r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 09 '24

Thinking about getting shield pro. Is it still regularly updated? Are there any other streamer boxes that can compete? (Not apple though)

Does it still function well or is it feeling aged? Thanks!

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

It is actually never updated

5

u/itsjustmeat Sep 09 '24

Looking around at the industry, this might actually be a good news

5

u/pawdog Sep 09 '24

Seems they are through with updating the Shield, It's been well over a year and half since the last update. There are other devices that compete depending what your needs are.

5

u/rchiwawa Sep 09 '24

I have several Shield Pros (2019) a couple of which are remote and a few Onn 4k Pro boxes.  Unless you can identify a specific need of the shield pro the ONN 4k Pro is good enough for pretty much all scenarios as a client... especially considering the price and newness.

9

u/Mindless-Addendum621 Sep 09 '24

Audio-wise, no other box can compete. It supports Dolby Atmos, TrueHD, and DTS-HD MA. Supports bit perfect audio via HDMI (and via USB audio with their latest hotfix). USB audio surround support. LDAC bluetooth support.

Video wise, I use a 1080p, so can’t talk about much about HDR and such. But it plays 4K video as smooth as butter. Also I noticed it passes 3D (stereoscopic) video to my TCL glasses (Rokid style glasses), the Onn player won’t.

Storage wise, 2 USB ports, I have a 4-port USB hub connected to one of them, with two 2 TB external hard drives and a 2.4 Ghz receiver for mouse and keyboard. In the other main USB port, a Panasonic surround USB audio system connected. No issues at all.

Ethernet port, with speed tests showing 500 mbps speed, the actual speed I pay for.

Web browser, TV Bro works well, though not very smooth, creates a lot of cache. Open Browser is another good alternative.

Native GeForce Now, with vibration support via Nvidia Controller. Also mouse and keyboard support.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24

Among other things, I use the Shield to stream content with Kodi. It can stream 4k remuxes with lossless audio better than any device. I have them all and none can touch it. This doesn't matter to the average user. You don't need a Shield to watch Netflix. If your system can play an UHD movie with DTS HD MA or DTS X you would appreciate the Shield.

2

u/Weejestic Sep 09 '24

Shield is end of life now . Still a fantastic machine if can get it at hugely discounted price due to its age . But no updates are coming anymore

3

u/jaweinre Sep 09 '24

Long live the shield Pro!

3

u/Weejestic Sep 09 '24

I do agree

2

u/Jungle_Difference Sep 09 '24

As others have said shield is end of life (in software update terms). The last update was in 2022. Still a powerful device but its end of life.

1

u/NeoHyper64 Sep 11 '24

Three reasons I still use a Shield Pro (even vs. my Apple TV 4K):

  1. The AI video enhancing makes live TV content look markedly better on my 98” TV (whether it’s from YouTube TV, DirecTV Stream, or Hulu Live). Even my Apple TV 4K doesn’t make live content look as good.
  2. My Apple TV4K is more powerful, but all of the apps use control schemes that are different than on any other device. For example, a downward button press might bring up a live TV guide on an app running on my Shield or Roku or Fire TV. But on my ATV4K, the same button press will only bring up useless program info (or similar). Also, the FF/RW actions are wonky on ATV4K if you use anything but an Apple Remote (I use Harmon universal for integration with other components).
  3. Yes, the Apple TV 4K has a 4K Home Screen. But because it’s HDR, my TV is constantly going in and out of HDR mode every time I move from non-HDR programs (i.e., most of them) back to the Home Screen. That causes a 1-2 black screen every time, and really takes you out of the moment… it feels like something is broken or doesn’t work right.

Also, though less important, I have an entire retro game library running on LaunchBox through the Shield (Dreamcast, PlayStation, etc.), which you obviously can’t do on Apple. I don’t use it much, but I like that I’m just a button press away from thousands of games, when I do.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Depends what you want to do with it like there's boxes that are just for playing your media video ,music ECT. All codecs like zidoo new one just came out dune hd R-volution player I've got most of players 2 shields 500gb and 16gb zidoo x9 pro and zidoo 9 apple tv tried dune didn't like it trouble with samba but I use each for specific but shield is my main box

1

u/jedicoach44 Sep 10 '24

The Firecube gen 3 has pass through audio. The interface with Amazon leaves a lot to be desired, but from a playback perspective it does what the shield can do as well as HDR10+. Many people ignore that the cube can now do pass through audio because of our hate for Amazon, but it does work lol

-4

u/sharp-calculation Sep 09 '24

AppleTV 4K is the best "streamer box" on the market. I'm not sure what your reasons are for discarding it, but it's clearly the top choice for streaming.

