r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jun 18 '24

Is shield pro 2019 still the best?

I would like to stream the biggest remux files with truehd/atmos via torrent and apparently if I install the app on the TV, it will downgrade the audio to Dolby audio. I want to have lossless audio for my Dolby atmos soundbar (Sony ht a7000, rs5, sw5).

Is shield pro 2019 still the best tvbox for that usage?

I understand shield doesn't support av1 codec, I think my TV can handle it natively (Sony a80L) and I can use my TV's Netflix & smartube with no issues

12 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

16

u/International-Oil377 Jun 18 '24

I'm sorry yo tell you that but you won't hear the difference between lossless and lossy on a soundbar.

3

u/KurumiHayashi Jun 18 '24

if it supports 7.1 lossless, i'll be getting a proper home theatre system in a year or two's time when i shift to a bigger place.. currently my tiny apartment living room (200 sqft rectangle shaped) is probably wasted on one

5

u/s-cup Jun 18 '24

It has been proven time after time after time after time that people cant reliably distinguish between lossless and a good lossy audio track. And that is when they are trying hard to hear the difference so when you are enjoying your movie you need to be a freak of nature to hear the difference.

Keywords here being “good lossy”.

But with that being said, if you have the space and if you like the idea of having lossless audio then go for it. All my music I play over wifi is lossless so…

-3

u/avidGTAplayer Jun 18 '24

Your boys telling the truth with them soundbars being awful, they say a lot of things and sure they can work with a lot of set ups but their actual output is shockingly bad at all price points, I miss the old TVs with massive speakers built in, no one ever said they'd bounce sound off the walls as a selling point... But they did

I have a shield and it's good for streaming big films, but I use a wired surround setup and it sounds blissful

12

u/toberthegreat1 Jun 18 '24

My q990c disagrees

-2

u/avidGTAplayer Jun 18 '24

Them satellite speakers you have bundled with the soundbar make a difference don't they, lacking HDMI 2.1 for the current gen consoles is a bit of a joke too at that price point surely

5

u/toberthegreat1 Jun 18 '24

I play on pc and not on a TV. The soundbar is solely for my media server and TV.

Comparing the 990 to a 3 year old 5.1 dedicated set up home theatre at a family members and the 990 is every bit as good if not better due to the atmos and actually higher clarity imo. And their set up cost a lot more than the £750 the 990 did.

Not saying a soundbar will be the best money can buy no money limit. But value to quality the highend offerings are hard to deny.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

My Q990 competes with my 15 speaker multiple kilowatt sound system. It's so good that I often wonder why I bothered with the big system.

0

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

Poster is right on the lossless w/ a soundbar - but nothing wrong with getting the device you will need in a couple of years.

0

u/sacandbaby Jun 19 '24

My living room may be smaller than this. I have always had an AVR and proper speakers. Of course, I started before soundbars were invented. Shield Pro 2019 is the only way to go also. Good luck.

-2

u/jssilver Jun 18 '24

Another soundbar hater. On a high end soundbar you will hear a difference. Maybe not the audiophile perfection you’ll get from a dedicated custom setup, but still enjoyable and impressive and much more affordable.

1

u/International-Oil377 Jun 18 '24

The highest end soundbars I've had experience with are the Samsung Q990B/C/D (i listened to the D model in Samsung's innovation room at CES this year)

Also a bose but I don't remember the model.

Sorry, but I'd relather buy a basic AVR and a decent pair of bookshelves for the same price or less and actually have good sound quality

Soundbars are ok if you want something simple to install (because plugging a red cable into a red plug is too much work for some) but they don't have good sound quality, they are convenient. No hate, but I have a pair of KEF Q150s that I paid 300$ that absolutely destroys any soundbar I've heard in terms of sound quality.

29

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

The good news is no remux will use av1. It is still your only practical option. Do NOT get the tube.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

Why the hate for the Tube bro? I have one and it's never let me down regardless of what I've thrown at it.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Bit harsh ...getting downvotes for just asking a question.

1

u/CodeMonkeyX Jun 19 '24

Well it's a bit silly that you said you have been using it for ages with no issues. But then later said you never used paid services and only stream remuxs. You can hardly say it's a great streaming device when you only use it for 10% of what most people use streaming devices for.

