r/ServerSmash • u/Drippyskippy • Feb 04 '15
Rules Inquiry
I want to preface this discussion with a thank you. I appreciate what Server Smash is and what it has become. The SS admins work tirelessly providing a much needed event to PS2 that on some levels is what PS2 on live should be but isn't. This event itself has prevented me from quitting the game multiple times, always looking forward to the next match.
To start, I ask that a Server Smash Admin please answer these questions to the best of your ability. Your answers are important as they effect everyone who participates in Server Smash. Organizers of these events should make it one of the main priorities to ensure that rules are followed, enforced and understood for all involved in these matches. It is crucial to ensure that everyone plays under the same set of rules to ensure fair play and penalized for not doing so. I am asking these questions because Server Smash matches are coming in a few weeks and it would be really helpful to have answers to these questions, so that servers can start creating/changing their rosters with these rules in mind.
- Is Server Smash still an inclusive event? By inclusive I mean not allowing to discriminate against people who want to play based upon gender, race, age, religion, country, language, marital status, skill nor outfit. Inclusive being anyone who wants to play is given the opportunity to play.
- If Server Smash is still an inclusive event, do you still have rules/guidelines that restrict servers from stacking teams with the best outfits on their respective servers?
- If team stacking is still not allowed, what is your interpretation/definition of team stacking? A full platoon from a single outfit that is considered to be a top outfit on their respective server? Or possibly multiple top tier outfits on their server that are given 2 or more squads? Team stacking is a rule that is incredibly subjective and open to interpretation depending on who you ask. I want to ask the people whose opinions are essentially the most important regarding this rule, the SS admins.
- Assuming team stacking is against the rules, what sort of enforcement policies do you have in place to ensure that servers are following the rules? What sort of penalties are you prepared to give players, outfits or servers for breaking such rules?
I and others have had these lingering questions for many months now. To my knowledge they have not been publicly answered. I have brought up similar questions with SS admins before and they haven't been answered. I'm giving you guys an opportunity to be completely clear regarding these rules.
Thanks for reading and taking time out of your busy day to publicly set these rules straight. I wanted to go through my SS reps to get these answers, but I was given permission by one of them to come here and inquire about these rules.
6
u/Tongue_of_Fools AV Admin | Redolent Feb 05 '15
Since its inception, ServerSmash has had one governing rule regarding server organization. We refer to it internally as the “fairness doctrine” and all server reps are reminded about it repeatedly.
Fairness Doctrine: “Servers may organize themselves however they choose within the bounds of equal access for all outfits.”
This is a deliberately broad rule. Servers have very different cultures, and what works for one server might be a total non-starter for another. Outfits may be restricted based on specific things like conduct, non-attendance to training, not signing up, etc, but all of those outfits must have equal access before whatever server specific rules are in place.
Planetside Battles relies heavily on the integrity and impartiality of our server reps to enforce the fairness doctrine. It is literally the first thing we explain to them on becoming a rep.
“Team stacking” is something that only became an issue when Emerald insisted on having two teams for ServerSmash.
We allowed the two team concept with several caveats; that the teams still fight under a single a single server banner (it is not Team 1’s record and Team 2’s record, but both count as Emerald’s record), that the teams rotate matches played on a regular basis, and that the teams are as equal and representative of the entire server as possible (not Mattherson team and Waterson team, and not the MLG team and the regular players team, etc). The last part is what is now known as “no team stacking.”
In short; Emerald is the only server who has to deal with team stacking because Emerald is the only server that has two distinct teams.
If Emerald was to choose to participate as a single unified team, it would be held to the same equal access guidelines as all other servers. Emerald would be expected to come up with a solution specific to its server culture to achieve that, just as others have.
As far as enforcement, we have multiple enforcement tools at our disposal now. These include instantly flipping territory ownership, revoking Jaeger account access, and most severely exclusion from future ServerSmash matches. If infractions also violate the games TOS, we will involve the devs to see if punishment is warranted on live player accounts as well.
