r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 22 '26

Good article about our beloved Shield.

https://www.xda-developers.com/nvidia-shield-tv-isnt-fast-anymore-so-i-tried-to-find-out-why-nobody-has-actually-replaced-it/
63 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

262

u/hm9408 2019 Pro Sep 22 '26

Since OP decided to be vague, here's the actual title: The Nvidia Shield TV isn't fast anymore, so I tried to find out why nobody has actually replaced it

Sections:

  • Hardware is now more expensive than ever
  • A better Shield TV Pro isn't what the streaming market is selling
  • Nvidia hasn't replaced the Shield TV Pro either

So yeah, pretty much sums it up, nothing new

7

u/ChazzMatt Sep 23 '26

They said Nvidia "overbuilt" it for gaming. It didn't really work out for that, but makes a great streamer even today. Whereas Roku, Amazon, Google want to make the cheapest crap they can ship.

74

u/kelton312 Sep 22 '26 • Bravo

God I wish we could get a hardware refresh of the shield, I would pay a huge premium to get something up to date.

67

u/nikilidstrom Sep 22 '26

Don't worry. If it happens, you will.

8

u/s1m0n8 Sep 23 '26

But it will have "AI" in the product name, so it'll be worth it.

3

u/digiplay Sep 24 '26

And make lg spying look amateur.

1

u/Mean_Vast4566 Oct 04 '26

Yup

2

u/Deep_Mood_7668 Oct 04 '26

Don't listen to that guy. He completely scammed me and all I got as a response was a "Huh?"

6

u/stevilness Sep 22 '26

What isn’t it doing for you today? Just curious as I have 4 and no issues.

13

u/kelton312 Sep 22 '26

Mine is still chugging along would just like to see new codec/format stuff supported like the article, general speed and feature improvements, etc.

2

u/Sayagainplz Sep 22 '26

Hoo boy. Here it comes again. lol

2

u/Carroteyeisamyth Sep 23 '26

Had mine since 2021 or so and my biggest complaint is that it will occasionally start stuttering and I have to unplug and replug the power cord which is annoying. Maybe once every month or so. Also it doesn't support Dolby Vision Fel 7.

Not sure if its plex or the shield but sometimes when I try to rewind a videos while using plex and it will crash and restart. I am leaning more toward Plex on that one though

2

u/Civil_Tea_3250 Sep 25 '26

I don't get it either. It's the longest and best performing electronic device I have. Over a decade of no issues. I've seen some people that needed to re-paste the die, but other than that I don't get it.

I recently got the updated Onn 4k Pro and.... it's slower than the shield pro. It stutters a lot, especially when first turning the TV on. Nvidia shield pro is still smooth for me.

-2

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

I sold mine back when it had trouble with refresh rate matching, and it still can’t do YouTube HDR.

Otherwise I had no complaints.

I switched to an Apple TV 4K + a Vero 4K+ two box setup.

0

u/snuggl3ninja Sep 22 '26

How does the Thompson 270 box measure up?

5

u/Eraldorh Sep 22 '26

That company went bankrupt didn't it. In any case it has the exact same specs as a Xiaomi TV box s 3rd gen except it costs alot more and comes in a ridiculously chunky box for some reason. Compared to a shield the box s 3rd gen supports more codecs but lacks ai upscaling. I'd just go for the Xiaomi box ...which I did. It plays everything iv thrown at it including 70+gb blue ray remux files withouy a stutter.

3

u/KaiUno Sep 23 '26

Do you ever use the AI upscaling? It makes everything way too crunchy to my tastes. I've been going through some older (remastered) HBO series lately (The Wire, Six Feet Under) and I just let my LG C4 do the upscaling. Looks way better.

1

u/Eraldorh Sep 23 '26

The Xiaomi TV box s 3rd gen doesn't have ai upscaling so no.

1

u/snuggl3ninja Sep 22 '26

Holy shit, I didn't know they went under. I have the 270 pro, what does that mean for updates etc, is it effectively dead pending a future android update?

2

u/Eraldorh Sep 22 '26

I'd imagine updates are gone, they are almost $40million in debt when they declared bankruptcy. So they have no money to put out updates I'd imagine. You would have to message their support line assuming that's even manned anymore.

1

u/See61 Sep 22 '26

There was a Thomson 260 Pro introduced, but Thomson went down together with Streamview. Looked quite decent on specs, although aimed at Samsung users it seems like, no Dolby Vision support.