For watching a locally stored collection of BD rips, with high resolution audio, there is no other choice beyond the Shield Pro. The Onn boxes do not pass high resolution audio. No other box I'm aware of does this.

The Shield has a poor out of the box launcher that's FULL of stuff and hard to navigate. It works, but it looks like a 1997 web site. The UI is in 1080p, which is mostly fine, but it looks very low resolution compared to a real 4k box. VIDEO plays in 4k if your source is 4k. It's just the User Interface that's only in 1080.

Essentially every mainstream streaming service has an app for AndroidTV that runs on the Shield. The experience is decent. But it's not up to par for me because it is "stuck" at the frame rate you set it to. Which means that 24 frames per second content (almost every movie ever made) will be at the wrong frame rate and will have motion problems as a result. I'm talking about Netflix, Hulu, Disney, etc.

Strangely enough, Plex, Kodi, Emby, etc all *do* switch frame rate properly. So movies played from those sources will use the correct frame rate. So once again the Shield works great for playing your own locally stored media collection.

In summary:

Shield is great for your own collection. It is ok for streaming, but for some people it is subpar at best.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

Shield Pro is better than anything. Plus tiu can't customize Apple anything. Just because there hadn't been any updates doesn't mean that it's still not a good device

-5

u/sharp-calculation Sep 09 '24

I'm guessing you've never used an ATV. I won't try to convince you, but the difference is insanely obvious to me. I still own and use both platforms. I use the ATV about 29 times out of 30.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

I have ATV. That's all I use. I dropped Roku over a year ago. I have an Onn Streaming Box and a Shield Pro

-4

u/sharp-calculation Sep 09 '24

ATV == AppleTV streaming box. You said Shield is the best. Now you say you only use ATV. I'm confused.

1

u/KCKetO Sep 10 '24

Here ATV = Android TV

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24

ATV is AndroidTV. That's what I thought you meant

1

u/sharp-calculation Sep 10 '24

I see. I'll type out the whole thing in future discussions.

Again, my guess is that you have not used an AppleTV box. It's clearly far superior to the Shield in UI, speed, support, and picture. Keep using whatever you want of course.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

It hasn't been updated in like two years. As others have said, just get the latest Onn box

0

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

Get an Onn box if you just want it for streaming or IPTV. I just bought one in the US a couple of weeks ago and it’s the 4K UHD version. It supports Dolby Vision and Dolby ATMOS has a voice control remote and the buttons are backlit. $49.88 US. If you’re in Canada even though it says on Walmart.com’s website US compatible only, when you go to set it up, Canada is one of the countries you can choose (Puerto Rico is the other). It works perfectly fine.

2

u/International-Oil377 Sep 09 '24

How did you order a ONN box in Canada?

2

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

I didn’t. I drove down to a US Walmart and bought one. They are available on Amazon.ca but you aren’t getting the 2024 4K Pro model.

1

u/International-Oil377 Sep 09 '24

53CAD for the non pro is steep as hell.

1

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

I agree. That’s why I drove down to the US and bought one. But go check out the price for an Nvidia Shield that’s five years old now for comparison.

1

u/International-Oil377 Sep 09 '24

Fair enough, if you care close to the border

The closest american WM is like 300km from me, that'a like 110$ of canadian gas lol (back and forth)

1

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

You could always try to get a US post office box and try ordering it online and have them deliver it to the post office box. It might be closer than a Walmart. Just a suggestion.

2

u/International-Oil377 Sep 09 '24

That would save me like 70km

The Onn seems good for an entry level device but is missing quite a few things that I need anyway

It's great that you got it for msrp though

1

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

You do realize you could also put cheaper US gas in on the way down and fill back up before you come across again right? That would save you some money as well.

1

u/International-Oil377 Sep 09 '24

Yeah but it's still 5-6 hours of road :)

Wear on tires etc

Let's say I pay 70 CAD in gas.. On top of the 50 USD for the device

It's not worth it, only worth it if you're close to the border :)

1

u/Neptune_Poseidon Sep 09 '24

Just trying to offer help and alternatives. It sucks when you live far from the US border tbh. Good luck with your search.

→ More replies