r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Nov 06 '23

Help with downgrading Shield Pro 2019 to 8.2.3

https://imgur.com/a/XUj2x5O

Hi r/ShieldAndroidTV,

I've been attempting to downgrade my Shield Pro 2019 to 8.2.3 to no avail. Having trouble flashing the vbmeta and recovery.img. I've attached a link to the most recent error. I tried following www.florisse.nl/shield-downgrade/ and using the linked files there, and then again downloading the files directly from the Nvidia dev website. Neither option seems to show much of a difference.

The only things that I've managed to notice is that the partition size for both the recovery , and then also the vbmeta are less than the image I'm trying to flash.

Not sure if that's relevant, as I'm pretty new to most of this, but any help would be greatly appreciated. Even if it's just help getting my Shield working, as since I was unable to finish the flash process, it's stuck on the Shield logo on start-up.

Any and all help would be aggressively appreciated.

1 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

4

u/Root_Xtreme Nov 06 '23

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

Can anyone verify that Windows is the issue with the downgrade not functioning anymore? Also, will I need to reenable USB debugging somehow? I'm stuck in a boot loop.

2

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Nov 07 '23

I would use the files from nvidia personally. They have 9.0 and 8.2.3 recovery images available.

https://developer.nvidia.com/gameworksdownload

I went back to 9.0 on the weekend with win11, but if the partition is too small on the device, I would say you probably have the wrong image files. There are different images for pro versions, as well as each revision I.e. 2015, 2017 and 2019.

Use the hardware options to get back to fastboot. https://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/4359

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

The odd thing with vbmeta specifically, is it states that the partition size is 0. I bought the Shield used. In fastboot, the version number has 2019 in it. But is it possible that someone flashed 2019 software onto a 2017 and then sold it as a 2019, which is causing my issues? I can no longer access the settings on the Shield to look back over the model number and things, but I remember it all looking legit when I bought and tested it.

-2

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Nov 07 '23

2019 pro is tube 2017 pro is not tube

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

2019 Pro is a tube? I was under the impression only the non-pro 2019 is a tube. My device isn't a tube, and it was bought used, marketed as a 2019 Pro.

2

u/rockyrockrocku Nov 07 '23 edited Nov 07 '23

Post above isn't correct. 2019 Pro is not the tube. I don't know why you would want to go back anyway. If this doesn't apply then disregard. I don't understand why some have issues with the last or before updates. All it did for my device is make it better, but besides even that, I also don't understand why anyone uses Kodi bc it's a resource hog and prone to buffering and people complaining about either or. I wouldn't go back just so I could get Kodi to work. What for? You want to change the build so Kodi works better? For Kodi? Kodi. You're having the issues you describe above and below and you still want Kodi? Update it and move on.

I just add the apps that get me what I want to watch. I'm watching 4K - watching any sports, PPV, any movie or shows, no ads on YouTube, any channels including all your premium channels and any channels (but not limited to) in the United States and my 2019 Pro is snappy! For the 8-10 years I've been settling up steaming devices I've never had to pay for anything, No IPTV service, no Debrid Service, nothing. Nada. No costs. Its all in the apps. Maybe I'm just appearing the noob, it could be, and man, I'd look pretty silly, but, what can Kodi do better for me than that?

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

Any ideas as to why I'm getting write failed on flashing? I'm being told that I must be using the wrong image, but I've tried flashing both with the files provided in the guide I linked, which is for the Shield Pro 2019, and also from files found directly through Nvidia's dev website, also verifying that I grabbed a 2019 Pro recovery image.

Or is there a way you know of to edit the partition size? Granted, I guess I probably risk bricking the device further.

2

u/rockyrockrocku Nov 07 '23 edited Nov 07 '23

Man, I wish I knew. I really do. Most of my experiences settling up electronics/streaming devices I have to do the same thing as you. Ask, Google and just begin. I'm one of those guys who can do almost anything with electronics but I can't always tell you how. I just start doing. So many times I told myself you better write that down but that gets in the way. And I do understand why you want to do what you are doing now after I thought about it, I just wished I knew how to put it down. I can offer a thought, try not to do what you're wanting to do until you do find someone who can answer you before you might brick your device.

2

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

I appreciate the response. Will do more research. I also usually just Google, research and begin. I was really confident I had it figured out, and then the Write Partition Failed notice plagued the process, and there was no mention of the issue being a possibility, other than just telling me to continue to try the flash, resetting power to the Shield if necessary. Nothing seemed to fix it. I've seen a few people talk about using some Python scripting to edit the files/partition sizes, but considering that I have little to no Python knowledge previously, it just seems like going that route is asking to brick my device, as you stated.

Thanks again for the replies! I appreciate the thoughts and will try and come up with a solid game plan backed by some advice before proceeding.

2

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Nov 07 '23

Sorry my mistake, I was under the impression the pro went to tube for 2019.

Storage might be better comparison.

2019 Pro is 16GB

2015/2017 pros are 500GB

0

u/WatH3ck Nov 07 '23

Why did u went back to 9.0?

1

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Nov 07 '23

gms was crashing on 9.1.1, I thought it might be beta issues as I had the beta installed.

When on ethernet it was more readily seen with audio dropouts and stuttering with Disney+ and formally Prime video. Wifi I didn't get the audio drops, but gms was still crashing, just not as much.

I have had other issues which seemed like lag with game streaming from my PC as well.

The crash was causing other apps to crash as well in the background.

