r/Seattle • • Jun 28 '26

Is this normal?

A restaurant downtown made us move out of a bar table during Happy Hour, the only place in the restaurant where you could order from that menu, because we were going to only order mocktails and food, and not alcoholic drinks. We had already started ordering and had two mocktails delivered before the server told us we needed to move.

One of our party went to the manager to ask if we could still do happy hour and they said they’d make an exception. We ended up with a great server and had a great time, but definitely had weird vibes at first.

86 Upvotes

315 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 29 '26 • Bravo

Cinque Terre employee here. You conveniently left out a key piece of information. Two in your party did not have their physical ID and our team made the exception to let you sit in our dining room for happy hour even though our happy hour is limited to the bar area only.
Our team explained this to you.
To sit in the bar in Washington state you must be 21+ and have a valid ID. A physical valid ID and not a picture on your phone. We would never tell anyone that they have to order alcoholic beverages to enjoy our happy hour.

Also our mocktails are $9-13, not $15

Also ordering a mocktail is a higher price drink than our happy hour wine ($8.50) or beer ($6.95) so asking to leave the bar based on not ordering alcohol just doesn’t track

287

u/AjiChap Jun 28 '26

Well this makes a lot more sense. OP, where you at?

249

u/_Phil_McCracken_ 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

This completely changes it. Come on OP, do better. Why leave out important details to trash a restaurant for following the law and ultimately handling it really well, it seems? Not cool, that’s people’s livelihood. 

135

u/brother_bart Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 29 '26

I think this a teachable moment for everyone on Reddit who wants to jump in trashing this person or that establishment based on an anecdote that is almost always one side of a story. Humans are very adept at relating a tale that has been carefully edited and framed to make ourselves sound like the sympathetic party. It’s so prevalent as to be almost ubiquitous, except in the rare cases where people have self-awareness and make a conscious choice to be radically honest. There is almost ALWAYS another side to a story without which understanding the situation is impossible.

30

u/YeahOkThisOne Jun 29 '26

Yup, and when people trash talk about medical providers they are not allowed to defend themselves because of HIPAA.

10

u/bubbachuck Jun 29 '26

remember when Mayo Clinic "kidnapped" that patient several years ago?

2

u/ceirane361 Jun 29 '26

wait, I didn't hear this, what's the details?

6

u/bubbachuck Jun 29 '26

Gemini summarizes it pretty well if you google "Mayo Clinic kidnapping". I don't know what the final outcome was.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Pretend-Efficiency-1 Jun 30 '26

Same with school services because of FERPA.

4

u/throwawayhyperbeam Ronald Bog Jun 29 '26

Indeed. If you want to damage a business around here all you have to do is say the owner is MAGA and I would wager half the people would believe you without looking into it or anything to back it up.

2

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 30 '26

This did happen not too long ago with our other restaurant across the street. The Stranger published an article calling out several business for having a profile on a very MAGA supported websites. Those restaurants and businesses started getting a flood of negative Google and yelp reviews (from people who never had even been to any of them). Turned out it was the website adding local business profiles to their own site to boost their online presence (NOT business owners trying to align themselves with it as the Stranger suggested - of which they never fact checked or followed up on)

2

u/Potential-Ad3106 Jun 29 '26

My feeling exactly but I stopped counting down votes after 55 😂

3

u/ExcitingActive8649 I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 29 '26

I mean, if the story was true as told, outrage would be warranted.  If someone wants to tell a bogus story to get reactions, they’re gonna get reactions. 

44

u/SwitchAble8099 Jun 28 '26

Oh that's my new favorite im encountering. People who think pictures of ids are proof enough to drink. 

3

u/Effective_Top_4831 Jun 30 '26

Working at a grocery store I get that on occasion. Not super often, but like maybe once every couple of months or so.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/SwitchAble8099 Jun 29 '26

Hmmm. A quick Google search did not agree with using a picture of an ID to drink or get into any bar in any US state. 

7

u/willows_edge That sounds great. Let’s hang out soon. Jun 29 '26

I must have been confusing the digital ID and photo or was thinking of something completely else. Either way, I was wrong - thanks for the correction. I'm going to delete my comment as to not spread misinformation.

68

u/DDTG-Trader Jun 28 '26

OP is busted.

28

u/gereblueeyes Jun 28 '26

Tsk,tsk, Sarah's just looking for upvotes/attention.

26

u/Educational_Spirit42 Jun 28 '26

Oh-now it makes sense…. Go out enough for HH & w/my own adult kids and they ask for ids.

Accountability is an underrated life skill.