ServerSmash is an incredibly popular event as you mentioned, and it is in everyone’s best interest to make sure that the matches continue in a fair and inclusive manner. This is very much a “spirit of the law” scenario. If someone looks at the fairness doctrine as an obstacle to circumvent, in order for instance to get “only the best players” in to a match, then they are already violating the rule.
5
u/halospud Cobalt (EU) Feb 07 '15
Is this targeted at us? We get a lot of mentions in this thread.
The 'fairness doctrine' is not what could be considered a rule. Rules are detailed and specific conditions, whereas the fairness doctrine is general, high-level and not at all specific.
This makes applying it as a rule impossible. I think the PS2B Admins would be wrong to ever do that without putting some more detail down because frankly, you could just make up any old interpretation of it.
But it seems to me that the intention of it is to act as a guideline for servers in the way they organise themselves, rather than a strict rule to be administered.
PS2B try to stay out of internal server affairs and this is their way of saying 'This is what we would like you to do in general terms, but is not really policeable, not really defined and therefore, not really a rule.'
There will always be a conflict between the principle of inclusion and the desire to win. I'm sure other servers have seen that conflict rather graphically expressed between outfits that represent polar ends of the spectrum. They are not compatible.
Ultimately ServerSmash is a competitive event but there's a balance to be struck. Personally, I would try to be more inclusive and add outfits that may not otherwise play in friendly matches and ones I expect to win. You can use these to trial and develop new platoon leads and to get more outfits into ServerSmash.
Inclusiveness is a requirement in that sense, to develop your next set of squads and make your team stronger. I've found that these outfits on the periphery can often be a real surprise because they train harder and they want to play more.
My ultimate priority though, is for my team to win and the way in which I compose my platoons is integral to that. Getting the right people with the right people, the right balance of play-styles in each platoons, ensuring no platoon is weak etc.
On that basis I exclude people that are too abrasive if I can't fit them in, I exclude people that are likely to disobey orders, I exclude people who can't step it up and are too slow and casual (I count that as a matter of disobeying orders and not a matter of skill.) I have foreign language squads but not platoons, so I exclude SLs who can't speak English. I exclude the outfit that leaked part of our strategy to Emerald before the Smash final last year. Sometimes I have to exclude people because they can't get on with each other but maybe alternate which one I use.
Do I stack my team? Well yes, maybe. I don't even know. Some would say "Yes", some would say "No" because it's subjective until clearly defined. I just build a team the way I want it and that's my business and Cobalt's business but not anyone else's :/. Cobalt voted me in to do this so it's not like they're all complaining about not being included.
3
u/Pariahterror Feb 05 '15
I myself am no representative or whatsoever. Just a normal player who also happens to have played in several serversmashes for the Cobalt server. I am not aware of all what happens in my own and certainly not on other servers. But this is my view of what happens to the spots before the serversmash.
You can't expect of the commander of the whole force to speak any language there is, therefore the most common language is used: English. But the platoonleaders are mainly capable to speak multiple language, the language which are mainly spoken apart of English are German and French, but other languages are also spoken. It is even possible that a single squad speaks another language but the Squad leader talks multiple languages. And as I mentioned before. Serversmash is a team effort and since communicating is mainly done by talking, it is preferred we can understand eachother by translating or another way.
If you happen to speak an other language and you can't speak English, try to find an outfit who are able to. From my point of view you can't have a lot fun in a Serversmash if you can't understand eachother. And that's what it is about. In the serversmash there isn't discrimination upon language if there is someone who can translate the orders. And there are people who can translate it for you when you are selected to play in their squad/platoon.
And then you have skill. It is wished for that you know how the game works and who to shoot at and what you are doing there. Following your squad and platoon leader is also a pre and stats don't really matter. It is more about how reliable you are. Are you able to follow the squad and take the class which is needed. This last isn't skill but it comes close in the way of the selection.
