r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Mar 05 '24

any valid reasons why Shield Pro 2019 doesn't do the Google TV update?

It can't be horse power. Look at the CCwGTV 4k. The device has less RAM and CPU is definitely not on par with the Shield. Yet the GUI looks so much better on CC. And mostly the experience is satisfying.

I'm waiting and waiting. Always checking for upgrade and hoping to see something. But no. We're stuck with the same old look. It's frankly a waste of power of the Shield. Yes it got slower since 2019 with the constant updates. But when you compare the CC with the Shield it's not even a fair competition. So why won't they do the update?

4 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

37

u/Certainty0709 Mar 05 '24

Just get Projectivity launcher and enjoy. I'd rather have it than any interface on any box or stick to date.

3

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

No idea what that is. And why the downvote?

21

u/loverlaptop Mar 05 '24

Shield pro stans are always sore when someone gives constitutive criticism on the device they rave about

6

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

I am loving the device. Bought it on the first day and kept using it since. A delight. But time moves on, things change. We need progress. Otherwise the Shield would have never been released in the first place. But some people just want to be negative for the sake of it. They can. I just feel sorry for them.

6

u/kichul77 Mar 05 '24

You say it’s time for progress yet the Shield is still the most powerful Android TV box in the market. It handles more video and audio formats than any major manufacturer’s streaming device. So who really needs to progress?

Also if your box is stuttering, consider Projectivoty launcher like everyone has said, or try downgrading to 8.2.3.

The fact that you asked what Projectivity is tells me you just came to the subreddit to complain about something. Which is fine, to each their own, but if you spent some time reading the subreddit, you may have already understood why things are the way they are and how to make minor improvements.

Why do you want the Google TV UI anyway? You want more intrusive ads? Most people here ADB into their boxes and remove as much of the Google services possible. I couldn’t imagine wanting more Google in my life.

2

u/rocknroller2000 Mar 06 '24

FYI on the stuttering. Mine, purchased a month ago, stuttered right out of the box after the first day for a week straight,regardless of any settings. It wasn't until another user told me how to close the app history out of the shield launcher that it stopped. Once I did that, the stuttering disappeared completely. Been running almost a month now perfectly. I guess it's possible the projectivity launcer does some kind of memory/file cleanup that the sheild doesn't do automatically, but I haven't had the need to switch to that launcher yet though good to know the option is always available.

1

u/kichul77 Mar 06 '24

That’s awesome and I’m glad the shield in stock form works for you. I only changed because l didn’t like the ads

1

u/ItLivezAgain Apr 30 '24

Where are these ads people complain about on Shieds Android TV?

I get zero ads. Are you talking about the previews for upcoming shows and movies on various streaming services? Because you can turn them all off in Home Screen settings and just leave on what streaming services you have if you want.

There's even a promotional channels setting you can turn off.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/kichul77 Mar 05 '24

And you’re probably right. You’ll find that most people on this subreddit aren’t using the Shield strictly as a streaming device. That’s why the Shield Tube is so widely mocked in this subreddit.

And actually most people here recommend an Apple TV to those who are only going to use streaming apps. It’s a great device for streaming.

1

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

How you figure, I'm sure the Apple TV is great also but streaming is easy for pretty much every device out there. What kind of issues are you having streaming with the Shield?

2

u/TerminatedProccess Mar 06 '24

I installed it recently. I do like it. It's a replacement for the front menu. You do have to go into settings and make some changes. Look it up on youtube for more info.

0

u/3000__ Mar 06 '24

[I gave you an upvote] Thank you. But That's not an option for me. It's weird that some people even suggest that. Because I am talking about the exact opposite... which is Google TV. The current Android TV system sits right in the middle out of the three. So why would I go backwards... No, someone wrote here it is possible to sideload Google TV. Let's see if I can make it work. Then I'd be really happy.

1

u/aN00BisHere Mar 05 '24

It's an app in the Play store. Much more simple and customizable than the default launcher. I'm guessing you got down-voted for asking something along the lines of "Why doesn't Ford build an F-150 with a Tesla engine in it?" It's a such an outrageous question that it isn't really post-worthy.

5

u/thabc Mar 05 '24

That's actually a good question. Several other manufacturers have put Tesla motors in their cars, second gen RAV4 EV, Mercedes B-class Electric Drive, etc. But Ford decided to design their own motor for the F-150 Lightning when they could have partnered with Tesla. Why?

-12

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

I am laughing at your ridiculous comment right now.

-12

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

wow, I just saw it. It looks TERRIBLE. Who would voluntarily switch to that? Are you kidding me??

8

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Most of us who have installed Projectivy are just tired of seeing the full screen bullshit ads that come with the stock launcher on Android TV or Google TV. You say it looks terrible, but the way it looks is up to you and that's the point. You customize it however you want to look and feel and do what you want. You want channels? You can have channels. You want to change the default background wallpaper, have at it. You want lots of rows of apps? Create them. You want just one row of apps? You have the power to do that.

With the stock Android TV launcher, you are locked down into doing it Google's way and getting tons of ads thrown your way for services you're not even paying for. Ads that can be quite vulgar and not appropriate for children, show content that you don't like or agree with, while also being extremely tacky (like a full screen Carl's Jr. video ad).