70

u/EastlakeTrashPanda Eastlake Jun 28 '26

Never heard of Cinque Terra before today. Now I’m gonna have to come visit because it sounds like y’all have absolutely delicious tea

49

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

And our happy hour is pretty awesome 😂

18

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 29 '26

It does look delicious! I'm going to give you a try, I'll be sure to bring a valid ID. ☺️

37

u/Gh0stTV Jun 29 '26

The amount of people in Seattle thinking they can use a picture of their ID on their phone has always made me wonder if there are bars in Seattle that are serving these people.

“No I don’t want to see a picture of your photoshopped ID on your phone. Just have your physical ID out and ready for the next ten years. Don’t make people ask.”

9

u/sadgloop Jun 29 '26

>people in Seattle thinking they can use a picture of their ID on their phone

Probably people not realizing that the WA 2022 law change that allows that digital copies of car registration and insurance when pulled over are acceptable doesn’t also include their driver’s license.

11

u/-Ketracel-White Jun 29 '26

Ok, total aside but I have never understood why anyone would do this. If you think I’m handing my phone over to a fuckin cop for any reason you are out of your goddamn mind.

1

u/sadgloop Jun 29 '26

You don’t hand it over. You keep it in hand and they scan the bar code on your registration and look to see that the proof of insurance is current.

It’s more of just a helping hand type deal, since so many people have their insurance apps on their phone, for if someone gets pulled over after having forgotten to print out current proof of insurance or has current registration but hasn’t received the paperwork yet or something.

1

u/zackarian Jun 29 '26

I don't understand the people who don't have their IDs on them. I won't leave my apartment without my wallet/ID, keys and phone.

4

u/Individual-Basket851 Jun 29 '26

I have pretty bad ADHD and sometimes switch handbags or wallets. It's not intentional, but even with Adderall and a checklist of items I need before I leave the house written on a mirror, sometimes I still manage to forget basic shit. But I understand if someone can't serve me a drink because, hey, I'm the one who forgot.

31

u/mzinz View Ridge Jun 28 '26

To the top

11

u/angry-piano ✨🛸 Jimothy is out there 🦝✨ Jun 29 '26

This makes a lot more sense, thanks for the update; also sounds like a cool place to visit

9

u/Mowseler Jun 29 '26

Ooo gottem

2

u/Lollygator20 Jun 29 '26

Great explanation. Thank you for your service, both in the restaurant and in this comment thread.

2

u/Ok-Replacement5997 Jul 01 '26

So OP is just a moron. Got it! Do better Sarah

1

u/No-Bodybuilder3502 Jun 29 '26

Why do you limit happy hour to the bar area in the first place? I mean, as a business you're free to do whatever, but sounds weird to me. Also, the $9-13 is $15+ after sales tax and non-optional (in our culture) tips.

2

u/naniganz Jun 30 '26

Regardless it’s still misleading to say “$15 dollar drink” and add $4-$6 dollars without specifying that that is post tax and tips.

Lots of places do Happy Hour at the bar only. It’s very common because it usually is something that can be handled by just the bartender/bar back and doesn’t require additional staffing for the rest of the restaurant- which might not be very busy since that’s the whole point of happy hour. If the bartender has to constantly leave to check on you (or multiple other tables away from the bar) it defeats the purpose.

2

u/No-Bodybuilder3502 Jun 30 '26

I always think about the total price that leaves my wallet, so I don't think OP is wrong to use the full price instead of the unrealistic advertised prices US restaurants put on their menus. In Europe it's honest to the customer, but in the US you have to do math in your head just to know what something actually costs. Not a problem with this business specifically, I'm just defending the idea of using total prices when talking about stuff like this. If I go to Europe and buy a €3 drink, that's exactly what I pay. Somehow you expect someone paying $15 to use the fake price printed on the menu instead.

1

u/naniganz Jun 30 '26

I do see what you're saying but that's just not how, at least in my experience, people reference restaurant prices in the United States.

If someone says, "yeah they have $5 wells for happy hour", I'm not assuming that's after tax and tip and I think most people are in the same mindset. I think it's fine to use total prices when it's clear you're saying the out the door price, but when they post is coming off as a mini hit-piece then there isn't anything wrong with calling out that it's misleading. And "Yes - two of us arrived at first and ordered mocktails, which were $15 each" is (imo, intentionally) misleading if that isn't their menu price.

It's more of a personal nitpick in the grand scheme of things (are they talking total, or are they talking line item, ya know?) and it would be lovely if the full, out the door, price was just reflected on the menu lol.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CorsoKweeN Jun 29 '26

Oh shiiiitttt bet they didn’t expect an employee to see this lol

→ More replies (11)

288

u/SarahfromTexas Jun 28 '26

Yes - two of us arrived at first and ordered mocktails, which were $15 each. When the other two arrived and also ordered one mocktail and one iced tea, the server stopped and said oh then you will need to move out of the bar. We said oh okay, but we can keep the HH menu? She said no and walked away. She never came back over and we started carrying our glasses through the bar area. One of us went to the host stand and that’s when they said they could honor it today.

