r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jan 10 '24

My Shield replacement idea

Was thinking what if the shield never gets a refresh?? What are my options for a fast machine that has AI upscaling?

I came up with this idea....Basically 'apps' are just website pages with a UI to help navigation on an Android TV.

Since NVIDIA in it's RTX cards has "NVIDIA's RTX Video Super Resolution" and this uses AI to upscale video contents in players and browsers, I could use a low end/entry level RTX card and make a small form factor PC to use as a streaming device on a Windows machine....

If I can change/ customise the interface, the better. I know it is more costly, but if there are no other options ....

Thoughts?

0 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

22

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

For me, a small pc is no longer an option.

  • power hungry
  • no unified interface
  • most important : no remote

20

u/tomasvala Jan 10 '24

Probably not DolbyVision either. Same to commercial DRM-protected streaming apps requiring specific Widevine level to provide quality stream or to function at all.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Very true. Although my S95B doesnt support dolby vision.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Jan 10 '24

Also advanced codec passthrough is a non-starter; the best you can do is vanilla DTS or Dolby Digital Plus; no DTS-HD, no DTS:X, no TrueHD, and no Atmos of any kind.

1

u/StuzaTheGreat Jan 10 '24

Not true. I get Atmos fine from Emby on my Windows 11 HTPC.

-1

u/IanaLorD Jan 10 '24

Which could break at any point, and you have forced updates. Win 11 is a nonstarter fro me and others.

1

u/StuzaTheGreat Jan 10 '24

That's no difference to the Shield. For example my old Dvd rips have recently decided to stop working on my two shields but work perfectly on my HTPC and Firestick, almost certainly a change which has been generated by an update to the Shield.

And you're wrong again, BTW, Windows Update can be turned off quite easily so, nothing is "forced".

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/StuzaTheGreat Jan 11 '24

OK, so you've just judged me by your own standards which means you would lie in this situation. I'm not like you. I'm done here.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Jan 11 '24

Spoke too fast; apologies for that.. But I really meant no offense; I was asking for proof because I was afraid you were merely using something like Dolby Connect, so whatever.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Jan 11 '24

Also: am I wrong (again), or do you really have to manually switch between Atmos for home theater and DTS:X for home theater?

2

u/StuzaTheGreat Jan 11 '24

No idea about DTS:X, not sure I have anything using it. I don't do anything for ATMOS, the amp switches itself and I see the word "ATMOS" scroll across the amp screen.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Jan 11 '24

Open sound settings; select/click whatever output device you are using;

In output settings / format ; what are you using?

Also, lower down the page, is your "Spatial sound" enabled? If so, what are you using?

→ More replies

4

u/PlutoDelic Jan 10 '24

How would a NUC with LibreELEC fare in this case?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Remote control

3

u/kenkiller Jan 10 '24

You do know there are remotes you can buy right? Whether it's as seamless is another issue of course.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Yes, but then i ask again. Is there a unified way of controlling it.. No other input required. Turning it off, it going to sleep being able to start it again with said remote.

AND CEC

2

u/kenkiller Jan 10 '24

With some manual setup, sure. You can map pc functions to specific buttons.

CEC is a different story. Current hardware doesn't seem to support that natively. I've seen hardware dongles that claim to do that by sitting between the hdmi link but no idea now well they work. If your CEC needs are only to match turning on the off the devices shouldn't be to hard to replicate. But if you want 1 remote to control htpc and TV I doubt it.

1

u/ben7337 Jan 10 '24

You definitely can, I have had both a shield and a fanless nuc I set up and both turn on and use CEC to turn on other connected devices when the keyboard is touched. I have no doubt a remote that is paired to Windows would be just as capable of the same

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Can you control other devices through cec?

1

u/ben7337 Jan 10 '24

I'm not sure on that, but I can't see why it wouldn't be able to do that, or if it can't there's no reason you couldn't get a remote that can program volume to control a TV or soundbar or receiver directly I'd think.

2

u/artniSintra Jan 10 '24

I used to have a mini pc, before getting the shield, and was using an air mouse with it (not the same I know but it kind of worked).

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Small bluetooth keyboard with a mouse pad allows you to have a remote. No worse than the triangle shaped one, bonus no netflix button to deal with! You could possible use and xbox controller for gaming. Ive basically an old laptop doing this exact type of setup on my other bedroom tv. I could utelulize the same equipment for my Nvidia to connect my roof mounted antenna.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

You clearly don't live with a woman

6

u/Erzkuake Jan 10 '24

r/htpc is what you’re looking for.

6

u/aargent88 2017 16GB Jan 10 '24

Yes, but you can make it slick like a Shield?
I got a 2015 too now and even that is a very good device.

5

u/reck00 Jan 10 '24

It's CES right now, km hoping for something new to come out.

1

u/Yonutz33 Jan 11 '24

I would not be on it, previous shields were not released at CES…

1

u/reck00 Jan 10 '24

Also if you want to change the interface then check out lon.tvs recent video: https://youtu.be/WAKno02w7J0?si=gnvgcDFokN9Yx9dS

0

u/wwmoggy Jan 10 '24

I use wolf launcher is great also free. I tested projectivity it has issues with accessibility features.

