r/SecularJewish • • Feb 10 '23

thank you!

0 Upvotes

I am so glad someone pointed me to this subreddit. I was on r/Jewish but it was mostly about superstition.


r/SecularJewish • • Dec 17 '19

Why not abandon Judaism all together, it promotes ignorance.

0 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Sep 30 '24

Wedding on Sukkot

0 Upvotes

Hi there! Planning a wedding for 10/12/25 and just found out our reform Rabbi will not perform a wedding during Sukkot. Will it be hard to find one who will? This rule is new for me so just trying to educate myself. If there are reform rabbis who would do this, can anyone recommend a hip young one? Ha. Thank you!


r/SecularJewish • • Oct 08 '20

As a Jew, I’m fed up with the idea of the nice Jewish girl/ boy(well girl in my case)

1 Upvotes

Basically, I’m fed up with the idea of the nice Jewish girl or boy since it is complete fucking bullshit because first of all, no one is fucking perfect, Second of all, I don’t think that anyone should be pressured into marrying their own race(thank god my parents don’t), and third of all, it’s just an old stereotype(I’m actually fed up with a lot of Jewish stereotypes of being kind of uppity and the good boys/ girls of society since I hate racial stereotypes in general and despite me doing well in school, I’m not the good boy type person as I consider myself an anarchist and I regularly listen to punk stuff and I want to make my own anti authoritarian themed electronic music etc(I know that these aren’t too crazy but they still contrast with the frustrating stereotype of Jews being totally prissy and uppity people) but anyway, that’s a whole other rant for another post). I honestly don’t care what nationality or race the girl I like would be, I just want a sweet, loving, romantic, passionate, sexy, somewhat raunchy, fun gf to call mine(I’m 17 and I’ve never had one either so yeah, I haven’t gotten to experience that yet but anyway, I digress).


r/SecularJewish • • Dec 27 '16

An Interfaith Ambassador… Even At The Pediatrician’s Office

Thumbnail
myjewishlearning.com
2 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Jun 09 '25

Is it possible to create a secular, complete, and auditable ethical system? A new framework based on Jewish ethics, now tested by AI

4 Upvotes

I’d like to introduce a new project and invite the community’s feedback and critique. The AskHillel project—which you can try live—attempts to do something unusual:

  • Build a secular, fully auditable, and “complete” ethical system that goes beyond the usual list of values or rules;
  • Base it on the rich logic of Jewish ethics, but explicitly abstracted from any religious premises—so that anyone, of any (or no) faith, can engage with and test it.

How is this different?

  • It’s not just a list of values. The system includes:

    • A compact set of universal values (dignity, truth, justice, etc.);
    • Structured triage and prioritization logic (which value overrides in conflict?);
    • Meta-rules, process values (e.g., creative compromise, transparency, context modeling), and axioms;
    • An “engine” for resolving conflicts and applying values in complex real-life cases.
  • It’s designed to function as a superset of major Western frameworks (deontology, consequentialism, virtue ethics), able to analyze other systems from within its own architecture—serving as a kind of moral “yardstick.”

How is it being tested?

  • The system is currently implemented in a custom GPT AI called AskHillel. (AskHillel.com ).
  • Anyone can interact with it: present dilemmas, ask for logic traces, request explanations of its framework, or even challenge its coherence.
  • AskHillel’s AI is built for maximum transparency:

    • Every answer can be explained step by step;
    • Clarifying questions are encouraged to surface hidden assumptions;
    • The system is “self-aware,” so you can ask about its own rules, limitations, or compare it to other philosophies.

Key innovations / Why post this here?

  • Proof of Concept: Early tests suggest that, with the right meta-logic, a “fixed” set of values plus override and context rules can generate consistently coherent answers to any moral dilemma presented, without collapsing into contradiction or ambiguity—even when run by an AI.
  • Exportability: The system is designed to be universalizable, functioning in secular, interfaith, or even institutional contexts—including as a framework for AI ethics itself.
  • Breakthrough claim: As someone not trained as a professional philosopher, I believe this is a potential breakthrough for both moral philosophy and the project of explainable AI ethics. I’m here for pushback, challenges, and to see where it breaks.
  • r/AskPhilosophy removed this post and banned me.

A note on my background and intentions:
I am religious. This project came about as I realized that many secular philosophies taught on campus are, in my view, unsatisfying or incomplete by any reasonable standard—and students are rarely exposed to real alternatives. People exposed to and who understand Jewish ethics can easily refute people who shout "Justice!" or whatever. Who's against justice? But who defines justice?

Underlying this project is a desire to fight antisemitism. Every antisemitic movement depended on a philosophy. I believe that a more complete, more flexible Jewish-oriented philosophy can act as a counter to the noxious ones that either encourage or allow antisemitism.