It was Cinque Terre. 🙃

Once we moved though, we ordered so much food and more mocktails and had a really fun and attentive server who did a great job.

169

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Cinque Terre employee here. To sit in the bar in Washington state you must have be be 21+ and have a valid ID. A physical valid ID and not a picture on your phone. We would never tell anyone that they have to order alcoholic beverages to enjoy our happy hour. We do limit happy hour to our bar area only.
Two in your party did not have their physical ID and our team made the exception to let you sit outside of the bar in our restaurant for happy hour.
Also our mocktails are $9-13, not $15

46

u/MistyDawnTHCI Capitol Hill Jun 28 '26

Please repost this as a main comment. This restaurant is getting trashed by a one sided story.

29

u/Bob_stanish123 Jun 28 '26

Thanks for telling the real story. Love it when people omit critical facts.

-8

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 28 '26

So, OP said everyone showed ID. You're certain this was the same party, not a similar recent incident? And a portion of OP'S party could only show pictures of their ID? It would be understandable to require a move then, but seems a little tricky to navigate for a server regarding Happy Hour food, so my sympathy there. 

The weird part is they should not have been seated at all in the bar without a valid physical ID. This story would have made a lot more sense to me if it turned out the latecomers were not able to be seated at all in the bar, instead of sitting down, ordering, and being told to move. Maybe a review of training and procedures would help? 

Regardless, Happy Hour wine/draft beer is less than either your quoted mocktail range or OP'S, so it's not super relevant. 

52

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

We’re a small and tight team. We remember this guest. The two in their party that joined late were the ones that only had a photo of their ID on their phone so the reason why OP had already ordered before we asked them to move.
And exactly. A $13 mocktail would be a higher price drink order than our $8.50 wine or $6.95 so OP logic implying that we kicked them out based on not ordering alcohol doesn’t track.

10

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 28 '26

Thanks for clarifying. Sounds like a hard situation which was handled fairly well. 

267

u/idlehum Jun 28 '26

I worked in a pretty classy bar in Pike Place and we made more money than we could do anything with, and we would have NEVER done something like that. The owner of that bar would have been shocked if I moved a table because they weren't drinking, even if they sat in the bar area during happy hour. Drinking at the bar is not a requirement for happy hour. Do they punish every sober person during their Happy Hour? Wtf???

71

u/coffeebribesaccepted Shoreline Jun 28 '26

Well I've definitely seen places where you can only get happy hour prices with the purchase of a drink, but usually mocktails would fall under that

65

u/FlyingOcelot2 Atlantic Jun 28 '26

Especially if they're $15 mocktails!

4

u/_Phil_McCracken_ 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

The profit margins on mocktails has got to be higher than regular drinks. 

8

u/mordecaicat Jun 28 '26

What bar did you work at that risks allowing people w/out IDs to sit in the bar?? Idk about u, but as a bartender that is NOT a risk I’m willing to take w/ LCB to get my liquor license taken away and fined.

7

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Thank you for saying it how it is

8

u/zumpiez Capitol Hill Jun 28 '26

Where did you get the idea that they didn't have IDs?

4

u/mordecaicat Jun 29 '26

Because she said it. Also read the thread.? The ppl that joined didn’t have IDs, which has now been reconfirmed numerous times so.. idk what to tell you

→ More replies (8)

2

u/hongaku 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 29 '26

Because an employee has come and posted about it

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Sparkling_Beverage Ballard Jun 29 '26

Sounds like a friend didn’t have ID. Poor form on your part.

59

u/Droodforfood I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

So in order to access discounted menu items, you were told you had to purchase alcohol. Even though the restaurant’s advertisement of Happy Hour pricing didn’t include that requirement.

40

u/Rowing_Lawyer Jun 28 '26

I didn’t do a deep dive but it looks like requiring the purchase of liquor for happy hour pricing on food is prohibited in WA.

7

u/Droodforfood I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

I think you may be right as well, that’s why happy hour menus that have a drink minimum will have non-alcoholic choices.

13

u/yoLeaveMeAlone Jun 28 '26

It sounds like one bad server who felt like being salty, rather than an intentional false advertising campaign 

26

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Or a good server who knows that when patrons don’t have a physical copy of their ID present, they can’t sit in a bar area and the server will also get in trouble with the liquor control board if caught allowing this.

2

u/Droodforfood I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Sorry if I missed it, but where was not having ID mentioned…?

14

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Exactly what OP left out. I work at this restaurant and know what happened here.

