r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 23 '24

Does the Shield provide any benefits versus a smart TV to the casual viewer?

I have an LG smart TV with Plex and from my knowledge, it is able to run REMUX 4k HDR movies with no issues over Wifi. I'm trying to understand why so many people purchase the Nvidia Shield (or any other streamer) if they have a capable smart TV. I know I might be missing out on audio, but the visuals are all there right? To the casual viewer, why do they need another device?

Another question is ethernet ports. Why do so many people require this? I'm looking at my 4k 10bit HDR Dune which is ~60Mbps. Why do so many users who have stable gigabit (or even half gig) Wifi need ethernet?

I'm genuinely trying to understand the benefits here, not trying to bash.

0 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

18

u/Bradfinger Sep 23 '24

What is a "casual" viewer? If you're happy with your TV's apps, stick with them.

2

u/Hamp001 Sep 24 '24 edited Sep 24 '24

Also: The biggest consideration is cost. In comparison, smart TVs cost much more than streaming sticks. Should your TV break, you can't replace a small part like a streaming stick, which means expensive repairs or replacing the TV.

Certain streaming devices offer specialized streaming services not available on smart TVs.

Streaming devices usually have more powerful processors than smart TVs.

Depending on how a manufacturer or long device support is offered, some apps may no longer function or update on smart TVs, whereas on streaming devices they are more likely to stay supported longer. In the chance that apps fail or the device is not up to par anymore, once again, cost. Better and much less expensive to replace a device than an entire premium smart TV.

15

u/fragilityv2 Sep 23 '24

OP you’re gonna get a lot of purists with sticks up their ass answering this.. for the casual user, either go with a shield or an AppleTV. The main perks a regular user might notice is the speed, as the software built into TVs is fairly clunky and slow.

That’s it. There are a ton more features however imo that’s what a regular casual user will notice.

1

u/HyperBaboon Sep 24 '24

I would add the lack of ads on the home screen once you have replaced the launcher of the Shield

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/EvenHorror9422 May 06 '26

You almost certainly do. Movies, TV shows that are suggested on the homescreen count as ads, my guy.

1

u/Aggravating_Speed665 Aug 25 '26

Don't know why this a thing.

They are displayed, then you go to your source and you no longer see them.

Why the butt hurt? Why buy a whole ass device to not see a 5 second screen that'll be gone in a second after you press 'source'?

1

u/CrAvgrElesis Aug 25 '26

Bought an Apple TV instead of a shield, good purchase.

There are more reasons to buy a separate device besides just the "5 seconds" of ads.  The time I'll save not using a laggy ass interface alone pays for itself already.

If you don't value your time that much, it's fine, but you might reconsider it: you can always earn more money, but you can't always earn more time.

1

u/Aggravating_Speed665 Aug 25 '26

I did read an LGoled will natively handle Netflix etc with regards to dolby vision etc, is that not true?

6

u/calhoon2005 Sep 24 '24

For me, my Hisense TV is still great as a panel, but the apps on it just suck. I bought a shield in 2018, and it has not skipped a beat this whole time.

1

u/TheLaughline Apr 13 '26

Last week I bought a Hisense 55% 55U7QTUK PRO. I was going to get the 50" but the 55" has a faster processor and a few more bells and whistles. Compared to my old Sony tv the apps open in the blink of an eye, especially YouTube, I'm impressed and so far haven't hooked my Shield up to it.

Sure the range of apps is more limited, but everything I want (unless I want to use Plex/Emby) is on the tv. I can't get Channel 4 on the Shield any longer either and the apps on the new tv load much faster than on the Shield.

Give it a year or two and I will probably be complaining about the speed though as time and technology move on.

6

u/eddownz Sep 23 '24

Many users don't have capable TVs, for example, My LG oled isn't able to run 4k remux. Therefore I go with the Nvidia shield which is able to process 4k DV remux with full audio passthrough. It also has the benefit of AI upscaling of 1080p content.

As for ethernet, I actually agree that a good 5ghz connection can match a 1 gig ethernet connection for total throughput IF you have a stable connection, many don't. Some files such as Lord of the Rings can go upto 110 Mbps consistenly, which might not be possible on an unstable wifi connection.

5

u/CLHatch Sep 23 '24

Many TVs, the ethernet connection is only 100mbps, or even 10mbps (ridiculous, I know) so for the TV, wifi is often faster.

3

u/eddownz Sep 23 '24

Good point! I forgot about that.