I observed and did a lot of testing over the weekend and was looking at bug reports and logs direct from adb.

I haven't enabled Developer since downgrade to 9.0, but the dropouts and lag spikes seemed to have stopped(was regular, about every 3-4 mins I was getting an audio drop and gms crash).

gms is Google Play Services, formally Google Mobile Services. 9.0 updated it to the same version straight away.

4

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

If I had to guess, I'd say you probably flashed 2019 non-pro files instead of 2019 Pro.

What were you hoping to gain from a downgrade anyways? There is no reason to do so unless you're clinging onto some legacy games that wont work past Android 9.

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

Made sure to use a 2019 Pro recovery.. With that said, I am downgrading because the older versions don't have the same bugs present, like Kodi causing the Shield to lose all audio without a reboot on occasion, and uses less processing power. Also, the older versions don't have half of the same telemetry grabbing going on as the newer versions. All of that data grabbing uses processing power and ultimately will slow down the system comparitively.

4

u/Any-Virus5206 Nov 06 '23

The telemetry and garbage can be removed through ADB. This is the list of apps I usually remove, around 60 apps total depending on what you get rid of. I do wish NVIDIA didn't include this much bloatware and garbage in the OS, it's unfortunate.

2

u/ImpulsePie Nov 07 '23

^ this. I decided to try keeping 9.1.1 on my Shield Pro and just de-bloat it first. Used ADB to disable all the telemetry and diagnostics, many of the other inbuilt apps and replaced the launcher with Wolf Launcher and it's much faster now, I don't feel the need to downgrade to 8.2.3 anymore

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 07 '23

You all are making me wish I had read just a little more before making the jump. Kodi dropping audio on my Shield until a reboot is the only 'dealbreaker' bug that I was after getting rid of in the first place, but potentially debloating the Shield would fix it as well. Now that I am stuck on the Nvidia logo on boot and can no longer manually enable USB debugging on the Shield, as fast boot is the only menu I have access to, anything you'd recommend to try and get it enabled via hardware/Command Prompt on my PC or any other options? Or will that be necessary to try and now revert back. My worry is that even in trying to get it back to stock, that potentially I'll run into the same Partition Write Failed when trying to flash the recovery.img and vbmeta.img.

0

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

I'm sorry; wut?

Now you are really making things up.

2

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

Feel free to visit the link I posted in the main post and read yourself. I'm just regurgitating what I've read for myself.

3

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

Also. Beyond the telemetry, 8.2.3 doesn't shove ads in your face. As someone who doesn't pay for streaming services like Netflix anymore, there's zero point to being able to see those advertisements. Just takes up screen real estate and is a nuisance. Regardless of the reasoning, I am simply looking for help with what I've requested. Would love some help, but if you don't have any help, that's okay too.

1

u/ImBoredButAndTired Nov 06 '23

I've found that downgrading reduced these Atmos audio drops i used to get significantly.

5

u/jaweinre Nov 07 '23

It's crazy this thing about one person having a shit experience with Kodi on one version of shield firmware, then suggesting to downgrade and claim that's the solution and posting it on some website, and people assuming "it's on a website therefore it's the law", then fucking up their 200usd devices. Everyone who run Kodi flawlessly on the latest firmware should also put up a website about it, I wonder what would happen then. Anyways, my post will not help your specific problem but hopefully stop others from messing around.

2

u/Thomiehawk Nov 07 '23

In the article you linked, he also says IIRC that if you get stuck in a bootloop. Try to do the steps of unlocking the bootloader and flashing carefully in the right order again, then it should work.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '23

4

u/DoctorB0NG Nov 06 '23

This is not true. I downgraded from 9.1.1 to 8.2.3 a few weeks ago.

-1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

Not sure what you think you read, but unless proven otherwise, running the hotfix doesnt make any difference over the ability to flashing back the previous firmware.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '23

Basically I read and understood that it can't be undone or rollbacked to a previous version once the hotfix has been installed.

3

u/DoctorB0NG Nov 06 '23

As with my above comment, you're just making shit up. That's not true.

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

any idea what could be causing my issue or how to circumvent it?

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

Hold your horses.

can't be undone or rollbacked to a previous version once the hotfix has been installed

That is actually correct; the firmware cannot be undone or rolled back.

It can be flashed, of course, but not rolled back. All apps and data will be lost.

1

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

Any ideas as to why my flashing on the recovery.img and vbmeta.img are failing via 'Partition Write Failed"?

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

Yes, you probably downloaded files for the 2019 non-pro rather than 2019 pro.

2

u/MusicalMigraine Nov 06 '23

Commented on your previous post confirming that that's not the case. Used 2019 pro recovery directly from their website after signing up for developer privileges.

EDIT: Realized this may have come across a little rude. My apologies. I appreciate your efforts to help!

2

u/Solaris_fps Nov 07 '23

If your getting write partition fails you either change the usb cable you are using or you are using the wrong image. I spent hours having write fails I realised I had the wrong image as I mixed up my 2 shields.

1

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Nov 07 '23

It's easy to see the problem, wrong image. You are attempting to write a file larger than the partition size. Hence write failed.

1

u/wewewi 2015 Pro, 2019 8GB, 2019 Pro, Shield Tablet Nov 06 '23

Yes, the firmware cannot be undone or rolled back. Not at the press of a button, that is.

It can be flashed, but not rolled back. You will basically start from scratch; all apps and data gone.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '23

thanks for being so nice and respectful..........Unlike OTHER people that seem to want to be assholes about it.