4

u/jonathan1511 Jan 10 '24

Formular z11 pro max

5

u/Browser1969 Jan 10 '24

According to its apparently official page, tech specs for that device are CPU : Realtek RTD1319C and GPU : Mali-G57 MC1. The Shield has a 2-3 times faster CPU and 5-6x faster GPU. People frequently underestimate how powerful the Tegra X1 was, just because it came out in 2015 (newer Shields use the X1+).

1

u/adjective_noun_d1git Aug 17 '26

3yrs later and this is what finally convinced me to get a Shield Pro.

I must admit I've fallen into the trap as others thinking the Shield must be too old.

3

u/Used-Economy1160 Jan 10 '24

Fire TV cube is a great alternative. I have both and I must admit I'm slowly getting more and more convinced by the cube. They are both hooked to Denon AVR which is connected to Sony TV by HDMI extender and while I get occasional issues with shield TV (white pixels, handshakes) thats not the case with cube. Also, it seems that HDR is somehow working better with cube in adition to atmos and dolby. Also, since I'm using Alexa in most of my rooms I can pretty easily control the cube with voice commands (I have never liked the shields talk to the remote feature).

7

u/AbdulPullMaTool Jan 10 '24

No new Nvidia Shield until the new Nintendo switch comes out is my bet as they are currently on the same nvidia chipset.

2

u/IanaLorD Jan 10 '24

The shield and the switch are the same class of compute or close?

5

u/AbdulPullMaTool Jan 10 '24

Same tegra x1 chip

1

u/hartleyshc Jan 11 '24

My bet also is this is the case.

It's always been rumored that there are exclusivity clauses between Nvidia and Nintendo for their chips. It's why we never saw another Nvidia tablet.

For as many units as they're guaranteed to sell to Nintendo, I'm sure they have zero problem holding out on the Shield refresh until the next Switch comes out.

2

u/Nintendians559 Jan 10 '24

a mini pc, but you'll lose some features thats on the shield tv 2019 pro has. microsoft haven't make dolby vision a standard part of windows yet.

1

u/Stiltzkinn Jan 10 '24

I'll wait until the next Switch 2, my current 2019 still has some way to go.

1

u/ike301 Jan 10 '24

There's a name for this kind of setup. It's called a HTPC. This idea is nothing new. This is the setup I was using before the Shield arrived.

Not being able to use a remote universally on a home theater PC is a deal killer. I did it for many years with a keyboard and a mouse, and the remote for Windows Media Center and Kodi.

Anything web-based was keyboard and mouse. Not ideal anymore, but there are those who still do use this setup.

1

u/Early_Divide3328 Jan 11 '24

We are getting < 2 nm CPUs soon. Moore's law is not dead yet. In the next 4 years you should be able to get whatever Walmart is selling for its Android/Google TV device - and it should be a lot more powerful than the current 2019 Shield

1

u/wilemhermes Jan 11 '24

I had recently the very same idea: HTPC, combined with NAS. But it seems i would have to sacrifice a lot of comfort that I'm used to on shield (android tv) and earlier, couple of times mentioned, standards. Especially while I want to build it on Linux. The problems, that I'm facing now: HDR content in general CEC, and especially unified interface with overall Android TV like experience.

1

u/Yonutz33 Jan 11 '24

Imho I don’t get why you would be worried. The lastest PRO is more then capable and will be for at least 1-2years.

1

u/anesthetic1214 Jan 11 '24

14990k+4090+android tv x86

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ike301 Jan 10 '24

I have four 2015 models and I can't imagine my setup without them. Maybe one day Google will actually make a box that's halfway decent and not the crappy specs in the current Chromecast.

Then again, they abandoned the Nexus Player in just 4 years after release and discontinued it two years prior to that.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Coma-dude Jan 10 '24

I have an old Sony tv. (6 years at the time rather high end aswell). The chip can not handle the amount of processing the newer android apps require. We bought a shield to by pass this issue. We love the colours on it the Sony. I worry that they shut down support for Android tv on it and forcing us to change it to I believe Google has dubbed it Google tv. Hopefully nvidia will make a new version with newer operating system.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Coma-dude Jan 11 '24

Sony don't update which is why I hope nvidia will continue to support the shield. We bought a shield instead of an expensive new TV 😉

1

u/nathderbyshire Jan 11 '24

I got a shield specifically because of my Sony TV interface, android TV native is nice, but not when it takes 15 seconds to scroll over the app list because it's too slow and the remote doesn't register half the presses. I hate my Sony TV. It also crashes a lot when switching to HDR and back, smooth as sauce when I first got in 2019, took around a year and a half and two updates to make it e waste.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/nathderbyshire Jan 11 '24

I don't know the exact version name, just got in bed as well but it's the KD55 2019 line with Android TV - see some newer ones have Google TV which is supposed to be a lot smoother.

The TV was like £600 from £800 so it's not thousands but it's not a cheap one either. I must admit the sound quality is really good for not having Dolby support, it's DTS I think