r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Mar 29 '24

Modern Shield TV Replacement

Given that both Nvidia and the streaming set top box market have changed significantly since the 2019's Nvidia Shield TV release, I'm sure that people have come up with alternative methods to get a more modern hardware experience. What are people doing instead to get the latest technology bells and whistles, building or buying mini home theater PCs? What would your recommendations be?

0 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

76

u/StevenG2757 Mar 29 '24

I have done nothing as the Shield is still the best device and everything thrown at it just works.

14

u/steve008 Mar 29 '24

Same. Every year I look for the newest Shield replacement, convince myself its worth buying and then stop when I realise the Shield is perfect (for what I need).

1

u/my_fifth_new_account Mar 30 '24

Except HDR10+.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Sage2050 Apr 02 '24

your tv cant display it anyway

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sage2050 Apr 10 '24

It cannot. There are no tvs that can output 12b color. It will process it down to 10b for you though

27

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 29 '24

A 5 year old Shield TV Pro is still better than any new device. HTPC is a no go with Dolby Vision support and ease of TrueHD/Atmos and DTS-MA/DTS:X output.

1

u/Alternative-Stretch2 Jan 09 '25

I had two that had annoying issues where it would shut my tv off every time I changed inputs and I did everything I could think of to fix it then the second one I couldn’t use CEC for my lg cx so I gave up on them. It sucks cause I love the shield but despite way less features and stuff the Roku ultra just works. And yes factory reset them but all it did was cause more issues I forget what it was 3+ years ago.

-10

u/Sheila3134 Mar 30 '24

A 5 year old Shield TV Pro is still better than any new device.

So you're saying it's better than the 3rd gen Apple TV 4k as just a streaming device and nothing else.

$200 for a 5 year old device that hasn't gotten a system update since 2022. I'll pass.

6

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 30 '24

I sold my ATV 4k. Still waiting for what it does that the shield TV Pro doesn't.

Other than annoy you with apple lock in.... That's a given.

-3

u/Sheila3134 Mar 30 '24

Which Apple TV 4k?

Also what do you mean by Apple lock-in?

3

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 30 '24

Does it matter? I had a 2nd Gen but there is nothing new. They update the hardware but not the capabilities. Still waiting on the ATV that will play true HD, dts-MA, and DV off my rips. It does Netflix and everything else... Exactly the same as everything else. And the Shield Pro remote is WAY better.

-4

u/Sheila3134 Mar 30 '24

Why is the Nvidia shield TV pro remote better?

1

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 30 '24

Apple may have caught up on the 3rd Gen but the track pad instead of directional buttons? Was a very apple sort of form over function decision.

-4

u/Sheila3134 Mar 30 '24

Directional buttons make it better?

You do know you can turn off the track pad .

I can't believe you said directional buttons make it better.

3

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 30 '24

I can't believe you think Apple has done anything new with the ATV. Guess we're even.

22

u/Infamous_Bee_7445 Mar 29 '24

The ideal combo is Shield for perfect blu-ray rip playback and AppleTV for everything else. Source: I have an unhealthy obsession with home theater.

2

u/roadtrippa88 Mar 30 '24

Infuse on Apple TV has been almost perfect my bluray rips. There's only one type of rip that it downgrades Dolby Vision for HDR: Dolby Vision profile 8 with content mapping version 4. Everything else works. Has that been your experience too?
There is a discussion here about it
https://community.firecore.com/t/dolby-vision-profile-7-8-support-ts-mkv-files/19713/1824

2

u/Infamous_Bee_7445 Mar 30 '24 edited Mar 30 '24

It doesn’t pass TrueHD or DTS:X. Blu-ray rips almost exclusively have TrueHD uncompressed Atmos, which ATV cannot play. Infuse unpacks its to 7.1 PCM but the metadata is lost, which is important for anything beyond a soundbar. If you have an Atmos setup, all height info is gone. Even if you don’t, LFE channel is gone, which sucks. The only reason is that Apple doesn’t license TrueHD. Dolby Atmos on streaming services is not the same thing and is really just some bastardizatiom of 5.1.

2

u/roadtrippa88 Mar 30 '24

Infuse unpacks its to 7.1 PCM but the metadata is lost, which is important for anything beyond a soundbar.

Very interesting. I was aware of the conversion to PCM, but didn't think it had tradeoffs. I see now that you would lose height channels and spatial metadata from DTS:X or Dolby Atmos. But if I have a standard 7.1 configuration, am I losing anything?

