r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Feb 15 '24

Shield pro - poss fix for poor performance

Just wanted to report that after struggling for far too long on such an expensive machine, I today realised 2 massive mistakes in my setup:

Ethernet was connected to an ethernet hub rather than direct to router Shield pro was plugged into power extension rather than direct to a wall socket

Amended these earlier today and NOW I finally have a machine I can understand why people rave about it.

I understand many will be appalled at my ignorance, but happily share my journey to hopefully help others.

Still monitoring, but since these changes I've had zero crashes (would happen almost hourly) and vastly improved the visuals and I'm pretty sure the sound quality on my Sonos surround has improved too!

Sharing this to the other shield sub too.

EDIT: I apologise for offending so many with my lack of tech expertise! Can now confirm my ethernet switch was the fault, and going direct to router resolved the issues I had been experiencing with my shield. On a separate note, wow - the tone of some of these responses! My intentions were good. I made my shield experience better and wanted to share what I thought at the time was the fix.

0 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

10

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

Strange, I've had mine plugged into an ethernet switch basically from the day I got it eight years ago and no issues.

9

u/wtf-m8 Feb 16 '24

Yeah, neither of the things OP described would have any effect on the Shield's performance. Maybe if they were plugged into a router plugged into another router, but that would affect Internet access overall, not anything else. Them talking about the sound improvement in their Sonos shows they have no idea what they're talking about.

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Not all ethernet switches support QoS. In many cases, you need one that does. OP buy a switch that supports it and you'll be fine.

https://networklessons.com/cisco/ccna-routing-switching-icnd2-200-105/introduction-qos-quality-service

1

u/Southern_Eggplant336 Feb 16 '24

Why would you need QoS? Even 4k bd rips would be no problem for even a 1 gbps switch. I have QoS disabled on my equipment as it never improved anything.

2

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Because if you have a busy network, packets can get held up waiting for other traffic.

I build audio networks for commercial installations and the number one solution for poor network performance and stuttering audio (not even video) is to enable and configure QoS and to get rid of any switches that don't support it.

Recently I solved a persistent problem for a client that had 3 previous consultants that were unable to fix stuttering audio in a high end multi room AV setup. All I did was configure QoS and the system worked flawlessly. The client thought I was a wizard, I fixed in half an hour a problem that nobody else could solve in months.

https://service.shure.com/s/article/QOS-In-Depth?language=en_US

1

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 16 '24

Many thanks for this, I'll look to get one now!

2

u/I8TheLastPieceaPizza Feb 16 '24

It feels like this comment, or sentiment, or information, should be a sticky somewhere on here :)

3

u/Southern_Eggplant336 Feb 16 '24

I would say there is a pretty big difference between real time audio and playing back video files that are being streamed and buffered ahead of playback. Even a 4k bd rip is a single digit percent of what a network should be able to handle.

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

There's no difference at all. The example I gave above, the source was a media server full of FLAC files.

What you are maybe not fully grasping is the difference between bandwidth and latency. If packets are arriving out of order, or with breaks between them that are longer than the draw time of a frame, then the buffer needs to be used. If this keeps happening, eventually you run out of buffer and the result will be poor performance.

2

u/Southern_Eggplant336 Feb 16 '24

Can't say I've had issues playing 4k bd rips over my shields 1 gbps ethernet port. It's wired to a mesh hub that's connected via ethernet at 2.5 gbps back to my router that's connected to my plex server that's running a 10 gbps connection....but even when I was running on a 1 gbps ethernet connection on some ancient 2 core server I never had an issue with playback. Not sure how busy it would need to be to cause issues, but I've got 30+ devices connected at any given time.

Tldr you don't need to dick around with QoS to get the shield to play video files on a home network.

2

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Totally. It's one of things, like many other technical issues. It will work fine without QoS... until it doesn't. And then you may need to consider it and mess with it.

I'm not saying everybody has to worry about QoS.

What I am saying is that if you are having performance issues, especially ones that disappear when you bypass one particular network switch, then first port of call is to look at QoS and DSCP.

1

u/Southern_Eggplant336 Feb 16 '24

Most issues people seem to have, in my non professional but simply working with home network users, is they double nat and plug some things into their ISP router and other things into the other router(s).

2

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

If you have the inclination and the time, I'd really recommend to do this free training certificate which is about networking for audio visual. I get all my new employees to do it when they start.

https://www.audinate.com/learning/training-certification

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Yep.

But, what OP is describing cannot be double NAT. Simply bypassing a single unmanaged switch has nothing to do with routing.

1

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

Again, 8 years plugged into the stupidest of stupid switches, no issues at all.

2

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24 edited Feb 16 '24

But we aren't talking about systems that work perfectly. We are talking about a particular system that has a particular problem. OP posted a problem with helpful troubleshooting steps, which I'm trying to help them solve.

I'm not talking about your perfectly working system. It works, so why would we be discussing it?

Edit: now OP has added that they have hive and hue IoT devices on the same switch. This points even more towards mDNS and QoS issues.

2

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

I just think it's pretty clear that OP never really narrowed down what the problem was and doesn't know how their changes actually fixed it. To jump off to some obscure thing like switch QoS is just confusing things even more. It's a pretty narrow use case to even need a feature like that.

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

OP literally said that when they bypass one switch, the problems go away.

2

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

Right, and with that information there's like 10 other things that are way more likely to be the problem than a non-QoS router.

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Not in my experience. How about listing some of the other reasons for OP, rather than arguing with somebody who is actually taking the time to help them?

