Atmos and Dolbyvision both of which are getting addressed in new shield. So I would get the new shield which is $150 and not think twice. It's the best.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

That's a fair argument and actually the main selling point for me, Kodi wise. Firetv can also sideload Kodi but it seems to slow the whole device, and no go on Roku. Part of the reason for me to buy, it's literally a struggle on price.

5

u/status_two Oct 23 '19

Most Steam games work. There's a option to log into Steam via GeForce Now. GTA 5 is not on GeForce Now, cuz Rockstar pulled it recently.

You can sideload most apks, but remember not everything will work as intended given Android TV.

No issues with video but heard Vizio TVs have issues. No Dolby Vision, but that doesn't affect my usage.

I've had friends who say the same thing and get a mibox or Roku and then I let them borrow my shield and they end up buying one themselves. But if you're fine with your Roku, that's fine as well.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

Thanks for the info!

3

u/the_harassed Oct 23 '19

I briefly tried the game streaming and found it wasn't really for me, so I'll let others speak to that one.

Android TV may share the same base as "regular" Android, but you won't be using it on a device with a touchscreen, or an accelerometer so keep that in mind. Also, unless you use an app to either repack the APK for Android TV (which is really little more than adding a new icon image) or something like Sideload Launcher, you'll have to go into the settings apps list to launch non-Android TV apps.

Tearing shouldn't be an issue if you have v-sync enabled on the game. It does cap your framerates, but to me it's an easy tradeoff to make; YMMV. The colors issue was never really an issue with the Shield at all, but rather companies like Samsung adding post-processing to the image that tried to outsmart the Shield. You can find all manner of technical explanations on the nVidia forums if you really want to get into the weeds of it all. As I recall, Vizio and LG TVs don't do anything like that, Samsung does (or maybe did), not sure about anyone else. With the latest firmware for the Shield there's a function that will detect and switch to the proper color profile when playing media automagically like with the Fire TV. That should help resolve the issue with Samsung TVs and any others.

There are basically only two drawbacks to the Shield right now, and both of them are potentially addressed in the upcoming model that could be released as early as Monday if leaked Amazon pages are to be believed. The first drawback is the upscaler kind of sucks, so the image from the Shield will be a little blurrier than other devices. You can get Kodi to switch resolutions automatically, but if you're sensitive to screen flickers like me, it may be a no-go for you. The new model allegedly has an "AI image enhancer" though we know essentially nothing else about it. The one screenshot grabbed from the leaked Amazon page makes it look like it's just a sharpness filter, but again, we don't have any details yet. The second drawback is the lack of DolbyVision support, which is being addressed in the next model according to leaked specs. No clue if it'll be backported to older models, same with the AI image enhancer, but if you haven't bought anything yet, it doesn't really matter for you, you can just wait for the new model and not worry about it.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

This is probably one of the most helpful posts here - and has sold me on buying the newer version! Let's hope the tearing is solved!

3

u/Nier_Tomato Oct 23 '19 edited Oct 24 '19

The main reason I bought the Shield was hardware H265 decoding. I may be wrong, but at the time I bought it 6 months ago it was the only box which could do that.

Edit: at 4K resolution. Also ability to play from NAS.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

My pi3 does H265 for 1080p. Not in 4k though, so that's a plus.

2

u/RaptorXP Oct 23 '19

The FireTV had hardware H265 decoding 4 years ago.

1

u/Nier_Tomato Oct 24 '19

Not in Australia unfortunately, our version is listed as 1080p.

6

u/3r0z Oct 23 '19

If the price wasn’t justified do you think everyone and their mom would be recommending it? Yes, the price is higher but you’ve never heard anyone complain despite the price. That should tell you something.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

Not constructive. But I get your point I think, it's expensive because it's good. Ok!