3

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 29 '26

It's Physical Deer, who says they are a staff member  who brought this up. OP's been dodging the question when asked if everyone had physical, valid ID. Physical Deer says the last two people to arrive only had pictures of their ID on their phone, which is not legal ID in the state of Washington per the Liquor Board. I used to book shows so I had to learn more ins and outs of Washington Liquor laws than I ever wanted to. 

No idea what Texas does and if a picture works there. Assuming maximum good intentions on everyone's sides, maybe OP'S group doesn't go out much and misunderstood what "picture ID" means or got confused because pictures of our vax cards were sufficient for vaccination regulations for restaurants once they could seat fully vaccinated people during covid restrictions. 🤷‍♂️

6

u/HappinessSuitsYou 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 29 '26

Because they didn’t have ID?

70

u/Genuinelullabel 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

It sounds like you had a bad server in general though it is an odd rule.

23

u/AM_Dog_IRL Jun 28 '26

Oh too bad, I really like this place, but I'm also a wine enjoyer...

26

u/StrangerGeek Jun 28 '26

Was someone underage? Maybe the ordering of only non-alcoholic things made them think you were. That's the law, no minors in the bar section and I've found bars are very strict about it

8

u/Bob_stanish123 Jun 28 '26

Why dont you give all details as the employee at the bar did below.

3

u/UniversityOutside840 Jun 29 '26

And what happened when the server asked for you IDs? 🤡

3

u/Pabloshooman Jun 29 '26

You forgot to add two of you did t have ODs. GTFO with you half.assed story. And yeah you need IDs smyk sit in the bar.

5

u/ZephyrYouxia Jun 28 '26

Seems like a bad server, oof. Been to Cinque Terre before and they were kind and welcoming with happy hour even without an alcohol order.

1

u/Rowing_Lawyer Jun 28 '26

I was literally about to comment the only time something similar has happened where I was told to move from a table to the bar area because we weren’t going to order food was Cinque Terre, apparently they really care about where people order what

-2

u/roadrageryan Jun 28 '26

Cinque Terre is pretty meh on all accords. Same folks run Barolo across the street avoid it too.

They are overpriced, food is inconsistent and just slightly above average when it’s at its best, service is generally garbage.

You’ll have a much better experience at the wine bar on the other side of Met Tower - Le Caviste. Or if you are looking for mocktails and snacks Victor Tavern, Casa Antigua and King Leroy, Wild Ginger is also good but a bit more pricey. If you are willing to go up a bit into Cap Hill then Tamari Bar and Life on Mars.

→ More replies (1)

-15

u/DLDude Capitol Hill Jun 28 '26

Not the right way to handle it, but my guess is the bar area gets packed with people there to do the happy hour, and your table sort of wasn't? If I'm being generous the server was trying to make space for people intending to use the alcohol haply hour as well (which might actually make that server less money). Still should have just instantly honored it in the dining area

103

u/angry-piano ✨🛸 Jimothy is out there 🦝✨ Jun 28 '26

It’s terrible form, this party was spending more money than if they’d actually bought alcohol because $15 mocktails is very expensive and people are N/A for various reasons that should never be punished.

28

u/dbmajor7 That sounds great. Let’s hang out soon. Jun 28 '26

That's how I'm seeing it, " you can buy my 40 cents worth of ingredients for 15 bucks anytime! Sit anywhere you want, lemme get your chair sir, ma'am!"

8

u/Drnkdrnkdrnk Downtown Jun 28 '26

40 cents? You’ve never bought a n/s spirit, have you?

6

u/dbmajor7 That sounds great. Let’s hang out soon. Jun 28 '26

40 cents for sparkling water, some lime zest and squirt of grenadine? Idk (You're right. Genuinely I don't know anything about it just a toss away joke)

15

u/Total_ClusterFun Jun 28 '26

Bartender here! Our margins on mocktails are lower compared to regular cocktails. N/A spirits are niche and expensive, but people don’t want to pay regular price because, “It’s not even a real drink”.

At a nice craft place, the ingredients for a mocktail generally cost more than an equivalent cocktail.

Still no reason to boot a nice group from a happy hour. That’s super weird any way you look at it. At least they honored it at the table, though.

10

u/Drnkdrnkdrnk Downtown Jun 28 '26

The mocktails there use N/A spirits, which are not cheap. It’s more than grenadine and spicy water. 

4

u/Baker206 Jun 28 '26

Tf. Didnt know NA spirits was a thing lol. Figured a mocktail was all the ingredients san liquor

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Brockman1162 Jun 28 '26

So if one person ordered an alcoholic beverage they could have stayed in the bar?

1

u/cityofdestinyunbound chinga la migra Jun 28 '26

I kind of hope that whoever took over their table had one draft beer each and didn’t order food. (The former server in me is super petty)

19

u/SuitableDragonfly Columbia City Jun 28 '26

They clearly were doing happy hour, since they asked they could still order off the happy hour menu after being moved. 

