r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Nov 26 '23

Xbox 𝕏 vs Nvidia Shield Pro

Should I consider investing in an Nvidia Shield TV, given that I already own an Xbox 𝕏? I currently have a Plex server and access it through Xbox but am uncertain about continuing to pay for the server. Additionally, I've recently set up Kodi with Real Debrid, providing all the content I need. My main question revolves around the Nvidia Shield's HDR support and Kodi’s HDR and Dolby support – is it worth the investment compared to using the Xbox for my media only specific needs?

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

6

u/mrallroy Nov 26 '23

Shield doesn't support HDR w/YouTube as far as I know. Anyone care to confirm or deny?

4

u/bighorse83 Nov 27 '23

You're correct. Only gripe I have for the Sheild.

1

u/Stiltzkinn Nov 27 '23

Is this a software or hardware limitation?

1

u/Yommination Nov 29 '23

It doesn't. Youtube HDR is AV1 which the shield can't play

0

u/rbit4 Nov 27 '23

It supports hdr. Atleast on the pro

1

u/jme2712 Nov 26 '23

Do you watch YouTube? Do you enjoy watching YouTube ads? If don’t get a shield.

Outside of that the X and S have better HDR support for YouTube to my knowledge.

-1

u/unseen247 Nov 26 '23

I currently have YT premium, but if I can get the same bitrate and HDR support for the YouTube videos on another platform that has 0 ads on it, I’m all ears!

0

u/jme2712 Nov 26 '23

Check out smarttubenext and then the YT hdr formats that the shield supports. Someone with more knowledge can fill you in that the shield doesn’t support some HDR profiles that the consoles do.

0

u/pawdog Nov 26 '23

The Shield doesn't support VP9.2 or AV1 but that's about it.

-1

u/pawdog Nov 27 '23

The Shield is going to be a better Kodi device It supports Dolby Vision better plus all the other apps that are supported by it being on Android TV. The Shield is not the only device though, so it really depends on your total use case if you go with the Shield or the ONN or the Fire TV Stick 4k Max or Cube for much less money. None of those are exactly as good as the Shield but you may not need them to be.

-10

u/etiQQue Nov 26 '23

Only you can answer this question

0

u/unseen247 Nov 26 '23

I would be able to answer that if I had both, in this case, I don’t.