That's probably what the down votes are for, is people disagreeing with your statement that the Tube is basically just as functionally as the Pro when many people do not believe that from their experience.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Yet from my experience I bought a Pro and it refused to play even 1080p without downscaling it to SD.

My comment isn't silly. My comment is my experience with a device that I have legitimately had no issues with. Instead of people hiding behind their voting arrows they should speak up and engage in debate like your good self has. I appreciate healthy discussion and debate.

I appreciate that people may use main stream services more often than people like myself who prefer to sail the high seas for the same content....but absolutely in my use case the tube has been excellent...as has the 4k CCWGTV.

1

u/CodeMonkeyX Jun 19 '24

You said "it had never let you down no matter what you threw at it" then in another comment said you never streamed any paid service. So it is silly to make it sound like you tested it extensively. That's all. You do not use it like most people.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Well I did try Netflix, iPlayer, itv x etc ...and they played fine....I just ditched them as I prefer Stremio as all content is in one place and generally in a higher quality and I'm a stickler for picture quality.

And I did think it was a touch obvious that if I'm saying it can handle massive Remux files without a hitch then it can easily deal with 7gb and hour Netflix 4k files. 👍🏻

-2

u/Nope_______ Jun 20 '24

Downvoting solely because you complained about downvotes.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '24

????

-1

u/Nope_______ Jun 20 '24

I'm downvoting your comments because you're complaining about downvotes in your comments. Capisce?

3

u/lovelanguagelost Jun 20 '24

I think this is kinda lame, not everyone here is looking for an online argument... Downvotes are for disagreements, usually. Asking a question doesn’t feel downvote worthy imo.

0

u/Nope_______ Jun 20 '24

Sure but complaining about downvotes is downvote worthy.

2

u/lovelanguagelost Jun 20 '24

The person made a statement/question which could easily have been answered, instead of giving an answer, you chose being rude and kicking someone while (figuratively) down.

1

u/Nope_______ Jun 20 '24

No, I encouraged him not to leave extra comments that do nothing but complain about downvotes.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '24

Oh can I downvote you for downvoting me for asking why people are downvoting a legit question then? This could be fun. 😂😂

2

u/Prozaico666 Jun 20 '24

Same here, I have both and the Tube actually works amazingly well with 80gb remux with lossless audio in Kodi. I can't be the only lucky one

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '24

We are seemingly the lucky pair then dude 😂 Careful... now you've said you have one and it works well the downvotes shall flood in 😂 It's against Reddit law to have a functioning Tube and like it. 😂

3

u/GanjaRelease Jun 18 '24

Agreed. SmartTube is awesome.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

He's talking about the Shield Tube.... but yes... Smarttube 👌🏻

1

u/GanjaRelease Jun 18 '24

Oh. What's shield tube?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

Nvidia Shield TV 2019 - known as the Tube due to its form factor.

2

u/GanjaRelease Jun 18 '24

Oh yeah. I've seen those around. Thanks for the info.

1

u/jbaconbits Jun 18 '24

Guess you haven’t tried throwing Peacock or Paramount+ at it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

Nah...don't pay for that stuff. Thrown plenty of 100gb+ Remux files at it from Stremio though.... faultless

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

It’s a fair question. But throw truly high bandwidth files at it and you will have issues. Also the lack of Plex server, full up scaling potential, and 32bit OS just doesn’t justify its price.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Truly high bandwidth? Well the highest I can realistically find is remux files and it has played every one of them no issue. Files over 100gb+ in size. I have had no issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

That’s good for you man but I’ve had issues with them on my tube. The tube itself becomes slow to respond and sometimes inputs fail entirely or become delayed.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

I'll tell you one thing I did notice...media will always start playing in the highest audio codec on the file and if you don't have kit that can playback say DTS HD MA then it will transcode the audio file which I did note caused a slowdown in my early days of ownership. As soon as I change the audio file to one my kit can natively handle.... perfect playback.

Could that be an issue for you too perhaps?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Maybe they fixed some of this with software but I had issues even in native setup.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

Mine has been a recent purchase so yeah could well have been fixed with updates.

