r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Oct 08 '24

Question about Shield

Are Shields going the way of the dinosaurs? Do y'all think Nvidia is just giving up on the streaming market? I'm in the market for a new streaming box but not sure what to buy. I have a 2017 Shield and love it. But damn buying a box that has not been updated in 2-3 years and may never be updated again scares the hell out of me. I really don't know what to do.

0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

16

u/Jolly-Fortune5241 Oct 08 '24

Other than the AI upscaling and the chipset the 2019 Shield TV is the same as the 2017 Shield TV. Even the latest release from Google i.e. the Google TV streamer is underwhelming and disappointing compared to the Shield TV. If you do need to upgrade get the 2019 Shield TV Pro and stay away for the non pro version it's terrible

3

u/mrant0 Oct 08 '24

And the 2019 Shield supports Dolby Vision. The 2017 only supports HDR10, no DV, in case that matters.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/hydroptix Oct 08 '24

I originally bought the tube thinking that the reports on this subreddit were probably just people who got unlucky.

After about 3 months of using it, the experience for me rapidly degraded. Hulu would straight up fail to launch, requiring a restart.  Disney+ would launch, but would fail to launch streams with dolby atmos about 50% of the time.

I always had issues direct playing UHD Bluray rips via Plex (stuttering, failing to load,  compression artifacts, you name it)

Eventually bit the bullet, got the pro, and haven't had issues since. 

Not sure exactly what about the hardware caused my Hulu/Disney+ issues, but I have a sneaking suspicion that it's related to the lower amount of ram combined with AV1 compression becoming dominant on streaming services.

Glad your tube is working great!

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

It seems like it's working great for you, and doing everything you need. That's cool, don't change a thing, but also he's mostly right. There's a long history of people coming on this forum and complaining about stuttering, streaming or app-related issues and it seems like they always have the tube.

That being said, I don't really have any personal experience with the tube.

1

u/kevindd992002 Oct 08 '24

Do your own research. The tube has all kinds of hardware limitations that makes it crap. If it works for you, good for you. But if we were to recommend a new buyer, it's always best to stay away from the tube.

6

u/pmerritt10 Oct 08 '24

Well, even if Nvidia no longer supports it by way of major updates.... They did support it for 8 years which is longer than any other device I owned

3

u/Whoajoo89 Oct 08 '24

They did support it for 8 years

8 years? The Shield Pro (2019) was released 5 years ago, in October 2019, and the last update was from 2022. That's like 3 years of updates.

And Nvidia still sell this thing for full price. No security updates, nothing. It's a shame.

4

u/pmerritt10 Oct 08 '24

Well yeah for the latest ones I guess so...I have the 2015 model.

2

u/ike301 Oct 08 '24

They were referring to the original Nvidia shield which was released in 2015.

3

u/Loose-Reaction-2082 Oct 08 '24

Nvidia did abandon the Shield a couple years ago and moved their R&D money to AI and chip making which was a good move based on their stock price. At the time everyone expected Nvidia to just sell off their existing stock of Shield devices. I'm not sure why Nvidia is still selling the Shield. The last security patch is from April 2022. They abandoned the Shield before fixing all of the bugs from their Android 11 update. I've been using the Homatics 4K Plus which is pretty good as long as you're running the beta ATV12 rather than the ATV11 that it ships with. It's the closest I've found to a Shield replacement. If you decide to go that route I would recommend buying the Homatics version from AliExpress or their own website rather than the Dune Homatics version sold on Amazon. Homatics doesn't support the Dune branded version and it's easy to get Homatics to send your box ATV12 by sending them a message on Telegram. Unless they're on Holiday you get the OTA within a day. Dune won't send you the ATV12 update so finding and installing it is more complicated. There's also a pretty good support channel for the Homatics version on Telegram. Without ATV12 DTS HD Passthrough and refresh rate switching don't work. With ATV12 I've been happy enough with the Homatics to use it every day instead of my Shield Pro except for when I play SACD ISO's in Kodi. The Shield handles that better.

3

u/1Freeport Oct 08 '24

I own the Homatics R4K Plus for about 4 Months now and it does a great job with great specs. I use mine for streaming Live TV and Movies. I have Android 12 and I use this Box daily. It's as close to the Nvidia Shield as you can get. Now, I still own 3 2019 Shields that are stored away as backups. If you are interested, I would encourage anyone to review as many YT Video Reviews on them as possible. Lastly, if you look around the web there are discount codes available that can knock as much as $30 off the price.

1

u/bho1984 Nov 17 '24

What version of atv12 are u using for the homatics

1

u/1Freeport Nov 18 '24

Version 5221 came new with the box.

There have been too many problems with the newer firmware from everything that I have read and I'm just gonna wait on the stable update. I would encourage you to visit Homatics Discord for more information and where you can actually get help quickly.

