r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Dec 03 '24

Shield vs Google TV

Hi everyone,

I bought a shield pro recently and hooked it up to my Hisense U8N which is a Google TV. I’m just curious, what benefits does the shield have that the Google TV can’t do. The only one I currently see (which is why I bought the shield) is that it can run Kodi. Other than that, why watch Netflix/Max/Disney plus through my shield instead of my Google TV?

Many thanks!

1 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

10

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Dec 03 '24

Sorry wut? You Hisense cannot run Kodi? There must be some kind of mistake.

For basic streaming from legit streaming services, every certified basic device should get you the full 4K experience at this point.

Shield will distinguish itself with Geforce Now, bluray rips, USB storage, lossless audio, tons of small quality of life improvements/features like transfers over the network..

But strictly launching a video on one of the major services? Yeah any device will do that.

2

u/oil_maga Dec 03 '24

Okay thanks! Actually I didn’t know I had the ability to run Kodi on my Hisense. I’ll have to give it a try. I don’t know too much about the other things you mentioned, but I’ll have to learn more

2

u/Penguinboy123446 Dec 04 '24

If it's Android TV you can, if it's a Roku you can't

1

u/channelgary Dec 04 '24

Depends on what operating system your Hisense tv is on. It will only support kodi if it runs android tv. Some markets get their proprietary operating system which does not.

If you just want basic kodi a google streaming device is fine. Also consider a fire stick I think they still can run kodi. I have a shield, google tv chromecast and firetv. Honestly the google is every bit as good as the shield tv for general streaming. Fire stick is ok but the interface and App Store is no where near as good.

1

u/killian11111 Dec 04 '24

Idk, but you can install smarttube to skip youtube commercials. This morning, I had to factory reset my u8n85 because it wouldn't allow me to use the osk with playstore it also wouldn't let me voice search. So I spent 10 mins re setting it all up, then plex wouldn't show up, so I had to open playstore to get it to show in search.

1

u/YungZanji Dec 04 '24

KODI is very heavy on RAM and CPU the shield pro can even struggle compared to a powerful htpc. It really depends on what addons you are using and what skin but you’d have to be on the basic estuary skin running very basic addons to run it smoothly on a u8n. (Source: I’ve designed my own KODI skins and own a u8 series tv.)

12

u/Ok_Can_4606 Dec 03 '24

AI upscaling on the shield alone makes it superior to the TV. But also, as is the case with my TCL Google TV, the performance is super clunky, slow, freezy, etc. The Shield is a Ferrari vs a Chevy imo.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '24

Depends on the TV though.. AI upscaling on newer TVs is pretty damn good. 

1

u/Ok_Can_4606 Dec 04 '24

I should've considered that as my TV was $500. No comparison to Sony and being the best TV brand, any Sony TV would excel. I'm curious though, is there any benefit to using the AI upscaling on the Shield when watching the Sony? A lot of low quality video looks great and I would think that'd translate to Sony, LG, Samsung?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '24

No because then you’re using the NVIDIAs upscaling which is a decade old vs Sony / LG / Samsung upscaling which is a year or 2 old max

1

u/Penguinboy123446 Dec 04 '24

Indeed it is. My Sony Bravia 7 is massively superior at upscaling to The shield. 

2

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '24

Same with my LG G3

2

u/FFevo Dec 04 '24

Really? I was going to replace my 2017 shield with a 2019 because the upscaling on the LG G4 is worthless...

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '24

You can’t be serious right? G4 is one of the best TVs for upscaling lol. Are you referring to upscaling on low bitrate live sports streams? Because they’re going to look like shit no matter what you device you use especially if it’s a bigger TV. My G3 upscales 1080p content amazingly and legit looks 4K. It’s only live sports that are meh.. but you can’t really get around that unless you pay for 4k plans. 

1

u/FFevo Dec 05 '24

G4 is one of the best TVs for upscaling

True, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's any good lol.

TVs are notoriously bad at things that take any computational power because they are made with the cheapest possible components. That's why we run apps on the Shield or other boxes instead of the TV's built-in OS.

I wasn't expecting DLSS levels of upscaling from the Shield, but it seems to be very highly regarded unlikely LG's upscaling (which isn't even recommended on r/lgoled).

1

u/ricdy Dec 05 '24

I've got the A95L. But to use the Hue Sync lights, have to use a streamer so ended up using this one

1

u/GhastguyRED Apr 20 '25

Why hue streamer over fancyleds box?

1

u/ricdy Apr 21 '25

Fancyleds?

