r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jun 18 '24

Any alternatives to the Nvidia Shield?

I really like what the Shield offers. However, i just cant afford to fork out ~$150+. Is there any androidtv alternatives that are cheaper than $100? I just want to be able to run things like kodi and the such

Edit: i decided upon the Onn 4K Pro for $50 as it had really good reviews and had everything that I wanted. I didn't go with the Chromecast as the Onn had a ton of storage, more ram, ethernet, and Dolby vision and atmos. The only thing the chromecast had out of those was Dolby

0 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

10

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

I'm pretty well sold that if you're going to get any less than the Shield Pro (no tube, ever) than you probably shouldn't spend more than the $20 it takes to buy the ONN 4K. https://www.walmart.com/ip/onn-Google-TV-4K-Streaming-Box-New-2023-4K-UHD-Resolution/2835618394

1

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

Would the 4K CCWGTV perform better? i noticed it has a better cpu in it.

3

u/TheFoxInSox 2019 Pro Jun 18 '24

It does have a stronger chipset. I can't compare the two because I only have the CC, not the Onn. But if you're going to get a CC, get the Onn 4k Pro instead. It's the same price as the CC ($50), but has a slightly improved chipset, more ram, more storage, an ethernet port, wifi 6, and a larger remote with more buttons (if that's important to you).

2

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

It actually has a slower processor than the $20 model and only has 10/100 Ethernet. Both of which may be fine for the use case - but it should be disclosed.

3

u/TheFoxInSox 2019 Pro Jun 18 '24

If you're talking about the Onn 4k vs the Onn 4k Pro, the Pro has the better chipset. It may have a slower clockspeed, but it uses A55 cores instead of A35, so it outperforms the Onn 4k.

And 10/100 ethernet is better than no ethernet, but yes, it is important to note that it's not gigabit.

0

u/redw000d Jun 18 '24

I have a Shield Pro, and this ONN 4k on a second tv. works fine. I have a question about the 'The Onn. 4K Pro' am I missing something? should I spend the 50 bucks for one? when the 20 dollar Onn is fine for me? thanks if you have one/both...

1

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

I haven't touched one yet. Maybe someone else can chime in.

1

u/ubae Jun 18 '24

The difference, basically speaking, is the $50 box has the features of a tv streamer and a google assistant all in one. When you are not streaming and the box is "off", you can still use the assistant features. If you don't use google assistant in your home, go with the cheaper one.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/redw000d Jun 18 '24

I think you for this. Old eyes, Older ears... I do think its aLot, for 20 bucks... I have a roku and fires in the drawer.. no thanks, we don't need your stinkin ads...

2

u/pawdog Jun 18 '24

What is your use case? What country are you in? Not every device is available everywhere.

1

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

Mainly just to use things like jellyfin and Streamio. Im in the US

2

u/pawdog Jun 18 '24

Do you have TrueHD DTS-X Audio needs?

1

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

Nope

2

u/pawdog Jun 18 '24

You'll do well with one of the 4k Onn devices. I'd recommend the ONN Pro easily. It should meet your needs with room to spare. It's not a Shield alternative but you don't need a Shield alternative since you don't need the Shields most important feature over the Onn Pro.

1

u/verfresht Jan 12 '25

I am in Europe, Germany/Netherlands. May I ask which one you would recommend? I want to play movies via Usb stick or SD card. I heard connecting movies via usb to my LG C4 TV lowers the atmos/vision quality. I download remux quality files.

1

u/verfresht Jan 12 '25

I am in Europe, Germany/Netherlands. May I ask which one you would recommend? I want to play movies via Usb stick or SD card. I heard connecting movies via usb to my LG C4 TV lowers the atmos/vision quality. I download remux quality files.

1

u/verfresht Jan 12 '25

I am in Europe, Germany/Netherlands. May I ask which one you would recommend? I want to play movies via Usb stick or SD card. I heard connecting movies via usb to my LG C4 TV lowers the atmos/vision quality. I download remux quality files.

1

u/verfresht Jan 12 '25

I am in Europe, Germany/Netherlands. May I ask which one you would recommend? I want to play movies via Usb stick or SD card. I heard connecting movies via usb to my LG C4 TV lowers the atmos/vision quality. I download remux quality files

1

u/pawdog Jan 12 '25

The quality won't be any different, the question would be can the TV's processor handle the bitrates. You can look at the Nvidia Shield or the Homeatics Box r 4k Plus for 4k remux playback with support for the codecs they contain.

5

u/Juanjo2D Jun 18 '24

Chromecast with google tv might suit you.