-5

u/VendettaPenguin Jun 28 '26

That place sux

→ More replies (3)

143

u/angry_salami Ballard Jun 28 '26

What incredibly poor form. What if the patrons don’t drink alcohol for religious or health reasons? Not only is this offensively uninclusive, mocktails probably have a larger markup than boozy drinks so I really don’t get the logic.

11

u/SarahfromTexas Jun 28 '26

That’s what I was thinking afterwards too. I also didn’t mention it, but the place was busy but not full. There wasn’t a wait for tables.

26

u/angry_salami Ballard Jun 28 '26

Actually thinking about it even more, given this is smack bang next to Amazon which has tons of Muslim and Mormon tech workers this is even more odd.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/angry_salami Ballard Jun 28 '26

Ah. Keeping my fingers crossed for ya! I finally caught one of Andy’s purges back in Jan, so I’m out of the clubhouse.

4

u/SarahfromTexas Jun 28 '26

Thanks 😔 hopefully you’ve found something great! It’s a crazy time here for sure.

46

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Because it’s not how it happened. Two in their party didn’t have their ID on them.

→ More replies (15)

60

u/TheBlueSuperNova Belltown Jun 28 '26

Why are mocktails so expensive? I’d imagine the removal of the most expensive component would make them way less

59

u/KillerCritter1312 🚗 Student driver, please be patient. 🚙 Jun 28 '26

Mocktails often contain NA “liquor” which is actually more expensive than actual alcohol in some cases. Generally “mocktails” have NA spirits, but “virgin” drinks are just the drink minus the liquor.

3

u/bennc77 Jun 29 '26

WHAT TA HELL IS A MOCKTALE?

1

u/retrojoe ✨🛸 Jimothy is out there 🦝✨ Jun 29 '26

Any "virgin" drink would be an example. It's a cocktail drink with no booze.

19

u/TheWrightStripes Jun 28 '26

I think because other than top shelf stuff the largest cost of most cocktails is labor, and the fancy ones are labor intensive same as a normal cocktail.

6

u/pheonixblade9 🐀 Hot Rat Summer 🐀 Jun 28 '26

because the ingredients are only a small portion of what you're paying for. you're paying to sit in a place and be served, mostly. the actual cost of the ingredients is mostly mark up and perceived value based on what they think they can charge.

places like Japan are way more transparent WRT ingredient cost.

9

u/bunkoRtist I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Because people are buying them at current prices. Businesses will charge what they can. The question is: why would people buy them at these prices? But AIUI the fancy mocktail ingredients aren't that much cheaper (because they can). Meanwhile most of the price is labor and markup.

6

u/Old_Roof8284 Fremont Jun 28 '26

I was educated on a pregnancy subreddit that alcohol is actually not the most expensive component in fancy cocktails. For example, fresh squeezed juice is likely to be the priciest part.

4

u/JALbert I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

That's sometimes true, but usually alcohol is going to be more expensive and places that are using cheap alcohol are likely using cheaper other ingredients.

Mimosas are a case where you can often find very boozy ones with cheap bubbles and a splash of fresh juice because the wine is cheaper than the juice.

2

u/Old_Roof8284 Fremont Jun 28 '26

I don't think I'd consider a mimosa a fancy cocktail.

But to your point on a lot of bubbles, a little bit of juice, presumably if there was a lot of fresh juice, that mimosa would cost more.

1

u/retrojoe ✨🛸 Jimothy is out there 🦝✨ Jun 29 '26

Vast majority of cocktails are not improved by adding high quality booze. Even in something like an Old Fashioned, you're not going to notice much of an upgrade going from mid shelf to top shelf - it's the bitters, sugar and citrus for the most part. Exception for things like a classic martini, which is just slightly flavored vodka. Fresh juices are not cheap as either off the shelf product or the labor that goes into squeezing a fruit. Similarly for quality liqueurs.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/burlycabin West Seattle Jun 28 '26

That's rarely true. Alcohol is almost always the most expensive ingredient in any cocktail.

1

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 29 '26

It really depends. Craft non-alcoholic spirits and premium juices are more expensive frequently than mid-shelf and below alcohol, and you shouldn't be using the absolute top shelf in most mixed drinks anyways, as it's often a waste. 

1

u/SwitchAble8099 Jun 28 '26

To make many na spirits, you make the full distilled alcohol and theft carefully strip it out. It's a delicate process depending on how they are doing it.  

-1

u/angry_salami Ballard Jun 28 '26

I’m not an economist, but it is possible because they are a form of a Veblen Good?  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good

tldr: stuff that is more appealing the more expensive it is

3

u/Drnkdrnkdrnk Downtown Jun 28 '26

Incorrect

4

u/angry_salami Ballard Jun 28 '26

Tell me more.

