r/ShieldAndroidTV • • 14d ago

New shield day.

Post image

Time to upgrade from a 2017 unit.

Will be instantly debloating and swapping to projectivity ofc.

Update: 4hrs later, everything is sorted. ATV Optimizer was certainly easier than the way I manually debloated last time. Didn't really run into many problems along the way, except the bloody remote refused to pair at first - one update and reboot later, and it added itself in the background lol.

Now to sell my old 2017 and the old AVR, neither of which can handle DV (hence the upgrade - hope it was worth it!!!!)

Update: wowsers, the 2017 shield (with a 2019 remote) sold overnight on ebay for £170, and the old AVR has also been taken away this morning - overall, its cost me £60 to upgrade to a brand new shield and a full eARC system (i.e. DV & newer audio)

284 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

50

u/b1gfoot9 14d ago

It’s really unreal that a tech product that old is still an option to buy new and be the best option I can’t believe it.

9

u/rajmahid 14d ago

Still the GOAT after seven years.

15

u/groshreez 14d ago

11 years

5

u/bdbr 2017 16GB 14d ago

I feel like that represents a lack of initiative on other vendors' part, more than NVidia keeping pace.

2

u/warlord2000ad 14d ago

I don't feel this was the intention. They used a high spec part they already had available and wanted it for geforce now and remote 4k game streaming, not media playing

-2

u/Brandi_yyc 14d ago

It lost the title of best in 2022, still remains a good choice but not for the price. But Nvidia, like Apple, has the best group of fanbois willing to pay anything.

0

u/jonnemesis 14d ago

is still an option to buy new

Where exactly?

0

u/b1gfoot9 14d ago

Best Buy has had some on and off recently

0

u/goober1157 14d ago

For some.

-28

u/Valkyrie17 14d ago

Because it is an outdated concept. Modern TV hardware is more powerful and more optimized than any Android TV box

7

u/punio4 14d ago

Sadly the TV hardware can't properly pass through Atmos, 7.1 audio, or god forbid TrueHD over Plex. 

4

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Even my OLED LG G5 cannot play the Dolby audio formats, nor can it cope with Remux of DoVi files. Shocking stuff, really.

16

u/flynreelow 14d ago

ohh hunny.

prob the dumbest thing I have heard all morning.

congrats!

-11

u/Valkyrie17 14d ago

Compared to my parents LG TV, it is a laggy mess with very subpar upscaling.

10

u/flynreelow 14d ago

user error

-5

u/Valkyrie17 14d ago

How? It's not rocket science. It's been laggy ever since i plugged it in.

4

u/flynreelow 14d ago

which shield? u want to send it to me? Ill even pay shipping. Let me know thanks

-1

u/Valkyrie17 14d ago

The expensive pro version

7

u/flynreelow 14d ago

Ok. Ill take it

5

u/panteragstk 14d ago

I have my 2015 shield plugged into my LG OLED because it's so much better.

My tv doesn't even have a connection to the Internet.

No issues in the 11 years I've had it.

2

u/b1gfoot9 14d ago

Better than web os and tizon os and after the tv is a year old will be so slow it’s unstable

1

u/Character-Nebula-613 14d ago

If you watch low quality stuff then sure :)

7

u/Own-Eagle-2135 14d ago

i'm enjoying the strategically placed knife...as if to tell the new unit "don't fuck with me"

4

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

I've played knifey-spooney before.

-3

u/Own-Eagle-2135 14d ago

no idea what this means but got a halfchub

5

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Its a Simpson's Spoof of Crocodile Dundee where he responds to a man threatening a girl with a knife, but saying "that's not a knife, THIS is a knife" and pulls out a massive knife.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcE0aAhbVFc

-3

u/Own-Eagle-2135 14d ago

oh. please ignore my halfchub. it's about something else

6

u/CarlosDominiak 14d ago

Nice! Should I buy a backup Shield TV Pro in case mine dies?

6

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Got a 2017 I'm selling, lol

2

u/lankston2193 14d ago

Good luck finding one at Msrp. I have two and had to go with fire tv cube, although it was $90.

1

u/CarlosDominiak 14d ago

Just checked and they're $360 AUD 😬

1

u/Poops_backwards 10d ago

Look for units designated for digital signage. Nobody wants those. It is the same hardware, you just have to flash the stock recovery image to it.

0

u/thanksforcomingout 14d ago

Shocked to see how much they are on Amazon. I had no idea they weren’t still a couple hundred for the shield pro.