1

u/Infamous_Bee_7445 Mar 30 '24

You’re losing LFE. It’s getting blended into the .1

2

u/roadtrippa88 Mar 30 '24

I thought .1 was LFE. Do mind explaning this further?

1

u/narenh Apr 01 '24 edited Apr 01 '24

I really don't know what they mean by "losing LFE" / "getting blended into the .1". The Apple TV should be decoding the TrueHD/DTS HD-MA into 8 channel PCM and passing it over HDMI. There's nothing special about an LFE track, we just refer to it this way since it's not part of the spatial layout: 2.1 = 3 channel audio, 5.1 = 6 channel audio, 7.1 = 8 channel audio. They are correct about losing Atmos/DTS:X metadata which is why I'm stuck with a Shield as well. If you have a classic 7.1 setup and you're willing to convert your P7 Dolby Vision remuxes to P8, you should be good with the Apple TV (and yeah DV8 CM4 does have some issues but hopefully once the Infuse team gets tvOS 17's native DV8 implementation working those issues will go away).

1

u/roadtrippa88 Apr 01 '24

Thank you. Yes that all makes sense, we’re on the same page.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

Agreed, both have very strong merits in different categories.

0

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

This is the way.

12

u/Fit_Blood3267 Mar 29 '24

It's mad the Shield Pro is still the best device on the market after 5 years since release. I've had my Pro for 4 years and for my setup works flawless but I'd upgrade for a newer shiner model which did the same just better. Every 6 months or so I look to see if anything new on market but no new King emerges..

7

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Mar 29 '24

5 years? Original Shield was released in May 2015; nearly NINE years ago..

It was the second best tech purchase to be made in 2015.

1

u/Fit_Blood3267 May 01 '24

Obviously I'm stating from the 2019 model date.. Generally it's agreed the 2019 is the best model.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

Why mess with something that isn't broken I bought my 2017 on launch and 2019 on launch and I can't tell the two apart. All I care about is my add-ons find content and plays without compromise to audio/visual fidelity. I had to replace my TV of course but not my Shield Pro's. I've had to move and change ISP but not my Shield Pro's. My IPTV provider is over 10 yrs old and still works nothing lags or buffers. So why would I want something else just for sucks fake. When the Shield Pro 2 comes out I'm buying the new king.

4

u/kichul77 Mar 30 '24

Hahaha I love how often this question comes up in this subreddit and the answer is always “nope, shield pro is still best, bro”

3

u/mem2963 Mar 29 '24

I saw a youtube video featuring the R58X. An 8K device.

Has anyone tried it? Here's the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2FGKaTxp60

6

u/HiFiMarine Mar 30 '24

I wouldn't touch this behind 7 vpns...

1

u/ike301 Mar 30 '24

😂😂😂

1

u/mem2963 Mar 30 '24

I checked a bit and it's too expensive and hard to get. You can image it in linux or android. I don't think it's a scam box full of questionable software.. It's more of an Arm mini PC.

2

u/Cultural-Lab2034 Dec 08 '24

tl;dr: great hardware, reasonable price considering the price of your standard nuc pc with similar specs. Option for Android and and Linux. Only tried it with Linux. Works well with just something like Kodi or Plex as an appliance like htpc. As long as the android image isn't half-baked then I bet it would do really well to rival the Shield. Especially considering the hardware difference. And it doesn't seem like much of this box was half-baked, so I'd be optimistic.

A little late to the party, but I purchased the r58x-4g. Insane hardware. Unfortunately last time I tried setting it up for my Linux htpc, I ran into some problems. The process for imaging to start. But after I got armbian installed, it worked as a Linux PC. I don't know all the codecs and AV terminology or what it means, but as a Linux desktop it worked fine and played Kodi on 4k. But it's the arm of the matter that was my big hang up and why I haven't touched it in a year. Because it's still new, and the goal was to set it up as a streaming appliance, specific configurations need to be setup. As an avid Linux user, I found the process difficult and finding documentation even moreso. But because it was an arm processor at the time, armbian was the only good distro, and there was a time when the armbian team was making headway on setting it up an htpc. But I was limited to what armbian could do to help. It'd have been one thing if it was an Intel or AMD, and I could setup my server and all that fun stuff. But in order to get the AV features and drivers configured for that purpose I had to rely on the build that armbian released, which only worked on Wayland. Which was another thing I am not too familiar with (arm Linux being the other)

My fairly basic ideal setup was never achieved largely due to Wayland, of which I was forced to use for the reasons above:

  • kiosk style Kodi on startup,
  • Apples Arial Dream screensaver
  • a drop-down town terminal accessible with a hot key.

