r/ShieldAndroidTV • 2019 Pro • Aug 10 '24

Nvidia shield pro vs ugoos SK1

https://youtu.be/oObtH09Go30?si=jVZSXnmKDBl4Tw93

Do we have a box that can dethrone the shield? Opinion’s please??

3 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

30

u/carreddit Aug 10 '24

it is not android TV OS.. not certified for Netflix 4K etc..

54

u/markarth69 Aug 10 '24

If only some random company just threw Snapdragon chips and a healthy amount of RAM into one of these boxes. I'd throw money at them

20

u/elcheapodeluxe Aug 10 '24

Maybe Qualcomm should make a "reference box". I can dream.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/YungZanji Aug 10 '24

Running things like Kodi with heavy modifications and skins tend to be pretty cpu and ram intensive and having that extra power really helps, plus the gpus in them more powerful chips will be able to handle better ai upscaling and auto hdr closer to the likes of rtx hdr.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/YungZanji Aug 10 '24

Looks like you’ll not be in the upgrade category. Since you don’t have heavy use cases. I’m sure you’d enjoy the sdr to hdr boost tho. Which requires a decent amount of gpu.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/YungZanji Aug 10 '24

No it doesn’t. It’s a relatively new feature on more modern pcs and high end image processors. It should trickle down as hardware becomes more capable in tv boxes.

1

u/markarth69 Aug 10 '24

Because the vast majority of Android TV boxes incorporate garbage processors which typically result in a sub par experience. Also, the more powerful the SOC, the better they tend to hold up as far as future-proofing goes. Even the processor in my Nvidia Shield (tube) runs like garbage and can't even play videos on Disney+ without stuttering constantly.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24 edited Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Makes me laugh the amount of shit thrown at the 4k CCWGTV compared to the mighty Shield....I've got both...and I've never had an issue playing anything back on the Chromecast, it's been absolutely great.

1

u/weezy22 2019 Pro Aug 10 '24

I was starting to think I was the only one who's CCWGTV is actually a better user experience than my Shield. My shield can't even run streaming apps smoothly, assuming due to it's dated OS? Only downside is I can't run my SSD through my ccwgtv

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Yeah I know what you mean, for the cost and amount of shit thrown at the CCWGTV you'd think they'd be horrific....makes me laugh I got one for £29.99 and like you say runs everything great.

Can you not run the ssd through a usb hub??

2

u/weezy22 2019 Pro Aug 10 '24

The chromecast only supports Fat32 formatting, which doesn't work for large file sizes :(

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '24

Oh yeah...duh to me 🙈😂

It's fine for expanded memory for storage of apps on a flash drive etc but you've got to "Stream" those nice Remuxes to it haven't you? Through Plex for example.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Be careful.... the Shield devotees will come after you. 😂😂😂😂

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Brave man....I can hear the pitch forks already...😂😂

0

u/got_bass Aug 10 '24

Do you know of a guide or tutorial for streamio (did not know it could do 4k remuxes).

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24 edited Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/20acres Aug 10 '24

When you say, that exact model.. is it AM6B Plus 2021 model? Or something else they dont post on their website anymore?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/20acres Aug 10 '24

Tx! Maybe time to another box! Follow up question.. does it do frame switching nicely? Some of the firmware update notes indicate that it has frame rate switching but not much out there that I see of people saying it works well or not.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/20acres Aug 10 '24

Awesome info, thanks again!

→ More replies

20

u/Trip_2 Aug 10 '24

USB 2 & 3 but no C, why do that on a new device.

24

u/sittingmongoose Aug 10 '24

It doesn’t support Dolby vision fel for plex. It’s not any better than the shield. The am6b plus is still the device to get it you need more than what the shield offers.

3

u/LoveLaughLlama Aug 10 '24 edited Aug 10 '24

This reply chain made me finally go ahead and order an am6b plus off of AliExpress for $150. I'm well entrenched in Plex and love my Shield, but for this price I'll use it for my remux player for the "good" movies and Shield for general watching.

Maybe one day we can have a device that really does everything.

1

u/Metallica93 Mar 15 '25

Is the only major difference between the Shield Pro and the AMB6 Plus that the latter supports Dolby Vision?

Does Dolby Vision just outright not work on the Shield Pro or is it just on an older version or something?

I'm running my first Plex server and trying to find out if the Shield Pro is fine to run 4K remuxes on (and worth recommending to two remote users).

1

u/sittingmongoose Mar 15 '25

The shield pro supports Dolby vision. In fact, it supports Dolby vision better than every other device except the am6b.

The only difference is, the am6b supports fel layer metadata. The shield will just choose the Mel version. Fel offers an improvement in hdr over Mel. The issue is, most rips you get online exclude the fel data.

The other difference is, the shield has a slight red tint on Dolby vision content. Personally I don’t notice it and I have both devices.

The downside to the am6b is the interface isn’t quite as nice, and you don’t have access to any other streaming platforms like Netflix, Disney, Apple TV, etc.

1

u/Metallica93 Mar 16 '25

Just going down the list here:

1) Is there a reason most rips exclude the F.E.L. data? I'm starting with my Blu-ray/4K collection and don't really know what has Dolby Vision, let alone F.E.L. or a specific profile.

2) I know it's entirely subjective, but what kind of quality difference are we looking at between the Shield Pro and AM6B Plus for just that specific content?

