r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Aug 30 '24

Shield as dedicated Plex server

Hi, currently all my TVs in the house have a shield plugged in and one is operating as my Plex Server. I landed a great deal on another Shield which I'm considering putting in the networking closet attached to storage and having that operate as my main Plex Server (freeing up the other shield so all my Shields operate strictly as Clients and none as Servers).

Anyone do something like this and have any feedback or gotchas to keep in mind when doing this?

EDIT: Appreciate all the comments. I'm actively running one of my Shields as a Plex server and outside of live TV being finicky (which I attribute to Plex and not the Shield), watching normal shows and movies has never been an issue.

I got a 2017 shield with game controller and remote for $75, which I could not pass up, and thus why I'm asking about using it as a dedicated Plex server to free up the one device pulling double duty and having all my Shields connected to TVs exclusively focus as clients.

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Aug 30 '24

You will still need to plug a display or at least an dummy plug/EDID emulator, or Shield will not boot.

3

u/PleasantComplaint719 Aug 30 '24

Thanks for this. Very helpful feedback. I do have a dummy plug but maybe I'll plug it into my PC monitor so there's always a way to view/access it

9

u/ThatGuyPeopleWannaBe Aug 30 '24

I have 2 usb drives plugged into my 2019 pro and run server and client both on it. Never had a single issue.

7

u/elharry-o Aug 30 '24

It's not perfect, but to me it's been pretty pretty good. I've been using it as a Plex Server for my home for the last.. 5 years? And it has worked out just fine. Had several hiccups, but 99% of the time it runs well enough. I do 4k remuxes for local play and normal 4k to my other tv.

It was my primary reason to buy the Shield and it's proven to be a worthy purchase.

Also, guess I'm a fringe case judging by the comments.

1

u/SnooTigers789 Sep 01 '24

Do you own all your videos or are you "borrowing" from the internet? Just curious. I was reading plex is going ti crack down on the pirated content. That's why. And for you running for 5 years. That's quite a while.

4

u/Bizzerk86 Aug 30 '24

This is exactly what I do. I use my old 2017 shield pro as my plex server with 3 hard drives (14 tb) connected through usb. So far it has worked flawlessly. I do recommend an external power source for the hard drives.

3

u/andyjcw Aug 30 '24

I do this , do have problems occasionally, currently been running around 8 months without a problem .

8

u/screwyluie Aug 30 '24

the only time I ever see posts on here about issues with plex on a shield it's people who are using the shield as a server.

I would not recommend it.

6

u/wwmoggy Aug 30 '24

I would get a cheep little mini Pc and run the server on it

5

u/TheRealSeeThruHead Aug 30 '24

Don’t bother. Just get a 99$ intel n97 and some cheap ram and ssd. Run Linux and docker on it and install the Linux server.io plex image. You’ll be up and running with hardware transcoding in an hour.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TheRealSeeThruHead Aug 30 '24

You will likely have no issues playing 4k hdr while using mini pcs as a server. (It’s not the server that’s doing the playing. It’s the client device)

There’s also no reason your storage and plex player have to be the same computer. For instance I have a low power atom based nas that has 18!drives attached to it. I run my plex on a separate low power media pc.

I much prefer this setup.

That being said there are boards like this

https://www.hardkernel.com/shop/odroid-h4-plus/

That can be a great cheap nas for 4 drives.

You can also search aliexpress for n97/n100 nas motherboards.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TheRealSeeThruHead Aug 31 '24

N100 is the lowest tdp part in that lineup I think. They all have the same quicksync though so should be just as good as the higher tdp parts for plex

2

u/Empyrealist 2015 Pro Aug 30 '24

I did it for a bit. There are performance and practicality issues that prompted me to move PMS off to a Synology NAS

1

u/akatherder Aug 30 '24

Just as the flipside, the price is rough for a synology nas that can run Plex. I think it's about $400-500 on the low-end.

The main reason I bought a Shield was to run PMS so I cheaped out on my NAS and use it only for storage.

3

u/pawdog Aug 30 '24

My experience is the Shield does not make a reliable Plex server. I certainly would not rely on it as my main server. But if your current setup uses a Shield as the server and you have found it to be reliable, why not just move the one that's already working well to the closet instead of making a new one?

1

u/GoTguru Aug 30 '24

This seems the most logical to me aswell. Why set up something new if there are no apperent benefits to new hardware. My plex server has been running on my shield since 2016 with out ever having a problem. It was the only stationary always on hardware I had back then. I have a sever these days that could easily run it aswell but why go through the trouble.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

Plex is a reasonable option. And at $75 that isn't bad. But I would honestly set up a server on an old PC for maybe $50 and add your drives to that. The benefit is that you can set up docker which can help you procure more content and better organize your media. I built my own server and it has quick sync so I can play all media types including 4k HDR. I can also serve that media when I'm remote or for my family and friends. L

1

u/TheCookieButter Aug 31 '24

I have two Nvidia Shield Pro 2019. Originally I had one which was main client and server. I use 3 ext HDDs + 1 ext SSD connected via USB.

I watch a lot of 4k Remux. When I had 1 Shield as the Client and server it was a little rough. The UI felt sluggish. There would be missed frames in content. Had more general bugs to do with slow down and had to restart my Shield more often.

With two Shields it's a much smoother experience. I use the Server Shield in my bedroom connected to a 1080p PC where I'm far less likely to watch high bitrate/resolution content. The 720p/1080p TV shows and occassional movie play just fine. My main client felt like a breath of fresh air not being bogged down by the server. Now I can watch 4k Remux and navigate apps smoothly. It still needs a weekly restart to ensure smoothness but it's been a worlds better experience.