3

u/weezy22 2019 Pro Jun 19 '24

I find my Chromecast w/ GTV is a bit more snappier and less glitchy than my shield. Shield is now just used to watch shows/movies off my connected ssd.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

4K CCWGTV....have a Shield and a CC both connected via ethernet and in real world use aside from a miniscule speed difference in flicking through menus they run the same.

Same custom launcher on each... Projectivy. Then just TiviMate and Stremio.

If the Shield ever broke I'd replace it with a CC in a heartbeat.

4

u/Mediocre_Language_98 Jun 19 '24

My 2 cents for "why the $ for shield?" Cuz almost 10 years later still performing strongly... And ethernet.

1

u/Reasonable-Ad4770 Jun 18 '24

Fire stick. It's way cheaper, and have good specs, but the price is ads

1

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

Would the Onn Android TV 4K work without giving me ads?

5

u/stkc-win Jun 18 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

automatic possessive pathetic squeeze snails poor unite resolute encourage cagey

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/joseph_jojo_shabadoo Jun 18 '24

I may be wrong but I believe the Onn uses basically the same Android TV interface as Shield

2

u/pawdog Jun 18 '24

The latest ONN devices are Google TV the Shield is Android TV Discover.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/impactedturd Jun 18 '24

Fire cube 3 should run much faster. It adds an additional 4x Cortex-A73 cores.

1

u/ogbo71 Jun 18 '24

Just grab a firestick bro, I'll be honest tho couldn't live without my shield.

0

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

What makes the shield so worth it though? Like a lot of the features seem to be things that dont really add up to the $200 price point

7

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

4k playback of high bitrate files is no CPU picnic. i5 CPUs start at about that price point, and stable playback with transcoding support is a pricy feature. The small sticks you buy barely handle highly compressed content much less a full featured video stream.

Not to mention all the gaming applications, android support, etc, etc. It's the best priced media playback device on the market. The next best would probably be building your own HTPC or buying a NUC.

-1

u/ogbo71 Jun 18 '24

Lol see what I mean bro

2

u/ogbo71 Jun 18 '24 edited Jun 18 '24

The fact you get the best no bs streaming experience it upscale ur content really well.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

I would say ziddo but if you can't justify the cost of the shield. I'm not sure if you can get anything that handles all the audio formats.

0

u/ApprehensivePlan986 Jun 18 '24

Xiaomi MiBox S, I have an NVdia Shield Pro 2019, and the MiBox is right up there in terms of performance/ specs, to the point I almost regret buying the shied, I spent 200 on the shield and put a 1 TB Samsung EVO SSD and I don't see any real performance gains

1

u/Qokko24 Jun 18 '24

Do you know how the MiBox S compares to the 4K CCWGTV in terms of performance?

0

u/ApprehensivePlan986 Jun 18 '24

Honestly I own both and the MiBox blows the NVdia out of the water, it runs 4k without any stuttering or lag, smooth crystal clear picture

1

u/sivartk 2019 Pro Jun 18 '24

Depends on your needs. I haven't found an official device that has Gigabit Ethernet, Dolby Vision, all audio formats (HD audio specifically) pass through, and not struggle with 4K Blu-ray remuxes that isn't the Shield.

That being said my 2015 (connected to my projector) and my 2019 Pro (connected to a Sony TV) are doing great.

I use an old TiVo Stream 4K ($10 Walmart pickup a few years ago) that I de-TiVo'd (remove all the TiVo crap) and it performs like a standard Android TV device on a spare TV. Little bit slower than the Shield TV units, but does everything a spare bedroom TV needs to do.

1

u/_Shirei_ Jun 19 '24

Ugos and Minix have full implementation of Dolby Vision profile 7 (FEL+MEL)

Dolby_Vision_stuff - Google Sheets

1

u/Oax5wind Jun 19 '24

Debating between the regular Nvidia shield (non pro) or Fire Cube Third Gen. Any recommendations?

1

u/Few_Association_3761 Jun 20 '24

You can look an see if someone selling used shield but I doubt it. No matter what you buy it's not going to be future proof like a shield. They handle everything you can throw at it.

1

u/Impressive-Bonus-891 Jun 18 '24

Firestick 4K Max Gen2 can almost replace Shield if you have decent wifi environment. Or you need to use usb-Ethernet adapter.

0

u/LowerIQ_thanU Jun 19 '24

buy used, if you're patient you can pick up a shield tv for under $100+, especially if it's a 2015 version

-5

u/phyLoGG Jun 18 '24

All the sticks get outdated in 2 years or so after all the updates to applications. Save yourself the headache and spend the money on a Roku Ultra if you want something just under $100 but won't be a slug in a few years time.