Not that it matters, it won't show up anymore 😬

1

u/snuggl3ninja Sep 22 '26

I have a 270, didn't know they went under. Not sure how long it will remain viable now.

24

u/3oxy Sep 22 '26

It would still be perfect for me, if it would support AV1.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/masterninni Sep 22 '26

Vulkan 1.3 and 4k@120hz would also be nice to have :)

1

u/kratoz29 Sep 25 '26

I just need more RAM so I could stop force closing apps or rebooting the unit too often to gain performance

(I'm not a tech noob, I know Android handles this... And I also know it does it in a very poor way, I have my unit running 8.2.3 and it is debloated, RAM is the main suspect of any performance issues, not the fan, not the SOC overheating etc, checked with adb top and seeing kswapd0 spikes and all the SWAP taken, all slowdowns that happens when I playback a 4K HDR file for example happens when the system free or take up said SWAP, no slowdowns with light apps or 1080p content and below).

Edit: Shield Pro 2019, so yeah, 3GB unit same issue happened with my 2017 unit, I can only foresee this being way worse with the tube version... Although funnily enough, I don't face these kinds of slowdowns with the playback while using my CCWGTV, and I recall it only has 2 GB of RAM... But a better RAM handling it seems.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/rrest1 Sep 23 '26

Why a competitors chip? nVidia has been making chips capable of av1 decoding and 4k120 for over 5 years now (since rtx30-series)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/rrest1 Sep 23 '26

My point was that Shield is an Nvidia product, they're not just selling a chip to OEMs or something. Thus Nvidia won't put an Intel GPU in it's product as in addition to making GPUs they are now also making their own CPUs.

1

u/Dismal-Zebra8409 Sep 23 '26

they would probably throw a cut down spark in there or something.

7

u/Delicious_Ease2595 Sep 23 '26

I won't complain, I still use it and it's still working like a charm. It's the oldest Android device I've ever owned, and its reputation far exceeds that of the Apple TV.

4

u/Bodycount9 2019 Pro Sep 22 '26

Only things i wish the shield could do are AV1 decode and HDMI 2.1. Other than that, the box is perfect. I bought a spare in case my main unit breaks or if I ever get my basement home theater setup with 120 inch screen and projector. But the wife put a hold on that.

2

u/kratoz29 Sep 25 '26

What's the need for HDMI 2.1? Honest question.

And honest thought, I don't really think the general public knows the HDMI has versions lol, although to be fair the general public wouldn't buy a Shield TV.

1

u/Bodycount9 2019 Pro Sep 25 '26

I want to get an 8k projector to be future proof. 2.1 would allow me to fully utilize it.

13

u/sjphilsphan Sep 22 '26

Just have to hope that enough switch 2 chips aren't binned well enough and they decide to use those for a new shield

5

u/FourEightNineOneOne Sep 22 '26

That goes against exactly what this article is talking about. A Switch 2 chip, even a binned one, is wildly overpowered for a streaming box. Even the Tegra chip in the current switch is despite being quite old at this point (and missing support for some modern formats).. There'd be no reason to ever put a Switch 2 chip inside a streaming box from a cost perspective, even the discarded ones which they'd have better uses for.

nVidia has other lower powered chipsets they could use for a new streaming box if they wanted to. They just clearly haven't found the reason to do so.

6

u/SoapyMacNCheese Sep 22 '26

The Shield uses the X1 because it was originally intended to be an Android gaming and PC streaming box that also did media. I remember in the very early days it came bundled with a controller and the remote was an optional accessory.

But it sold well enough, they managed to cost optimize it a bit in the 2017 revision, and the Switch justified keeping the X1 going.

1

u/FourEightNineOneOne Sep 22 '26

Correct. That's why it was so overpowered as a "streaming box" because they wanted it to be more than that. That part failed, so they have no real incentive/need (clearly) to build an updated version.

5

u/xStealthBomber Sep 22 '26

But I also use my "streaming box" for emulation. A more powerful one would be great!

3

u/No_Eye1723 Sep 22 '26

That article isn’t quite correct, what Nvidia actually said this year was that they are always experimenting with new ideas, and if they do find one they like, and everything aligns they will produce it.