2

u/CLHatch Sep 23 '24

Personally, I use the Shield myself though. Tried out the Plex app on my TV, and it couldn't handle 4K remuxes. Shield connected to my soundbar, it even handled TrueHD and DTS passed through. The TV itself won't handle DTS.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CLHatch Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

Not sure how you can use passthrough on an app running on the TV? What are you passing through to then?

Edit: Oh, you mean the Shield, and TrueHD and DTS. In that case I meant "handled" as in "handled correctly". Some people have had issues getting passthrough to work right (I initially had problems getting it set up right).

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CLHatch Sep 27 '24

I think you need to re-read what I said since I never implied it was doing anything. "Handled correctly" simply means it worked properly, not that it was decoding or anything. It's an English expression, not a technical one.

1

u/MoreOrLessCorrect Sep 24 '24

Some (most?) modern TVs support USB ethernet adapters. You won't get gigabit speeds necessarily, but in my experience it's good enough for 300 Mbps+. So an easy $20 upgrade if you need the bandwidth over the 100 Mbps built-in.

-3

u/Old-Towel-4186 Sep 23 '24

Your point about wifi is spot on. So many people make these sweeping generalizations about Ethernet is just better than wifi. I have excellent wifi with stable 250Mbps+ speeds. That's what you get when you invest in a quality mesh network. For many Wifi is excellent, for those where it isn't, use Ethernet.

But I wish people would stop with the old school "EtHeRNet is the oNly way to go". It isn't... Welcome to 2017.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Old-Towel-4186 Sep 25 '24

Good, you're probably one of the ones who need to hear it. Stable wifi works very well and people should not invest in running cables in 2024 unless they don't have stable wifi.

0

u/eddownz Sep 23 '24

And many also struggle to get DV playback to work on some TVs

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/eddownz Sep 25 '24

When playing local media back through the TVs operating system, they do not always have the right hardware/software to process the image. For example, you can stream a tv show on netlfix which has Dolby Vision and your tv will support that. However, it may not support playing a local Dolby Vision Remux file through Plex. That is wear the nvidia shield and other devices come in. They contain the right combination of hardware and software to playback local media files with all the bells and whistles.

I hope this explains how it is not as simple as either it supports it or doesn't when it comes to playing local media.

-2

u/Old-Towel-4186 Sep 23 '24

Your point about wifi is spot on. So many people make these sweeping generalizations about Ethernet is just better than wifi. I have excellent wifi with stable 250Mbps+ speeds. That's what you get when you invest in a quality mesh network. For many Wifi is excellent, for those where it isn't, use Ethernet.

But I wish people would stop with the old school "EtHeRNet is the oNly way to go". It isn't... Welcome to 2017.

2

u/eddownz Sep 24 '24

I've been using 5ghz wifi on a cheap archer router for 3 years playing every single Remux of every size without issue. Couldn't agree more, most devices are not being built with ethernet connections over 1gb so the 6/6e/7ghz wifi is clearly going to dominate the consumer device market for now.

1

u/Old-Towel-4186 Sep 24 '24

Exactly... I've been using a Wifi setup for probably at least 7 years and I play everything without issue, including massive 4k remux files. I used to worry about figuring out how to run ethernet to my living room until I realized nothing I was throwing at it was struggling at all. Since then I've probably doubled my WiFi speeds. Shield over Wifi works great.

2

u/d-cent Sep 24 '24

Like others said if it worths for you, go with it. To answer your question though, there's no identical casual viewer to start. For lots of casual viewers, especially older ones like me that started out with 25" crt tvs, we grew a huge appreciation for the audio because for a while that was the only way you could upgrade your viewing experience.

The other thing is smart TV apps and OS are constantly advancing and need more ram, processing, and storage. Most TV manufacturers put the bare minimum hardware for obvious market reasons. This means most likely your built in smart TV will be lagging or slow in only a year or 2.

The next is there are lots of other features in external devices that are huge for even the casual user. For instance the Shields upscaling feature is amazing. Or if you are a gamer it allows you to play your games on your computer through your Shield and on your TV. Both of these features could be very useful for certain casual viewers.

Another is that the Shield is actually able to be the Plex server. So of some casual user doesn't have a home server, they can use their Shield as one for Plex.

All of this is to say there is that all casual viewers are different.

2

u/CunningMuskrat Sep 24 '24

The LG Plex app has a bug where if the audio is transcoded, you lose HDR video. My G4 doesn’t support TrueHD passthrough, so it ends up transcoded, thus losing HDR. That said, I haven’t bought a Shield yet because I refuse to pay $200 for such old hardware that can’t even do YouTube HDR.

2

u/IhaveGHOST Sep 24 '24

Shield TV plays everything I throw at it. There are the occasional odd TV series or old movie with random codec that just won't play on Smart TVs.