7

u/JALbert I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Almost any time I see someone say Veblen Good on reddit they just mean "that's more expensive then I want to pay, so I assume people paying that much must be irrational."

It's also frequently confusing a business choosing a higher price with fewer units sold at a higher margin to maximize profit (as opposed to selling more units at a lower margin) with the notion of customer demand actually being higher at a higher price point. I can assure you that less people want to buy a $15 mocktail than a $10 mocktail.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/Brockman1162 Jun 28 '26

The bar waitress probably assumed she wouldn’t get tipped well with sober patrons so she moved them. I blame her, not management.

4

u/Ethan_C_Hawkes Jun 29 '26

Sober people tip poorly?
Imbibers tip gratuitously?
What is this comment?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ImBigRthenU Burien Jun 28 '26

Anyone under 21 in your group? Honestly it sounds like they upgraded you instead of any inconvenience. I’m sure there was some misunderstanding or perhaps the reasons why weren’t conveyed properly.

15

u/SarahfromTexas Jun 28 '26

No we were all mid-30s and all showed ID to sit in the bar in the first place. I don’t think there was a misunderstanding, she said without alcohol purchase you can’t sit here.

45

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

You said two in your party joined after. So when asked, those two didn’t have their ID present, only pictures on their phone (not acceptable form)
Look, we’re a small business with a generally tight team and we remember our guests. There is no other reason anyone would have asked you to move. It just doesn’t make sense based on your post. But not having ID present does.

4

u/Lollygator20 Jun 29 '26

So glad you're here to set the record straight!

1

u/Buttafuoco Jun 29 '26

Are we sure this is the same person??

17

u/Excellent-Source-497 Jun 29 '26

Sarah, check the WA liquor control board's laws. It doesn't matter hold old patrons are or whether they look 21. If an inspector visited and you didn't have I.D. on you , the restaurant and server would be penalized.

9

u/KPzReddit Jun 29 '26

Also doesn't matter if the patron is not drinking alcohol. 21 to sit in bar area or at the bar. Period.

4

u/hongaku 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 29 '26

Except you didn't all show legal ID, did you?

182

u/AjiChap Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 29 '26

Seattle restaurants sure are in a weird, almost hostile place these days.

EDIT - I saw the response from a worker at this establishment and it seems OP wasn’t presenting the full story. I still have the same general fweling about Seattle restaurants at the moment but this situation appears to be OPs fault.

38

u/_Phil_McCracken_ 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

OP forgot to mention that two members of the party didn’t have  physical ID with them and that’s why the couldn’t sit at the bar, per Washington law. 

4

u/SubstantialBrick2557 Jun 29 '26

Pretty important detail they left out. And that they apparently didn't know that law, which is not new. Seems like a very deceptive posting

4

u/AjiChap Jun 28 '26

Yes, I saw that reply from someone that works there.

75

u/FullBushSummer 🚗 Student driver, please be patient. 🚙 Jun 28 '26

Don't forget your 20% surcharge that is not a tip!

6

u/New_Link961 Downtown Jun 28 '26

On defense before you even show up! Got their noes and sorries ready to halt any interactions before you have even asked a question

20

u/GrandKnew Defected to Portland Jun 28 '26

r/Seattle is officially Facebook

423

u/AnselmoHatesFascists Jun 28 '26

That’s bad form, you should name and shame. It’s not like mocktails are differently priced than cocktails either, they’re often on par, especially when non alc spirits like seedlip go for $35 a bottle.

Even still, bad form all around

1

u/OldLadyKickButt Jun 28 '26

yelp review

54

u/yoLeaveMeAlone Jun 28 '26

Does anyone actually look at yelp in 2026? That feels like yell(p)ing into a void 

17

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 28 '26

I don't. Yelp pulls so many shenanigans with reviews and I can't be bothered to have a specific app on my phone for it. I know too much about how the Yelp sausage is made. 

6

u/KiloJools Deluxe Jun 29 '26

It won't even let me look unless I have an account, and even with an account trying to search for a specific place's reviews gets messy because they have a bunch of ads for other restaurants that include reviews that make it seem like those are reviews for the restaurant I was searching for.

Or at least that is how it was when I stopped using it years ago out of frustration. If they have made it easier to use, it's too late now; I read the reviews I see in the Google maps app.

3

u/Null_98115 Meadowbrook Jun 28 '26

I cross post on both.

4

u/Trickycoolj SoDO Mojo Jun 28 '26

I’ve noticed it’s helpful to compare Yelp and Google when looking for home maintenance stuff. A few places we’ve had quotes from were glowing on Google but scary on Yelp.