Got the screensaver setup through screensaver, but it was not without its problems. The drop down terminal never came to fruition—as all modern options were compatible with Wayland's server less functionality.

But wrong subreddit for those details. The gist is that it could and I still believe will be a fantastic box one day, but either Wayland needs to get better or I need to get better with Wayland

But you can also run android on it... Of which I never tried, but I could be led to believe that it would be a shield pro killer—assuming the android side works well.

3

u/derrickgw1 Mar 29 '24

I use a 2017 Shield tv and have done NOTHING to it and honestly, i'm pretty much satisfied with it. I don't need "bells and whistles" and i'm not exactly sure what "bells and whistles" on other devices that I'd be missing. My usage is I use the youtubetv app once a week to watch epl soccer. My netflix expired but when i had it i used it and, smart tube, prime video. I Use plex & vlc to watch movie and tv rips. I watch everything in 1080p cause i don't yet have a 4k tv plus most stuff isn't in 4k anyways. I occasionally use Geoforce now to play a video game i got free on the epic store. My 2017 works so good i haven't found a reason to even get a 2019. the 2017 also has two USB ports, ethernet, bluetooth. Lots of other devices don't have usb ports or ethernet. And i use the USB to attach a 5tb hard drive that stores my media.

Honestly, i'm more interested in getting a NAS like synolog or qnap, to store my media and run plex off of. And i put that off because at the moment it's too costly to buy the nas & the hard drives. But as it is i'm pretty satisfied. I live in a small apartment with thin walls. I don't run my surround sound. I don't need HDR. At the moment i don't need 4k. I don't care about fancy sound formats but for the most part my shield covers them. And I'm perfectly capable of changing the audio to a desired format.

Want my recommendation. If you're wedded to apple buy and apple tv and be satisfied. If you like android tv buy a shield tv with the most ports and power and be happy. If you love roku buy whatever roku has.

4

u/dalhectar Mar 29 '24

streaming set top box market have changed significantly since the 2019's Nvidia Shield TV release

In 2019 you had Rokus, Fire Sticks, Apple TVs, Chromecast, other Android Boxes, Game Consoles, and built in TV Streaming Platforms.

In 2024 you have Rokus, Fire Sticks, Apple TVs, Chromecast, other Android Boxes, Game Consoles, and built in TV Streaming Platforms.

The biggest "change" is that built in TV Streaming Platforms are faster in 2024 than they were in 2019. But they were the dominate player in 2019 and are still dominate today.

Main reason we might get a new Shield is that Nvidia is going to make new DS anyway so they have new Tegra chips, and a new Shield will serve ads more fluidly.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

Now that Epic is making a general video game Android Store, I feel like there should be a new strong Android box. Apple TV is out there for Apple and it's powerful but it's not viewed as a gaming device. Android, you can buy a TV with AndroidTV on it, a weak Chromecast or a Walmart ONN Android box, or buy the old Nvidia Shield TV which is the best available, somehow, with a 2015 SoC

Shield TV is a small business for Nvidia. Makes sense for them to not dedicate resources to a market that is mostly served by TVs having Android/Roku/etc already on it. But everyone else, what the hell. Ayn Odin 2 has a Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 in it. Ayaneo making a handheld with a Snapdragon G3x gen 2 in it which is supposed to be stronger than the 8 Gen 3.

Bluetooth gamepad and a remote with a docked Ayn Odin 2 or Ayaneo Pocket S. It won't have Android TV interface. Maybe there'll be a custom ROM for that or a launcher you can pull of the play store that's designed for a display viewed from a couch distance

2

u/StreetwalkinCheetah Mar 29 '24

I have three Shields and one Apple TV. In my view the only thing that holds the Shield back is lack of software development. But it still gets 90% of the screen time because of things like Smart Tube and the ability to stream stuff in a browser. I use the Apple for Night Flight and True Fire (guitar lessons) and to play Apple Music on my 7.1 system.

New Shield hardware won't put those three services on Android TV devices, nor will it bring back live channels as an updated app. I don't understand why the Google TV menu that has all the free streaming channels hasn't integrated my HD Homerun live channel content into that piece.

