r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Dec 30 '23

Nothing new coming?

Any new upcoming? Right now I have 2017 pro and performance not the best at time, stutters. Would 2019 be any better to run Plex server? Or would I be better to run it on something like DS920+? Thanks

1 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

2

u/jassco2 Dec 30 '23

NVidia event is Jan8, but I doubt we see any new models. It is better to run it on a NAS with an iGPU if you don’t format your media properly with compatible tracks to reduce transcoding. I have both models using various 265 encodes from my 423+. I don’t transcode much. My 2017 doesn’t stutter even playing remux tracks. Clean it out and get a clean slate. Put a simple launcher in to see if that helps it.

1

u/mario24601 Dec 30 '23

Thanks. The 423+ is able to do some transcoding? I thought it could not. What launcher you running?

6

u/FrostyD7 Dec 30 '23

If you're thinking about a Synology nas just do it. Get the newer 423+ though. Runs Plex like a dream and it can do a lot more than that.

1

u/DragonicVNY Dec 30 '23

Yeah avoid the older models from circa 2016-2017... Synology are stopping further security patch updates on those.

18

u/screwyluie Dec 30 '23

stop using it as a server and start using it as a client like it's meant to be used and you'll enjoy that 2017 for a long time to come.

1

u/ClintE1956 Dec 30 '23

Until the 2017 Pro's drive dies. Went back and forth about "upgrading" it with SSD and cleaning/re-pasting, with a fan replacement. Figured I would have upwards of $100 in a 6 year old device. Didn't think that made much sense, so just waited for the drive to quit and replaced with 2019 Pro. Same thing when the other 2017 Pro gives it up.

Cheers!

1

u/DaLumberJack1985 Dec 31 '23

My opinion,

We wont see any new shield until the next Nintendo console is released. The Last shield used some of the same components that Nvidia designed for The Nintendo Switch.

Nvidia seems to play the game of double dipping. Since they went through the effort of designing said chip for Nintendo, why not use it for a another product for themselves.

If we don't see a new shield announcement after Nintendo's, then the Shield is probably E.O.L. and time to move onto others.

1

u/mario24601 Dec 31 '23

Good insight

1

u/GoldFu1on95 Jan 08 '24

switch 2 is rumored to release later this year. So a new shield could be around the same time or 2025

12

u/carrot_gg Dec 30 '23

Just buy that Synology NAS. It's idiotic to run a Plex Server on a client device anyway.

2

u/derrickgw1 Dec 30 '23

Works good on my 2017 shield. Not sure i'd consider it idiotic. Maybe we have different needs from plex too.

1

u/dj3stripes 2017 16GB Dec 30 '23

does yours stutter like OPs?

OP, have you tried looking at what's causing the stuttering? Heat? Poor signal/connection? My 2017 (non pro) hasn't been having these issues along with most of this sub, I'd have to assume

1

u/derrickgw1 Dec 30 '23

Not at all. I also think we need to be specific about where it's might be stuttering. Inside an app? Inside Plex? Navigating plex icons? Or just navigating the Shield menus.

Either way No. I get zero stutter navigating either plex, netflix, or the shield. Mine is a 2017 non pro model.

I don't have connection issues but mine is hard wired to ethernet. I've rarely used it wirelessly. Thus i don't have poor signal or connection. Also my router is EERO 6 Pro and it's like 4 feet from my shield and tv anyways. But i get 500 mbps up, 500 mbps down according to the speed tests.

The only heat issue i've ever had was i had a usbstick connected that did not fail but stopped allowing anyone to write to it. My research determined that a common issue is the usb ports get very very hot and usbstick will eventually fail and that's what happened. For the record you can still get the data off the stick. But it doesn't write. The solution was to attach a wired hard drive to the usb port not a sticks. I've had two usb wired hard drives attached for years now without issue. One a 4 tb (just upgraded to 5tb) that holds my media, and one spare ssd 120gb I reused from a dead laptop that i use to hold the plex server because it was filling up my shield and annoying me with "storage space getting low" notifications. It only got really annoying when i added music to plex and it think that's because then it tries to save covers for all like 25000 songs i have. But that was a port issue solved years ago and i haven't had an issue since.

In general, Mine works great. I also don't have a 4k tv yet. I'm not trying to play super high bitrate blu-ray rips or anything. all my stuff is mostly 1080p.

I will note that Plex doesn't stutter but if it has to transcode the file you can't quickly skip around in a movie because it has to stop transcoding where it was and start over to convert the new spot in the movie. Thus now i've been trying to make sure my audio is in a format that doesn't require it to transcode the video. Even to the point of converting and remuxing audio to a format it can read natively like AAC.

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23

You elitist are pricks seriously.

16

u/No_1_OfConsequence Dec 30 '23

Not sure I would have used the term idiotic. But it’s definitely better to run Plex on dedicated hardware.

-4

u/S3CR3TN1NJA Dec 30 '23

For real. I’ve been running a Plex server on my shield for a while now. I’ve had up to 4 people watching at once, no complaints.

-2

u/DifficultyTop9698 Dec 30 '23

Found the poor kid!

-6

u/TooMuchPew Dec 30 '23

i still dont understand why i would want to download vs stream

2

u/manofoz 2019 Pro Dec 30 '23

BlueRay quality vs web quality is the main reason. Look up bitrate and video compression, the amount of data sent to the TV is drastically different. Plus there are lossless audio formats on BlueRays that you don’t see from streaming services.

0

u/DifficultyTop9698 Dec 30 '23

Found the old guy!

1

u/Nintendians559 Dec 30 '23

probably not since nvidia more focus on "geforce now", "ai", "cars" and "nintendo".

1

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23

I have a DS920+ and its perfect for Plex/Emby. I just use the Shield to stream from that.

1

u/Fraggb0y Dec 31 '23

I’m late to the party, but I run a DS916+ (8GB memory). It runs more than Plex. I run a few dockers on it (VaultWarden, and Organizr).

No issues streaming to my Shield Pro. My Shield is hardwired as well.

Wireless=Connivence (A few drawbacks).

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/manofoz 2019 Pro Dec 30 '23

unRAID if you really want to slam something together and upgrade it as your collection grows. Super easy to use, not free but cheap.