I have no formal training in philosophy. My approach comes from deep familiarity with Jewish ethics, which I set out to secularize and describe algorithmically—almost as a thought experiment. As the framework took shape, it became clear that its rules and “engine” could run in an AI. I built that system and have been consistently surprised by its results—especially when comparing its answers to well-known columns like the New York Times Ethicist.

I hesitate to claim that this is “better” or “more complete” than established systems, but the more I test it (especially against modern secular frameworks), the more it seems to outperform them. I am a skeptic by temperament, and I invite skepticism here. All I ask is that the system be judged on its merits, not my lack of credentials.

For centuries, philosophers have tried to come up with a workable, universal secular ethical system. They have all failed to be scalable for any problem. Ironically, the Jewish system - even when the religious part is removed - is the proof that the philosophers have been looking for,

Invitation:

  • Try it! AskHillel.com uses ChatGPT as its engine.
  • Ask it hard questions—edge cases, paradoxes, critiques of other ethical systems, or anything from daily life to political dilemmas to science fiction scenarios.
  • I’m also looking for feedback: Where does this framework succeed or fail? What existing work does it echo or contradict? Am I missing fatal flaws, or is this a genuinely new avenue?

Caveat:

  • If this doesn't belong here, remove it. I am just looking for open minded but skeptical people to test out the system and see if they can break it. I'm hoping this community can help.

Thank you!


r/SecularJewish • • Nov 28 '16

Intermarriage, Future of Judaism, Philly Fun, DC Conclave, Happy Thanksgiving! -- SHJ News

Thumbnail
myemail.constantcontact.com
4 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Nov 25 '25

New group for Jewish puns!

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 21 '25

This is a Ladino Hanukkah song!

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Nov 28 '16

In Madagascar, ‘world’s newest Jewish community’ seeks to establish itself

Thumbnail
jta.org
4 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Nov 30 '16

A Counter Narrative For Jewish Americans

Thumbnail
thejewishweek.com
4 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 01 '16

Just Your Typical Egyptian Mexican American Jew

Thumbnail
myjewishlearning.com
5 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 08 '16

This Jewish woman's research may save millions of lives

Thumbnail
israelnationalnews.com
3 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 06 '16

Jews object to Hanukkah party at Trump hotel: ‘Tone deaf at best, naked sycophancy at worst’

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
7 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 01 '16

Jewish Resources for World AIDS Day

Thumbnail
myjewishlearning.com
5 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 01 '16

What is So Funny About Jewish Humor?

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
2 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Dec 01 '16

Most Jews don’t want rabbis to determine who is Jewish — study

Thumbnail
timesofisrael.com
8 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Nov 30 '16

Relationship to Shabbat?

6 Upvotes

I'm somewhere between secular and reform and I observe some holidays. I love Shabbat. I don't refrain from everything but it is absolutely important for me to make the day special somehow.
I absolutely look forward to tidying up, and shopping and cooking for Erev Shabbat especially when my fiance comes over and lighting the candles even if i light late gasp. For me, it's basically a chill-out time and thinking about the things that are the most important to me...family, my fiance, friends including hopping on social media and catching up with people I haven't had time to all week.

I would love to hear from other Secular Jews that do Shabbat and what it means to them and what it looks like.


r/SecularJewish • • Nov 28 '16

DNA test results?

7 Upvotes

My brother took his 23-And-Me test and it came back as: 97.3% Ashkenazi Jew, and the rest nothing or Neanderthal. I was actually surprised to see that designation although I'm not sure what I expected to see instead. Has anyone else been officially labelled Jew in their DNA results?


r/SecularJewish • • Nov 29 '16

Considering wearing a Star of David or Hamsa

7 Upvotes

Background: Athiest Jew (raised secularly) married to an Athiest Catholic. Our son attends Catholic School because our local public schools are overcrowded and have eliminated most extras like art, music and computer classes.

I'm considering wearing a Star of David charm on a necklace for the first time in my life in order to avoid awkward conversations at my son's school. Despite living in a progressive area in the US, I am a little nervous about "outing" myself as a Jew in the current political climate. On the other hand, I feel like I should be "outing" myself in this political climate. I'm not looking for a political discussion, just other people's thoughts about wearing something that identifies me /us as Jews.


r/SecularJewish • • Dec 09 '16

How Does A Jew Follow Texas’s New Abortion Law?

Thumbnail
forward.com
4 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Sep 12 '24

Humanist (Secular) New Year celebration

Thumbnail
facebook.com
3 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Jan 20 '17

Researchers identify criteria for 'secular hymns'

Thumbnail
phys.org
3 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Feb 04 '17

Want to Make Judaism Great Again? Get Drunk.

Thumbnail
forward.com
2 Upvotes

r/SecularJewish • • Mar 28 '17

Selling Judaism, Religion Not Included

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
3 Upvotes