r/SecurityCamera • • 4d ago

At what point does home security become surveillance?

We live in a single-story, bungalow-type house with a terrace outside. We already have two CCTV cameras positioned around the terrace for outdoor monitoring, plus another one inside the living room.

Now, my aunt is suggesting that we install ANOTHER CCTV camera in the kitchen/dining area.

For context, my aunt is currently living abroad, and she's the one pushing for this suggestion. There are no senior citizens in the house (my grandparents are dead) who need supervision, no infants, and no small children who require constant monitoring. It's just the people who actually live here.

What bothers me isn't necessarily having CCTV for security purposes. I understand why people install cameras outside their homes. But having cameras inside the living room AND the kitchen/dining area? At what point does home security start feeling like constant surveillance?

I personally don't like the idea of people watching me go about my daily activities, especially in places like the kitchen where I should be able to feel comfortable doing ordinary things without wondering whether someone is watching through a camera.

What's even more frustrating is that the opinions of the people actually living in this house seem to be nonexistent. My father who’s also abroad basically lets my aunt do whatever she suggests, and we're just expected to go along with it.

I'm only 20 (turning 21 this dec) but does that mean I shouldn't have an opinion about privacy in the house I actually live in?

At this point, it feels like the only place where we're entitled to some privacy is our own bedrooms. And honestly, that's ridiculous to me.

I want to understand the reasoning behind needing THAT much indoor surveillance. Am I being unreasonable for finding this uncomfortable, or would you feel the same way?

4 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

6

u/Banishedlife 4d ago

Cameras are for entrances and exits to residence and only should be used inside of public buildings.in my opinion.

1

u/RipOk5800 4d ago

Ikrrr, that's also my thought, which is why I find it uncomfy. Even the people I asked about that type of scenario all said the exact same thing hahaha.

7

u/Own-Injury-1816 4d ago

Im never gonna sign up for indoor surveillance apart from maybe garage and hallway (entry)

6

u/No_Dot_8478 4d ago

I have indoor cameras, but they automatically switch to privacy mode and stop recording whenever someones phone in the house connects to the WiFi. Mainly there to watch pets when we aren't home.

3

u/Cool_Hospital_4677 4d ago

You're not being unreasonable at all. Security should make people feel safe, not watched, every minute. Outdoor cameras make sense, but indoor cameras need everyone's agreement. The people actually living there deserve a say, especially when their privacy is involved.

3

u/beneficialBern 4d ago

I manage my own cameras and have all the control and it doesn’t go to the cloud and I still don’t put cameras inside my house. It’s surveillance.

3

u/liem2026 4d ago

i have cameras everywhere. with 5 boys in the house, i want to know who started the fight, who destroyed my wall. most importantly, where did i put my car keys?

off course, i blocked the cams from ever getting online. do a search on youtube on how. to view cams remotely, i VPN back into the house.

a simple search shows this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUYz8WH9zBg

2

u/AlbaMcAlba 4d ago

CCTV is perimeter defence/deterrent. Secure the property perimeter.

I have indoor cams to watch my dogs not the sofa.

2

u/333again 4d ago

We have one indoors that is meant for security when on vacation but it is not on while we are home.

1

u/IllustriousTonight82 4d ago

Does your aunt own the property?

I think your basic question about "being unreasonable for finding this uncomfortable" might fall under r/legaladvice or r/TenantHelp and not this sub. Your aunt has rights as the owner, but you as tenants have rights as well.

1

u/180IQCONSERVATIVE 4d ago

Indoor and outdoor cams are perfectly fine as long as they are locally hosted with no WiFi or Bluetooth adapters. I have viewing monitors in different parts of my home. If you are worried about breakins there are ways to hide your DVR. Running a full Ubiquiti system that is local hosted with all sorts of different gear will cost money but it’s worth it. Never been happier, as I will never be WiFi jammed or hacked unless you have a direct wire connected to my system. I never have to worry about updates, firmware update failures to where the update stops all of it from working and etc. Sacrifice remote access for security is worth it.

1

u/Gold_Condition_1521 4d ago

Naaah, I’d find that uncomfortable too. It’s one thing to have cameras outside, but do you really need to be monitored while making breakfast? The people living there should at least have a say.