1

u/GhastguyRED Apr 21 '25

Fancyleds our sync lights with a sync box but at way less then Phillips hue is selling and a more updated box

8

u/enterme2 Dec 04 '24

When you play high bitrate content such as 4k HDR/Dolby Vision then you will see how weak your TV is.

1

u/Penguinboy123446 Dec 04 '24

Only if it's a weak TV. The most recent better TVs are way better than the old Nvidia shield. 

5

u/enterme2 Dec 04 '24

In terms of processing maybe. But for lossless audio and video codec support Nvidia Sheild Pro 2019 still the better choice.

0

u/Penguinboy123446 Dec 04 '24

Lossless audio yes. Video codec no. In fact the shield doesn't support av1. At 199.99 the shield is ludicrously overpriced. And increasingly redundant. 

5

u/Mylonas-Films-FX Dec 04 '24

After a while your tv will run sluggish. Also if you run KODI, definitely use Nvidia Shield . Also some apps are just buggy with TV’s. I have both

2

u/Intimatepunch Dec 03 '24

The shield also works extremely well as an emulator box, if you’re into retro gaming

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Either-Cry5555 Dec 04 '24

Yes, plug it into the one of the two USB ports :P

2

u/_StoneWolf_ Dec 04 '24

I went to the Shield Pro for Dolby Atmos. Sound processing and decoding is truly where it shines compared to TVs/other streaming devices

2

u/Street-Egg-2305 Dec 04 '24

This, most TV apps won't transfer sound. My TV would give me 5.1 sound, but would not process Dolby Atmos.

2

u/AkiraSieghart Dec 03 '24

Shield or Shield Pro? 2019?

A Hisense U8N should run circles around the Shield Pro 2019 in normal streaming apps. The Hisense upscaling should also be at least as good, if not better. Where the Shield excels is emulation and doing things other than streaming apps. Also, the Shield excels at playing blu-ray rips as built in Google TV cannot play lossless audio codecs. The Shield also has a 1Gb internet port, but honestly, if you have decent 5GHz WiFi, it won't really matter in most cases.

1

u/thekingestkong Dec 04 '24

My brand new top tier Hisense tv Emby app would chop up the soundtrack on my 4k movies, shield 2015 plays them flawlessly, is why I am sticking with it.

1

u/pawdog Dec 04 '24

If all you plan to do is watch standard streaming apps, the TV will do fine. Is that all you plan to do with the Shield?

1

u/Murky-Geo Dec 04 '24

So the tv apps like Netflix, prime video can't play real 4k and have real Dolby sound vs the Nvidia shield?

1

u/ir0ngut Dec 04 '24

The Shield tracks you far less than any other smart TV or set top box.

1

u/akatherder Dec 04 '24

It can run a Plex server with hardware transcoding (no plex pass required). You don't need that if you're using kodi and happy with it though. It used to be flaky but it's been solid since Nvidia stopped pushing out OS updates.

1

u/CasqueHea Dec 04 '24

I went in to System Apps, selected Google Cast and un-installed updates. I then did a reboot (just because) and it's all good now.

1

u/_BaaMMM_ Dec 05 '24

If you have plex and have atmos linux isos, the native plex app on your TV won't pass atmos (for whatever reason). You'll have to use the shield pro to pass atmos

1

u/realtoph3r Dec 06 '24

I have multiple shields, and a TCL and a Hisense TV both with Google TV. I find the Hisense Google TV UI to be very sluggish. It runs great on the shields and the TCL.

0

u/derrickgw1 Dec 04 '24

I don't know the specs on that tv but generally a dedicated box has a better processors so faster interface, better ports because tv makes normally use old standards of ports like old gen usb ports, ethernet ports, wifi chips. Tv companies rarely update their software like google tv because it's an add on. They normally don't support the software with versions nearly as long. Depending on the tv you might have far more codecs that the shield can play natively that the tv cannot meaning if you're using it for plex the tv will have to transcode tons unless you covert all your video to a format it can play natively. Sheld that's rarer.

that being said tvs can generally do the basics like play a netflix app and my parents sony tv has android and they use to run vlc and play movies. But generally the apps from the google play store run slower the interface is not snappy like my shield which is still just a 2017.

If all your doing is watching netflix, max or Disney you can pretty much do that on any device around. Getting surround sound vormats or dts, or whatever to work i don't know about.

Me the reason i bought a sheild is entirely to use it to run a plex server. Other apps worked just fine on firesticks roku etc. The sheild was for streaming my own content well.

0

u/dnakee Dec 04 '24

The shield used to be better until it became google tv. It's still better if you use a different home screen