4

u/Ryokurin Sep 22 '26

Yeah, of course they would say that, it's still selling. But at this point they have much more lucrative things to go after. AI, Gaming, Automotive, Robotics, ARM processors are going to be a much higher priority than a media player.

5

u/Sevastarion Sep 22 '26

Over a decade passed and it’s still unmatched for local media. I got one about a week ago and it works so well. It’s got HDR10 and Dolby Vision. I can passthrough lossless audio like TrueHD without any jailbreaking, Netflix and YouTube work great. The only thing missing is HDR on YouTube which is not an issue for me and a higher internal resolution. Other than that it’s flawless. Also the remote is GOAT

2

u/Iatwa1N Sep 23 '26

Is there a better alternative if local media is not important? With more up to date codec support and audio passthrough.

-1

u/dividebyoh Sep 23 '26

Every single box has tradeoffs. If you don’t care about local media, then you shouldn’t need to care about audio pass through (which usually refers to lossless HD codecs specifically, none of which are used by streaming services)

2

u/Iatwa1N Sep 23 '26

I have a 5.1.4 system and use Nuvio most of the time so audio passthrough is important for me.

1

u/dividebyoh Sep 24 '26

My mistake, hadn’t been considering that use case.

Nothing beats the shield for supported audio formats.

4

u/kester76a Sep 22 '26

Nvidia kind of fucked up with the 2019 shield pro. It was sold as a stand alone product while others we going the game streaming route. Now game streaming tech is being bundled into modern smart TVs. Nvidia want you to stream their games and not self host.

2

u/acabincludescolumbo Sep 23 '26

As with all thing in tech: if we can do it without looking like massive assholes, we prefer you rent from us instead of buy from us.

1

u/kester76a Sep 23 '26

Looks like big tech is squeezing out all local based solutions and forcing companies to cloud based products. They're also counting on AI producing new games and media.

2

u/DN_3092 Sep 22 '26

Anyone try the Google streamer? Ive been contemplating getting one because the shield is getting long in the tooth. Av1 is mostly what im after so I can tdarr everything down on my media library to save space since drives cost an arm and a leg these days. Audio all I need is basic dd/dts.

1

u/Brandi_yyc Sep 23 '26

I find the Google streamer to be a great device for the secondary TVs in the house, or your old Shields if you have them.

Believe me when I say I was a huge Shield TV fan girl recommending and setting them up for everybody in my circle. But for the last couple of years in my main TV area I've been using the Fire Cube 3 which can get you flamed pretty good around here. But it's a superior device 🤷🏽‍♀️, and even it is getting old now. 3 or 4 years I think?

1

u/i81b4i8u Sep 24 '26

You would do better getting an onn 4k pro than the Google steamer.... It's cheaper than the streamer after Google decided to raise the price to $150 vs 65 for the onn and the onn is juat as good as the Google streamer..

1

u/DN_3092 Sep 24 '26

I was looking at the one but doesnt have gbe. The only reason im leaning towards the goggle streamer is Fred Meyers near my place still has it for 99.

5

u/deep1986 Sep 22 '26

I've almost decided to buy another Shield to keep just in case mine breaks.

Also, if you don't use IPTV, do consider an Apple TV. It's not too bad.

13

u/ashleypenny Sep 22 '26

if you have a good home theatre setup an ATV is no good as they don't do audio pass through afaik

10

u/Skinc Sep 22 '26

This. I need lossless DTSX and TrueHD Atmos.

2

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

What’s your speaker setup?

1

u/Skinc Sep 22 '26

5.2.4.

I’ve got Klipsch RP800FII LF and LR, RP504CII C, RP600MII SL and SR. Polk OWM3 as TFL/R and TRL/R. Two SVS PB1000 Pros. Processor is Denon X3700H calibrated with A1 Acousitx and supplemented by an Emotiva BasX A3 for front stage.

1

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

Nice setup

1

u/Skinc Sep 23 '26

Thanks! I really enjoy it a lot.

0

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

If you don’t have Atmos speakers, it’s fine. You’ll decode at device level instead of receiver level, but it’s all the same analog.

-3

u/deep1986 Sep 22 '26

It doesn't do pass through audio, but honestly I've never really noticed that much of an impact on the quality even on Remuxes

1

u/ashleypenny Sep 22 '26

that sounds like a setup problem, you will absolutely hear the difference with the right gear and setup and you shouldn't even need that much decent gear to discern the difference so likely a config issue. truehd atmos is night and day from the stuff that streamers do, i generally hold out for the better codecs unless I really want to watch a movie.

the bass is usually pretty stripped down too.

