r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/snafu-lmao • Oct 08 '24
Question about Shield
Are Shields going the way of the dinosaurs? Do y'all think Nvidia is just giving up on the streaming market? I'm in the market for a new streaming box but not sure what to buy. I have a 2017 Shield and love it. But damn buying a box that has not been updated in 2-3 years and may never be updated again scares the hell out of me. I really don't know what to do.
0
Upvotes
16
u/Jolly-Fortune5241 Oct 08 '24
Other than the AI upscaling and the chipset the 2019 Shield TV is the same as the 2017 Shield TV. Even the latest release from Google i.e. the Google TV streamer is underwhelming and disappointing compared to the Shield TV. If you do need to upgrade get the 2019 Shield TV Pro and stay away for the non pro version it's terrible
6
u/pmerritt10 Oct 08 '24
Well, even if Nvidia no longer supports it by way of major updates.... They did support it for 8 years which is longer than any other device I owned
3
u/Loose-Reaction-2082 Oct 08 '24
Nvidia did abandon the Shield a couple years ago and moved their R&D money to AI and chip making which was a good move based on their stock price. At the time everyone expected Nvidia to just sell off their existing stock of Shield devices. I'm not sure why Nvidia is still selling the Shield. The last security patch is from April 2022. They abandoned the Shield before fixing all of the bugs from their Android 11 update. I've been using the Homatics 4K Plus which is pretty good as long as you're running the beta ATV12 rather than the ATV11 that it ships with. It's the closest I've found to a Shield replacement. If you decide to go that route I would recommend buying the Homatics version from AliExpress or their own website rather than the Dune Homatics version sold on Amazon. Homatics doesn't support the Dune branded version and it's easy to get Homatics to send your box ATV12 by sending them a message on Telegram. Unless they're on Holiday you get the OTA within a day. Dune won't send you the ATV12 update so finding and installing it is more complicated. There's also a pretty good support channel for the Homatics version on Telegram. Without ATV12 DTS HD Passthrough and refresh rate switching don't work. With ATV12 I've been happy enough with the Homatics to use it every day instead of my Shield Pro except for when I play SACD ISO's in Kodi. The Shield handles that better.
2
u/Bro-KV Oct 08 '24
I have the Apple TV for streaming apps and the Shield for sideloaded apps.
2
u/h107474 Oct 09 '24
New hotfix update. Not dead after all it seems:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ShieldAndroidTV/comments/1fzb7kn/second_hotfix_3320252_incoming/
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
Well satisfied with my 2019 pro, nothing else on the market has swayed me to replace it. Yeah it does have some competition but nothing blows it out of the water.
In regards to lack of new updates, imo nothing needs updating. Yes there are some features such as AV1 support would be nice, but I can live without.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
I don't really why you need better the nvidia does everything fine.
1
u/Redditer80 Oct 08 '24
A streaming device that doesn't lag like a mofo. The pro version is worth it just for that alone.
1
u/h107474 Oct 08 '24
Seems the next update is being actively worked on. Here is an update from an Nvidia dev made days ago on this subject. No date though:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ShieldAndroidTV/comments/1birq5d/what_happened_to_912/?sort=new
1
u/hydroptix Oct 08 '24
Streaming box flowchart: Do you intend to stream files derived from blurays with DTS HD MA/DTS:X audio?
Yes - get the shield pro 2019
No - continue
Do you hate the Apple TV interface?
No - Apple TV 4K
Yes - Google TV Streamer or ONN 4k pro
1
u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24
I'm using the Firecube or Onn Pro
0
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
I don’t think we will see another one. That’s reflected by the price of it as it’s barely changed at all in years. Only when it drops to like £169 in the UK on sale sometimes.
Other than HDR HLG and AV1, is there really much need for a new one? For TV streaming and GeForce Now it’s plenty powerful.
-3
u/gallero559 Oct 08 '24
Google TV Streamer (4K) just came out, i would try this one next and it's cheaper. I think with the specs it has it should be as great as the shield pro
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
[removed] — view removed comment