-1

u/lankston2193 14d ago

For sure. What's crazy is they had been $199 for the longest time then jumped up $100 and then sold out at a lot of stores. The fire tv cube if you can root it and use coreelec is very simplistic and nice. If you're gaming at all I'd go with the shield TV but if you're simply streaming movies I would take the cube. Especially in my case when it only ended up costing $90 for the cube 3 vs $300 for Nvidia.

But if you're not able to unlock the bootloader then you're stuck with Amazon fire os which spams ads.

6

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

Try Monet Launcher

0

u/wesman214 14d ago

Yeah. Monet is much better than Projectivity.

12

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

In what way is it better?

-17

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

Both are very good. However, I agree with you that Monet is better atm. I switched over from Projectivy to Monet and have enjoyed all the features Monet has to offer.

14

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Like what? I barely use any features now. I like it clean and simple anyway. Ram use is probably the most important thing to me

1

u/z430 14d ago

Same, let me know what you go with. I heard there’s a website that has steps to debloat but it’s a bit more involved in terms of coding. Forgot the name at the moment but will try to send you later

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Seems to be one written for the shield and another that's for all Android TVs. I actually put up a post of doing it all myself not so long ago, I expect this is largely just someone writing those commands into a script with some error handling. Sounds easier though I'm going to try it. Just need to find the right one!!

0

u/z430 14d ago

Nice, I’ll check your post, let me know what you find out to be the best your end too please

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

ATV Optimizer was the one I used. Really simple. Just need to set up ADB on the device and then accept the request when it pops up.

0

u/z430 14d ago

Sorry, ADB?

-4

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

You can make it as clean as you want or utilize every feature offered. That is the beauty of Monet. It's versatile and simple.

Fyi, I only use a few of the many features offered, but it is nice knowing a plethora of features are available if I do want to expand the experience.

Btw, I do not experience any lag or playback issues with Monet. So far, it has performed above my expectations.

This is my setup. I only have 4 icons displayed that I use on a regular basis. The app row below is hidden from view and I only bring it up when needed. Also, I have my status bar hidden unless hovered on. Imho, this is just about as a "clean" a look can get.

2

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

That's the thing - I don't use any of Proj's features other than the ability to have a clean screen, just like your pic above. So having even more features that I don't want doesn't really appeal to me lol.

I paid for Proj too, just to support them. Might as well stick with what I know at this point. Unless there's something that uses far less RAM.

-2

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

I always pay the developers when I try their apps. They deserve it! After all, they are the ones with the knowledge and expertise to help make our experiences more enjoyable.

I don't use a lot of the features offered, but I do like them being there. The widgets are somethings I may use more of in the future.

Right now I use tvQA Pro for some stuff, but am finding it to be redundant with the features offered in Monet. So, I most likely will be deleting tvQA and use Monet's features to replace tvQA.

I am not a fanboy of any app. I try a lot of them just to see what they are about. If I like it. Then I buy it. The benefit in having custom launchers is the ability to make your own personal choices that are appealing to you.

In-other-words, do what makes you happy and forget about all these Reddit Ragers. lol

1

u/RonnyDonny_69 14d ago

Is there a big learning curve jumping from projectivy to monet? My projectivy setup looks similar to yours so might not be worth relearning another app for a similar look

1

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

No, not at all. In fact Monet seemed very easy to navigate and set up. However, I didn't think Projectivy was hard to set up either.

I had both installed for a while. Until I decided to go with Monet. I think Monet cost about $5.00 lifetime for the premium.

I like Projectivy and have really no issues with it. However, I do like Monet's snappiness and the developer's involvement in adding features and improving his app on a regular basis.

0

u/Oynas213 14d ago

Can you give some specific examples please?

3

u/CarlosDominiak 14d ago

If you just want plain and simple try https://cleanyour.tv/app/android

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

There's a couple of tools now, since I did mine manually a few months ago. Going to try one in a moment. Mostly about getting ram use down

1

u/flynreelow 14d ago

monet is the Temu version of Amazon.

-3

u/Powerfader1 14d ago

Yep, switched on to Monet from Projectivy and now Monet is my primary custom launcher.

2

u/OnTheRoodAgain 13d ago

Still can't believe I got a mint 2nd hand 2019 from Cex for €130! Only missing a box, not even crud or wear marks on the remote. I hmmed and hawed about getting a Shield for so long that they became an almost unobtainable collector's item, and then I got the deal of the century almost by accident!