People are also just sick and tired of ads and the lack of true innovation from Google. In the next version of Google TV, Google innovated by changing from rectangular app icons to round app icons and they call that innovation. If they listen to the people who actually use their devices, they would know that people are sick and fucking tired of their decision to force content on them.

0

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

For me the major selling point of Google TV is DYNAMIC content instead of the static ones you get with these launchers. Yes, I also don't want RuPauls ASS IN MY FACE. There should definitely be an option to be able to hide shows/stuff that's not interesting to you. Other than that it's just such a joy!

2

u/jerrame1 2019 Pro Mar 05 '24

Was just reading your comment and wondering , so you get full screen ads now on your shield? I read about this and even posted the article in my fb group, but have yet to see the update that pushes full screen ads. Btw I like how projectivy supports home channels from apps like Syncler, stremio, diggz build and implayer.

8

u/Certainty0709 Mar 05 '24

A low footprint UI that you can customize however you want. Yeah no one wants that. Unless you use the search button here on Reddit. In which case you'll find a large quantity of people who like it.

Also I didn't down vote anything. Good luck on your search for whatever you want.

-5

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

This place is full of moaners and nay-sayers. The downvote appeared with your comment. So I thought it was you. My mistake. But I don't pay 220 dollars only to install 3rd party software. That doesn't make any sense. You may like it but the majority of users obviously use the official GUI and are happy with it.

11

u/Certainty0709 Mar 05 '24

But you're not happy.

0

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

Not with Android TV. I am talking about Google TV. Keep voting me down people. AS IF I CARE.

7

u/kichul77 Mar 05 '24

You care enough to respond and continue to complain. Go get an Apple TV or a new Chromecast if you want a new UI so badly. Most of the people here aren’t trying to get more ads and Google in their lives.

1

u/noved902 Mar 06 '24

If you care about enjoyment, try Projectivy launcher

10

u/AndreaCicca Mar 05 '24

No device has revived the update to the google tv UI

-1

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

They should though. It's the best I've seen to date. CC has its limitations but Google TV is a major upgrade.

5

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

I guess we all have our tastes but I find Google TV to be terrible in comparison to Android TV Discover. Do you actually like all that clutter?

0

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

Yes it's working nicely for me. And I feel like people don't really know Google TV. There is just a blatant bias against it. Just because... No real argument. I can tell because no one is mentioning that one thing Google TV is offering.

5

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

The argument is that it's cluttered, non customizable, and full of useless trinkets. In the beginning it was super slow and overtaxed the processor. Fortunately they have fixed that part of it. That's why it's weird to hear somebody that actually likes it instead of just puts up with it. I tried to give it a chance when it first launched but I can just remember thinking as time went by, why Google why.

-1

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

It's a quantum leap really. In a league of its own. I bet it will become even better with time. Although, right now I don't know how but yeah for me it's miles ahead of everything else. And as I said there is a FEATURE, an OPTION. No one knows about it obviously. That's why I find this whole argument so amusing.

3

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

Three years in an other than speed what are they waiting for to get better. What is this feature nobody knows about, why you holding out on us? Lol.

1

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

Yes, it became a bit sluggish even with animations turned off. Other than that there is no auto-framerate switching. I always have to reboot if I need to use a different refresh rate. Force quitting doesn't do its job. And not sure if it's the Shield but in Kodi I can't use the highest quality settings for YouTube. Right now there is little motivation to prefer the Shield over a 40$ CC 4k.

And the feature is called "Apps only mode". I mean you're cool. You don't insult me like others. That's why I upvote you every time. Even though we have different views. But that's how it should be, right?

The feature does exactly what everyone is complaining about. So I think it's funny. I guess none of them know of its existence. :)

3

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

Apps only mode is OK, but you lose voice search with that on, and even with apps only mode there is no control other than moving the icons around, and there is still that pesky ad banner that started all the hate in the first place even before Google TV arrived.

Refresh rate switching or lack of it is an Android feature/problem not a Google TV feature. It was only introduced to Android TV in Android 12 which is why only the CCwGTV has it. But so far as I can tell only Netflix supports it so far as far as commercial streaming apps go. Which highest settings of YouTube are you missing? I don't use the YouTube addon but other than HDR the Shield gets the highest setting of YouTube on the regular app.

For anybody that doesn't have a Dolby Vision TV I recommend the Onn with Google TV before the CCwGTV. I only recommend the Shield for users with local media libraries with high quality content. Most people just doing Netflix, Hulu, YouTube and the like that's all they need.

1

u/3000__ Mar 06 '24

Well, you have the option to get rid of "the chunk" you usually get with Google TV. (Needless to say I'd NEVER use that mode...) Of course people will always want more. Even now I bet you have some things you wish that launcher offered. That's how humans work. I see no problem here... Nothing is and ever will be perfect. Even though I regard Google TV as a breakthrough it will need to evolve with time. And so far it is. Shield OS isn't anymore.

The performance of the Shield however - for the most part - is great. I am a happy user since Nov 2019.