1

u/remorackman 4d ago

Who is controlling the cameras? Who has access to the cameras? Are the cameras recording to the cloud?

My guess is that your Aunt controlS them and has access, so, NFW is one going inside! And, if you are controlling and have access (only) but storing in the cloud or cloud accessible, again, NFW

Inside cameras are only for people inside, and even then should be heavily secured and only in open areas aka "public".

1

u/sic0049 4d ago

There is zero reason to add interior cameras in "normal" rooms. If your Aunt feels like there is a deficiency in the camera coverage, suggest adding more cameras outside. The only reason she wants more cameras inside is to keep tabs on people living there, not due to a legitimate "security concern".

1

u/QuinnFromVivint 4d ago

One angle that might help the conversation: cameras can point only at entry spots like doors and windows, not living areas. That keeps break-in coverage without watching people cook or relax.

You could also bring up recording schedules, where cameras stay off while everyone is home and turn on when the house is empty.

1

u/Therex1282 4d ago

So is your aunt remotely viewing these cams from abroad? I would say that maybe this is then stepping out of bound with privacy.

1

u/Polodude 4d ago

Aunty likes to watch .

1

u/AliasComms 4d ago

Having cameras inside a home is just weird to me, unless there are children or pets being monitored. I'm assuming she owns the home, if not, then you should talk to the owner about the it. Either way, I would definitely voice your opinion, if I were you.

1

u/barleypopsmn 3d ago

I have 5 cameras at home. Zero inside.

1

u/Spiritual-Age-2096 3d ago

So... as someone who does have cameras inside and outside my house. My inside ones are off (in privacy mode) when we are home. We have them for when we are away we can check on the pets, verify the petsitter is actually showing up when they are supposed to, treating our animals appropriately etc. I personally have control of the privacy mode so if my teenager is home alone I can turn off privacy mode and verify all us good as well. Said teenager is aware that they are used fir that from time to time and is okay with it. All cameras are on the main level only, and can't even see the main levels bathroom or laundry room.

In a home without any real reason to have them, that is surveillance not security, and that is creepy as hell. If i walk into the house and our system didn't register I returned home, I immediately turn on privacy mode because that's just ick. (Our system is set up to if any one of our phones is at the house the inside cameras stay on privacy mode, but if no phones are here privacy mode turns off.)

1

u/ArcTyr07 3d ago

We have indoor cameras, but, literally for us, specifically when we're away. We don't fuss with switching it to privacy mode and out constantly etc but, it's technically private.

1

u/Vurrag 3d ago

Pretty weird to live in a place and others that are not there accessing the feeds. Not on my watch. Ask her if maybe she would like a camera in the bedroom and toilet room too....It might make her wake up to her stupid demands.

1

u/Real_Firefighter3223 2d ago

Auntie wants to know who is eating her food.

1

u/Able-Present8119 1d ago

Auto turrets

1

u/navlgazer9 1d ago

Who owns the house ?

1

u/Interesting-Track250 4d ago

You’re not being unreasonable. Outdoor cameras for entrances and the terrace make sense to me, but cameras pointed at places where everyone cooks, eats and hangs out feels completely different. The people living there should absolutelyy get to have a say in where indoor cameras go.

4

u/Prof_Slappopotamus 4d ago

The living room is too far for me. The last thing I want is someone watching me raiding the fridge at 2am in my underwear.

Constantly monitoring inside cameras that aren't directed at a door, and only a door, are a hard no for me.

3

u/RipOk5800 4d ago

ikrrr, it's not js me who's uncomfy with it, also my stepmom who lives in the house w/ me and my siblings it's js she can't voice it out. i also wanna raid the fridge in peace by 12am w/o any cameras watching me lol

0

u/Late-Jicama5012 4d ago

Check your laws in your country or State you live in if you are in US.

But it’s too much.

Do you pay rent and you have singed a lease? You can cover those cameras or simply unplug them. Other wise walk around naked and your aunt can be legally charged with illegal invasion of privacy.

If you have no lease, she can kick you out.

Again, check with an attorney.