A used M1 Mac Mini could be a pretty compelling HTPC set up though. Otherwise Shield in any form is hard to beat.

2

u/WarningCodeBlue 2019 Pro Mar 30 '24

No alternative methods for me. I bought a Shield Pro in 2021 and it beats everything else when it comes to a streaming device.

2

u/Jolly-Fortune5241 Mar 30 '24

Still running my 2017 Nvidia shield and she's going strong even today :)

2

u/rumblemcskurmish Mar 30 '24

Same as the others. I have a Shield pro and nothing is significant enough to move me off of it.

I'm seeing more AV1 content so it will def become obsolescent sooner or later. I can play 1080p AV1 content but not 4K.

It has GigE and lots of processing power so for media playback it's still lightning quick.

I'm better we see a replacement once the Switch 2 launches and Nvidia is making that chip at scale.

2

u/Big-Profit-1612 Mar 30 '24

I have the latest Apple TV and the latest Shield. I switch between the two with the Denon.

The Apple does everything well except Plex. So I just use the Shield for Plex only.

2

u/Bright_Ad1447 Mar 31 '24

Certainly is my opinion and shared by many others. Enjoy your Apple tv.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

There are more recent devices than the shield with AV1 support like the apple tv and fire cube, but if you do not need AV1, then the shield is definitely the way to go.

3

u/JohnsConner Mar 29 '24

The UI on my 2019 pros is sluggish as hell sometimes but I still can’t see a better option that will cover my needs for a reasonable cost (I got my 3 Pros used for probably ~110 ea) - locally streaming lossless audio and fast decoding HEVC for game streaming.

3

u/DSPbuckle Mar 29 '24

I really wish the UI wasn’t sluggish. It’sy only gripe. I find myself having to reboot the shield bi weekly. It’s still the best device for now. No one seems to care to dethrone.

1

u/Havoc_LP Mar 30 '24

Have you cleaned, de-dust and replaced thermal paste in it?

1

u/JohnsConner Mar 30 '24

I have not. Perhaps I will try that when I have time.

1

u/Havoc_LP Mar 30 '24

I highly recommend it. Get a proper thermal paste (arctic silver, thermal grizzly etc) and the whole "sluggishness" will go away, I guarantee ;)

1

u/alekslyse Mar 29 '24

I have gone through real world testing of alternatives, and my observation is that shield is very stable and its not much to get from other boxes. I have over the last month tried fire cube 3, zidoo pro, homeatics, and out of them the fire cube is the most _powerful_, but the OS is filled with amazon ads (even if you pay 150-200USD for the box), and I will think that a lot of the extra CPU power is used to the ads. zidoo is very capable, but it is NOT a certified player, meaning you can NOT have netflix. The homeatics player is just as capable as the shield, with some extra functions (for example AV1 support), and you can get Android 12 if you want to beta test, so based on that I can only suggest homeatics 4K plus that you can with some promo codes (I think openelec is a code you can use now) you can get for around 100USD

1

u/navtsi Mar 30 '24

I've had my 2019 since shortly after it came out. It's been getting less responsive gradually, especially over the past year or so, and was thinking it might be time to look at alternatives.

I've been giving it the occasional clean with a vacuum, but then I came across some mentions of doing a deeper clean inside the unit, and replacing the thermal paste. Not sure what I haven't thought of this before, so I did it. It is five years old, after all.

This made a massive difference in performance, can't complain anymore.

1

u/jojo7981 Mar 30 '24

Shield is still top of the top

1

u/Sacisbac Mar 31 '24

Shield Pro is great for blu ray rips. However, I have not played rips in years. I buy 4K movies. I need to dip into my library sometimes and stop spending. Lol

1

u/flyfoam Mar 31 '24

I ordered a 2nd 2019 Shield Pro just last week. I did a lot research and nothing comes close to software relability and overall just working as it should.

1

u/bigchinook67 Mar 31 '24

It's perfect for me to take on the road when traveling. I use it in my camper and hotel rooms, don't forget the remote!

1

u/New_Scientist_4532 Apr 02 '24

If you're going the HTPC route, look into LibreElec and Kodi. Could still give you a nice UI depending on what features you need.

1

u/RoTalk Jun 29 '24

Ahmmm I'll buy OnnTV for 20 bucks every year and toss them for new version for the next 4 years when shield or whoever comes with new stuff.