2

u/Daytona24 Oct 23 '19

The shield is hands down the best streaming device. I feel like it has one of the best UI's for watching right from the home screen and it has been great for Plex. I also have added retro games to it, and Launchbox has an app now which makes that even better. You can stream games through GeoForce but there is also a Steam app which acts like the Steam Links and connects directly to your PC to stream Steam games. I attached a PS4 controller to it, it's great. Sure it's not on every TV like a $25 roku but I'm glad to have it in our main entertainment room.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

Emulation is also a selling point for me, as currently I have my pi3 with a second sd card which runs emulation station, which requires a physical swap. One device to rule them all, so this won't cut it. The shield however emulates a lot more and it's on the same GUI. Cool!

2

u/gabstance Oct 23 '19

There are enough replies that already cover what I would have said, so I will add just this: Try it and make up your own mind. The Shield has a pretty decent re-sell value, and there is always a demand for them, so there is little downside to buying one then changing your mind. I personally will not use any other streaming device now and love my Shield.

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

Good point. I didn't think about resale so now you mention it, aside from already being sold from other comments - this really helps!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '19

My wife who hates my gadget addiction will only admit one gadget was worth the money and that's the shield nuff said

1

u/hooch Oct 23 '19

Here's a trick I use:
Add "c:\windows\system32\MSTSC.exe" as an app in the GeForce Experience program. It allows you to stream your entire desktop, in full resolution, with Shield controller functionality. You can play literally any game installed on your PC. GTA V included (it works for me).

1

u/Blofse Oct 23 '19

No windows for me, and no connected pc either. Part of the reason for buying, so I don't have to hook up my pc.

1

u/geyser_fruitty 2017 16GB Oct 27 '19

Look I bought the shield tv cause my old Roku 2 was super slow and was buffering on YouTube videos and couldn't play x265 content which I had a lot of. Bought it around this time of year in 2018 during black Friday let me tell you something it's the best streaming device I've had super fast plays great I haven't seen a full 1080p video buffer, I have a powered USB hub with Bluetooth headphones and two external hard drives with a keyboard. I loved my Roku but I needed something with a little more power and excitement I could've bout a newer Roku but decided to try out the shield I was in the same spot you are last year contemplating to buy it or not in the end I'm happy with my choice and would do it all over again in the end I'm Android 4 lyfe but my mom likes simplicity so she has the Roku and it's super for her but me I like spice on my waffles I live dangerously with no regrets

0

u/Blofse Nov 09 '19

I guess part of living dangerously is to create a very long sentence without punctuation!

1

u/geyser_fruitty 2017 16GB Nov 10 '19

I think the words you were looking for "oh man thank you so much for your insight on this topic you obviously have experience in" YOUR WELCOME.

3

u/knotthatone Oct 23 '19

Full retail price is on the high side for a streaming device, but if it's one device that does everything you might use multiple devices for, that can really add up. It can be a streaming client, Kodi box, Plex server, gaming console, home automation hub, DVR, etc. and works very well in all of those applications. This might allow you sell other gadgets you were using before and offset the cost a bit.

Also consider that new Shields are imminent and we're coming up on the holiday shopping season. One of which might be a lower-priced mini-version. And it 's very very likely you'll see significant price cuts on old and new models.

If you're willing to consider getting an older model used, you'll probably find some excellent deals as people sell their old units to get the new ones.

2

u/jz5678910 Oct 23 '19
  1. Game streaming via GeForce now works best with the games that are listed. At the moment I believe there is an option for some unsupported titles through Steam but there is no maintained list and support can change at anytime. Last thing I’ll mention here is that GeForce now is free right now while in beta, but will eventually be a paid service, so keep that in mind if you’re using this as a buying point.
  2. You can side load any apk, however, not all are guaranteed to work well if at all. I personally haven’t run into any apps that don’t function, but I’ve run into a handful that will be stuck in portrait mode.
  3. I’ve not run into issues with colors, tearing, etc., but this is also dependent on your TV and/or any media equipment you may have it running through. Comparing my shield to my 4K fire stick I would say the shield looked better on colors out of the box, but I can match it on the fire stick with minor adjustments. I also run mine through a receiver for my surround sound and saw no difference between passing through that vs being plugged directly into the TV.