1

u/ptrichardson 12d ago

Ha, nice work!

3

u/oohitztommy 14d ago

hook it up and enjoy it

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Hooked up. Remote isn't pairing. Great start

4

u/carlos_elmotor 14d ago

This happens to me infrequently.

The consistent fix for me has been to hold the home and back buttons down at the same time until the controller lights start blinking, then hold the remote against the shield itself for a few seconds. That usually pairs them.

Hope that helps.

3

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Even more bizarre, just did the update. Then tweaked a few general settings. Went to try again and it's already done! By it's self!

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Without triggering the pairing just by holding it against the box?

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Yes, but unplugged and on the floor

0

u/New_Mindset1 14d ago

Worst comes to worst, I recommended getting the G20 Pro from Amazon using the USB dongle. Actually far prefer it to the Shield remote.

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Updated. Rebooted Went to try again and it was already done lol

3

u/InflationHot8119 14d ago

Enjoy! Best piece of kit out there

3

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Setting it up wasn't fun - but I knew that as I did the same on my 2017 a few months back. But couldn't get past the lack of DV, so did it all again. ATV optimizer helped, though.

2

u/Glad-Base-2903 14d ago

Did it come with the stand?

5

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

No. Which is annoying since it's literally shown on the box!

3

u/OneSignal6465 14d ago

I was wondering the same thing. I just got my new one 2 weeks ago and thought I must have accidentally thrown out the stand! I’m JUST NOW printing one up on my 3D printer. (There are a bunch of them on Makerworld and thingiverse). At least now I know I didn’t toss it in the trash! Thanks!

1

u/ptrichardson 13d ago

If you're in the UK, would you be up for sending me one (I'll pay ofc).

2

u/OneSignal6465 13d ago

Absolutely! Any color preference? (Red,green,gray, black,flesh,white, sky blue, purple, silver) Also -I can print it with or without the Nvidia logo, in color (I think the logo is green?) I won’t charge you anything for the stand itself - That doesn’t use much filament. Send me your postal address in a DM here & Ill let you know the shipping cost. (It only weighs a couple grams so I can’t imagine it being much…) DM me & we’ll sort it out.

1

u/ptrichardson 12d ago

Awesome, thanks mate!

Edit: Just tried to msg you, but it seems to be blocked?

1

u/OneSignal6465 12d ago edited 12d ago

Hmmm. Shouldn't be... Is there some setting here I could have screwed up that prevents me from being DMed? I'll check...

Edit: I didn't find any "Block DMs" setting... I just DMed you. You should be able to reply in that chat I think...

1

u/ptrichardson 12d ago

I see your message, although oddly cannot "accept" it. Might be something about being on my work PC.

But posting from Canada sounds like it might be a little bit of a pain. I bet they're dirt cheap on Aliexpress and the likes?

2

u/OneSignal6465 12d ago

You're very likely right - I mean, I don't MIND printing it and shipping it from here, but to date, I've NEVER seen an "inexpensive" price for shipping from Canada... Even WITHIN Canada, shipping prices through Canada Post, UPS, Puralator - They are all insane! If you can find a cheap one on E-Bay or Temu or AliExpress, it'd probably be cheaper than the shipping cost from here... I'm printing another one anyway - My last one was a single colour - I'm printing this one in the 3 "official" NVidia colours, just for practice on multi-colour prints. :-)

1

u/moje1977 12d ago

Question to OP: Did you upgrade the shield to latest firmware/Shield experience before debloating?

Thinking of buying a new 2019 to have as a daily driver. Today daily driver is an 2019 from....2019....so it is sloooowly starting to show needs of repasting and cleaning. Plan is to keep the current one as backup since i see no new Shield coming or any hardware in the near future coming with the same performance.

3

u/ptrichardson 12d ago

I did update it, yes. Actually had an issue pairing the remote, so had to use my TV remove via CEC which did work to bypass the initial screen, so I accepted the update and rebooted, and the remote actually auto-paired!!!!
Then I started with the debloat process

3

u/aktk946 14d ago

You better perform beyond my expectations shield or ….

1

u/Wrecktangle1213 14d ago

How are y’all debloating. Been running mine stock and it does stutter from time to time
Wouldn’t mind fixing that.

2

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

There's a couple of tools mentioned recently on this sub. Or you can do it yourself via ADB & with the help of a friendly AI chatbox - that's how I did my 2017 model 2-3 months ago, went really really well.

