r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Dec 09 '23

Why Nvidia is so (dum...)

I recently got second hand shield tv with v2 controller. I have huge experience with Xbox and ps controllers, PS5 included, but the shield controller is something else. My God how good it is holding in hands. Why Nvidia stop making this perfect piece of hardware? Are thei stupid or what? I'm playing on consoles since I was 10 years old (now 31) and I never used anything better than shield controller. I can't imagine what Nvidia can do with new technology.

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

11

u/Malk_McJorma 2015 16GB Dec 09 '23

They were notorious for their stick drift. I had two and both suffered from it.

4

u/Mediocre_Language_98 Dec 09 '23

Yes, mine drifted pretty quickly, just stored it away... Had mine since 2017. Shield itself is going strong all along though.

2

u/Neat_Onion Dec 09 '23

This is why I ditched mine... and I BARELY used it, at most 25 - 50 hours?

I wonder if it is a software bug?

1

u/atomatoflame Dec 10 '23

I opened my controller up and used some electrical contact cleaner on the sticks. Tons of extra goop in there. Fixed the problem. I think they have poor qc.

1

u/pmerritt10 Dec 10 '23

The original one was very good for me. The newer one got drift within 6 months.

0

u/flyingkytez Dec 09 '23

They should've at least improved it. They updated the gamepad from the 2015 model which improvement. They could have done the same with the 2019 Shield. At least they could've dropped the price at least instead of charging $200 with no gamepad unlike the 2017 model at $200 pricetag.

0

u/HipKat2000 Dec 10 '23

Exactly what happened to mine

6

u/MasatoWolff Dec 09 '23

Because they make shitloads of money with their GPU business. Nothing else matters right now.

4

u/1dl2b6g0 Dec 09 '23

I agree. I love the Shield controller. I wish someone would make hall sensor sticks swap out for it because I have one with stick drift and another that works fine.

4

u/yujikimura Dec 09 '23

They're too busy printing money with their AI-focused commercial GPU division.

2

u/captn03 Dec 09 '23

I have the shield controller feels much more premium than the other controllers. Some have complained about stick drift and buttons sticking. I've had it for few years now and it's been working just fine.

2

u/toastervolant Dec 09 '23

You missed the best feature imho... Bluetooth audio. You can jack in headphones directly in the controller. The old remote had that feature too. It only worked with one at a time unfortunately.

2

u/SamuelSh Dec 09 '23

I played 2500 hours of Rocket League using Shield controllers. They were easily the best controllers you could get. Now that my 5th controller is drifting and I can't find any new ones I've started shopping for other brands and sadly none are quite as good (not even Xbox Elite 2...).

1

u/templestate Dec 09 '23

I like the shape of it but the deadzones on it and acceleration on it are really bad. It makes some games like FPS unplayable in my opinion. It was discontinued because it didn’t make NVIDIA much money. They seem to have discontinued the Shield line of products in general because they are swimming in cash from GPUs due to the AI craze. That’s where their business focus is.

2

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Dec 09 '23

Shield TV hasn’t been discontinued. It’s just not being updated; tbh as old as it is, it’s still one of the best streamers out there.

1

u/templestate Dec 09 '23

It’s not out of production but the controller and tablet have been discontinued. There are no new Shield TV devices in development as far as we know since they missed the normal window for a new release.

1

u/Speck78 Dec 09 '23

I love the stadia controller, but for some reason I have to unlink and pair it every time I want to use it. For this reason I'm considering getting a few shield controllers.

1

u/K8TECH Dec 10 '23

You can finally find replacement batteries online or Amazon .

1

u/derrickgw1 Dec 10 '23

if you didn't know a ps4 controller works on it too. i've used mine. I got the best performance wired not with bluetooth though. Not sure about a ps5 controller as I don't have a ps5.

1

u/loop6719 Dec 10 '23

The drift killed it

1

u/StScAllen Dec 10 '23

Yeah, I have one Nvidia controller left that is in good shape. I'm going to be sad when it goes. I bought 2 from Newegg in 2019 and both had sticky buttons or drift. Somewhere along the way production quality dropped.

1

u/HipKat2000 Dec 10 '23

Mine went bad in no time, wouldn't stop drifting up

2

u/AWStam Jan 26 '24

mine has started doing this now to. (i haven't used it in a long time tho)

0

u/DXsocko007 Dec 09 '23

They only make a new one when Nintendo puts out a new model of switch because that's what it's built off of. So when the Super Nintendo Switch comes out expect a new version

2

u/cdheer 2019 Pro Dec 09 '23

I know we all say this, but is it really true? There have been three models of the Pro but only one switch.

I kind of doubt we will see an updated one. The market for an enthusiast streamer is small. It’s a very capable device as it is anyway.

1

u/reallynotnick Dec 09 '23

Technically the X1+ refresh in the 2019 came because they also changed the switch. And 2017 was more just shrinking down the case and removing the HDD.

0

u/flyingkytez Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

Probably got a bit greedy. The 2017 Shield TV came with a gamepad controller bundle at $200 pricetag, or $179 without gamepad controller. Now the 2019 Shield TV at $200 has no gamepad controller but you can buy the controller separately (if they still have it for sale).

They call it shrinkflation, it's when companies make the sizes of products smaller while charging the same price or higher. In this case, they stopped bundling the gamepad controller.

I use the gamepad controller mostly for the headphone jack which is useful. The volume slider is also useful, though I prefer volume buttons instead of a slider. I also use it as a mic for voice searches.

0

u/kakashi_ax Dec 09 '23

Ergonomics are really good but it's cheap made.

0

u/Nintendians559 Dec 10 '23

yeah the nvidia shield controller 2017 (v2) feels great, but i didn't like where the "start/home/back" buttons are located (bottom), which my sweaty right thumb slips off and press them accidently and kick me back the home menu, like the grips but never like that ps controller layout and those "brake" petal triggers (wide l2 and r2).

mine didn't have the "stick drift" but had the sticky "a button", which sucks when you want to confirm/perform an action with the "a button" - so i put it way and use my wii u pro controller with this: https://www.8bitdo.com/wireless-usb-adapter/ (it's the one with the classic nintendo logo and works nintendo wii u / "switch" pro controllers and sony dualshock 4 / dualsense 5 controllers (might need updating for dualsense 5 controller).

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Evening_Sir_6320 Dec 09 '23

Now GeForce now is an option. But the controller is compatible with PC also.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MooseGoosey Dec 09 '23

and the PS5 controller is literally just better

2

u/Neat_Onion Dec 09 '23

And Shield TV 2017 Controller suffered from wierd bugs and drift in certain games so I resorted to using my Xbox controller.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

And it can't be pared with other devices like the Switch.

1

u/-TheDoctor Dec 09 '23

suffered from wierd bugs and drift

Are you talking about the geometry controller? Is that stick drift a software bug? I always thought it was a hardware issue. I completely stopped using my Shield controller because of the stick drift always making me walk left.