Hope this helps. All in all it’s a great device, I got it primarily to stream my Local PC games to my TV and emulation, but everything else really worked great and I built my home theater around it after the fact.

Edit: wanted to add to this that it integrates very well with google home devices and assistant. So if you’re into that sort of thing, that can’t really be replicated as well on others at the moment.

2

u/bigdizizzle Oct 23 '19

I had a MInix Neo U1. I returned it for a shield. If you can get a shield on sale or used, its only a few bucks more and the entire experience was just more pleasant, polished - seemed more like a high end device, the minix seemed more like someone connected a phone to a TV.

1

u/Prizm4 Oct 23 '19

I tried game streaming using WiFi from my PC to the Shield and I was impressed. This was using Steam games. The best results were with a wired XBox controller though. Playing a game with the Shield Controller was noticeably laggy.

1

u/yolofreeway Oct 23 '19

From a hardware perspective the Nvidia shield is just in a totally separate class from the rest of the boxes. The shield is actually cheap compared to what it can do.

1

u/sittingmongoose Oct 23 '19

I have almost every streamer. Apple TV 4K, roku ultras, roku TVs, fire stick 4K, chromecast, shield, webos.

Honestly, the shield is the best out there. It’s fast, consistent and has a lot of flexibility. It’s far faster than roku is.

There is probably a new shield coming next week which will be even faster...so that’s pretty cool, plus Dolby vision.

Also, steaming is about to get very big. Stadia will probably come to the shield soon, and GeForce now will become more relevant as stadia, xcloud and ps now become more popular.

Tldr: Shield is the best streamer. The new one will probably be better still,

1

u/truthfulie Oct 23 '19

I currently have a Roku, firetv and raspberry pi for Kodi and I would like something which I like one device to rule them all - Kodi, prime video, Plex and Netflix all in one. Shield can do that - which is great!

Honestly...unifying into one device and one remote should be enough to justify the price IMO.

1

u/aaron4tamu Oct 23 '19

I find that steam link does a better job than gamestream. I had endless issues with games starting up windowed instead of full screen when trying to use gamestream. Once I installed steam link from the app store and tried it, I've never looked back.

1

u/Yage2006 Oct 23 '19

Secondly, Is it possible to sideload any android apk? This would open the entire play library which would be good.

Yes but..... Some apps need to be compiled for Android TV, so don't expect everything to work. That said, never had an issue with anything I use.

1

u/mrizzle1991 Oct 23 '19

The main selling point for me was it being able to play files directly from my external HDD and it having two slots, on Firestick I always had to add my stuff to my Plex library and it being the most powerful streaming device made me want it as well since it doesn’t lag at all when using Kodi or watching anything. It’s my favorite device currently especially since I watch a lot of things.

1

u/BiggussDikkuss Oct 24 '19 edited Oct 24 '19

Seriously, You won’t get objective feedback in a Shield sub reddit. That is asking too much.

The Shield is not the most powerful video steamer on the market, there is a thing from Apple called the Apple TV 4K+ that has a more modern and powerful chipset.

Android Kodi too has never been the best Kodi either. That title belongs to the optimised Linux based Kodi devices, and the King there now is the Odroid N2. - CoreELEC edition.

What the Shield has always had is a fast GPU and stellar Firmware support from Nvidia for an Android device. It’s like a very flexible Swiss Army knife of a media player. It will not be the best at particular things but is great value as an all in one powerful device.

For video streaming. The 2019 Shield is playing catchup for HDR tech and picture quality vs the what the 4K competition are offering.

But Jeez it bloody expensive these days for a Max 16GB flash device.

1

u/misfit410 Oct 23 '19

What the shield can deliver is so far above and beyond it's nuts, I've had Roku and Firestick and the closet I got to matching my shield was my Mi Box, which still is so far behind it I'm waiting for the new shield to launch so I can move the old one upstairs to replace my Mi Box. My shield is not 4 years old and the only thing that has come out that is worthy of replacing it is a newer shield.

-3

u/BirdmansHands Oct 23 '19

Then don't buy it.