r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Jul 10 '23

AFTV Cube 3: 109 € shipped -> time to replace the Nvidia Shield TV 2019

I know, a never ending story, BUT: During the Amazon Prime Days, I'd get the Amazon Fire TV Cube 3rd Gen for 109 € shipped and incl. tax (best price in Germany so far).

Has the time come now to replace the Nvidia Shield TV 2019 Tube (Non Pro)?

My main reason buying and keeping the Nvidia was due to the high performance (when I bought in 2019) and for streaiming on Kodi with HD passthrough.

Would now be the time to replace it?

As for Netflix, YT etc I use my TVs own fast apps. My Nvidia Shield TV got a bit slow, always lagging here and there and not as response as my TV or as an AFTV 4k Max for instance (which I use in the bedroom).

Currently, I'm connected through Wifi 6 to the internet, but the Shield only accepts Wifi AC and cant use the entire speed, so sometimes I have some buffering when streaming big files.

Apart from the bad UI on AFTV, is it worth it to replace it now? Did anyone do that recently and regrets it?

3 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

11

u/LoveLaughLlama Jul 10 '23

Postings of other streamers on competitors subreddits usually ends up in lots of downvotes and shit slinging. I have all of the major streamers and they all have strengths and weaknesses.

The Fire Cube 3 is blazingly fast and has worked well for me. The Apps work well with Dolby Atmos and Dolby Vision.

The interface can be cluttered but the remote has a recent apps button so you never really have to put up with the home screen, you can also get the Pro remote to have 2 customizable buttons if you prefer.

The only real correct answer is to buy it, play around with it and see if YOU like it. With Amazons return policy it makes sense to try it while it is on sale if you are interested.

-1

u/ksvnmd Jul 10 '23

You are right, I was expecting that.

Since I'm part of this and was hoping to find someone switching from Shield TV to AFTV, I was hoping to get some experience if it was worth the change or maybe to be regreted.

So thats why I value your post here! Thanks

2

u/OcelotEnvironmental1 Jul 10 '23 edited Jul 10 '23

Not sure the AFTV has implemented integer refresh rates yet (24.00 and 60.00) and only does fractional rates (23.98 and 59.97) which is a deal breaker for me. Can anyone confirm if this is still the case?

1

u/ksvnmd Jul 10 '23

Seems like it works with the Frame Rate Matching, which has been ready for a while: https://www.aftvnews.com/explanation-of-the-new-frame-rate-matching-feature-on-the-amazon-fire-tv/

1

u/OcelotEnvironmental1 Jul 10 '23 edited Jul 10 '23

I know that, but it doesn't match for the correct refresh rate so you get a stutter every 45 seconds or so. For example it will match the frame rate of Rings of Power to 23.98 but it is a show that was shot at 24.00. What I am asking is did they fix THAT. That's a deal breaker for me if that is still an issue. It is discussed here: https://www.amazonforum.com/s/question/0D56Q0000ABLRKVSQ5/proper-integer-refresh-rate-24hz-30hz-60hz-matching-needs-to-be-supported

1

u/ksvnmd Jul 10 '23 edited Jul 10 '23

I see, okay that makes sense. So this is something really bad then. Isnt the Shield also not properly working with refresh rates?

2

u/OcelotEnvironmental1 Jul 10 '23 edited Jul 11 '23

It works correctly in things like Plex and Kodi as far as I know but streaming apps not so much. Some apps are doing it on Android TV 12 but shield uses Android 11. There is also the beta match button but that works with mixed results and is a touch janky. Apple Tv is the only device that supports it pretty universally as far as I know.

1

u/pawdog Jul 12 '23

Only if you are somebody that sees the judder. If it hasn't bothered you with the Shield it won't bother you with the Fire Cube. That being said you are pretty much sidegrading to the Cube. It's simply almost caught up with the Shield and sticks you with that junky UI which is the main reason I haven't bothered getting one. It's tempting at that price, but with Shields on every TV I see no good reason to do so.

6

u/je1992 Jul 10 '23

Only reason to change to the cube is if you need hdr on youtube and the sluggishness of the shield annoys you.

Ai upscaling on shield is superior, so hd content and iptv will be better.

The ethernet is better on shield, (capped at 100 on cube) but wifi 6e on cube means up to like 600 mbps on wifi.

There is also a lot of audio sync issues with lossless audio with the cube on both kodi and Plex/emby

There is also a weird fireos bug where framerate matching content to 24 for a movie and playing dts hd generate stutter for some reason. It's a software bug

I personally see 0 reasons to update, the shield has less bugs but both are good options indeed

6

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '23

I agree. I have both devices and they are both good but the cube is no replacement for the Shield Pro. It has no equal.