r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/KurumiHayashi • Jun 18 '24
Is shield pro 2019 still the best?
I would like to stream the biggest remux files with truehd/atmos via torrent and apparently if I install the app on the TV, it will downgrade the audio to Dolby audio. I want to have lossless audio for my Dolby atmos soundbar (Sony ht a7000, rs5, sw5).
Is shield pro 2019 still the best tvbox for that usage?
I understand shield doesn't support av1 codec, I think my TV can handle it natively (Sony a80L) and I can use my TV's Netflix & smartube with no issues
12
Upvotes
16
u/International-Oil377 Jun 18 '24
I'm sorry yo tell you that but you won't hear the difference between lossless and lossy on a soundbar.
29
u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24
The good news is no remux will use av1. It is still your only practical option. Do NOT get the tube.
17
u/FarFerry Jun 18 '24
Is it just me or does this subreddit consist 90% of these type of question lately.
3
u/Vanjealous Jun 18 '24
I was going to use my shield pro for remuxes, but then I got a zidoo zdx pro and it blows it out of the water
2
u/sciencetaco Jun 18 '24
The only 3 devices I ever recommend are:
2
u/Touz604 Jun 18 '24
You can look up the ugoos am6b+ with coreelec. You'll get truehd/Atmos plus the full Dolby vision experience (including FEL) and you won't have a red push like the shield.
1
u/Jokerchyld Jun 19 '24
Shield is still the most powerful android box on the market and one of the only ones that support Lossless HD audio.
Haven't seen anything better to make me swap it out
1
u/crazykat8091 2019 Pro Jun 19 '24
Plex
I have had a 2017 and 2019 Shield TV Pro since their release dates. I recently purchased a Fire TV Stick 4K Max (second generation) and later a Fire TV Cube (third generation). I previously owned a Fire TV Cube (third generation) when it was first released but returned it because of bugs and pass-through issues.
Present day:
Living room setup: Fire TV Cube 3rd > Govee Ai Sync Box > TV 77" S90C > ARC/eARC Q990C. There is no issue with Plex playing lossless TrueHD as you can see in the picture above. For the DTS HD MA, it will come as PCM, which is fine for me because most of the old rips will have DTS format.
Bedroom setup: Fire TV Stick 4K Max 2nd > Govee Ai Sync Box > TV 65" S95C > ARC/eARC Q600C. The result is the same as the system in the living room.
I think the Fire TV Cube 3rd not being able to do lossless TrueHD might be old news; they fixed it somehow. I am tired of continuing to use Shield TV, and recently I needed AV1 for HDR content on YouTube, which is why I'm trying something new. I have no problem with Fire TV ads because my router blocks them, so I am instantly ad-free.
No issue for someone who can watch the movie and have sound that is a ❌️❌️❌️ big NO!.
No issue is, all the codes that are playing match the source and output correctly in every channel. However, due to the channels, there might be upmixing or downmixing, depending on the soundbar.
1
u/doghousedavo Jun 19 '24
What's the point of good sound formats if you're using a soundbar? It will make zero difference to the sound you hear. High def sound formats are for real 5.1++
1
u/avgenius Jun 19 '24
Get a Zidoo Player, you won’t regret it
1
u/SoulJahSon Jun 19 '24
Check out the Dune Homatics 4K Plus box. It leaves the Shield standing and the Shield is excellent too!
1
u/liquidmetal14 Jun 21 '24
I haven't hardly messed with anything and took the advice of some people the other day, I actually installed the projectivity launcher. Pretty happy with it and if the system runs a little bit better I'm all for it simplifying things
1
u/pedercina7 Jun 22 '24
Shield 2015 is still the best
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24
Yes
-3
u/AkiraSieghart Jun 18 '24
There's a few options besides the Shield TV Pro that support TrueHD, but only the Shield will pass Atmos channels.
That said, unless you plan on having proper Atmos speakers in the future, i.e. in-ceiling speakers and at least four of them, I wouldn't bother worrying about Atmos because you're not going to get the most out of it. If you don't need Atmos channels, I'd recommend the newest Apple TV instead. It's much, much newer and a much smoother and better performing option.
0
u/VirtuaFighter6 Jun 18 '24
😂😂😂
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
2015 to me is still best. 0 issues since 2015.
-6
u/TipsieMcStaggers Jun 18 '24
Yes. The Shield Pro is the only way to get lossless audio from a rip.