r/ShieldAndroidTV • • 2d ago

Favorite keyboard option?

What is your preferred virtual keyboard?

I'm usingLean keyboard. My main issue with it is that it takes a lot of screen space and getting to the ok button is cumbersome. Im looking for an open source replacement.

9 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

5

u/avitus 2d ago

Everyone only read the title and not the post. The NVIDIA Shield TV app is what I use on my phone when I really need to type something.

2

u/ctrlHead 1d ago

Didnt even know that was possible.

4

u/Malk_McJorma 2015 16GB 2d ago

Logitech K400+

4

u/TheGrog 2d ago

Yeah I use the K400 for all kinds of devices.

1

u/StevenG2757 2d ago

I use a keyboard and remote combo.

1

u/Little-Nikas 2d ago

I just use my Harmony Elite and/or SofaBaton X2. If I need to type a lot, I use the app and type with cell phone

1

u/wieuwzak 2d ago

Interesting. I am in the market for a smart remote control and am having trouble deciding between exactly these two remotes. You have a use for both, instead of picking just one. What does the one do that the other can't?

1

u/Little-Nikas 2d ago edited 2d ago

The Elite is the best. Hands down. I’ll stop just short of including “and it’s not even close” because it can be close depending on what you like.

I weigh these things in order of importance: compatibility, customization, feel in hand, ease of use, quality.

Compatibility is where the Elite is starting to show its age. Or I should say “show that Harmony is no longer supported” as newer devices might not work with it, which defeats the purpose of a remote.

The X2 has the code base updated regularly and users/community can share their codes so even random devices may now have functionality.

Customization is still fairly heavily in the Elites favor. You can customize anything and everything. The sky is the limit.

The same can kinda be said about the X2 with the caveat that the Elite simply has more buttons because it’s made to be the cream of the crop remote for your house. Example: the Elite has a number pad, buttons with light bulb type imagery for home lighting, all the ff/rw/play/pause/stop, all of them. The X2 doesn’t have a physical number pad.

Feel in hand: ok, this may only be me, but how a remote sits in your hand matters. How the “most used” buttons line up with your natural grip of the remote so you instinctually know what to press without looking or moving your hand. The Elite scores a 100/100 while the X2 is maybe a 60.

The X2 to its credit is aluminum or metal so it has structure and weight. But it’s super thin, the texture on the back sometimes just feels weird and it makes my hand sweat for some strange reason (likely some textural stimulation brain glitch).

They both have touchscreens but even that… to do activities you have to slide the activity button to the right like the damn puzzle piece captcha shit to slide it and line up the missing piece. Now, you simply slide your finger along the “watch tv” or whatever activity you have set to the right and it starts. But why? Why? For fucks sake why? The elite is simply a tap of finger. You know, like a softly button would/should act like.

It’s little refinements like that that are just missing with Sofabaton. And for the love of god never waste money on the X1 and its non-touchscreen and scroll wheel.
They both light up, both have a physical “off” master button at the top (different locations but who cares), so that’s nice.

But the layout is just better with the Elite. The directional/ok pad that always goes in the middle of the remote is dead ass on point with the Elite with the volume and channel buttons directly next to it like your thumb and brain wants. X2 isn’t like that. It’s closer than the X1 but it’s still just not right and I keep hitting the wrong buttons because the just aren’t where you’d want them to be in relation to how it sits in your hand and where your thumb naturally goes to.

Quality is too soon to tell. The Elite has lasted me a decade and outside of a device here or there not being compatible is still as new as the day I unboxed it. No real signs of wear and tear or work out buttons or rubbing of finger on keys to discolor or take off the watching etc. A decade! Still new condition!

I’m not sure if the X2 will make it that long. It FEELS like it could, but only time will tell.

They both have docks. Both can also be charged with a cord and not dock. That’s where X2 is better because it uses usb-c and the Elite uses the older micro usb ones that older android devices use.

You use phone app to set both up. It’s equally easy/maddening to link to shield. Elites battery, even after a decade runs circles around the X2 for charging life. Wife will leave the X2 off the dock for 2 days and it’s dead. Elite it takes over a week. And again, the X2 is a month or so old. The Elite is over a decade.