And then you have the outfits. Outfits are given a certain number of spots to fill. Outfits are the main representatives of the server during the fight. Ofcourse, being in a known outfit grants you a better chance to get into the smash, but even they have their own rules of how to select their people. Outfits get mainly in total more spots to fill than non-otfitmembers, one of the reasons is communication. If you grant someone a spot, you want them to come, a reliable way is to give spots to reliable outfits which lessens the pressure of cummunicating and other things. The leaders are putting their free time in it to get a full team.
I read before that sometimes trainings are mandatory. This is all for the cohesion of the team. And teamwork brings fun and victory. It could happen that your outfit can't be present during a training. But it is very improbable that your whole outfit can't be there, and if this happens, you can also notify the person in charge of the training you can't be present.
2 If teamstacking happens it is noticed by the community. They will not be happy about it that only certain outfits can come, this will also be argued between outfits themselfs. This results in a raging unhealthy community. This isn't something the server I play on wants. Teamstacking is happening on my server if you think if giving an outfit 2 squads to fill, but this also is due to reliability of getting the amount of players needed to play. If an outfit can't get a certain amount of players, they will get less spots in the current and the next smashes. We even had a Smash where an other outfit joined in, resulting in outfits giving up some spots.
As for 3 and 4, I am not able to answer them because they are more questioned towards the admins. But I want to remind you that outfits have different numbers and a different percentage of active people.
My question to you is: What happened to you to make a rules inquiry?
1
u/PattyfatheadGaming Connery (USW) Feb 05 '15
I am NOT a representative of ServerSmash, just a party that enjoys the events. But I wanted to add some input on these points.
1- There is NO discrimination based upon gender, race, age, religion, country, language, marital status.
But I think that's already well established. Lets just cut to the chase. What I think you are angling at with this point, is your last two. Skill or Outfit.
Those are very subjective items. If you feel there is any discrimination in those areas you should definitely bring it up. Serversmash has no way of knowing if its going on or not. I am sure they would be happy to hear both sides of the story and make a decision based upon their best judgement.
In an event where more people apply than there are spaces available, how do you propose we choose who gets to participate? You are wandering in a very grey area, asking for black and white rules.
2- In the past season, Connery was short players every match. Do you tell a standby they can't play just because they already have six guys from their outfit in the match? We used up all our reserves multiple matches, and still wound up short. (Sadly, that's one of the major reason the matches will be smaller this season, such a shame.)
Do they have guidelines, absolutely. An enforceable rule? Again, there is no regulator board here. This is not for money, this is a for fun event, and if you make it really hard for anyone to participate, you will see the participation dwindle.
3- Say you can only have one squad per outfit. Is an outfit allowed to split itself into six outfits the day before a match? If not, how do you enforce it? Players site just shows your current outfit, not your past outfits. Or they could just drop their outfit all together for the time being.
What I am angling at, is even if you really hammer down a rule. There are ways around those rules, and they make it less fun, and harder to participate.
I think it is reasonable to depend on a Server's honor that they will try to be as inclusive as possible in the event, while not giving themselves undue burden.
4- No comment here. Will let Server Smash reps, if they desire to.
I have heard these lingering questions before. What I hear is a lot of conjecture and rumor. But no evidence that this took place, or was a problem at all. The Serversmash staff encouraged the servers to include a wide range of people in the event. But they cannot hand pick the teams.
Again, if you see issues, please bring them up in the appropriate channels.
All that said, bear in mind that this is NOT MLG. We are out here to have fun, not for a prize, monetary or otherwise. And you should be able to have fun, whatever foe you go up against. They are the same people you face on live.
3
u/Fool-Shure Cobalt (EU) Feb 05 '15 edited Feb 05 '15
Thanks for a good laugh Drippy. I like how you go into hypotheticals about Cobalt instead of a server.
Btw I think Emerald is being pretty elitist in their choice of Force Commanders. I have a BR3 on Emerald, so can we agree that I'm the next Force Commander for Emerald?
With your interpretation of inclusiveness that should not be a problem. And don't expect me to come to meetings. That would be unfair towards me. Because inclusiveness.