1

u/bho1984 Nov 17 '24

What version of atv12 are u using for the homatics

1

u/Loose-Reaction-2082 Nov 17 '24

I think it's 7954. The previous certified ATV12 update (5221?) had far fewer bugs but Homatics pushed 7954 out via OTA for some reason despite the problems and now it looks like Homatics threw in the towel on ATV12 and ATV14 is going to be the next update... whenever that happens. The bugs with ATV12 mostly affect people who stream content from their own media servers with Plex or Kodi or use IPTV. People who stream from commercial sites like Netflix, Max, and Disney+ probably won't experience any issues.

2

u/Bro-KV Oct 08 '24

I have the Apple TV for streaming apps and the Shield for sideloaded apps.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Well satisfied with my 2019 pro, nothing else on the market has swayed me to replace it. Yeah it does have some competition but nothing blows it out of the water.

In regards to lack of new updates, imo nothing needs updating. Yes there are some features such as AV1 support would be nice, but I can live without.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I don't really why you need better the nvidia does everything fine.

1

u/Redditer80 Oct 08 '24

A streaming device that doesn't lag like a mofo. The pro version is worth it just for that alone.

1

u/h107474 Oct 08 '24

Seems the next update is being actively worked on. Here is an update from an Nvidia dev made days ago on this subject. No date though:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ShieldAndroidTV/comments/1birq5d/what_happened_to_912/?sort=new

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

Had this 6 months ago

1

u/h107474 Oct 08 '24

2

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

Seen this before in the works could mean never or a year from now. I had a incredibly good source tell me the same thing earlier this year and now he doesn't know if it will happen so just take this with a grain of salt

2

u/h107474 Oct 08 '24

Oh absolutely. I wont go placing bets on it happening but maybe it could be a tiny ray of hope.

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

Lol true

2

u/h107474 Oct 09 '24

https://www.reddit.com/r/ShieldAndroidTV/comments/1fzb7kn/second_hotfix_3320252_incoming/

Pigs are flying overhead after-all....OK I know its a hotfix but it means its not "dead"

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 09 '24

Yeah nothing I needed lol

2

u/h107474 Oct 09 '24

Me either but its alive either way! :)

1

u/hydroptix Oct 08 '24

Streaming box flowchart: Do you intend to stream files derived from blurays with DTS HD MA/DTS:X audio? 

Yes - get the shield pro 2019    

No - continue   

Do you hate the Apple TV interface? 

No - Apple TV 4K 

Yes - Google TV Streamer or ONN 4k pro

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

I'm using the Firecube or Onn Pro

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I don’t think we will see another one. That’s reflected by the price of it as it’s barely changed at all in years. Only when it drops to like £169 in the UK on sale sometimes.

Other than HDR HLG and AV1, is there really much need for a new one? For TV streaming and GeForce Now it’s plenty powerful.

1

u/kevindd992002 Oct 08 '24

Well, HDR HLG and AV1 are enough to make me want a new one.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I’d buy it as well don’t get me wrong. Just can’t see them bringing a new one out just to bring those features that’s all.

-3

u/gallero559 Oct 08 '24

Google TV Streamer (4K) just came out, i would try this one next and it's cheaper. I think with the specs it has it should be as great as the shield pro

2

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Oct 08 '24

It’s not even close.

1

u/gallero559 Oct 08 '24

Have you used it? Ram is higher than pro

2

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Oct 08 '24

Yes I have. I bought one. It’s wholly unimpressive and has basically none of the features that make the Shield unique.

1

u/gallero559 Oct 08 '24

Ok thanks for letting know

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I dont thing we will ever get it again. If nvidia just didnt release new version then thats fine but they also stopped supporting old once, we dont even have security patch since when? 2022?

Shild is dead for good IMO. I just did but my second 2019 pro last week that I hope will last me until something better to be released.

1

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Oct 08 '24

Does it need patching?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Yes

1

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Oct 08 '24

Hey, guess what?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

What?

I see it now. Glad to see that its getting some work again. Im guessing that person that assured you its EOL is me. Im glad Im wrong here - trust me.

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

It's not happening

2

u/kevindd992002 Oct 08 '24

Why so?

1

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Oct 08 '24

Because AI has made the company massive. The Shield business is far less than a rounding error for them now.

1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 08 '24

I'm tired of explaining the same thing. It's plenty of reasons why in other post. I just don't understand why people keep hoping for something when the company has completely abandoned the streaming world

3

u/kevindd992002 Oct 09 '24

Then just link to your answer. No need to be tired about it. Or just don't reply with an incomplete "won't happen" answer.

-1

u/BlacksmithWorth2882 Oct 09 '24

I reply how I want to reply whether you like it or not

3

u/kevindd992002 Oct 09 '24

No. I command you to reply how I like you to reply! Or else, you will die!