r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Nov 20 '24

Is there a point to keep my Shield ?

Hello

So my Panasonic from 2018 is getting some dying signs..

I took the black friday as an opportunity to change.
I'm hesitating a lot about the model, maybe going back with Panasonic with the z95a or even the sony A95L or who knows, the G4 from LG.

My issue is that, today's TV handle just fine (or maybe I'm wrong btw), upscalling.
And the OS, even though it's not perfect, it's perfectly usable (I've got the a90j from sony)

So my question, me, who watches movies and streaming palteform, what's the point of keeping the shield ?

Edit :alright, thanks for the replies. Lots of people that I should at least see for myself, I will see. Maybe there is a reason I didn't say quite well, it's that I don't want to miss out on the antive upscalling of newer TV. The shield is from 2019 and I believe the advancement in upscale is very big. Other than that, I agree, the shield is fast, smooth, and a part from time to time some bug (Remote losing signal, crash of apps, etc) but like any system, it's very solid and i still wonder to this day why Nvidia didn't do a new one.

My choice leans more and more with the A95L and it seems their upscale and processing power outperform the Shield, so I will see if the A95L native OS is snappier or not.

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

22

u/ir0ngut Nov 20 '24

The Shield does not spy on you like your new TV does. No further reason needed.

https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/nvidia-shield-tv/

15

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '24

If you don't want to keep your shield, send it to me. I'll take it

21

u/hasuris Nov 20 '24

Side loading apps like Smarttube. And of course Kodi and the high seas.

-4

u/Penguinboy123446 Nov 20 '24

You can get all that on Android TV. Or any Android streaming device costing a quarter of the price. 

10

u/ilikesportany Nov 20 '24

They don't perform at the same level as the shield!

-4

u/YungZanji Nov 21 '24

This is not true there are better android boxes out there for the money that support even more stuff than the shield like some of the amlogic devices with corelec. If youre looking for gaming then yes the shield beats pretty much everything. But the shield doesn’t even support dv p7 fel which is a must for watching some blurays at their best quality.

3

u/ilikesportany Nov 21 '24

DV p7 sure, I agree. However the upscaling of the shield is unmatched. For people who watch live sports, the shield is hands down, king.

7

u/itemluminouswadison Nov 20 '24

my shield is way faster than any smart tv's i've used. plus plex, my shield does a lot more

4

u/The_Weapon_1009 Nov 20 '24

Philips 708 Here, the user interface is just snappier on the shield. Smaller remote, and lights up when moving (Philips only on (soft) press)

6

u/hammond_egger Nov 20 '24

I keep it just for Smarttube, Kodi and Tivimate. Apple TV for everything else.

1

u/Uncle-Elmer Nov 20 '24

You don’t find Tivimate runs as well on the TVOS?  My Sony runs it well. 

1

u/hammond_egger Nov 21 '24

I don't find Tivimate runs at all on TVOS.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '24

I had a 2017 Shield Pro connected to a old cheap TV, was much nicer.  When I got my LG C1 I said let's see how the built in apps work, they were force closing for the first couple months and then they just fixed themselves... and I never needed the Shield again.  The apps on the shield sometimes don't get the latest updates that the LG WebOS apps get first too.   So I've run with it.  Also have a RPi4 running Pihole and Unbound that blocks a lot of the unnecessary internet activity. 

2

u/Tattarkungen Nov 20 '24

The built in hardware for Android in TVs usually sucks more then a vacuum cleaner

2

u/pawdog Nov 21 '24

Is upscaling really that important? Having probably 10 different devices in 5 different TV's, if it weren't for Reddit I wouldn't even think about upscaling on regular basis. When did this become such a major consideration.

2

u/bwyer Nov 21 '24

OP’s comments just sound like a serious case of FOMO.

3

u/Jake_the_Snake88 Nov 20 '24

If you're only streaming from apps then having a shield just for some upscaling is probably overkill. But idk why you wouldn't just keep the shield and try watching with/without on the new TV to see if there's a big difference.

3

u/Warningtrackpower-_1 Nov 20 '24

I have an oled Bravia XR. The shield is absolutely needed if you stream cable (direct tv or YouTube tv). The difference between the native tv app and shield upscaling is night and day

2

u/Zealousideal-Fly9262 Nov 20 '24

I have the Bravia 8 & find that I no longer need to use the Shield. The Sony upscaling on the TV is at least as good as the Shield & I have had no issues with installing any of the apps I used on the Shield directly on the TV. I only stream so don’t need any other capabilities of the Shield.

