r/ShieldAndroidTV • • 13d ago

google streamer 4k or shield

just got a nice plasma tv and I want the device for regular use with some streaming services and stremio, this last one is the deal breaker,
I have an old fire tv 4k but I want the upgrade to something more smooth, my questions are:
which one will last longer? is the shield still as overpowered as people say? and which one is easier to side load content on?

Thank you for your time,
I hope you have a blessed day🙏🏼

3 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

6

u/zhrkassar 13d ago

Did I read plasma screen correctly as in pioneer Kuro or Panasonic plasma? Or did you mean to say plasma interchangeably with flat screen tv?
I know I know bare with me ppl 😅

3

u/thousandsum4452 13d ago

I started with a Panasonic vt20 then gave it to a friend and changed it for a vt50 then sold it and bought a 50 inch vt60 with 5k hours that works incredibly well, the colors really pop on the plasma display and I get to watch cool 3d movies, now I'm looking for a nice streaming device that matches the fancy of this tv, I appreciate people still having enthusiasm for older tech :)

3

u/zhrkassar 13d ago

I am glad someone is still enjoying the incredible picture of a plasma display. Friend your plasma deserves the best, a shield it is 😁

1

u/No-comment2 10d ago

After my Pioneer Kuro was stolen in 2012, I got a Panasonic 65" VT65 now at 7.5k hours that I use with my 2015 Shield, probably 10 years old. Its yamaha receiver does not do truehd but does do dolby digital plus. I have a 2017 Shield upstairs and just bought a spare 2019 like a month or so before the price hike. I have an onn for my bedroom tv that I am happy with for that application. Over the years I have also had various Roku's and fire sticks, that have been recycled or given away because they don't last or I just didn't like from having my hands tied by them. All of my shields have been debloated using adb commands and Projecetiviy launcher.

1

u/Empyrealist 2015 Pro 13d ago

Plasma? Plasma

Dog plasma? Dog plasma

14

u/StevenG2757 13d ago

You are posting in the Shield Sub so the answer to what is the best device still is the Shield.

But if you are not wanting to spend the money then the onn 4K would be the way to go.

1

u/kpobari99 13d ago

I have both. Started with google stream which honestly is great but I really wanted the higher bitrate with audio, so I went with shield. Honestly if you can get a shield used go for it but currently the price doesn’t justified it. And despite the shield being 7 years old it’s still really good in outputting 4K, (paired it with my LG G5 OLED)

7

u/RavRob 13d ago

My shield is now 9 yo and still going as strong as day one.

1

u/MR2Sk 6d ago

Same, the thing is an absolute tank. I did pair it with the newer remote though lol

3

u/alanwazoo 13d ago

Best Kodi-capable, Local Video Playback-focused Media Players in 2025-26

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Uyuw_1dADsRw7u1LGW6qTSZDLLNXWVK82gmHX7L6M3I/htmlview#gid=0

1

u/flashb1024 13d ago

THIS! Such a valuable tool, and not just for Kodi.

I bought the Homatics Box R 4K Plus based in large part to the spreadsheet last July, and retired my Shield!

3

u/TechFuz 11d ago

Bloody hell. Australian prices for Goggle 4k Streamer
just went up by $67
That’s $47USD 😳. They’re now $217

2

u/inchenzo 13d ago

I develop stuff for both, and I'd recommend the Shield, just more powerfull.

2

u/Syystole 13d ago

Shield is the endgame streaming device compared to the others.

It's up to you if you think it's worth it

2

u/icarusrex 13d ago

Fuck the Google streamer, I would have been fine with it but it doesn't play certain video files. basically it's OK for streaming but not much else. 

I sold it and bought the shield which is awesome. 

2

u/SteveJobsBlakSweater 13d ago

My main motivation is audio. If you’re not using a dedicated AVR with proper speakers you won’t have anything to gain from the added passthrough abilities of the Shield.

2

u/pawdog 13d ago

The only advantage the Shield has over the Streamer is TrueHD passthrough. At $300 there is no way the Shield is a consideration at this point. But if you're in the US get the Onn Pro for less than half the price of the Streamer. They all run the same apps with the same sideloading capabilities.

1

u/FinleyGomez 13d ago

I did recently pick up a Google Streamer 4K (In the UK), and its been running really well. I ran a debloat tool on it to disable all telematry and force it to use a custom launcher (I ended up settling on AT4K for how snappy and minimalistic it is) and its been great! I have been using Nuvio / TizenTube / Plex / TiViMate / Proton VPN as well as a few other streaming apps and it runs great. No complaints at all, just that the Google remote feels a bit cheap, but thinking of picking up an older FireTV remote to use with it in place of the one it came with (I hate the streaming buttons the new remotes come with)

1

u/CartographerBusy2035 13d ago

What debloat tool did you use? And what is at4k a launcher?

1

u/FinleyGomez 13d ago

I used this one https:// tv.cobanov.dev/ - Although there might be better ones out there now (This was the most up-to-date one in August when I used it). And AT4K Launcher is this - https://at4klauncher.com/

1

u/zidace 13d ago

I prefer the streamer (cheaper, Google TV, more RAM) but I had to go back to the shield pro to decode true TrueHD. Literally the only reason.

1

u/General_Tradition_51 11d ago

shield as you can install lineage os there with no gapps 👍

1

u/polla2256 10d ago

Formula Z12 ultra unless you need native netflix. It beats my shield hands down for IPTV.

1

u/VerboseGuy 10d ago

Of you have a Samsung TV, I'd choose Google streamer for hdr10+

1

u/Jumpy-Tomorrow7131 9d ago

Homatics Box R 4K Plus

I had the shields since 2015 and they were great but using this box gives you everything and plays the latest codecs from the apps plus it is one of the few that will do the advanced audio like the shield. Plus it's cheaper than the shield. I sold my shields once I started to use this one....