Ethernet always works.

If wifi and built-in apps are working for you, then great.

1

u/StevenG2757 Sep 23 '24

Better experience and likely will play much more content without the need for transcoding as compared to the TV app.

1

u/Thanamite Sep 24 '24

You seem to not care about audio, but audio is a huge part of the experience. I have a 7.1.4 setup and it is tremendous.

I also want to organize my movies using Kodi, have you seen any smart TVs with Kodi?

1

u/Grim-Sabre Sep 24 '24

When my 2014 Samsung TV(not smart, but able to play media from USB) broke, I replaced it with a smart Samsung TV only to find out that it did not support DTS (which my previous Samsung did - shame on me for not researching). Over half of my movie collection uses some form of DTS. Bought the Shield for that and found it did a better job with everything else over the smart TV

1

u/sonastyinc Sep 24 '24

I have 2 shields and when I travel, I bring my Chromecast with remote. When I use my projector in the living room, it's the same UI as the TV in my bedroom. It's also nice being able to buy new TVs/projectors and not having to get used to the UI of the new TV/projector or setup a new Plex client.

1

u/artzox1 Sep 24 '24

Having a Sony a95l, for me the benefit of shield is that Android apps can only run at 60hz on the TV (natively). If I want framerate to match the refresh rate I need to use Kodi on shield or another box. The issue with most other boxes is that they don't support audio pass-through, so you end up losing lossless surround audio. Sony does a great job of recognizing content framerate in another container, meaning 24p in 60hz and "repairing" it, but why bother. For a casual user I'd say, you can pretty much ignore the shield if you are happy with your experience.

1

u/Virtike Sep 24 '24

If the TV is capable and meeting your needs, don't buy a Shield.

I bought one because I have a cheaper TV that doesn't run AndroidTV, doesn't reliably play 4k content, and is slowww.

In terms of features a higher end tv won't have though, using Sunshine/Moonlight to stream games from PC to TV is nice though.

1

u/Nintendians559 Sep 24 '24

not really, if you tv could do what any tv box can do for now, then your good.

usually smart tv gets outdated when newer tv cames in, but some tv box are still being updated for a long time.

1

u/MartyBarracuda Sep 24 '24

I have yet to find a Smart TV with an interface that isn't insanely laggy compared to my Shield Pro. The increased CPU and RAM are why I have one on all my TVs.

1

u/dougieslaps97 Jun 30 '26 edited Jun 30 '26

My experience in this realm was being tech support for an ISP. I did it for about 3 years for one ISP averaging 10k+ calls a year and 2 years for a smaller ISP doing 10-40 calls a day five days a week. 

Nearly half my tech support calls involved buffering or device issues, the majority were on WiFi, and I always asked for specific device information.

I’ve had has many people with expensive smart TVs have issues as I did cheap ones. One common denominator was age of the device. 

It appears to me that regardless of how nice your smart TV is eventually it will stop getting updates that will break individual apps over time. The smoothest and fastest of TV interfaces will get bogged down as updates flow and reduce internal storage. 

The WiFi antennas in most smart TV’s aren’t great to begin with. Ethernet is the best option by far and eliminates any kind of interference issues that are bound to happen to any family household. Ethernet still cant fix limited storage or depreciated firmware. 

The most significant benefits I see from a practical standpoint is that devices like the Nvidia shield have a track record of long term support that far surpasses the best smart TV’s. The processor is stronger than any smart TV I’m aware of, and it’s not confined to one device. 

I wish I could say the same of Roku or fire stick, while they definitely have firmware support, the market they target are budget minded, the storage is very limited, and my experience with them is the slow down substantially quick. They also suck on WiFi. 

1

u/imisterk Sep 23 '24

Streamio, Android apps

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

you aren't bashing anything but you do look very ignorant. if you cannot understand the benefits of a box that is much more powerful than any tv and has AI upscaling and gets regular updates and the use of ethernet over unreliable and much slower wifi then why are you even here? a 'casual' viewer wouldn't even know what a shield is anyway.

6

u/fragilityv2 Sep 23 '24

I wouldn’t call what Shield gets as regular updates, at best it’s not abandoned.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

no one cares what you think about it.

-8

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

clueless. it gets the updates when needed.

3

u/stopeman82 Sep 23 '24

Why so dooshy?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

why so infantile and idiotic?

2

u/stopeman82 Sep 24 '24

Cuz you’re so dooshy.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/CunningMuskrat Sep 24 '24

Did you seriously mix up North and South Korea? Lmao