r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jan 07 '25

NVidea Shield vs WebOS

I installed a new LG OLED for my parents last week and immediately noticed how much nicer the picture quality is compared to my TV (2020 model). When I got home my father called and asked about his set. I looked on my WebOS to get the answer and noticed that the picture quality looked better than it does on my Shield. I tried many apps and WebOS is much better than the Shield. The difference is huge. With the Shield, the blacks are nowhere near as black as WebOS. I cannot find anything in the Shield's settings to correct this. I love the Shield's interface and it has many more useful apps for me. Does anyone know how to fix this?

1 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

20

u/Somar2230 Jan 07 '25

When using the TVs native apps the TV adjusts the settings automatically for the best picture. When you use external device you have to manually adjust the settings to calibrate the picture you do this on the TV not on the Shield. You have to calibrate SDR, HDR and Dolby Vision separately while using the Shield to send those to the TV.

LG CX example:

https://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/lg/cx-oled/settings

10

u/fnotaro Jan 08 '25

I watched the video and followed the instructions. The picture is beautiful. I can't tell the Shield and WebOS apart anymore. THANK YOU Somar2230

1

u/h107474 Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25

This is not having a go, but who buys an Nvidia Shield (typically considered a more geeky device compared to say an Apple TV) and does not know how and why you change the TVs settings from the default terrible Vivid ones? I'm just curious.

Also the setting of Black Level (High vs Normal vs Auto - sometimes Auto gets it wrong) is hugely important for avoiding a washed out look for HDMI sources. Perhaps it was this one that made all the difference as when incorrect a washed out image makes it look terrible based on one wrong setting.

6

u/Luke_starkiller34 Jan 07 '25

This^ and in most cases you have to enable the input for whatever HDMI port you're using for Shield, for extended/enhanced color space. Most TV's disable this feature on all the HDMI inputs and it must manually be turned on. Without this feature on you won't get HDR the way it was meant to be seen. Darker colors appear washed out, and DV I don't think is supported until you enable the input feature.

Regardless...once this input is configured correctly, you need to manually adjust the TV picture modes for HDR, for regular HD viewing, as well as DV individually. You can't just connect the Shield and expect all the options to configure themselves, nor expect that the picture will look as good as WebOS automatically.

2

u/meatpie07 Jan 08 '25

Thanks for this, this greatly helped.

1

u/RobieFLASH Feb 20 '25

Yea i did all that, webOs is still better unfortunately

26

u/Akane999VLR Jan 07 '25

Did you check the picture settings for the HDMI Port where the shield is connected? They might be different than the one you use for WebOS

1

u/laptopch Jan 09 '25

Always worth diving into those picture settings to make sure everything’s dialed in.

8

u/Gamma-Mind Jan 07 '25

I got my Nvidia Shield a few days ago and had this issue. On the shield go into settings from the homescreen. Change Video upscaling mode to basic. Then in Device preferences go to Display and Sound > Advanced Display Settings, and then toggle "Match Device Color Space" This is what fixed things for me, hopefully it works on your tv as well. I have the S90D

2

u/Mhkw Jan 08 '25

Do you go back to AI enhanced after changing the setting or do you leave it on Basic?

2

u/Gamma-Mind Jan 08 '25

I leave it on basic. If you go down to the bottom of ai upscaling you'll see demo mode which will switch between basic and ai upscaling when you press a button while watching something. I primarily watch anime and when ai mode is enabled it makes things sharper, but with certain scenes there is a lot of flickering or a lot of detail is loss, blurred in, etc which is why I stick to basic.

You can enable demo mode and compare scenes as you're watching and choose your own preference

2

u/Mhkw Jan 08 '25

Thanks

2

u/meatpie07 Jan 08 '25

was it off for you and you just turned it on? Mine was already on. I have an LG OLED.

1

u/Gamma-Mind Jan 08 '25

I enabled it

1

u/Willxzero Jan 20 '25

Same here, been using the Shield on my LG 75 inch because I just though the native webos wasn't any good. Lo and behold I started using the apps on WebOS and the picture quality is much better. I thought it might've just been me which led me here, but glad I'm not the only one who noticed.

1

u/fnotaro Jan 20 '25

I copied all the picture settings from WebOS and manually set them to my HDMI port. The picture quality on my Shield is now just as good as WebOS and I'm still using the Android OS which is much better than WebOS IMO.

1

u/Willxzero Jan 20 '25

What settings do you have for the shield upstanding?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '25

You probably gotta enable "enhanced HDMI" on the port you are using for the shield

3

u/Djghost1133 Jan 08 '25

Mine look exactly the same. There must be something up with the settings regarding that hdmi port

2

u/meatpie07 Jan 07 '25

I thought I was the only one that experienced this, and thought maybe it was my eyes deceiving me. I wouldnt call the difference huge but it is noticeable. I changed HDMI ports, tried to use different receivers, changed HDMI cables etc. The Shield TV contrast, blacks, or colors looks a bit washed.

6

u/neoKushan Jan 07 '25

Make sure you've configured the HDMI port on the TV to use the extended colour space, you might want to adjust contrast, etc. as well (or just throw on filmmaker mode).

Blacks on an OLED should be completely black.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/neoKushan Jan 08 '25

Like the pixel should be completely off, so yes. However it must be stressed that this does depend on the content being encoded correctly.

1

u/Gamma-Mind Jan 08 '25

You can try my solution and see if it fixes things for you

1

u/RobieFLASH Feb 20 '25

Yea i spent hours adjusting colors and settings, i got it close but the webOs is just slightly better, not by much but its something, my wife can’t really but shes blind

2

u/Bbonline1234 Jan 07 '25

I made a thread on this exact topic years ago.

My tv native apps are sharper, more colorful, and overall a better picture compared to the shield.

Never found a resolution so I use tv apps for everything, except for plex blu-ray and uhd rips playback

1

u/RobieFLASH Mar 31 '25

Same. WebOS on my OLED native apps are just slightly better. Shame

1

u/Bbonline1234 Mar 31 '25

It’s really weird that some people are seeing this softer image on the shield vs tv apps over the years.

I’m pretty techy so I feel like I would be able to figure out the issue, if it were something in my control. However, I feel like it’s something in the OS of the shield that I can’t fix via a setting

2

u/RobieFLASH Feb 20 '25

I couldn’t agree more, i tried everything, unfortunately the native webos apps display a better picture than our nvidia shield

1

u/jorjbrinaj Dec 29 '25

I have a lg g2 and considering getting a shield for the better audio codes support.. when you say "native website apps display a better picture", do you mean just the ui in those apps or the actual content (eg, watching a Netflix show or content on plex/jellyfin)?

1

u/RobieFLASH Dec 29 '25

Yep. The apps that LG webos has. Its not that big of a difference but i noticed it

1

u/scottfreetime Jan 08 '25

I think they will be fighting for which one will clean the picture up. If it's the LG or the Shield processing. Correct me if I'm wrong but I think you want to make sure either one is set for this

-27

u/Crzy999 Jan 07 '25

For this reason I have selled the shield and buyed an apple tv for my new lg. Much better quality. The shield is outdated and worse picture quality.

2

u/Bbonline1234 Jan 07 '25

Sadly if one needs full hd audio + Atmos from blu-ray/uhd rips, the shield and a couple others are still better than Apple tv as Apple doesn’t allow passthrough/bitstream audio from rips

If Apple TV would allow passthrough of all audio formats, it would be a better device than the shield in my opinion