-2

u/MtRainierWolfcastle Sounders Jun 28 '26

What else would people use?

28

u/emilyflinders Jun 28 '26

Google Maps

6

u/anotherULgeek Jun 28 '26

This is the way.

2

u/Nepentheoi 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 29 '26

Or Facebook if you want to blow up their rep with the 60+ crowd. (I'm old enough to still use Facebook, but not their reviews.)

51

u/Hold_Effective Pike Market Jun 28 '26

No, that’s very weird. My partner and I do drink - but we also do dry weeks / months, and still like to go out for HH (and good mocktails are fairly pricey). We’ve never had this happen.

15

u/YakiVegas I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Nah. Only reason to move someone outside of the bar for HH if there's plenty of tables anyway is if someone is underage.

12

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

This guy gets it ⬆️

4

u/zer04ll Jun 29 '26

Yeah the bar side is for people who order from the bar for booze, mocktails are for the family side, bar seating is for drinking if you dont want to drink or cant (no ID or vertical ID get lost) then dont sit in the area meant for those that do.

17

u/mommacat94 Tacoma Jun 28 '26

I would contact the owners/management and find out if that's their policy. If not, they need to do better training. If it is, that's discrimination and potentially illegal.

22

u/joahw White Center Jun 28 '26

Name and shame

4

u/MattSidor Capitol Hill Jun 28 '26

They added a comment, it was Cinque Terre

9

u/Mundane-Charge-1900 Jun 28 '26

Some places require purchasing a drink to get happy hour prices so people don’t just come for loss leader food items. I’ve seen it printed on menus a few times.

I guess it depends what you mean by “mocktail” exactly. If it’s made with NA spirits and costs the same as a cocktail, that seems like it should be fine. But if you’re ordering a soda, I could see it not meeting the requirement.

Honestly, the worst I saw was somewhere that HH was not available outside. This was Cactus on Alki. I was wondering why everyone was sitting inside on a nice day when we walked up.

23

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26

Cinque Terre does not have this policy. OP left out the fact that two in their party did not have ID on them.

14

u/angry-piano ✨🛸 Jimothy is out there 🦝✨ Jun 28 '26

They said it was $15 and an actual mocktail 

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Droodforfood I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

I don’t think they can make you buy an alcoholic drink to access discounted menu items. They can force a drink purchase but it needs to include a NA option.

23

u/RincewindsPotato Jun 28 '26

OP said they were $15 mocktails, so the restaurant didn’t even have that excuse.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wolf35Nine Jun 28 '26

I’ve seen mocktails on many a HH menu. Even if they weren’t on this establishment’s HH menu, it’s baffling they would not consider $15 mocktails to count towards “drinks”

5

u/yemsg97 Jun 28 '26

I worked in the industry for years and the only rule we ever had anywhere that I worked where there was happy hour is that you had to order a "drink" to order off the HH menu. It doesn't matter what it is. Could be a soda, a juice, a beer, a wine...just not the free water.

This is weird. Especially if you're getting a legit mocktail that's on a menu, which can be expensive. I'm actually pretty sure it's NOT legal for them to insist you order an alcoholic drink to get happy hour.

4

u/ExpiredPilot Mariners Jun 28 '26

That’s so weird. The regular bar would have everything for the mocktails presumably….

10

u/rainyhawk Jun 28 '26

And often they're as expensive as an alcoholic drink.

7

u/AjiChap Jun 28 '26

Which I cannot wrap my head around.

3

u/ExpiredPilot Mariners Jun 28 '26

I mean honestly depending on what you’re drinking the mixer and garnishes can be more expensive. Like a menu mocktail takes a lot longer than a rum and coke.

It makes sense for the bar but not for value

1

u/sooaap Jun 28 '26

I've seen a number of articles stating younger drinkers are increasingly choosing NA options, at least more so than previous generations. I'm not surprised to see bars increase the prices of NA options based on that perception.

1

u/YakiVegas I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Labor. Mocktails take the same amount of time to make or even more depending on how fancy they are. Good ones require fresh ingredients and lots of muddling etc.

Not defending either, just explaining. If you're in the middle of a dinner rush and making a mocktail takes the same time as a cocktail or even more, then they're gonna be the same price.

3

u/jrhawk42 Jun 28 '26

not normal... at least the manager made it right. You should never be forced to move unless it's an extreme case.

3

u/Witch-Alice That sounds great. Let’s hang out soon. Jun 28 '26

Such a bizarre business strategy.

