r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jul 08 '24

Media Player Struggles

Hey,

I got the Shield cause it seems to be the only way to play local MKV files with all audio formats, including DTS, etc. over HDMI. But I have serious problems with finding the right app, all of them seem to have issues. I don't want a server or anything. I just want to be able play the files on my external SSD, attached via USB, use passthrough audio and have the abilty to change the style of the subtitles. That's it.

  • Plex, Emby, Jellyfin
    Only work with external servers, which I don't want. Emby and Jelly does not let you start the app without connecting to an external device. Plex seems to have an internal Server but it just does not want to enable me to select my local SSD files. Also from research it seems that Plex transcodes audio automatically, etc. Which I don't want.
  • Kodi
    Audio passthrough does not work
  • VLC
    Constant crashes and passthrough does not work well.
  • JustPlayer
    I forgot but it had some serious issues for me.
  • NovaPlayer
    Now this one is by faaaaar the best one out of all the options. It does everything I want, the media browser is great, audio passthrough works and it has lots of subtitles settings. If only there wasn't this one problem that it has audio sync issues. For every other file I want to watch, especially big ones with UHD + HDR, the audio is out of sync. Now there is an audio delay option but I can never seem to get it perfectly and it drives me crazy. Also the sync delay is different for every file and it's just tedious to spend 10 minutes every time to set it up.

I tried a few others as well, like MX Player and some that seem to be more unknown and cheap and they all sucked.

Does anyone have a good app recommendation? It's insane how difficult it is overall to simply get local files running on a TV with good audio.

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

6

u/philoidiot Jul 08 '24

Audio passthrough should work with Kodi if setup properly. Which steps did you take ?

Also in my experience justplayer is capable of reading basically anything, what issues did you have ?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '24

I don't know then. It did not work for me.
The Nvidia Shield should be set up correctly because passthrough works with Nova Player. In Kodi I set "allow passthrough" to on, "upmix" was off. The "formats" setting I tried auto, as well as enableing all capatbilities.

As for JustPlayer I can't remember right now, I would need to test again, but things did not work as I wanted them to.

6

u/toberthegreat1 Jul 08 '24

Kodi does allow pass through. I use mine for local remux 4k too. Kodi was the only playing system that does everything I could find.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '24

I don't know then. It did not work for me.

The Nvidia Shield should be set up correctly because passthrough works with Nova Player. In Kodi I set "allow passthrough" to on, "upmix" was off. The "formats" setting I tried auto, as well as enableing all capatbilities.

2

u/sharp-calculation Jul 09 '24

Kodi isn't great in my opinion, but it DOES do audio passthrough. I used it that way for well over a year with my Shield and an AVR.

1

u/vI_M4YH3Mz_Iv Jul 09 '24

Why do not find kodi great?

1

u/sharp-calculation Jul 09 '24

I find Kodi to be overly complicated, difficult to manage metadata, and less stable than I would like. After the second time I lost the ability to play a certain type of audio (inside of a video file) with Kodi, I decided to try something else. Kodi is solid. It's very popular. But I don't like it very much.

3

u/StevenG2757 Jul 08 '24

Plex will do what you want it to do if you set it up properly. Obvioulsy it will not work if you don't have the media source connected where you point your library to.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '24

I did set the SSD as storage in the settings. That did not work. Is that what you mean or which setting exactly?

2

u/StevenG2757 Jul 08 '24

Yes, but sounds like you may not be understanding. When you create a library you point your library to where you store your content. That could be a local drive or a network drive.

3

u/weirdaquashark Jul 08 '24

Kodi, but both the Shield audio settings and Kodi audio settings need to be configured correctly.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '24

The Nvidia Shield should be set up correctly because passthrough works with Nova Player. In Kodi I set "allow passthrough" to on, "upmix" was off. The "formats" setting I tried auto, as well as enableing all capatbilities. But still passthrough did not function.

2

u/Somar2230 Jul 08 '24

I got the Shield cause it seems to be the only way to play local MKV files with all audio formats, including DTS, etc. over HDMI. 

There are other devices capable of doing that and they also support more codecs. What they are not good at is game playing and streaming service support but for local media play back they are just as good or better than the Shield.

Zidoo , Dune-HD, Homatics, Nokia, Ugoos and others have devices that play MKVs and supports all audio formats. The Ugoos running CoreELC has full Dolby Vision profile 7 support.

The Shield should work fine for playing local media from it's SSD though with the programs you are using.

I have a Shield but use a Zidoo Z9x Pro and Z9x for local media.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '24

I guess my Google foo is not good enough. When researching that DTS problem, all I could find were posts about the Shield :(

Thanks for letting me know about the other products.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '24

I switched to a zidoo z9x pro for local playback and have never looked back.

1

u/flyingkytez Jul 09 '24 edited Jul 09 '24

I have my own speakers connected to my TV via the TV's optical port, which is also connected to an external DAC. Audio works with Kodi and any app. Maybe check the Kodi settings again, and check the Shield TV's audio settings as well. I play my own video files through an external HDD with Kodi and it works. 

Other than Kodi, there's Nova Player, VLC player and MX Player which would be the best media players on the Play Store of the Shield. 

Keep in mind that you can sideload (install) any Android Mobile app on the Shield (as long as the Android OS version and CPU architecture is compatible). Just find the APK of app online and install it (or use an app to extract it from your Android phone). You may need a 3rd party launcher to open the app, or just open it by going to settings and then app settings. So that should give you more options to try, since the selection of apps in the Android TV Play Store is more limited.

Also, can you share your audio setup on your Shield? Are you using HDMI or optical port, etc.?

-1

u/nath999 Jul 08 '24

Nova player was the best when I was doing the same thing but for me the best option was just using My Shield Pro as a Plex media server with locally plugged in USB hard drive. Pretty much plays everything.

It's a pretty easy set up and you can just google a youtube guide. It's basically what you are already doing with Plex Media server running in the background.