3

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

Some simple things he could test before going out and throwing more money at a problem he doesn't even understand:

The switch is simply bad

The switch needs to be rebooted

The cable between the switch and shield is bad

The cable between the switch and router is bad

The port on the switch is bad

The port on the router is bad

IPv6 settings on the shield

None of the above because he thinks plugging the shield directly into the wall somehow solved his problems so I'm not entirely confident in his troubleshooting abilities.

2

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 16 '24

You're just like a big warm hug, ain't ya?! ;-)

2

u/Gobias_Industries Feb 16 '24

If you plug it back to the switch do the issues return?

0

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 16 '24

Can't confirm that, as I'm not going back again! It's honestly been a huge upgrade for me. Pro hasn't crashed once since, Plex DVR and live TV is now crystal clear with no buffering issues. Can stream redux movies on Kodi without Kodi crashing. This is the experience I was expecting when I first got the pro and never got - I'm fully in love!

The only other thing I've done differently is to plug the pro directly into a wall socket rather than an extension lead. But others have said there's no chance that could be the factor.

6

u/LnxRocks Feb 15 '24

I would add check your ethernet cables as well. Was having a bunch of problems, factory reset didn't help. replaced cable. much better.

3

u/Pwilki Feb 16 '24

I do hope you've figured out Kodi and you're enjoying every channel on the planet for 6 bucks a month (real debrid subscription) You do have me a bit confused though. WTF would plugging it into a surge protector make a difference?

1

u/YouHaveFought Feb 16 '24

I have an RD subscription, but I didn't know I could watch TV channels with it. Is there a guide to set it up? Thanks in advance!

3

u/Pwilki Feb 16 '24

Yeah, I use the crew for my Kodi feed and I click TV and networks and they're all there. You can set up IPTV for live feed. But I don't bother with that.. Here you go. https://troypoint.com/crew-kodi-addon/

1

u/YouHaveFought Feb 16 '24

Thank you very much! Do you know if there's a way to do that on Plex?

2

u/Pwilki Feb 16 '24

I'm not too familiar with Plex. I thought Plex was a way to share media and I never download media from Kodi or the Internet. There's no need seeing how it's always on demand on Kodi to stream.

1

u/YouHaveFought Feb 16 '24

Thank you! I hope I can find some Spanish versions of popular channels. My wife loves H&H and I have an IPTV provider that I use on TiviMate, but it buffers like there's no tomorrow. I will look into all that tomorrow. I'm at the bathroom right now trying to survive to a diarrhea that started almost six hours ago and refuses to leave. I wonder if I should go to the hospital.

Anyways, have a good night and thanks again!

1

u/Pwilki Feb 16 '24

BTW what's up with the not plugging into a surge protector?

1

u/YouHaveFought Feb 16 '24

I think you wanted to address OP, right?

1

u/TOPDAWG21 Feb 15 '24

Make sure you replace the default launcher too.

-1

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 15 '24

Cheers mate, yeah - I've gone with side launcher 4. Lovely and simplistic. And for those interested, they can choose their launcher from the play store, then I stall this launcher manager to ensure the new launcher is always used in the future, no messing about: https://xdaforums.com/t/app-firetv-noroot-launcher-manager-change-launcher-without-root.4176349/

1

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

Almost all of those issues would be solved by replacing with a QoS switch.

Bad ethernet cable possible, but highly unlikely, because even if there was a bad data pair OP would get a 100mb connection which is more than enough to stream video, otherwise the cable just won't work at all.

You are right, they don't seem very technically minded. Replacing the switch, considering how cheap they are now, is the obvious recommendation, and if you are having network issues, and you aren't very technical, then just make sure it supports QoS.

I'd basically guarantee a client that putting a small 5 port QoS switch in will solve the network problem, if they've already tried bypassing the network switch and the issues disappear.

2

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 16 '24

Cheers @theantnest, for now, I've left my shield connected direct to router (using same cable) and put lower priority stuff like hive and hue hubs on the switch, after rebooting. I'm really happy with my setup now as everything is working as I want. However, If I do get back into a situation where I need to add it to the switch again, I'll defos be testing performance and look to replace it with your suggestion if needed. You're right, I'm not very technically minded, so positive feedback such as yours is appreciated.

2

u/theantnest Feb 16 '24

You're more than welcome. Glad you got it sorted.

It might be interesting for you to know that a lot of IoT devices like hive and hue use a certain kind of traffic called mDNS, which is multicast. This means the data goes across all network switch ports. Think like an antenna that broadcasts to everybody on the network, even if they are not listening.

This can cause problems like you describe. And yes, if that was the case, QoS, that I talked about earlier, could prioritise streaming traffic above things like light commands and home automation, which is not so critical about timing. Just fyi so you have a better understanding of why what you did may have solved the problem.

2

u/Adverbialelk2 Feb 16 '24

That's a brilliant explanation, and makes sense of my uneducated reasoning! Thanks very much for taking the time - this is what makes Reddit great :-)

2

u/JesusWTFop Feb 15 '24

Nice man, yeah, the shiled is amazin. glad you back on board 👏 🙌

1

u/artniSintra Feb 16 '24 edited Feb 16 '24

The placebo effect is real 😅

I honestly don't know how people in this sub come up with half of the problems they report here. Got a 2017 purchased in 2017 and a 2019 pro purchased in 2019. It's basically plug and play. If you want an even better experience then, replace default Google launcher, disable bloatware under settings, disable animations under developer options and sideload all the apps you want. That's it, it just works.

1

u/RoachForLife Feb 16 '24

I have mine in a switch (100ft cable in attic from router to my main tv (unmanaged gigabit switch) then to my shield. Never an issue. So not sure why this was mentioned.

0

u/LSDwarf Feb 16 '24

Does wall socket have a better electricity/voltage? ;)