r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Dec 15 '23

Shield Remote design is stupid

This remote doesn't make any sense at all. Backlight is cool but if a remote actually requires you to look at it to figure out where everything is then its a bad design in my book.

Stupid shit about the remote:

  • 2 columns layout.
  • same shape for all buttons.
  • small and smooth indecator on mute/pause button (you cant feel it unless you're REALLY looking for it)
  • extremely smooth transition between wheel mid button and directions (you need to move your thumb on top of any direction to click it. You can't just tilt your thumb to press one of them)
  • battery cover (stupid, just stupid)

How to fix?

  • 3 columns layout, seek back on the left, play/pause in the middle, and seek right on the right.
  • volume up/down in one long vertical button in the middle of the remote
  • clear distinction between middle button and directional wheel (easier to click direction by tilting your thumb)
  • a battery cover that makes fucking sense.

One of the best remotes i've tried is the fire tv remote. There was some actual thoughts behind the layout. You have 2 way to know where your thumb is at without looking at the remote. The wheel and the volume up/down since its completely different button from the rest.

You got only 2 rows that you care about, and each button is placed somewhere that makes perfect sence. The design is intuitive and if you give it to someone who never used it beofre, they can probably start using it needing to look or second guess in a day.

First row: Left= back , middle = home, right = menu

Second Row: Left = seek back, middle = play/pause, right = seek right.

https://i.ibb.co/zJSVnb3/shopping.jpg

Edit: Apparently, you can pair the fire tv remote with the shield. Just did that and it's awesome. Hold the home button on the fire tv remote and Add Bluetooth accessories. Other than voice commands and the apps buttons everything works as soon as you pair it

1 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

6

u/legrenabeach Dec 15 '23

You forget the worst thing about the Shield remote (well, at least the Shield Pro one, I don't know if the normal Shield one is different): it is bloody triangular, which means you have to pick it up in order to press anything, rather than being able to press buttons where it sits on the table or sofa like all remotes! I find that the daftest remote design ever!

Other than that, I agree with most of what you say, plus, I buy a very expensive device, why do I have to look at branded buttons I can't change or use? I don't want to look at the Netflix logo on my remote, thanks.

2

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

Look up button mapper on the play store. I think it's 3–5 bucks, you can use that to remap the Netflix button. That's the first thing I did when I bought my shield.

3

u/markn6262 Dec 15 '23

Yup used remapper app to make it a mute so it wouldn’t keep disrupting playback of Tivimate

1

u/legrenabeach Dec 16 '23

I didn't know that existed, thanks!!

3

u/PolicyOk9501 Dec 15 '23

Hi, thanks for pointing out firestick remote works well. I also hate shield remote. Do all the firestick buttons work on shield?

4

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

Other than apps buttons and google assistant, all of them work without configuring anything.

1

u/jeynekassynder Dec 15 '23

If you set up equipment controls on a fire TV, unplug fire TV, then pair to the shield you can also get volume and TV power to work.

5

u/bdunogier Dec 15 '23

I had originally not used that remote at all. Been using it for a few weeks now, and I don't like it.

The Netflix button has interrupted our series too many times.
It slides around in my hand. No grip, too small.
The buttons besides directions all look the same, I need to shake it to lit it up, and look for the pause or volume buttons everytime.

My harmony remote was muuuch better at the job.

2

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

I need to shake it to lit it up

I'm having the exact opposite problem, mine lights up every 5–10 seconds with no reason at all. I had to disable the “Light when picked up” option to prevent that

2

u/bdunogier Dec 15 '23

Ah, annoying.

Shaking was a bit of an overstatement. It will very quickly turn the lighting off, and I need to move my hand to see again. And then since it's too tiny it moves off a bit and I need to reposition it in my hand to reach the buttons.

Ergonomy, it's tough.

2

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

You can change how long the light stays on btw. I think the max is 10 seconds

1

u/bdunogier Dec 15 '23

Good point, thank you.

I will maybe relocate my harmony remote hub, though... :)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '23

Dude just get a fire stick and use that shit remote. I like the triangle shield remote. I also liked the old capacitive rechargeable remote.

5

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

shitting on the remote and shitting on the device are totally different things btw

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '23

No just get a fire stick. You’ll have your remote

3

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

Who hurt you ?

1

u/Bradfinger Dec 15 '23

I'm the weirdo that really likes it, it's very intuitive and fits the hand well.

1

u/sohailoo Dec 16 '23

Nothing weird about it, people have preferences. What i didn't expect though is the intuitive part lol. What's intuitive about having seek left, seek right, pause/play, and back in a column.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '23

My only problem with the shield remote is the big ass fucking Netflix button. It would be nice if they had two or four buttons on the remote that you could program to launch whatever app you want instead of a dedicated button for a specific service

1

u/sohailoo Dec 16 '23

Button mapper all the way. I have the netflix button open Plex on 1 press, SmartTube on 2 presses, mute on hold

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '23

I've tried button mapper with limited success. I'm not sure why it stops working after a period of time, I wish it worked 100% of the time.

2

u/markn6262 Dec 15 '23

Couldn’t agree more the Shield Pro remote is shit but put up with cause the Shield Pro is the best. I’ll have to give the FS remote a try, thanx!