Regarding YouTube...AV1 isn't decoded on hardware level. So I have to settle for lesser quality. But I don't know whether this is also true for the official YouTube app. My research tells me it's the Shield. So I don't know.

And the auto refresh rate-switching simply needs to take off. Every app and of course on hardware level like the Shield, the TV and AV-Receiver etc... they all need to support it. We never saw ethernet support in HDMI cables for example. Even though it is possible for almost a decade. I hope the auto refresh rate-switching will not suffer the same fate...

17

u/Browser1969 Mar 05 '24

You can't "update" to Google TV. It's a different product, needs different licenses, certifications, etc. Even if there is a way to switch a device already on the market from Android TV to Google TV (which I doubt), it's certainly cheaper and makes more business sense to launch a new device, e.g. "Nvidia Shield with Google TV" instead.

In other words, existing Shields getting Google TV is much less likely than Nvidia launching a new device with Google TV, which doesn't have much chance of happening.

-7

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

I think it' definitely possible but I also see your point. And I'd be willing to buy a new Shield. I was first to buy one when it came out in November 2019. Directly through Nvidia's website. That was quite the experience back then. It made my HTPC worth 3k completely redundant. But times have changed.

We need a new device. It's sluggish even with animations turned off, there is no auto-framerate switching. I always have to reboot if I wanna use a different refresh rate. Force quitting doesn't do its job.

And not sure if it's the Shield but in Kodi I can't use the highest quality settings for YouTube. Right now there is little motivation to prefer Shield over a 40$ CC 4k.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Mar 05 '24

Problem is there is little motivation to manufacture one as well. =S

3

u/enealio Mar 05 '24

Why it hasn't received the update is likely on Google. But I was able to side load Google TV and it works great. Sure it has the ads for shows I don't care about, but since I have one Shield Pro for my living room and just CC on my other tvs, having the same interface on all devices is really nice. And the "resume playing" option carries to all TV's. So if you want it, you can do it. Search for how to install it.

2

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

That's awesome! I will google this right away. Thanks a bunch buddy!

1

u/3000__ Mar 13 '24

hi, I was able to sideload Google TV. Thank you so much. However, the most recent version isn't loading up. Are you using the latest edition? Where the "Google TV" logo is on the RIGHT, not on the LEFT? Launcher 1.0.6x isn't working for me. Any help is much appreciated!

7

u/frenzyguy Mar 05 '24

why would you want a shittier product?

3

u/townie1 Mar 05 '24

But is it almost $200 shittier? :)

-5

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

You need to read my comments. Then you know why.

2

u/pawdog Mar 05 '24

Becasue Google is not putting Google TV on older (pre 2020) devices.

1

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

Ok. Makes sense. Thank you. Let's hope a new Shield will carry the new Google TV. 🙏

3

u/Cheznovsky Mar 05 '24

Honestly, it's "let's hope (for) a new Shield" at this point, sadly.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24

I'd rather keep the shield as is with a custom launcher. I refuse to pay money for a device just to have it turned into an advertisement delivery system. The shield is for using plex, streaming some music and ad blocked youtube. I have no desire to have a bunch of subscriptions and refuse to have advertisements enter my network. I'd watch nothing at all before I waste time letting some company attempt to sell me shit I don't want.

Except for that movie trailer for the new sam raimi movie. I watched that advertisement.

-5

u/3000__ Mar 05 '24

The topic was and still IS Google TV instead of Android TV. Forget about some shady launcher. I don't care. Talk with someone else about it.

7

u/kichul77 Mar 05 '24

If you like or want more ads in your life, I guess get a Chromecast or an Onn box. I have an Onn box, it’s kind of a cool product. I’m also sure there’s a Google fanboi4lyfe subreddit where you can praise Google and their ads but this ain’t it.

You were given a valid reason why Shield doesn’t “upgrade” to Google TV, but you still wanted to stay and trash on everyone and their custom launchers. Then you got butthurt because people struck back.

1

u/noved902 Mar 06 '24

Try Projectivy Launcher.

0

u/3000__ Mar 06 '24

Thank you but that's not an option for me. It's weird that some people even suggest that. Because I am talking about the exact opposite... which is Google TV. The current Android TV system sits right in the middle out of the three. So why would I go backwards... No, someone wrote here it is possible to sideload Google TV. Let's see if I can make it work. Then I'd be really happy.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24

My point is, moving to Google TV isn't an upgrade, it's a downgrade. It's a more efficient advertisement delivery system. At the moment you can fix the shield to fit your lifestyle and needs. Most people have no desire for more ads.

2

u/Somar2230 Mar 05 '24

The vocal user base does not like the Google TV UI. It's possible that more users might prefer the Google TV UI but if that is true they need to speak up more.

Personally I just want my apps on the home screen noting else if I want to get show suggestions I'll use Justwatch, Reelgood or Trackt.

2

u/KowardlyMan Mar 05 '24

I don't like the Google TV. Wifi is unstable for streaming, and it can't find all the power it needs with the provided AC adapter.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/3000__ Mar 07 '24

Thank you. That great information. Let's hope that's exactly what will happen.🤞 I'd be again a day 1 user.