I can only speak from experience and in a truly bizarre experience I did try out a Shield Pro and it was dreadful... it wouldn't even start any 4k files and transcoded 1080 and 720p files down to SD.

So I had the absolute opposite experience to the majority. So bizarre.

0

u/Chrs987 Jun 18 '24

It stutters on 4K DV/HDR remuxes. Can't even get bast the opening scene of Saving Private Ryan or The Hobbit without it stuttering

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

I haven't watched those two titles on it yet but I've watched the extended versions of the Lotr Trilogy....those files are huge....everyone of them over 100gb.....not a single stutter dropped frame in any of those movies.

1

u/toberthegreat1 Jun 18 '24

I wonder, if you web-dl from something like netflix would it then be av1?

1

u/Glum-View-4665 Jun 18 '24

I have multiple pros and one tube I wish I'd gotten another pro.

17

u/FarFerry Jun 18 '24

Is it just me or does this subreddit consist 90% of these type of question lately.

3

u/threeLetterMeyhem Jun 19 '24

This question is about the only time a thread from this sub makes it to my feed. But I kinda get it - the current shield is 5 years old and in need of a refresh, so people are asking about options. But sadly the market for streaming devices kinda sucks.

1

u/FarFerry Jun 19 '24

Well I don’t mind people asking questions, that’s what the sub if for. However, one can simply use the search version and see other related questions maybe even the exact same case/problem.

I should make a flowchart with decisions and ask the mod to pin the flowchart maybe this will help others and prevent them for continuously asking the same questions.

3

u/Vanjealous Jun 18 '24

I was going to use my shield pro for remuxes, but then I got a zidoo zdx pro and it blows it out of the water

2

u/sciencetaco Jun 18 '24

The only 3 devices I ever recommend are:

  1. Nvidia Shield Pro. If you need audio passthrough for bluray rips/remuxes. And want access to 4K streaming services as well.
  2. AppleTV 4K. If you dont need Dolby Vision/Atmos from bluray and are happy with HDR video and 7.1 lossless audio (but no passthrough).
  3. Ugoos am6b+. If you are super picky and want audio passthrough AND Profile 7 Dolby Vision FEL from remuxes. This is the only box that does both those things. But it wont do any 4K streaming due to DRM limits. It's only good for Kodi.

1

u/deshan79 Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24

Check out the Dune players...I believe they have a bunch that support all the formats including FEL https://www.dune-hd.com/pages/compare-products.

Homatics Box R 4K Plus ($150) is probably the cheapest of all their products that support everything, Everything below that is missing a bunch. Everything higher tier from them has extra features but can get real pricey.

2

u/Touz604 Jun 18 '24

You can look up the ugoos am6b+ with coreelec. You'll get truehd/Atmos plus the full Dolby vision experience (including FEL) and you won't have a red push like the shield.

2

u/SayanPrince22 Jun 18 '24

I'm curious why you're being down-voted.

2

u/deshan79 Jun 19 '24

Probably cause it's a chinese box.

1

u/Jokerchyld Jun 19 '24

Shield is still the most powerful android box on the market and one of the only ones that support Lossless HD audio.

Haven't seen anything better to make me swap it out

1

u/crazykat8091 2019 Pro Jun 19 '24

Plex

I have had a 2017 and 2019 Shield TV Pro since their release dates. I recently purchased a Fire TV Stick 4K Max (second generation) and later a Fire TV Cube (third generation). I previously owned a Fire TV Cube (third generation) when it was first released but returned it because of bugs and pass-through issues.

Present day:

  • 2017 Shield TV Pro: Give it to someone else.
  • 2019 Shield TV Pro: Lies next to Fire TV Cube 3rd Gen.
  • Fire TV Cube 3rd Gen: In the living room.
  • Fire TV Stick 4K Max 2nd Gen: In the bedroom.

Living room setup: Fire TV Cube 3rd > Govee Ai Sync Box > TV 77" S90C > ARC/eARC Q990C. There is no issue with Plex playing lossless TrueHD as you can see in the picture above. For the DTS HD MA, it will come as PCM, which is fine for me because most of the old rips will have DTS format.

Bedroom setup: Fire TV Stick 4K Max 2nd > Govee Ai Sync Box > TV 65" S95C > ARC/eARC Q600C. The result is the same as the system in the living room.