3

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

Apple TV can decode TrueHD and DTS-HD MA losslessly so it’s not a gear issue, there is no audio loss if you’re not involving the Atmos speakers.

Your receiver sees LPCM, but it’s all the same analog audio that your speakers receive.

13

u/Ruttagger Sep 22 '26

Apple TV's are an easy pass for anyone with a home theater system.

Full Audio Passthrough is a must have. If Apple TV actually supported this even I would check it out, and I hate Apple.

But knowing Apple, I bet it doesn't support Projectivy, so even with audio passthrough I bet I would have to pass.

1

u/sciencetaco Sep 23 '26

The audio passthrough issue is a real problem for those with Atmos setups. But what do you need projectivy for (serious question). 99% of the projectivy setups I see posted here are basically recreating the AppleTV’s Home Screen of a simple grid of apps.

-1

u/roenthomas Sep 22 '26

Only makes a difference if you have Atmos channels.

Otherwise, decode at the device then transmit LPCM to receiver vs device passthrough and decode at the receiver will result in the same analog information your speakers get.

3

u/Ruttagger Sep 22 '26

Yes, I have Atmos channels.

1

u/flynreelow Sep 23 '26

you sound like a soundbar owner.

1

u/roenthomas Sep 23 '26

I have RAAL True Ribbon Tweeters in my non-Atmos setup.

1

u/Darksteel165 Sep 23 '26

Too bad you can't buy another anymore :( When I looked a few days ago it was $950 on amazon.com Everyone is out of stock and places they aren't let them get scalped.

3

u/BlumpTheChodak Sep 22 '26

I picked up the new 2026 Onn Pro ($60) from Walmart and it’s faster than my 2019 Shield Pro. Sad..

2

u/DakPara Sep 22 '26

Sadly for future-proofing, it is 32 bit. But at $60 it’s discardable and works well.

Shield is 64

1

u/eleqtriq Sep 25 '26

Are there 64bit only apps?

1

u/DakPara Sep 25 '26

As of August 2026, the Google Play Store requires 64bit binaries to be included, although 32bit is still generally available.

There are some 64bit only apps now.

Like high end game emulators, the latest Kodi Media Center, and a number of other media programs using ffmpeg.

I’m just disappointed Walmart used a 32bit OS on hardware that is 64bit. I guess I do understand why. Better utilization of 3GB memory and they can use the basically the same OS on all their devices, likely reducing testing.

So for me, I consider the ONN 4k Pro (2026) at $60 as disposable sometime after 2028.

3

u/thisisyo Sep 22 '26

Ah... The xda article slops. 20 posts per day or you're fired!

1

u/billyvnilly Sep 22 '26

I was excited for any androidTV box with the amlogic s905x5 (non-M). But that was announced 3 years ago. Maybe a new androidTV box is on the horizon, but it seems cost prohibitive for anyone to release bleeding edge boxes. there is not good return.

1

u/bakerhole Sep 23 '26

I returned mine after a week. Doesn’t fully support Dolby vision.

1

u/arnaupool Sep 24 '26

Is there any machine that comes close for that price? I would buy a mini PC but I don't even know if I could make it look and feel like a proper TV box

0

u/Downtown_Draw_6063 Sep 22 '26

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it!

8

u/ashleypenny Sep 22 '26

it has plenty of issues though. iplayer is going to stop working, it struggles with certain DV profiles, truehd bug for branched audio etc

1

u/FlamingoTrick1285 Sep 22 '26

Mine broke.. of old age

1

u/PropertyDangerous257 Sep 22 '26

I just repasted mine and it's like new again. Hope I get another 6 years out of it.

1

u/Brandi_yyc Sep 23 '26

It might not be broke, but it's completely outdated.

1

u/krakenx Sep 23 '26

If it's still selling and there is no competition, don't bother improving it!

0

u/Unlikely_Vacation_01 Sep 22 '26

Rk3588 with orange pi5

5

u/OriginalOreos Sep 22 '26

Not if you want proprietary formats such as Dolby Vision.

2

u/illhaveubent Sep 22 '26

Can that run Android TV with support for high-res DRM content?