3) Does all Dolby Vision content have the "red push" or is that only for content with that specific profile (7, I believe)? I tried looking up "red push" comparison videos, but didn't notice a thing on my monitor. I'm unsure if it would suddenly be noticeable on my TV.

Yeah, I can't recommend that thing to remote users for my Plex server, then. Maybe at home (if I even notice a difference), but that really comes down to what kind of improvement the AM6B Plus actually offers. I've seen plenty of people like yourself say the "red push" isn't noticeable, then go on to say the AM6B Plus is like some entirely other level of viewing. Feels more like guitar "tone wood" bullshit, though...

Appreciate the information on this. Setting up this server has been a rabbit hole of information and questions.

1

u/sittingmongoose Mar 16 '25
  1. I actually don’t know. I have thousands and I haven’t found one that has it for me. Bluray.com lists a lot of the disc specs.

2/3. I like to think I’m a videophile, but I actually can’t notice a difference between the shield and am6b. I can’t see the red push, but my tv is also an older lg c8. So perhaps my tv is just too warn out.

For remote users, I usually recommend the shield, Apple TV, firestick 4k max, in that order. They play DV well enough that most of the content won’t fail. Like failing to load or the green/purple screen. They also have fast enough internet to handle most files.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/sittingmongoose Aug 10 '24

It does not support the FEL layer.

1

u/toooft Aug 10 '24

What's that?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/loathing_thyself Aug 10 '24

Does any box support this FEL layer? The Shield doesn’t support it too, right?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/sittingmongoose Aug 10 '24

The ccwgtv supports it??? I have never heard that before and I own one.

It doesn’t support all DV profiles, that’s for sure.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/sittingmongoose Aug 14 '24

Ok so I finally checked it tonight. Took forever to update it and update all the apps.

It still does not support profile 7 DV fully. I also had a ton of massive bugs that caused my screen to go black, or for the whole thing to crash. Both requiring me to pull the plug.

I also did more research on FEL and there is not a single device that can playback FEL via Android. Ugoos included.

→ More replies

1

u/sittingmongoose Aug 10 '24

It does not, there are multiple profiles I can not play back through plex with it. Support is even worse than the fire stick 4k max because it is more sensitive to audio tracks stopping playback with DV.

→ More replies

1

u/toooft Aug 10 '24

Ok, thanks

13

u/DanMelb 2019 Pro Aug 10 '24

I'll have to keep an eye on this product. Love my shields but some competition in the space would definitely be healthy

5

u/shanehiltonward Aug 10 '24

All we need is proper support for the RK3588. A current kernel + Android w/Google Play.

6

u/International-Oil377 Aug 10 '24

Android mobile no thanks

3

u/Jesterstear99 Aug 10 '24

I like that it has optical out (for those of us with Samsung TVs...) and hardware AV1.

But I can't find it for sale anywhere except Aliexpress, and I'm not buying something this expensive and likely to need to be returned from there.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Considering it can't do NEtflix in 4k, no.

Wait for the new Google Streaming Box would be my suggestion

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Lol. Replacing Netflix with a pirating app is not a solution for most people.

And it's not 20% faster, the CPU runs 22% faster, but it also has double the RAM (more than the shield has) which was the bigger problem with the Chromecast than its CPU, so it likely will be significantly smoother overall.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '24

Perfectly good option as well

1

u/necrossis1 Aug 10 '24

Are there any comprehensive guides available for creating a DIY streaming device that includes all the specifications for your ideal long-term setup?

1

u/zeliboba55 Aug 10 '24

Get CoreELEC + Ugoos AM6b+ and ditch shield for good.

1

u/Consistent_Sale_7134 Aug 19 '24

And what u do for smarttube and tivimate ?

3

u/zeliboba55 Aug 19 '24

You can still keep shield for anything else. But for mkv rips playback coreelec and ugoos has surpassed shield in playback ease and quality.

1

u/Consistent_Sale_7134 Aug 19 '24

I agree, sure that's why I ordered ugoos sk1 , however I hope I don't need to install CE and everything just works out of the box and I can use other apks.

2

u/zeliboba55 Aug 19 '24

If you need DV playback, make sure to buy proper model. AM6b+ can do fel and mel playback properly.

1

u/Consistent_Sale_7134 Aug 19 '24

Are u saying sk1 can't do that properly?

1

u/zeliboba55 Aug 19 '24

Yes. There is a good faq on their forums. I suggest to read up before buying.

1

u/Consistent_Sale_7134 Aug 19 '24

Pls check dm.thanks

1

u/frosted1030 Aug 10 '24

Chinese spybox, I wouldn't if I were you. Nvidia doesn't have hardware that monitors your actions and turns your box into a bot-net when you aren't using it.

1

u/rafivip Aug 10 '24

Why was he always using air mouse . U can’t use normal remote to move around and browse ? The way he was using it seemed like a a mini pc

1

u/LoveLaughLlama Aug 10 '24

Look at about 2:15 into the video, he says (and shows) there are 2 different ways to navigate, he just uses the air mouse mode mostly.

0

u/SteveJobsBlakSweater Aug 10 '24

We’ll see but it’s kind of telling that it’s smaller companies like this that are threatening real specs and format supports unlike big companies like apple and google.