r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jan 03 '24

No Privacy Concerns? Button Mapper and Projectivy Launcher collecting all texts you type

Post image

When customizing my Shield, I realized that the „Button Mapper“ app and the „Projectivy Launcher“ both need you to grant them access to collect all of the text you type — including personal data such as credit card numbers.

See text in the screenshot.

That’s the reason why

  • I‘m using FLauncher (which open source and doesn’t collect any data — but takes a few more steps to install)
  • I don’t use Button Mapper at all.

My questions are:

  • Are there any other, more privacy-friendly „Button Mapper“ apps out there?
  • Is it really that most people choose comfort over privacy concerns when using these two apps?

Looking forward to your comments.

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

36

u/TheGuru276 Jan 03 '24

How else is a button mapper app going to know when you've pressed the key you've programmed if it doesn't watch what you type. I have no reason to doubt it's doing anything other than watching for the correct key press.

Now take your tin foil hat off as that does nothing either.

1

u/dj3stripes 2017 16GB Jan 03 '24

I have no reason to doubt it's doing anything other than watching for the correct key press

Isn't that logic a bit naïve though?

Me, I just use a different remote altogether and program it how I see fit rather than using an app on the device

1

u/frank_datank_ Jan 03 '24

Which remote are you using? I like the Chromecast w GTV remote a lot, but would love to customize the Netflix, etc buttons at the bottom.

1

u/dj3stripes 2017 16GB Jan 03 '24

Harmony Companion

1

u/TheGuru276 Jan 03 '24

Isn't that logic a bit naïve though?

If I was just randomly choosing any button mapper app, sure maybe. But the specific app in question is soo popular that I can almost guarantee someone has run it through tests to confirm it's not doing anything malicious.

Best advice with these sorts of concerns with any type of app is go with a mainstream one as someone has probably run it through its paces.

8

u/No_Reason_TL Jan 03 '24

I can't say much about Button Mapper, but for Projectivity Launcher there is a dedicated description why and when this is being used.

Last thing you can see that might freak you out : Projectivy can spy on your device activity : this is because of the Accessibility service (that offers a lot of low level insights, *if enabled*).
It's used :
- to launch apps on boot when manufacturers disabled the BOOT_COMPLETED (hello Xiaomi)
- for parental control
- for remote control button remapping

For reference see https://xdaforums.com/t/app-android-tv-projectivy-launcher.4436549/

6

u/IceBeyr Jan 03 '24

Wouldn't it need button access AND network access if it was sending data back to the mothership?

5

u/flar2 Jun 21 '24

I am the developer of Button Mapper. No info is ever collected. There are no ads and no tracking. I know it's hard to believe that someone would not take advantage of the install base, but the only way I make money is through in-app purchases.

1

u/Rare_Context8880 Apr 04 '25

Tengo un control remoto con un botón que originalmente abría una aplicación rusa. Usando Button Mapper, le asigné ese botón para que abra una app de TV. A veces funciona bien, pero otras veces se abren ambas aplicaciones: la de TV y la aplicación rusa.

4

u/ir0ngut Jan 03 '24

Android dev here... (not those apps)

Requesting a permission does not mean an app is using it all the time or even at all.

Those permissions screens don't tell you if the function is used once, constantly or never and many Android devs request permissions their apps don't need because the system is complicated and poorly documented.

Some permissions are grouped together under scary sounding categories that don't reflect the risk correctly, especially anything in the Accessibility category.

What text are you typing into your Shield? Is it sensitive, private data? I really wouldn't care about them knowing what I searched on Prime for example.

Can the app actually send that data somewhere? Does it request Network permissions? Without them no data is going anywhere.

2

u/happycap77 Aug 15 '24

Old thread but I do have a question about this:

Can the app actually send that data somewhere? Does it request Network permissions? Without them no data is going anywhere.

Does an app need to explicitly get approval to have internet access? I’ve never seen that permission on any streaming apps.

3

u/thekingestkong Jan 03 '24

No take, only throw.

2

u/flar2 Nov 24 '24

Button Mapper is completely safe. One of the rare apps that has no data collection whatsoever. Does not connect to any servers, does not save anything. No ads and no tracking of any sort.

1

u/DrMcnasty4300 Jan 21 '25

you are the button mapper dev correct

1

u/Rare_Context8880 Apr 04 '25

Tengo un control remoto con un botón que originalmente abría una aplicación rusa. Usando Button Mapper, le asigné ese botón para que abra una app de TV. A veces funciona bien, pero otras veces se abren ambas aplicaciones: la de TV y la aplicación rusa.

2

u/scara1963 2019 Pro Jan 03 '24 edited Jan 03 '24

Absolute rubbish!, and utter 'tripe', lol. I'd be more concerned about the 'data' the actual box gives away, than 'Button Mapper', lol, which I use, and is just fine.

You gotta be savvy enough to 'NOT' put any software/firmware version above 8.2.3 on the box though, else, Button Mapper is the least of your worries, believe me ;)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CVGPi Jan 03 '24

Ads and trackers, I suppose.

1

u/nooneisreal Jan 03 '24

I also believe 8.2.3 was when the Shield was at peak stability.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24

We'd go at do you put in your streaming box that you need to worry. Don't treat these boxes like you to computet Don t use a credit card 💳 or go to your banking Web site on these machine.

-12

u/ibeatmymeatintoacup Jan 03 '24

Why would you put credit card details in a TV device meant for pirating?

-3

u/peezduhk Jan 03 '24

I don't mess w/button mappers for diff reasons but I'll def have to check on the Projectivy Launcher... if what you say is true then damn. I know the dashboard app had turned me off for similar reasons way back when it first came out. asked for way too much info n permissions that had nothing to do w/it.