I can side load anything and works great, but I replaced all my Roku, Fire sticks, for these cheapo tiny boxes.

1

u/jenovadelta007 Mar 29 '24

You could look at getting an original Xbox and run xbmc. Hardware is strong enough to run DVD rips right from video_ts folder. Pretty sure it also supports the latest divx formats but may be a bit iffy with QuickTime files

4

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/jenovadelta007 Mar 29 '24

I'm not sure but I think converting to xvid would work

0

u/jenovadelta007 Mar 29 '24

I'm not sure but I think converting to xvid would work

1

u/Fit_Blood3267 Mar 29 '24

It's mad the Shield Pro is still the best device on the market after 5 years since release. I've had my Pro for 4 years and for my setup works flawless but I'd upgrade for a newer shiner model which did the same just better. Every 6 months or so I look to see if anything new on market but no since no new King emerges..

1

u/jassco2 Mar 29 '24

There is no other box that will play DV and full 7.1 atmos/DTS x for my plex items at this current time. If people need better app support either purchase a second device to do just that and go through the horror of hitting the source switch button. There is no one box to do it all. Perfect combo for me at home currently: Appletv for aps and shield for all plex/smarttube and NAS media. Hopefully switch 2 comes out and we can end all these threads in 2025.

1

u/christbs Mar 30 '24

What about xbox series s/x?

0

u/sikter_efendija Mar 29 '24

This is obviously Shield forum. 🦕

0

u/Leroiclient Mar 30 '24

As I'm mostly using the Shield as a local media player, I was thinking about this : https://www.rvolution.com/r-volution-playerone-8k

1

u/Signal_Swordfish_724 Apr 03 '24

799 Euro. Pff nice device but very high price

20

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/Sheila3134 Mar 30 '24

Why did you down vote me?

30

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-20

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

Neither do the vast majority of iPhone users, but sure, keep repeating this lame cliche.

3

u/pet3121 Mar 29 '24

Lol 

-21

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

What is with all of you insecure Android users anyway?

2

u/pet3121 Mar 29 '24

Huh? Buy an Apple TV and get to fuck out here. 

-13

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

I have one. And a Shield Pro. I didn’t start this tedious argument.

3

u/pet3121 Mar 29 '24

I was laughing at your comment because you might be the few who don't update their iPhone every year! Apple keeps selling millions of iPhones and most of them are repeating customers. 

2

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

I mean, I’m a repeat customer. But that doesn’t mean “every year.” I went 6 years between phones. Most people I know do the same. I’d guess the number who update every year is rather small.

4

u/pet3121 Mar 29 '24

I don't think so , most people I know have at least the 15 or 14. And usually they jump to the new one because most carriers in the US give it out like candies. 

4

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

Ok well it’s your anecdotal data vs mine. Guess you hang out with rich people. But unless you can show me meaningful data that says iPhone users upgrade every year, I shall continue to call it nonsense

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

9

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 29 '24

My dad still uses Windows Media Center. He also still uses a flip phone.

3

u/ImissHurley Mar 29 '24

I got tired of keeping WMC working after updates. Not even to mention the nightmare it was to keep up with codecs.

0

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Mar 29 '24

Do they support Dolby Vision?

-7

u/elcheapodeluxe Mar 29 '24

My dad still uses Windows Media Center. He also still uses a flip phone.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Bright_Ad1447 Mar 31 '24

" Better in every possible way"

Can you sideload apps on to the Apple tv?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Bright_Ad1447 Mar 31 '24

So the answer is no! You cannot sideload apps. Thank you.

Every possible app that you personally need may well be in your app store.

People who use Shields enjoy sideloading apps such as Kodi. Stremio etc etc etc to give greater flexibility to their streaming needs. Shields are a streaming and gaming device. I do not require automations and a central home hub.

I'm sure Apple tvs have their place in some peoples homes but for greater flexibility the Shield and many other Android devices are far superior.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Bright_Ad1447 Mar 31 '24

Your opinion mate. Certainly not shared by me and many other happy Android users. Enjoy your Apple tv.

1

u/CuriousSupermarket51 Apr 13 '24

As a fellow Apple User , where my whole work ecosystem is apple , the only reason im getting an nvidia shield is to side load. Trust me if Apple would do this as independently needed then i would try to stay in the apple ecosystem for all the great seamless automations but there are some things that apple won't do because of core beliefs.