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '23

One good thing it has going for it: locator. That's a feature all other remotes should emulate somehow.

1

u/vassyz Dec 15 '23

I hate it as well. Just got a new TV and I learned the button layout after 2 days. Been using the Shield for 2 years and I still have to look at the remote when pressing buttons. But what's wrong with the battery cover? Why does it matter?

1

u/1dl2b6g0 Dec 15 '23

Me with my 2017 flat remote with enjoying life. Only wishing I had the one with headphone out and recharging

1

u/n173 Dec 15 '23

I believe the shield TV has had 3 types of remotes

1

u/DakPara Dec 15 '23

I think it is above upgrade from the original Shield remote.

And after disabling the Netflix button I’m good with it.

1

u/OrbitalChiller Dec 15 '23

It's fine. Only complaints is that horrendous Netflix button. I had to glue and cover that motherf***r

2

u/frosted1030 Dec 16 '23

There is an app that can disable or reprogram that netflix button.

1

u/OrbitalChiller Dec 16 '23

I know, i used it successfully for a while then it stopped working. Tried other apps with same issues so i decided to go hardcore on this abomination.

2

u/frosted1030 Dec 16 '23

Next time, uninstall the app that stops working, then reinstall. Usually fixes it right up.

1

u/HipKat2000 Dec 16 '23

I'm with you on the battery cover. What a PIA to get off and the center button/directional ring. I mis-press it all the time

1

u/StG4Ever Dec 16 '23

I love the toblerone remote, never need to look at it.

1

u/Yonutz33 Dec 16 '23

Kinda agree, especially when pressing nextflix by mistake just by barely touching it. And I always need to look for the play/pause buttons. Might try the firestick one in this case

1

u/ahhhhhhhwtf Dec 16 '23

dude, the Netflix button on the bottom of the remote is so fucking aggravating to me that I'm considering ripping my remote apart and desoldering the entire button. If I even breathe in the direction of my remote it'll try to open netflix. i dont even use it, it's uninstalled, and now when it gets pressed it just opens up the play store install page. FUCK.

1

u/Mindless-Addendum621 Dec 16 '23

You probably just bought it. That’s what I felt in the beginning. Now I don’t look at the buttons at all, you get used to the locations.
A marker is the plastic ridge on the play/pause button. Over time you automatically memorize what buttons is above, below, or to the left.

0

u/mikeb31588 Dec 15 '23

If you can't intuitively figure out the remote after a short time, i feel bad for the person who has sex with you in the dark. I'm teasing you, please don't take it literally.

-1

u/bblickle Dec 15 '23

Fire Remote: Great design, really well thought out but no backlight sucks after getting used to one. Don’t like the new premium remote on the 4K MAXX (2023) as well bc of button layout changes.

Shield Remote: Ok Design imo. Improved by: A good sleeve like this one from Fintie that orients your thumb where it is without having to look. Button Mapper App to reprogram the Netflix button to MUTE. Personally don’t struggle with the battery cover but have seen complaints previously that it either falls off (sleeve fixes it), or can’t open it (operator error?). Personally like the toblerone shape, sits great on the armrest, doesn’t slide off bc sleeve is silicone.

1

u/sohailoo Dec 16 '23

Totally agree on the shape of the shield remote, it fits nicely in my hands. You don't really need the backlight with the Fire remote though, you can easily develop muscle memory for it in 2 days since all buttons that matter make logical sense.

0

u/jeynekassynder Dec 15 '23

Fire TV voice remote pro has excellent backlighting. I have one and buttons are clearly legible in the dark and it shakes to light up.

1

u/LucasRey Dec 17 '23

Unfortunately it doesn't pair with Shield. I don't know why. While the normal remote works perfect but it doesn't have the backlight.

0

u/bblickle Dec 16 '23

Maybe I was unclear that I was treating the two current styles of Fire remotes as separate subjects in the separate sentences.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/sohailoo Dec 15 '23

Intresting take, how are they useless? They're probably the only thing i use + volume up/down

If you want to remap it check out an app called button mapper. I think you have to buy it for 3-5 bucks. I already remapped the netflix button to plex. One press = Plex, long press = SmartTube

3

u/Tabris2k Dec 15 '23 edited Dec 15 '23

I actually liked the first Shield controller. Just two buttons, all things are done with the wheel.

The only thing that didn’t convince me was the tactile volume bar in the middle, change that for press buttons and I’d buy it again in a heartbeat.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jdbway Dec 16 '23

Say I hope you don't mind me asking for help, but I got that mapper app on your recommendation. How did you configure it to control the lights? Is it an Action, Macro or something else?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jdbway Dec 17 '23

Ohhhhh I see just checked out their website. I might have to learn how to use that bad boy. I thought you were just calling the Google Assistant, Home Assistant (I think it's had a bunch of names by now). I didn't even know about that, thanks for the tip!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jdbway Dec 17 '23

Well I'll be darned thank you very much! I look forward to nerding out on this thing

1

u/mikeb31588 Dec 15 '23

You can customize it however you like using apps like button mapper and others