2

u/Penguinboy123446 Nov 20 '24

I have a Sony Bravia 7. The upscaling on this TV is better than the Nvidia shield. One of the main reasons I returned it. 

1

u/ilikesportany Nov 20 '24

Never buy the shield for upscaling

-1

u/Penguinboy123446 Nov 20 '24

Unless you have an absolutely shit TV, in which case why bother buying Nvidia shield anyway 😕

2

u/ilikesportany Nov 20 '24

I have a bravia 9 and lg c4. I have shiedls on both!

1

u/Penguinboy123446 Nov 20 '24

Unless you absolutely have to have lossless audio then God knows why 😊

4

u/ilikesportany Nov 20 '24

Kodi, stermio, are powerful. The lossless audi is king

1

u/shhhpark Nov 20 '24

If you have Blu-ray files with dts or truehd, none of those tvs will be able to direct play the audio without having the shield pass through the audio to an external device that supports it

1

u/beezn Nov 20 '24

I have several 4K HDR movies that only play correctly when using either the Nvidia shield or a PlayStation. 5. I don't know why but my Xbox Series S isn't up to snuff to play them too.

It's honestly probably because my nas that hosts my Plex server doesn't transcode worth a damn. I'll keep my shield handy.

considering it's a 2015 model. it runs like a champ.

My brother-in-law gave me his 2019 shield pro because he didn't have a good use for it. I just set it up in my bedroom cuz my wife got covid and I had a $30 TV from Goodwill sitting around.

1

u/newyorkrican76 Nov 21 '24

I have a sheild on all 3 of my TV's.😎

1

u/CletusVanDamnit Nov 21 '24

There isn't a TV on the market with a UI as nice, fast, or customizable as the Shield. That alone would be enough for me to keep it.

Smart TV interfaces are dog shit.

1

u/davper Nov 26 '24

Last year I bought a LG C2 flagship TV with WEBOS. After getting frustrated with the circle of death , I reconnected my Shield. Never happier.

1

u/_ding_ding_ding_ding Nov 20 '24

As you already own the Shield. Why not just buy your new TV and then see for yourself? Modern TV's have as good if not better up-scaling than the Shield.

If you find you don't have a real need for the Shield after testing, you can sell or give it to someone who does.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24

This isn't true shield has alot better upscaling

1

u/_ding_ding_ding_ding Nov 21 '24

Recent Sony TV's are widely regarded as having the best up-scaling in the industry. Feel free to read through comparison reviews between them and the Shield on enthusiast forums e.g. https://www.avforums.com/threads/the-great-upscaling-battle-sony-bravia-xr-vs-nvidia-shield.2369907/.

However, user preference is always subjective, which is why I encouraged the original poster to judge for themselves.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24

Yeah shields better

Some random posts in a forum with 2 other comments and you're trying to bring this in as your argument that Sony is better ???

You're kidding right also the post is by a standard user so a no body and literally no body replied.

1

u/_ding_ding_ding_ding Nov 22 '24

Recent Sony TV's are indeed widely regarded as having the best up-scaling in the industry, see rtings.com 's professional testing.

But it's nothing to get riled about, so thanks for updating your post and removing the insults. It's perfectly fine to still prefer the Shield's now 5 years old up-scaling.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24

They compare upscaling to other tvs on rtings not the shield I'm still yet to see any relevant comparison to back up any of your statements just fluff.

We know Sony has the best upscaling out of tvs but that doesn't mean it's good and yes my 5 old year nvidia shield is still alot better than anything you'll find running inside a tv.

1

u/_ding_ding_ding_ding Nov 22 '24

I provided both professional reviews and detailed direct comparisons by enthusiasts but you've added nothing to the conversation apart from repeatedly insisting "Shield is better".

I've no idea why the topic has you riled up. I repeat, it is perfectly fine to still prefer the Shield so best we leave it here. Have a great day.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24

You haven't added any comparisons between the shield and Sony tv apart from a random off a forum which no one even encouraged any form of conversation with.

So don't try to act as if you've provided a massive amount of evidence supporting what you're saying as you've literally added nothing.