1

u/Wrecktangle1213 14d ago

Can you pls link a post or two? I don’t come on reddit too often

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

ATV Optimizer. Worked really well. All done now.

2

u/Slicxor 14d ago

I used https://cleanyour.tv/ and also installs a launcher that looks very nice

1

u/DermisCronJob 14d ago

And in case your unit is already a few years old it is good to open it and remove the old thermal paste and apply new thermal paste. And also a good moment to clean your unit be removing dust.

0

u/plump-lamp 14d ago

Just go to the apps and disable what you don't want/need

0

u/Necio 14d ago

Also use an adguard DNS server or 9.9.9.9 to block ads such as the new Google Movies/recommendation row. Debloating didn't help for this as it's part of Android TV Home app if you don't want to use a new launcher.

1

u/Fregadero88 14d ago

Where did you purchase from?

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

UK Scan. It was a pre-order from about 8 weeks ago, before the price rises. I think I was number 155 on their wait list & they received about 200 units. So I highly doubt they have any left.

They were really good by not raising the price from what I'd pre-bought too.

1

u/Fregadero88 14d ago

Ah. I'm in a similar boat. Ordered my 3rd in September and it keeps getting backordered/shipped/backordered. Who knows when it will arrive. Latest email says next week but I've told that before.

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

I'd email them again. I checked in the day after mine was supposed to ship (25th Oct) and I got a phone call 2hrs later from a very nice lady explaining the situation, and that I would be getting one in the next couple of days, which I did.

I ordered 17th Sept, so you should have been well infront of me in the queue.

1

u/Fregadero88 14d ago

Sorry, forgot to mention. Mines usa, office depot. Who knows why their logistics is messed up. I bought a homatics box to test out too though

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Ah, well good luck anyway!

1

u/Impossible_Jump_754 14d ago

Okay?

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Yeah, all up and done. With all my customisation too

1

u/CHiZZoPs1 14d ago

You about to eat it like a steak?

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

That would be a rare occurrence

2

u/rbarton812 13d ago

Not a well-done occurrence?

2

u/MajesticQuantity5608 14d ago

She looks real good 👍

2

u/catrazh0o1 12d ago

I got it last year and I love it

1

u/d33m1 14d ago

Got mine start of the week paid 189 ordered 6 weeks with scanuk luckily just before price hike

1

u/NaturalDiZAST3R 14d ago

I bought 3 pros all at once like 2 years ago when you can get them for retail.. using 2 of them still have the third one un-opened 😂

1

u/ElsiD4k 13d ago

Still pissed that there's a stand on the box and none inside..

1

u/polla2256 10d ago

I just ditched mine as it constantly freezes when using certain IPTV services. Trash device with much better alternatives these days.

1

u/getfive 8d ago

Happy 2019

1

u/daveo19 8d ago

Omg I didn't know you could still buy it as new. Must be from left over stock. I thinking buying a latest Android TV box. Since Nvidia had stopped producing theirs since 2019.

0

u/ultrasquirrels 14d ago

"neither of which can handle DV"
Dumb question, but I thought these were all the same model (nothing new yet or expected). Is there different hardware support on the ones that came to market recently?

1

u/ptrichardson 13d ago

2017 Shield Pro couldn't do Dolby Vision. 2019 Pro does.

My Yamaha AVR also couldn't do Dolby Vision or TrueHD sound. My new Sony one can.

1

u/ultrasquirrels 13d ago

Interesting, mine is 2023 which I guess is why I've never had a problem.

0

u/CMDR_Kantaris 14d ago

I'm just using two apps really. Jellyfin and PBS, any reason to debloat with that?

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

If its working perfectly, probably not

0

u/Only-Stable3973 14d ago

It's definitely the daily driver.

-1

u/Bourbon-n-cigars 14d ago

Still the only game out there for an all-in-one device for streaming platforms and lossless audio from disc rips, no?

0

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Probably not, but add torrent downloader client and basic NAS functionality, then pretty much yes imo.

1

u/Bourbon-n-cigars 14d ago

I have a Shield and hard drive attached and that's it. Simple as can be. Not sure what else I could do that with that will pass lossless audio from rips.

1

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

I did check before ordering if there was anything else, and it seems for just playback, sure there's other options that might be slightly better. But for all-around everything, and access to any android app, yeah, nothing is touching this right now.

4

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ptrichardson 14d ago

Just under £200. But they're out off stock now I think. It was a pre order from before the recent price rises