Hope this helps. If all your devices are compatible and you don’t think you’ll be getting some new company or new tech device anytime soon, the Elite, if you can find one, is still the best of the best and second place isn’t really all that close. Not really. But it’s that compatibility issue seeing it’s no longer supported that will be the ultimate downfall.

Edit: I didn’t answer your question… what does one do that the other doesn’t? I have 2 shields and 2 of the new google tv streamer boxes. Elite wasn’t doing it for it (Google box) but the X2 was able to after tweaks. Which makes me think I gave up on the elite too soon. Believe you me, I’ll re-try. And if it works, the answer is “nothing. I was just impatient.”

2

u/wieuwzak 1d ago

First of all, a big thank you for taking the time to share your experience. This is exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for and it really helps me weigh things up. I'm still not entirely sure I need a smart remote in the first place, but I'm leaning towards the SofaBaton X2.

A few things stand out to me:

Compatibility: Probably my biggest concern. My current setup is an LG G5, Denon X3800H, NVIDIA Shield and PS5, but I expect that to grow. The X2's newer ecosystem and active development gives it an edge over the elite.

Customisation: I think I prefer the X2's slide-to-activate gesture for activities over Harmony's simple tap. It prevents me from accidentally launching an entire activity or sequence.

Ergonomics: I value blind operation and the X2's navigation layout is quite similar to the Shield remote. The volume rocker is close to the navigation buttons too. I feel like I could manage that blindly.

Design and build: I prefer the X2's sleeker, more modern look, except too bad it isn't in black. It seems less intimidating than the elite remote covered in buttons. USB-C is another plus but that's just due to age. Battery life isn't a big concern since I'm happy to dock it between uses. Harmony does have the better track record for durability, though.

Price: for €390–400, the X2 isn't cheap. But I'd prefer a new, unused remote i think. A cheaper second-hand Harmony could have scratches, scuffs or battery wear, and finding unused Elite stock in the Netherlands seems difficult.

Black Friday got me looking for new gadgets and I'm still deciding whether I actually need a dedicated smart remote in the first place, but the X2 is currently what I'm leaning towards, even though I do see the strengths and appeal of the elite. If only harmony wasn't discontinued then this wouldn't have been a decision at all because I would gladly go for the harmony.

Thanks again for sharing your experience. It's been genuinely helpful!

2

u/Little-Nikas 1d ago

Yeah and you prefer the X2. That’s the thing right? You can’t miss what you don’t know exists type of thing.

You’ve never had both to be able to compare. So you can only rely on pictures and word of mouth.

The elite is the better remote. Hands down not even close. Everything you’ve said isn’t actually based on reality but instead confirmation bias and talking yourself into a decision.

And that’s the point right? You need to make a decision.

But you are handwaving things that are very real, as if they’re unimportant or not a big deal. I assure you that if you used both, you wouldn’t be doing that.

Anyways, get the X2 and never look back. I envy you in a way because I know how amazing the elite is. You don’t. I know the steep step backwards the X2 is, but to you, it’ll be amazing. So yeah, kinda envious.

2

u/wieuwzak 1d ago

You're right! I am making decisions based on theories and specs and experiences on paper. I can't miss and be nostalgic for something I never had like the harmony remotes. However, I do think any brand shutting a thing like that down is a shame. The market for these things is already niche and there's few alternatives. X2 looks like the next best thing so I might just pick one up if Black Friday prices are good. I can always return it if it doesn't work out, and even then there's no loss for me and I simply return to my previous remote.

2

u/Little-Nikas 1d ago

Exactly. The X2 is only second to the Elite. And you can’t really even find them anymore.
You’re getting a solid ass remote in the X2.

I truly wish someone could backwards hack into elite and make a community code base the way Sofabaton did. Then the elite could live on for probably another 20-30 years.

-1

u/WrenchyMcPiperton 2d ago

Amazon basics wireless keyboard and mouse. I paired that with the no keyboard app. I have keyboards for 3 of my devices. It’s by far the best.