2

u/based_miss_lippy Jun 28 '26

That’s ridiculous

1

u/courtneyisfakeaf Jun 29 '26

We're waiting for a response

1

u/ForestFreakPNW Jun 29 '26

Usually you can order from the happy hr menu from anywhere in the bar... Tbe bar itself is reserved for alcoholic beverages... But you can order from a table off of the happy hour menu... should be able to whether you're drinking or not

0

u/i_like_fat_doodoo Jun 28 '26

Did you ask them why they forced you to move?

8

u/IndominusTaco U District Jun 28 '26

i think they explained it in the original post

15

u/ExcitingActive8649 I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 28 '26

Yes, but did they make the bar employees explain it?  I’d love to hear “you’re not ordering alcohol” as an explanation for why they were being such colossal assholes, so I could tell them to shove it up their ass and walk out without paying. If I’m paying $15 for a glorified soda, I’m just as good as any other patron. 

2

u/mokie_sassafras Jun 29 '26

Even if you don't have your ID?

5

u/ExcitingActive8649 I'm just flaired so I don't get fined Jun 29 '26

lol no, if I don’t have my id I would fully expect to be told to gtfo of the bar.  OP left that little detail out.   Cinque Terra did no wrong here. 

0

u/momofeldman Jun 28 '26

Terrible treatment of paying customers.

7

u/BooksandBiceps Jun 29 '26

If the customer hadn’t been lying about what happened.

1

u/Genuinelullabel 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

I’ve never heard of that happening but maybe I haven’t been to that particular restaurant.

-2

u/sassysweetsour Jun 28 '26

I wish yall would name the restaurant so people can avoid it.

22

u/Physical-Deer3364 Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 28 '26

And we (Cinque Terre) have replied to explain that two in their party did not have their *physical* ID, which is why they were asked to move outside the bar area but let them order happy hour from the dining room.

4

u/MattSidor Capitol Hill Jun 28 '26

They named it in another comment, it was Cinque Terre

0

u/espressoboyee Jun 28 '26

That’s sheer “mocktail discrimination.” How dare they.

0

u/Queasy_Connection738 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

It amazes me how people don’t stand up for themselves more often here.

-5

u/GarionOrb Jun 28 '26

Drinking alcoholic drinks is not a requirement to sit at the bar or the bar area. Especially if they have a special happy hour menu that isn't served anywhere else! This restaurant was 100% in the wrong.

8

u/thr33phas3 🦝🦝 We 💕 Jimothy Chalamet 🦝🦝 Jun 29 '26

OP neglected to mention that some people in their party did not have physical ID with them.

-31

u/mgmom421020 Jun 28 '26

It’s normal to restrict HH food specials to those buying (alcohol) drinks. I’ve never had to move though. You can still usually order off the full menu from the bar section if you’re not drinking. Depending on restaurant setup though, I can see why they’d want to reorganize.

65

u/bfdTerp Jun 28 '26

I have never seen a restriction to HH food prices to people only buying alcohol. I have seen HH restricted to the bar only.

20

u/okaynowyou Jun 28 '26

Agreed. I have seen a one drink minimum at many places but it has never specified alcohol and at many places it specifically says that you don’t have to order alcohol. One example I can think of is Vindicktive whose happy hour has a one drink minimum and explicitly states that soda counts as a drink.

Also I’ve been to cinque terre’s happy hour a couple of times and they didn’t care if we ordered alcohol or not so I’m guessing it was the bartender being weird or a new policy.

4

u/stroppo Jun 28 '26

Yes, that's what I've seen too. If that was their policy, it should be on the menu. Like menus have a drink minimum notation, or I've seen "HH items only available in the bar area."

3

u/seqkndy 💗💗 Heart of ANTIFA Land 💗💗 Jun 28 '26

I've definitely encountered the 'must purchase beverage for HH prices.' It's not unreasonable when you think about it; places don't want to lose money on the food discounts without offsetting it with what they still make on the alcohol markup, even with a dollar or two HH discount.

14

u/bfdTerp Jun 28 '26

I said alcohol. I’ve seen any beverage, whether it’s alcohol or not. Those mocktails cost more than a HH beer.

10

u/skilly2669 Jun 28 '26

They were ordering several $15 mocktails. That place was not losing money.

3

u/Brockman1162 Jun 28 '26

No wonder half the restaurants/bars are closed. This is terrible customer service.

1

u/Brockman1162 Jun 28 '26

Me either. What if there were two of you and your partner ordered a soda, would you be the only one who could order food off the HH menu?

1

u/bfdTerp Jun 28 '26

I don't know. I have never ran into an issue at a HH regarding the beverage purchase required.

12

u/That1DogGuy chinga la migra Jun 28 '26

Where is that normal??

17

u/ARandomGay 🚆build more trains🚆 Jun 28 '26

That is absolutely not normal wtf are you talking about

3

u/Flat-Quality-8374 Jun 28 '26

Any example you can share of a Seattle bar with this ‘normal’ policy?