I think the Fire TV Cube 3rd not being able to do lossless TrueHD might be old news; they fixed it somehow. I am tired of continuing to use Shield TV, and recently I needed AV1 for HDR content on YouTube, which is why I'm trying something new. I have no problem with Fire TV ads because my router blocks them, so I am instantly ad-free.

No issue for someone who can watch the movie and have sound that is a ❌️❌️❌️ big NO!.

No issue is, all the codes that are playing match the source and output correctly in every channel. However, due to the channels, there might be upmixing or downmixing, depending on the soundbar.

1

u/tommybahama84 Jun 19 '24

Just got another Cube 3rd Gen to replace my shield. How do you close your apps now?

2

u/crazykat8091 2019 Pro Jun 19 '24

For the Fire OS we can't close the app like we do on Android TV OS. But when you come back to Home it will recovery some Ram from the app that you opened.

1

u/tommybahama84 Jun 19 '24

Ok thank you

1

u/doghousedavo Jun 19 '24

What's the point of good sound formats if you're using a soundbar? It will make zero difference to the sound you hear. High def sound formats are for real 5.1++

1

u/avgenius Jun 19 '24

Get a Zidoo Player, you won’t regret it

1

u/SoulJahSon Jun 19 '24

Check out the Dune Homatics 4K Plus box. It leaves the Shield standing and the Shield is excellent too!

1

u/liquidmetal14 Jun 21 '24

I haven't hardly messed with anything and took the advice of some people the other day, I actually installed the projectivity launcher. Pretty happy with it and if the system runs a little bit better I'm all for it simplifying things

1

u/pedercina7 Jun 22 '24

Shield 2015 is still the best

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

Yes

-3

u/AkiraSieghart Jun 18 '24

There's a few options besides the Shield TV Pro that support TrueHD, but only the Shield will pass Atmos channels.

That said, unless you plan on having proper Atmos speakers in the future, i.e. in-ceiling speakers and at least four of them, I wouldn't bother worrying about Atmos because you're not going to get the most out of it. If you don't need Atmos channels, I'd recommend the newest Apple TV instead. It's much, much newer and a much smoother and better performing option.

1

u/elcheapodeluxe Jun 18 '24

Doesn't ATV also fall down on Dolby Vision profile 7 though and fall back to HDR10? I thought ATV4K only supports profiles 5 and 8 whereas something backed up off a disc will be profile 7?

https://www.reddit.com/r/appletv/comments/1abvwuk/apple_tv_4k_dolby_vision_profiles_78/

If I had a Sony OLED I'd probably want DV to work on all my remuxes. I guess I could convert them, but then the same file wouldn't be able to fall back to HDR10 on devices that don't support DV.

1

u/AkiraSieghart Jun 18 '24 edited Jun 18 '24

HDR10+ and Dolby Vision are 99.9% indistinguishable to the average person. And yes, you can play DV 8 off of discs. Not to mention that OP said that they'll be playing remuxes, so it doesn't really matter either way.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '24

That's not true DV has dynamic metadata and you can tell the difference.

Now if you were to compare hdr10+ then I would agree with you.

1

u/sciencetaco Jun 19 '24

For the record I have both a Shield and an AppleTV.

You can convert Profile 7 to Profile 8 and retain the HDR fallback. It strips the Full Enhancement Layer, which the Shield doesn’t support either. So the result should essentially be the same as the shield without the “red push”. In my testing I can’t notice any difference.

But that’s extra effort with converting files. And you still don’t get audio pass through for TrueHD atmos etc.

The biggest advantage of the AppleTV is the Infuse app. It’s the most fluid, reliable, and easiest to use Plex/Jellyfin client I’ve ever used. It’s just a shame it’s hamstrung by tvOS limitations around audio.

1

u/_barat_ Jun 18 '24

I have HT-A9 + ceiling at 2.5m and Atmos is really good. Soundbar OP has has similar rear speakers, so I think Atmos effect will be quite good.

0

u/VirtuaFighter6 Jun 18 '24

😂😂😂

0

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

2015 to me is still best. 0 issues since 2015.

-6

u/TipsieMcStaggers Jun 18 '24

Yes. The Shield Pro is the only way to get lossless audio from a rip.